HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

runningdogx

735 karma · joined April 7, 2009

submissionscomments
runningdogx··on Arrays considered somewhat harmful
I don't understand the recent (from the last few years to a decade) intertubes hatred of "weasel words".

Sometimes* they are used to purposefully obfuscate or render a questionable argument virtually* unassailable.

Sometimes* they are used to express a complex reality that is not black and white. Most* real-world issues are shades of grey on top of shades of grey, mixed with some cause-effect loops, and turtles all the way down.

runningdogx··on Adder: Python with a Lisp
A flag to enable targeting stackless python instead of normal python?
runningdogx··on Study: GM corn causes organ failure in mice
Agreed, I hate GM scaremongers as well.

The suspect species of corn (and soy, for that matter) with genes to produce pesticides, however, might cross-pollinate. In that case, it's not only GM corn that's suspect, but all corn.

edit... I still don't think it's clear whether the problem is with the gene producing pesticide, or excessive external pesticide/herbicide use.

runningdogx··on Roll your own LinkBait headline
Awesome! It could use another pattern relating to the web video codec war.

(obresult: Watch How Intelligent Agents Capture Wild Giraffes)

runningdogx··on Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period
I do.

If you want to write a parsing program that can delineate sentences, doing so in the face of abbreviations can be difficult. If, for instance, a sentence ends with an abbreviation, and the next sentence starts with a proper noun, an algorithm would detect a run-on sentence and would have to resort to tearing the grammar in the two adjoining sentences apart to figure out where to split them.

If there is a double space between sentences, the problem is reduced to a trivial string splitting operation.

Furthermore, any app that visually displays the text should know that some people use two spaces between sentences, and can trivially correct for this if it's implementing its own fancy typography. HTML already ignores multiple contiguous 0x20 spaces. Any text rendering algorithm fancy enough to implement good typography can likewise simply ignore the double space.

Double spaces between sentences have no mandatory effect on visual layout since layout algorithms can ignore the extra space, However, it can have a significant effect on the speed, if not accuracy, of text parsing algorithms.

runningdogx··on US Export Regulations on Crypto Eased
This is interesting. If I'm reading it correctly, it continues to give open source crypto an advantage over commercial crypto, since commerical crypto is not publicly available and therefore sellers have to do some due diligence about their customers to make sure they're not selling to e.g. a North Korean government front.

I don't understand why the BIS can't say the cat's out of the bag, and deregulate encryption software completely. If North Korean and Iran and Libya aren't using good encryption, it's not because they lack access to it.

If a company can make money selling crypto to regimes like that, what's the problem? Money flows into crypto companies' pockets at the expense of idiots in those regimes who could be implementing their own systems based on open source crypto software, without paying companies from imperialist, corrupt, decadent western societies a dime.

Why is the state department opposed to letting U.S. companies make money off of enemy regimes?

runningdogx··on RIP Bill Zeller
I had that same impression. Although he repeated some of the basic points (darkness, depression, social isolation) ad nauseam, he strikes me as someone who had potential as a writer. It's tragic that he did not explore writing as a non-terminal outlet for his darkness.
runningdogx··on Google Will Become an AI Company
Without a human driver, how will a cab company keep fares from trashing cabs? The issue of ensuring payment becomes a serious problem. Do you put credit card entry pads on the outside of the cab to prevent any of that? How long until someone superglues it?

With human drivers, there's a social norm to prevent misbehavior, and in extreme cases the driver can stop and insist that the passenger get out.

Even if the cab companies put human toll collectors in driverless cabs, although that could work, there would be less respect for cabbies who are not driving. I fear that bad behavior would still flourish.

runningdogx··on Prof. Ross Anderson's response to a takedown request about security research
The U.S. Constitution absolutely cannot be amended by Congress.
runningdogx··on My conversation with AT&T
I have griped to AT&T several times about how their 2wire 3800hgv-b router (used for their UVerse service) is broken when you set up pass-through to an internal box. They call this "DMZplus".

What happens is that when icmp packets relating to connections from the DMZplus host arrive at the 2wire router, the 2wire drops them. This breaks path MTU discovery, unix-style traceroutes, etc. It is not a general limitation of the 2wire box, since hosts that are not using DMZplus can receive related icmp just fine. It's caused by the pathologically stupid way that the 2wire router implements "DMZplus". It basically assigns itself AND the internal host the same external IP address, and uses its best guess which traffic to forward and which not to. They missed some corner case relating to ICMP in the state tracker, and AT&T's response is that since it's a "feature" that few people complain about, if I want it fixed I shouldn't be using UVerse. Even after I've pointed out that this behavior violates the tcp/ip standard.

runningdogx··on InnoDB faster than NoSQL solutions?
This sounds like Drizzle, where they've modularized almost everything, and you can get similarly ultrahigh tps by keeping connections open and bypassing the standard sql parser and query planner. (Obviously, the assumption for such high numbers is that your disk array can keep up or that the transactions are only hitting memory.)
runningdogx··on "Google asserts copyright, even on work I do in my own time." (Snap framework)
And, as johnl asked in the github thread, does Google hold copyright on Chris's comments here on HN?

Code, comments... they're both speech. If you can sign away code copyright in an employment contract, can you also sign away copyright to all human language speech you write?

runningdogx··on SecDef Gates on Wikileaks
This classy response by Gates is but a brief glimpse of honesty from an otherwise hysterical, paranoid, and secretive government. A statement like this would never have occurred if Assange had not released these documents.

The standard rhetoric from Washington is that it's important to keep secrets, and that's why so much is classified, and why it needs to remain classified. Assange AND Gates have demonstrated that this is not true, that release of these cables and the earlier military leak (which DoD found did NOT reveal any sensitive intelligence sources or methods) do not seriously threaten our safety.

Contrast that with statements from Sarah Palin, Congressperson Peter King, and others, who are basically calling for Wikileaks to be classified as a terrorist organization. King in particular noted that the requirement seems to be met -- that Wikileaks represents a "clear and present danger" -- which seems to be contradicted by Gates' statement. Also, in academic political science, terrorism is generally defined as -violence- against a non-military target to achieve a political end, so there's no terrorism involved here from an academic perspective. If King is correct and that's the requirement, it is too broad.

Cablegate has thus been valuable in demonstrating hypocrisy among politicians and political hacks. If there's a story here, it's that politicians are trying to whip Americans into a frenzy over some embarrassing but not critical leakage.

runningdogx··on Schizophrenic Brains Not Fooled by Optical Illusion
It's probably one of those things people end up memorizing, when learning about lenses or 3d figures like polyhedrons. It's like latitude and longitude. You can try to derive meaning from e.g. "lat = lateral", but then, do the lines go across or are they measuring distance across (which would make the lines vertical)? Either you memorize the correct answer, or you can easily get mixed up by over-analyzing the meaning.

concave -> (cave, cavity) -> hole

convex, you sort of just have to memorize. As best I can tell from introspection, I've associated the sound/visual of "vex" with "outward"

runningdogx··on Prof Gives Lecture to Prove He Knows Students Cheated; Over 200 Students Confess
Here's the video of a part of the first lecture in which he claims he writes the test questions:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJG7aCQtI8E

Based on that, I think a reasonable student would conclude that even if a publisher's test bank is not supposed to be accessible to students, using that test bank would not constitute cheating. Since the prof wasn't forthright in stating that he would use the publisher's test bank, he has no right to complain that students used it to study.

runningdogx··on Prof Gives Lecture to Prove He Knows Students Cheated; Over 200 Students Confess
If it were a process-oriented class, that might be justified. For instance, in a pure math course, you wouldn't want to read an off-syllabus math text in which the author proves theorems that show up on later problem sets or exams.

However, those sorts of courses are not typical, and it falls to the professor to make clear and explicit if external material is forbidden, and to explain why.

Since the existence of a test bank implies the exam was (mostly) multiple choice, the above concerns do not apply. There is no reason to forbid students from learning from external resources if your idea of testing them on their knowledge is giving them a multiple choice test.

The proper (and common) scope for restricting external materials is an individual problem set, quiz, or test. It's implied unless stated otherwise that you shouldn't get help for specific problems or questions from external resources, but it is almost never implied or stated that external resources are banned in the scope of an entire class. In that context, if you go exploring for materials and find something that helps you on a later problem set, quiz, or test, that's your reward for seeking out more materials to learn from.

runningdogx··on Prof Gives Lecture to Prove He Knows Students Cheated; Over 200 Students Confess
That assumes that proof of anything is required. That's not usually how college disciplinary actions work.

At its worst, universities will sometimes assume a student accused of wrongdoing is lying, and punish the student based solely on the word of the faculty/staff bringing the charge. This happens in lesser cases where the administration thinks it can get away with it, and when the student is frightened of harsher sanctions that might be inflicted if the student asserts his or her rights and demands a full hearing process.

At its best (typically in more serious cases), the disciplinary process resembles a civil case (except instead of a jury, it's more of a tribunal) where the required proof is a preponderance of the evidence.

It's no wonder 200 students confessed. If I was in that class and I'd never seen the test bank, I'd have confessed too. It's been my observation that the disciplinary process is better at railroading not-provably-guilty students than punishing provably-guilty students. I would not want to take my chances.

runningdogx··on UK Government: will not support Net Neutrality
Many U.S. cities have historically granted right of way (to run cables) to one "phone" company and one "cable" company. In my area, we have AT&T and Comcast. It's up to the cities to allow more competitors, and many are unwilling to do that (or unable, if they have long-term agreements with the existing carriers).

It's a classic case of public policy lagging behind technology, with politicians having no concern for technological progress and free market principles, unwisely entering into long-term agreements with telecom companies.

runningdogx··on TSA encounter at SAN
What happens if a passenger opts for the groping session, and then hits on the groper and insinuates loudly that the groper is gay? Is that arrestable?

Some people have to fly, but that doesn't mean they can't turn these situations into comedy highlighting the stupidity of the system.

runningdogx··on Htaccess Tricks and Tips
First of all, I haven't used apache httpd in production for years and I'm happier for it. It's inefficient. .htaccess only compounds that inefficiency.

General: 1. I've found using anything but GMT/UTC on servers is a recipe for confusion.

4. Great idea, but like most of the recommendations, it's not .htaccess specific. Websites should either redirect www.foo -> foo or foo -> www.foo. Presenting a consistent hostname that way can prevent some cookie-related headaches, and will avoid having search engines index different pages under different hostnames.

8. That recipe inadvertently deletes Cache-control: private

runningdogx··on Why You Should Be Using Virtualisation In Your Development Environment
If all you want to do is limit memory usage, process control groups can do that with less overhead than a VM.

kernel/Documentation/cgroups/memory.txt circa line 255

runningdogx··on MySQL Editions
From Monty's presentation about MariaDB, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AL1l9Puh0sk I got the impression that MariaDB is the primary open MySQL fork, with Percona merging their patches and becoming a downstream of MariaDB. Did MariaDB and Percona have a falling out in recent months?
runningdogx··on Brooke the Immortal: An American Child May Hold Secrets to Aging
I think they are obsessing unnecessarily on the semantics of what "development genes" are.

I strongly doubt there is a bright line separating developmental genes from normal steady-state genes. A multicellular organism is one hugely complicated, parallel, state machine. If certain states become unreachable, that doesn't necessarily mean all the genes responsible for those states are no longer doing anything.

runningdogx··on Generating Thoughts, or, the Feynman Family Phrase
Generalizing the the thought patterns De Bono suggests, where you take a thing to be considered, and have a list of "lenses" through which to consider that thing, seems to be very valuable. The same methodology applied to businesses is described in e.g. Gareth Morgan's _Images of Organization_.

The principle flaw of using that technique for decision making is that the n-dimensional consideration space has to be mapped into a single dimension, which can be problematic or impossible. Many intractable debates are the result of inability for two parties to agree on how to map the thought-space (roughly, where each separate aspect of the question is its own dimension) into a simpler (linear) space which facilitates making a decision.

Knowing whether a dinosaur can see into, or get into, your 2nd story bedroom may help for some lines of inquiry, but whenever you instantiate a concept as a less abstract thing, what you gain in intuition, you often lose by introducing artifacts that hold true for the more concrete example but not for the concept itself. This happens all the time in mathematics where a theorem seems to be true when considered in a less abstract simplification, but counterexamples can be found when a more accurate but less intuitive and more abstract conceptual model is used.

runningdogx··on "Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer"
The second comment on scientificamerican.com (by richard2010) after the article explains why we should not dismiss precautionary worry.

There are many other ways radiation can affect microbiology besides directly ionizing atoms.

runningdogx··on Women refuse to go through airport body scanners
Are you sure? There are two different technologies being used in various countries for scanning passengers.

1. millimeter-wave

2. backscatter x-ray (low power)

It is not clear whether mm-wave photons can be biologically damaging. However, there are plenty of articles from the UK claiming that UK body scanners (at least some of them) are x-ray, not mm-wave. Are you saying all of them have it wrong, and that the UK is using 100% mm-wave scanners?

runningdogx··on The House Passed the Health Bill
In no small part, food is medical care. Good food is good preventive medical care. Bad food is like trying to perform a back-alley abortion.

But I take your point. Medical care doesn't have a higher priority, but its nature makes it a more important issue for government to deal with. The statistical nature of medical costs is that the vast majority of people cannot prepare for the worst without buying into an insurance plan of some sort. Food costs, although they can go up a lot during crises, never reach such heights. Barring a severe depression or massive food shortages -- which it should be noted affect everyone, not just a small portion of the population -- people living above poverty can shift their budgets to be able to afford food even if the price goes up 50%. Hardly anyone can modify their budget to be able to afford bypass surgery or treatment for cancer.

However, another side to the issue is that the government already interferes substantially in food costs and food policy. There are substantial subsidies paid to corn and soy farmers, for instance, driving consumer costs of many food products below the actual costs of production if you take away government subsidies.

runningdogx··on The House Passed the Health Bill
I agree everyone should eat a healthy diet and exercise regularly, but that is impossible to verify.

How would the government (or a private insurer for that matter) attempt to verify whether I ate Kashi cereal for breakfast instead of an egg mcmuffin and coke at the nearest mcd's drive-thru? Random blood draws and expensive blood analysis?

How would the government attempt to verify whether I exercised getting my heart rate above 120 for 20 minutes at least 4 times a week? Mandatory wifi-enabled heart-rate monitors for everyone, to be worn 24/7?

In either case, there would be massive fraud, and efforts to combat fraud would lead to wholesale violation of personal privacy in contravention of established 4th amendment constitutional law.

runningdogx··on The end of AI winter?
I don't think Norvig thinks differently; he's just using the term "AI" differently. "AI" in the context of the OP is "strong AI" or AGI (artificial general intelligence). Dr. Norvig takes the term "AI" to also encompass "machine learning" in the sense of developing algorithms that learn within limited problem domains. When Norvig means AGI, he says it explicitly (see the video at around 7:30 to 8:30), and he also says specifically that Google is not interested in general intelligence.
runningdogx··on Beautiful Minds: Relations between genius, creativeness and mental illness
I think a group of humans can certainly be regarded as an organism in its own right. I think far too few people take this "new-age" concept of meta- or super-organisms seriously. However, evolution cannot work in the same way on such meta-organisms.

Intelligence and the emergent phenomena it creates (strategic planning, willful competition) will logically overshadow almost everything else in determining group survival for higher organisms.

I suppose one could make a different but related argument that because certain mood disorders seem to be linked to creativity and intelligence, and because those things confer group advantage (in developing competitive strategy), depression might indirectly provide group advantage.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →