HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

saddlerustle

1,625 karma · joined March 26, 2017

submissionscomments
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
> Avoiding paying more than the US rate doesn't require any of these shenanigans. They could just charge royalties to the US.

I'm not sure exactly what you mean by this

> Dividends are always much lower than profits, and many companies don't do them at all.

Dividends are lower than profits only for companies that have opportunities to reinvest profits into growth. For companies that don't, in principal, you'd expect dividends to be exactly profits.

> Shareholders already own those profits, and cash is reflected pretty directly in share prices. They don't necessarily have to "return" value this way.

There's large opportunity cost to shareholders for companies to hold onto cash, which is usually in low-risk investments, compared to how that shareholder would invest it themselves. That's what I mean by cost-of-capital.

> Many don't.. eg Berkshire.

This is a bit of a special case because Berkshires core business is making investment decisions (and doing so through a holding company is itself tax advantaged). When the day comes the value of Berkshire companies consistently underperforms the market, shareholders will absolutely demand Berkshire start distributing profits instead of making investment decisions on their behalf.

> A small, unsophisticated company doesn't get to (eg) reinvest its profits tax free.

It absolutely can reinvest its profits tax free! It just can't build up a long-term cash pile tax free.

saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
Broadly, the point of these tax structures for US companies isn't for the company to completely avoid paying US corporate tax, it's to

- Avoid paying corporate tax at a higher rate than in the US, and

- Defer paying corporate tax, often for decades, until theres a more favourable tax situation in the US, or a better opportunity to reinvest their capital comes up.

At the end of the day the profits belong to the shareholders and the only way to return the money to shareholders is by paying US corporate tax. Shareholders usually don't mind these arrangements because the tax savings is often more than the cost of capital having the money sitting unproductively.

saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
> Once the cash is in Bermuda, the game is done. The Bermuda company can hold it, buy shares, etc.

A Bermuda subsidiary can't repurchase shares in the US parent company without booking those profits in the US.

saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
Apple pays a regular dividend and does regular share repurchases. Since 2012 its paid out about a half trillion dollars to shareholders. These are equivalent from a corporate accounting point of view, share buybacks are paid out after US corporate taxes are paid. Buybacks are preferred recently just because of the better tax treatment from an investor point of view, it changes nothing for the company.

As for how the money gets to Ireland, most of Apple's non-US operations are subsidiaries of Apple Ireland. For illustration, there's this (somewhat outdated) graph of the revenue flows on wikipedia: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a5/Apple%27...

saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
The majority of Apple's sales is to consumers, so it's equivalent for the sake of argument.
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
That's not how it works at all. Apple Ireland is used to defer taxation on non-US sales, but those profits still needs to be eventually repatriated in order to pay out dividends and fund US R&D, which is the majority of its fixed costs. Profits from US sales stay in the US, and on net Apple Ireland pays Apple US 10's of billions a year.

You can see their filings here: https://core.cro.ie/e-commerce/company/112189

saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
While yes liquidity drives share prices over the short term, as a general rule that's nonsense. What do you think it means for them to be "valued as a commodity"? Why do you think shares have any value at all, or have any connection with company performance? Over just the past 3 years facebook has paid out almost $30 billion to shareholders through repurchases and has plans to pay out $25 billion more. That's the majority of what its market cap was just 8 years ago, and it's still a growing company. Do you think it does that just for the fun of it?
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
No, the value of benefits in kind count towards the income tax band.
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
If that was deemed likely, the company's shares wouldn't be worth anything. Facebook and Google routinely do share buybacks these days (which is equivalent to paying dividends)
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
Companies shifting profits to compensation is better for states than booking corporate profits, because income is taxed at a higher rate.
saddlerustle··on G7: Rich nations back deal to tax multinationals
What you're describing is a method of deferring taxation, not avoiding taxation. Google is a US publicly traded company so its profits ultimately belong to its shareholders, and it can only pay that out via the US.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
"global surveillance by profit-seeking corporations" is a string of scary words, but gossip is much more likely to cause the average person clear, tangible harm. Just pointing out that digital tracking is creepy doesn't do much to convince most people to inconvenience themselves at all.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
Regardless of what those third party companies told their users, users would have had to accept a pretty clear dialog [1] delegating access to their Gmail accounts. That's just how google oauth works.

[1] https://i.stack.imgur.com/aBTMm.png

saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
This is a good point and a good reason to prefer first-party apps!

No need to hide it, Life360 clearly states right near the top of its privacy policy "In order to keep our Service free for most users, we generate revenue through trusted data partnerships. We share device data, including location and movement data, with trusted data Partners for tailored advertising"

saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
I don't recall the Ashley Madison leak having anything remotely similar to the data on OP's list.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
All the internet access examples on that list would use encrypted connections, so a cellular company wouldn't be privy. Cellular companies do have course location data, but to be pedantic that doesn't really apply to any of OP's list.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
That covers one or two of the list I suppose, but is there any reason to believe Akamai is lying to its customers and harvesting their users' data? I can't think of any incentive for them to do that, it would be brazen fraud for an insignificant revenue source.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
That article is just describing gmail APIs, which requires explicit user consent via oauth to enable. This is no more shocking than gmail supporting IMAP.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
Which company, apart from Facebook, Google and Apple, would remotely have access to any of the data on that list? Facebook Google and Apple don't share data with data brokers.
saddlerustle··on 43% of South African youths are not in employment, education or training
"Youth unemployment" is not measured the same as "Youth not in employment, education or training". Spain's 15-29 NEET rate peaked at 28% per the OECD
saddlerustle··on 43% of South African youths are not in employment, education or training
This is not a valid comparison. "Youth Unemployment" is calculated differently than "Youth not in employment, education or training". The equivalent statistic for Spain per the OECD is ~17% now, not 38%.
saddlerustle··on Why we should end the data economy
The direct mail advertising industry was thriving in 1995. You could buy datasets of people by income, car ownership, shopping habits, etc even easier than you can now.
saddlerustle··on 43% of South African youths are not in employment, education or training
For comparison, this is the relevant OECD series: https://i.postimg.cc/vmPyCfNL/img4.png

(via https://data.oecd.org/youthinac/youth-not-in-employment-educ...)

saddlerustle··on Why are house prices rising so fast in a pandemic?
Citation needed. In almost every western city I've looked at construction rates a small fraction of what they were in the 70's, and occupancy rates are at an all time high.

Construction rates in England: https://research.euro.savills.co.uk/_images/350.jpg

Occupancy rate in London: https://i.imgur.com/jX1OpmS.png

saddlerustle··on iOS 14 tracking changes sees big ad spending drop, tumbling prices
And yet when Apple describes how they track where you are, what apps you use, and what news you read for their own advertising platform, they don't use that word [1]

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202074

saddlerustle··on Facebook faces ‘devastating’ EU-to-US data transfer ban
The last published DPC audit found that it does [1]. There's really no reason to subject themselves to huge fines and lie about it, a very small fraction of facebook users delete anything.

The "data dump" you're referring to was probably scraped from public facebook pages before you deleted the account. There has never to my knowledge been a case of private data becoming public that was exfiltrated from facebook proper.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20171218060100/https://www.datap...

saddlerustle··on Facebook faces ‘devastating’ EU-to-US data transfer ban
> Tried to delete FB, ig or WA account completely? Every imaginable Ui obstruction and retention trick will bother you on the way out.

Deleting WhatsApp is Settings -> Account -> Delete My Account -> Delete My Account

Deleting Facebook is Settings -> Account Ownership -> Deactivation and Deletion -> Delete Account (With a very clear choice between deactivation and permanent deletion) -> Delete Account

Compare that to unsubscribing from the New York Times...

saddlerustle··on Facebook faces ‘devastating’ EU-to-US data transfer ban
I guess a US company running that ad would no longer be allowed to do purchase attribution.

More practically through, all of facebook's infrastructure is built on a transparently globally replicated database. Data siloing was only originally considered for launching facebook in China

saddlerustle··on Ads are impersonating government websites in Google results, despite ban
VPNs are pretty mainstream these days. If you talk to anyone working on anti-abuse you'd find the answer to most "Why don't you just.." ideas is because it'd impact many orders of magnitude more legitimate users than victims.
saddlerustle··on Google fined €100M by Italian antitrust over Google Play abuse of dominance
The majority of italians rate the independence of courts to be poor, which is among the lowest ratings in the EU [1]

[1] https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/justice_scoreboar...

← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →