HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sahila

392 karma · joined May 5, 2014

submissionscomments
sahila··on The average college student today
But how far do you go with the blame?

If the universities hold the bar high, they'll risk their funding from parents not wanting to enroll their child and the government not funding a failing school. The blame should be on society?

I think professors are in a good place to actually step up and say no. They're all highly educated individuals who can likely leave academia and get jobs in the private sector. They're best set up to break the cycle.

sahila··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
Wouldn't AI generated art be derivative work done by Google (or whoever) when creating their Gemini models? So then Google owns all gemini created ai artwork?
sahila··on How Many School Shootings? All Incidents from 1966-Present
School being back on isn't a satisfactory answer to why there's a such a large increase. It went from 124 in 2019 to 349 in 2023, nearly 3x as many shootings.

I don't know the answer but I would guess it's either Covid's social isolation effects on people, more societal stress with high inflation, an impending recession, and unknown job future for many, or Tiktok/social media becoming a bigger part of our lives.

sahila··on El Salvador abandons Bitcoin as legal tender
Because if you/they knew that, then they'd be buying more bitcoin.

On a much smaller scale, your dollar goes up by 5% every year but you still use it everyday because all your monies are in dollars. If all your monies are in btc, you'd have to sell to buy things.

sahila··on New Zealand welcomes digital nomads by loosening visitor visa rules
>If anything, it's good for countries to have people coming in whose only effect in the economy is spending their money, better yet, money brought from elsewhere, an immediate net gain to that country's wealth.

This seems debatable, there is an influx of money to asset owning individuals at the expense of most other locals now having more competition for housing and services.

sahila··on Stargate Project: SoftBank, OpenAI, Oracle, MGX to build data centers
> They are not told they need to get an engineering, medical, or finance degree to make going to college worth it, economically.

This is a very well known fact. When I was in high school in the 2000s, it was a well known joke about how the arts / english majors won't land you a job. And even if you never heard about it, the data for average salary for graduates in the college, its dropout rates, and salary by majors is highly publicized. This isn't advanced research to do and in the age of internet, someone considering college should be able to do. I think the problem is no one believes they are the average case and instead are the exception who'll make it work.

sahila··on TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday
> hostile foreign government

I don't take this as a given and I believe the US government has caused more harm to its own people than China has today; US spies on its citizens, unfairly enforces laws against people, create laws that benefit 1% of its citizens to the detriment of the rest, forces its people to go wars they doesn't support, create rules that target certain genders and races, and so on.

Importantly, the US government is able to enact more harm on its citizens than China when it feels like.

sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
Please explain how they get next to nothing? We have a pretty damn functional society - police, firemen, judges, law and order, a military, roads, and the ability for them to do business and get richer. Society entails that those able to provide more, so that's just part of it. We ask able bodied men to most serve on the front lines of our military, mothers most often play the role of raising our youth, we are have a role to play and in return we get live petty peacefully.

Do you have a better model?

sahila··on Olympians turn to OnlyFans to fund dreams due to 'broken' finance system (2024)
No, the biggest factor is that certain sports are more entertaining than others - even individual sports - and I'd pay to watch some but not others. I'd pay more to watch cyclists do the tour de france or tony hawk go on a half-pipe or Mike Tyson fight someone than someone do a long jump; it's just more fun!
sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
Is your opinion that extremely wealthy don't try to reduce their tax share as much as possible, either through clever accounting on their current year taxes or by influencing politicians/policies to lower their taxes directly?

Why do most middle class earners pay more than their millionaire and billionaire counterparts as a percentage? Sure you might say W2 tax rate is higher than capital gains, but why is that the case?

sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
Because no one is actually seriously proposing to pay prisoners the same rate as real firefighters; we just shouldn't be using prisoners. Would you allow prisoners to volunteer as teachers, nurses, engineers? Why is the market for firefighters the only one that gets free volunteers from this pool?

But it's not just hurting the firefighter market, lots of people just have issues with using prisoners as slaves.

sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
Can the prisoners volunteer to be teachers or work at Meta too, or is only one market affected?
sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
Couldn't the same be said of a fire department with a $800,000,000 budget? Clearly they're not doing so hot, we should cut it further.
sahila··on LA wildfires force thousands to evacuate, NASA JPL closed
She cut some 2% of the LA fire department budget, 17M out of 837M. The outrage is politically fueled more than any rationale reasoning.
sahila··on US egg industry kills 350M chicks a year. New tech offers an alternative
Fair enough, but I don't think that would be consistent when applied to people. Which is to say ethics likely isn't that important for most people - we often try our best to prevent death and may even increase someone's suffering to prolong their life.
sahila··on US egg industry kills 350M chicks a year. New tech offers an alternative
When speaking of ethics, how do you measure the ethics of causing pain vs killing? I'd say even a 1% reduction in consumption (killing) is better than whatever pain reduction.

I guess the point is you and others feel so strongly about ways to reduce suffering but couldn't care less about life.

sahila··on U.S. math scores drop on major international test
What subject did you learn in school that you perceive to be useless today? Honestly, I think the baseline learning in math, english, history, and science are all great and should still remain.

That's not to say there aren't useless classes and I think the second language course shouldn't be a hard requirement but otherwise I'm not sure what to the cut. Even PE is key for health.

sahila··on Tokyo is set to introduce a four-day workweek for government employees
What about the nanny wanting a 4 day work week, and what if they have children of their own?
sahila··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
That makes more sense to disable as SMS is expensive. This is still fairly easy to set up yourself using a tool like IFTTT[1] or similar.

[1] https://ifttt.com/search/query/twitter

sahila··on Peloton to charge $95 activation fee for used bikes
> One last point is that I think Peloton gets unfairly targeted for non-use. Gyms, all fitness equipment, even things like boats and motorcycles are frequently bought and never used. Just how consumerism works.

What's different with a Peloton vs others is that there's a ongoing subscription cost, so it sitting around unused with a subscription is a real monthly cost. A better comparison would be a gym membership. Also the Peloton takes a lot of floor place in your home and can't really be stored away.

sahila··on Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious
Because they created the search engine, and truthfully profit motives produce better products at lower costs than non-profits generally across the board. The alternative is having government creating software and it’s hard to point to any public US website/app where I’m amazed.
sahila··on Google is a monopoly – the fix isn't obvious
How does your rationale explain Internet Explore/Edge and Safari which both have abundance of money and still can’t outcompete Chrome? This goes back to the original point about Google search being superior to Bing, and not just because it’s free.
sahila··on How Olympics officials try to catch “motor doping”
What does net net mean in this context? Is the implication that there's more riding ebikes vs regular ones and so they're more active? Hard to imagine that there's people taking long rides on ebikes, if they even last that long (25+ miles rides).
sahila··on Taking away iPhone made daughter a better person
Sometimes I wish we wouldn't limit these studies / conclusions to just children. Certainly children are more susceptible and lack greater control than adults but the negatives of high phone usage and social media propagates throughout society and adults. Of course whereas a parent can take away their daughter's phones, who's to take away ours?
sahila··on Apple unveils 'Passwords' manager app at WWDC 2024
Why do you have the need to use different browsers? Use the one you like on all your devices is easy.
sahila··on Spotify won't open-source Car Thing, but starts refund process
Good to know, appreciate the context.
sahila··on Spotify won't open-source Car Thing, but starts refund process
I'm a bit skeptical about them actually being recycled though. How many of the appliances are recyclable? What parts of them are vs what ends up in the dump? Everything I've heard - and admittedly I haven't looked too deep - is that recycling is mostly a sham and mostly just ends up as waste either here or shipped overseas for someone else to deal with.
sahila··on Ilya Sutskever to leave OpenAI
Maybe “better the devil you know than the devil you don't” applies?
sahila··on Microsoft CTO: Thoughts on OpenAI (2019)
Sure and not to discredit your observation, but what other observations have you made in the last 5 years that didn’t pan out? Regarding politics, sports, stock market, covid, or other tech trends? The evaluation can’t be looking back, and if you’re right about 1/10 things, would that warrant a $1b investment in each?
sahila··on Cardio fitness is a strong, consistent predictor of morbidity and mortality
Your comment just gave me a thought of how cool would it be if society had a mandated activity hour in the morning. I’m imagining loud speakers attached to poles outside making announcements and all businesses closed for that hour, and people all out and about exercising, walking, running, talking. Yes it’s a bit like school but society can be so much better if we prioritized good living!
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →