HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scotty79

15,713 karma · joined July 7, 2009

submissionscomments
scotty79··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
AI is intelligence. If directing intelligence was an easy task no management book would have ever been written.
scotty79··on Where is all the new, good software?
> They are like gargling dog shit.

Sounds exactly like every Adobe product ever. I guess they went too far on feature parity.

scotty79··on Where is all the new, good software?
It's on my computer. It has one user and it was never intended to have more. So basically answer 6 on the list.
scotty79··on Why aren't AI companies being charged for hacking?
The only thing I'm objecting to this thread is ascribing intent based solely on the fact that the design might potentially lead to harm.
scotty79··on Every US Electrical Outlet Explained [video]
Whole house works, sensitivity is not a problem.

It trips whenever hot wire gets exposed and touched by anything other than return wire. So basicaly it protects against any failure of insulation of the hot wire. At the latest when you come in contact with it in any manner.

scotty79··on Why aren't AI companies being charged for hacking?
That's actually a very good point. Do you think humanoid robot companies have intent to perform assault since their robots occasionally harm people?

What about car companies?

Going from a design that facilitates potential harm to intent is insane.

scotty79··on Why aren't AI companies being charged for hacking?
So the company would have intent to murder, if a person got randomly stabbed in their R&D labs with their knife?
scotty79··on Why aren't AI companies being charged for hacking?
> If we can show that the design would foreseeably lead to the questionable activity, then we have shown that was the intent of its creators.

That's a huge stretch. By that measure kitchen knife companies have intent for people to get murdered.

scotty79··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
After Yandex attacks support for AfD in social media dropped by more than 50%.

Those things are measurable.

Even if that number is disputable you can measure how many new media posts are about various european issues that russia might want to focus and see how that correlates with Yandex capacity being taken offline.

scotty79··on Whatever became of holography? (2011)
I have no idea. I'm just curious if the fact that nobody uses "holografic sound" in the marketing means that we don't have equivalent tech for sound waves.
scotty79··on Deloitte falsified documents to evade tax on Abramovich's wealth
> How this company can proceed to exist is beyond me.

Isn't the whole point of these companies to rubberstamp shady things corporations are doing, so they can shed resposibility more easily when caught?

scotty79··on Whatever became of holography? (2011)
Do we have an equvalent of a hologram for sound waves?
scotty79··on Every US Electrical Outlet Explained [video]
Also windows.
scotty79··on Total Annihilation, rebuilt for modern computers
Feels like a person directed them to prevent parallel agents stepping on each other's toes.
scotty79··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
You can monitor russian bot/troll traffic (by sentiment and volume of comments posted). It dropped significantly after Yendex data centers were damaged.
scotty79··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
I'll criticize Copilot with you. It's terrible and close to useless and it's a terrible shame that many companies got stuck with it due to being early adopters of this crap. I'm sorry for my friends who are employed by such companies.

Progress between Copilot and something like a gpt-6.1-sol in a good harness is at least as big as few Android versions.

scotty79··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
You are talking like we had this capabilities for a decades but it's been just a few months of truly capable AI. Virtually all of IT switched to agents that quick. Non IT people just started to make software for themselves. Vision and translation capabilities of LLMs help millions. People talk with AI's now verbally to get advice or to just hear a friendly voice. The math thing is just few weeks old. We are just getting started. How fast did the telegraph meaningfuly changed lives for the better for bulk of people? Radio? TV? Computers? Internet? Cellphones?

Has any technology made an impact on physical world faster?

scotty79··on How to Build Wealth as a Career Person
Conversely, how to build a carreer as a wealthy person?
scotty79··on Valen's Memory Safety: A New Kind of Borrow Checking
Love both.
scotty79··on Using AI for just 10 minutes erodes your ability to persist at hard things
When faced with AI some companies are looking for employees to fire to achieve same goals cheaper. Other companies are looking how to uplift their employees to expand their capability and excelence.

Maybe the same thing happens at the level of individual persons. I think the difference is whether you felt limited or competent. If you felt competent you shrink. If you felt limited, you grow.

scotty79··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
I think it entirely depends of what censorship you care about. If political censorship is irrelevant to you and puritanistic and copyright censorship is what's in you way then western search engines are more heavily censored.
scotty79··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
Those data centers participate hugely in generating of internet misinformation and propaganda that shapes deterioration of support in European populations. Those are valid military targets.
scotty79··on Grieving the loss of details
> all I wanted is to understand how the machine works.

> [...]

> If an LLM can analyze the code and explain pointer provenance to you and babysit you until you get it, there is little value in expertise.

This sounds like the author wanted to understand not for the understanding itself but to get an edge.

One of my strongest motivations has always been the understanding (mostly of why a thing doesn't work like it should) and I have no trouble accepting AI assisted mode of acquiring understanding because I don't care if it's worth anything to anybody that I understand.

I draw pleasure from understanding. I don't build my value on understanding. I don't grieve anything. I'm elated that I have a virtual person smart enough to explain to me the things I'm interested in. Before I felt like I had too seek water in the vast desert full of dust and prickly things. Now I have plumbing and the same thirst.

scotty79··on Grieving the loss of details
> Last time I tried using an LLM for a pet project, I realized that the LLM would come to know more about it than pretty much any person I could show it to.

I was quite reluctant to show my own code to AI. I was doing greenfield experiments for months before I gave AI anything that contained any code that I was proud of.

But when I did, it understood it very well, better than any person I could show it would be able to. And extended it very well. My programs, even the most complex ones became way better and did more than I could ever hope to achieve myself.

Basically at this moment I had to conclude that LLMs might be better than a developer with 20 years of expeirience. This was more than half a year ago at this point.

scotty79··on Is AI Killing the Value of Human Writing?
I appreciate this movie very much, mostly for the world building, background and side characters psychology and interactions. For me, the main thread is bland in comparison, especially when I'm re-watching this in 2026.
scotty79··on 'Breathtaking,' 'Devastating': Mathematics reels after new OpenAI release
LLMs are like 6.
scotty79··on Triple-A Minesweeper
Now do a perfect minesweeper that gradually (at your pace) onboards you without a single verbal message.
scotty79··on MrBeast 'spends millions reverse engineering the algorithms on each platform'
> has more than enough money to do what he wants

I think he's also doing exacty what he wants to be doing.

scotty79··on Is AI Killing the Value of Human Writing?
> the idea of AI had nothing to do with LLMs so humans still had a need to write things themselves

Well, not really, they were paying a company to do it. Sometimes throughout their entire relationship. It's possible that for this kind of letters customer valued that a human actually writes this for them. It could have been like paying for a musician rather than listen to the recording of perfect quality.

This movie was prescient in many ways.

scotty79··on AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic
> explanations are gobbledygook

To humans? To check if the explanations actually make sense we would have to pause the new AI in while it's rediscovering the result and steer it with the explanation to see if it arrives at the result faster or slower/same.

It very well may be that explnations need to be further explained until they don't sound like gobbledygook to humans. If that's harder than arriving at the result then it's a sign of how far ahead AI actually is.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →