HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

scotty79

15,714 karma · joined July 7, 2009

submissionscomments
scotty79··on How Protein Took over the World
> that "fiber" is chemically modified resistant starch

So basically toss a shovel of potato starch into your protein shake and be done with it. It's flavored so strongly to make whey protein palatable that you won't even notice.

scotty79··on Bitwarden Dual License Model
I'll be moving to PearPass ... there's really no reason for any company to hold my passwords for me.
scotty79··on Lobbying Is Corruption
"Corruption is BAD"
scotty79··on REA Reverse – Engineer Anything
By that definition scarcely any bug gets fixed ever. Perfect is the mortal enemy of good.

Also I don't think it's an honest take. You took this stance because the change was done by AI. If a person patched MS app he uses that had a bug that bothered him for a decade you would be more appreciative.

scotty79··on Show HN: Let your AI agents paint big arrows, boxes and text on your screen
Quite uselsess, it doesn't tell me which file to edit, what to put in there, nor what command to invoke with what arguments.

People can do and do better with googling. Proportion of people who found the answer to that question through apropos to people who found that answer googling is probably less than a million to one.

scotty79··on Food processing influences metabolism and brain activity
I wonder how they managed to put in same amount of salt in the low processed meal. That cheese must be super salty.

I'd also wonder what would happen if they didint use heat treated carbs in the ultraptocessed one. If I were to guess I think they might be main offenders.

scotty79··on Show HN: Let your AI agents paint big arrows, boxes and text on your screen
Not if I can't do

apropos switch desktop to dark mode

and

aprops set dns to 8.8.8.8

scotty79··on Show HN: Let your AI agents paint big arrows, boxes and text on your screen
I don't understand this question. Please elaborate.
scotty79··on Why are coding agents so dumb?
> My dream agent

I have no idea what stops that person from just making it, with an agent of course.

scotty79··on Show HN: Let your AI agents paint big arrows, boxes and text on your screen
In 40 year software designers couldn't figure out that there should be a search function for every functionality that your computer provides.

When we got a form of such search, it searched all of the internet alongside with the functions of your software on your computer. You had to tell it manually what software you have and when it found something you had to fish out the description of what to click to get the functionality you are seeking and then click through some dumb ui to actually invoke it.

Agents are the first thing that can lead you directly from "I know what I want my computer to do." to "Actually doing it."

Success of agents is founded on the profound and sustained failure of all of the software designers and developers ever.

scotty79··on Pointing AI at archives found a forgotten meteorite, lost rhinos, and more
I didn't read it beyond few fragments about meteorite. But I enjoyed the rhino.
scotty79··on Pointing AI at archives found a forgotten meteorite, lost rhinos, and more
I'm sure that if he didn't do what he did, he would lear about Dutch East India Company so so very much.

Remember that even junk food is more food than junk and you can survive on it for years.

scotty79··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
If DeepSeek was smart enough. There's a huge risk that it isn't since the only model that ultimately succeeded was Opus 5.5 (sol and astra were tried before).
scotty79··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
I think he has 5-10 of $200 subs, but yes, that's the general idea.
scotty79··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
You can count tokens that were used on your subscriptions and mutliply them by token api prices to get a memeworthy very large number.
scotty79··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
He uses it for his real code bases to speed up their compilation and opensourced it so the application might be wider than motivation.
scotty79··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
> Ouch, that is brutal and honestly, quite embarrassing but confirms what I have been seeing for a while.

What's most interesting is that Opus wasn't told to toss out the Codex crap. It decided to do that on its own. Which might mean that LLMs are actually getting a reasonable taste.

I've seen on youtube that some guy implemnted game engine with Astra and Claude. Astra wasn't really given fair chance because it didn't decide to work as long as Claude and the guy didn't force it. But still, scripting code within the engine that came from Astra was chaotic, messy, piling up things, but the code that Claude made looked downright pleasant.

scotty79··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
> problems are being solved autonomously by AI prompters who have no interest in the broader field itself once their initial target is "solved"

This is pretty much what a person that proivded patronage to a matematician used to be. API prompters are people who provide patronage for AI mathematicians.

You don't talk with them about the discoveries. About discoveries you should talk with who actually made them. Namely the LLMs.

Another analogy might by that you shouldn't expect to have interesting discussion about the essence of art with art producer.

Just thank them for the inference they covered and interact with the results instead.

scotty79··on It may soon be possible to create "mirror life"
It's nowhere close to being possible. To do anything related to life you need to have a lot of complex molecules. When you do things with normal life you can have genetically modified organisms that will produce whatever substance you need in whatever amount you need.

To get mirror substances you need to create them chemically which is PITA even if possible.

I highly recommend watching an interview with a person that achieved best results so far with creating artificial normal (for some definitions of normal) almost life from the grounds up.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4WywVQfIV4

There is a section of whether this kind of work enables creation mirror life as well.

scotty79··on What's Earth's dominant species by mass?
So, did the cows achieve great evolutionary success, or terrible tragic failure?
scotty79··on Mistral Large 4
Do you doubt? Already plenty of people prefer people skills of AI chatbots to those of other people.
scotty79··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
Sorry, I didn't mean his personal signature, just some signature that AI makes for the work it creates.
scotty79··on Mistral Large 4
I'm afraid it might be the other way around. RSI might pick all of the low hanging fruit soon. There must be a physical limit of how much intelligence you can squeeze out of some amount of parameters and compute.

There are going to still be worthwhile improvements but they are going to be more like not how to make transformers 10x cheaper but how to make next training run cost 9 trillions instead of 10 with a very particular optimization designed at the cost of hundreds of millions for this one specific run.

scotty79··on Mistral Large 4
I wish US was rich enough to subsidise development of open source science and useful open AI models. I wouldn't mind US waging this kind of wconomic warefare against China or everyone else on the world.

Charity and kindness is not a motivation, it's an outcome of what you do.

scotty79··on Mistral Large 4
I think the moat is going to be compute. So far compute needed to push the frontier is still extremely cheap so the capital can afford to spread its bets. But when further improvement is going to cost in trillions, capital will have to pick a winner and bet only on him. It won't be a matter of finding the best bet, it will be a matter of survival.

This will cause the picked winner to get massively ahead with sheer compute alone used both for training and inference dedicated to recursive self improvement.

scotty79··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
Image generation models are not LLMs and are significantly dumber.

We are probably some years away from a strong LLM with natively visual output.

scotty79··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
Maybe you could tell it to put in your signature to avoid putting in a random one in a spot that the model decides should contain a signature?
scotty79··on Why Common Lisp is now the best programming language
> the language you know best is the best one

I almost never read the code now so how well I know the language is pretty irrelevant.

What's most important is how well the language can give feedback to LLM while developing.

Second most important factor is how good technically is the final artifact.

Rust seems to be quite good for both.

Speed of iteration would be cool but LLM thinking takes the bulk of time anyways.

Live debug through something other than computer use would be cool as well but I don't know how well LLMs can use auch things for any given language. I just usually tell it to heavily instrument code and put in debug bridges in the app its building to inspect and ivoke stuff while the app is running.

scotty79··on Anthropic Subscriptions Offer 5x+ More Value Than OpenAI
There's a simple explanation here.

Anthropic has way more inflated api token priced than OpenAI what is plainly visible on cost charts.

scotty79··on Questions for Believers in AI Consciousness
When I see a cat chasing something while he sleeps I can pretty much be sure he dreams. Thus by my count he's conscious.

I'm not really sure if Charcot-Wilbrand actually means lack of dreams since REM sleep still seems to be going on. I think we just have less evidence for the dreaming.

Of course there might be dreaming people that are unconscious but I don't think we believe unconscious people are actually devoid of consciousness in philosophical sense.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →