HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sgt101

7,940 karma · joined January 24, 2012

nothing to see here, move along, move along.
submissionscomments
sgt101··on Scallop – A Language for Neurosymbolic Programming
Anything can do anything else given enough time and power, but I think: no, not without shenanigans. This has primitives for interfacing to nn's including foundation models so you can ask it (for example) to label images of cats and dogs using clip, then you can reason over the results.

So it's intended to combine nn reasoning and logical reasoning cleanly.

sgt101··on The political economy of Manus AI
Ironically the OP is called A_D_E_P_T - ADEPT was the first "proper agent project" I got involved in, back in 1996! I just looked at a couple of deliverables & tidied a demo as it was closing then, but then I did more work on lots of old MAS projects for years after.

Here's the thing - we failed.

Why? Three things.

- service providers like Expedia, Lastminute.com, Zwillow did the data integration by hand. They were able to afford to do this (the bit we didn't expect) because they were able to attract adverts and charge a transaction fee. They had a business model.

- Specific applications like the HMRC self-assessment were able to offer a user experience that gave close control and easy completion. The agents we built were able to do easy completion but they took control off the user and could not perform at 100%. Users were not confident and so didn't use them.

- We did most of the work pre iPhone, so we didn't have the right interface. Of course that has changed... but the Appstore also changed things and user expectations are sky high now.

It was also fersum difficult to program proper MAS. The issue is creating a system based on the expectation of behavior of many other systems which is of course a combinatorial mind bender. We mitigated this a bit with ideas from economics and game theory, but I think we were a long way off solving it.

LLM's do provide extra capability for solving some of these problems, and you young people are so clever and hard working that maybe you can just blitz through some of the others. I can't get at Manus yet, but I don't really expect that it will be a proof of this.

sgt101··on The political economy of Manus AI
Also, I think it's existence might disrupt the financial system shomeewhat!
sgt101··on Gemma3 – The current strongest model that fits on a single GPU
vibe testing, vibe model engineering...
sgt101··on What made the Irish famine so deadly
So, when you say "they" you mean the Protestant Irish ruling class?
sgt101··on UK homes install subsidised heat pumps at record level
I think that this is a new(ish) thing though. When the UK was pulling gas out of the Irish Sea and the North Sea for domestic heating gas was much much cheaper than electricity. Then gas started being used at scale for electricity generation (the so called dash for gas). Then we moved to just in time import gas and things got very expensive.

So - things have changed.

sgt101··on Why Quantum Engineering Is Emerging as a Distinct Industrial Sector
Look at what the major banks are doing.

All of them have some sort of post quantum security program.

None of them have deployed post quantum security at scale.

To me this means that they have a estimate of >10 years <30 years for Q day.

I disagree with them - I think >20 years < 50 years... but wtf do I know! I'm a fella on the internet with an axe to grind :)

sgt101··on Why Quantum Engineering Is Emerging as a Distinct Industrial Sector
When I was asked to work on this stuff (I didn't want to because I knew very little about it, but it was a "do you like eating hot food and sleeping inside" kind of moment) I got this book: https://amzn.eu/d/chnBwVy

I think it provides very useful abstractions for thinking about QC.

sgt101··on UK homes install subsidised heat pumps at record level
I think that the issue is claimed to be that the pump will use lots of electricity trying to keep up with the heat escaping and therefore will not be economical.
sgt101··on UK homes install subsidised heat pumps at record level
Super interesting - more info like this helps.

I have a 17th Century cottage and the folks came and just said that there was no point at all... maybe they were clueless!

sgt101··on UK homes install subsidised heat pumps at record level
Climate wise: yes.

Housing stock wise: not so much.

Heat pumps seem really good for well insulated modern houses, much of the UK's housing stock is >100years old and pretty drafty.

sgt101··on Apple M3 Ultra
indeed, it does not.

I am thinking that 7 A100's would be the lowest price for that, and that would be $80k with good discounts.

sgt101··on The Differences Between Deep Research, Deep Research, and Deep Research
I think it's normal to invest authority in a report that someone else has prepared - people take what is written on trust because the person who prepared it is accountable for any errors... not just now, but forever.

LLM's are not accountable for anything.

sgt101··on The Differences Between Deep Research, Deep Research, and Deep Research
Isn't this the worst possible case for an LLM? The integrity of the product is central to the value of it and the user is by definition unable to verify that integrity?
sgt101··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
I think this shows the problem of non fiscal pegs - the value of rare earths or duterium is going to be impacted by technical change. For example let's say that a new processing technique means that a rare earth can be extracted at 20% of the current cost, or a new deposit is discovered. The whole economy is now flexed around this change... which has nothing to do with the economy.

I don't think that there is a fixed asset that could be suitable as a proper peg.

sgt101··on The Demoralization is just Beginning
The two UK cases:

- Nazi pug man got a fine of £800; no jail.

- Cheshire people; in the context of rioting and the consequences of rioting.

For the record I think (personal view only) that the Nazi pug man should never have been prosecuted, I personally find it grossly offensive but I think that the harm of stopping people saying these things is greater than the harm of the idiot saying them.

The Cheshire thing I find much more serious, it seemed to me that this was about people calling for other people to get hurt and killed. Is it really the case that it's ok to threaten people or to call for violence against a community in the USA?

Also, what about folks like Snowdon and Assange? I mean if freedom of speech is absolute in the USA why can't they just tell the CCP about USA nuclear control?

sgt101··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
I understand the points you are making above and can see that they are backed by the data. I was clearly thoughtless identifying Australia as the opposite of England in terms of available land.

In England I believe that low rise apartments are a big part of the solution. Currently almost all apartments in England are one or two bedrooms, and additionally the buildings are aimed at the luxury single market. If planning laws made four distinct rooms at least 3m * 3m mandated in 50% of new build apartments then they would become viable for family living. After Grenfell it's simply impossible for England to use high rise apartments to solve this problem, but I have stayed with friends in Germany who lived in a block of large apartments on four stories in Saarbrücken and they seemed ideal and worked for them as a family.

sgt101··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
I don't expect the private sector to fix it spontaneously if left to it's own devices.

This is (as you flag) a specifically political problem - not a commercial one. There are political fixes which are available, but have not been taken. There are planning reforms, and fiscal reforms, that could change the housing market very significantly - without enabling a free for all that would simply result in the creation of thousands of five bedroom des res's all over the home counties. This would not salve the real social ills that bad and limited housing have created, but it would destroy what's left of the countryside. England is as densely populated as India, and we need to manage what happens to land in our country in a way that Australia and the USA doesn't.

sgt101··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
I looked this up (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_centre#Global_Financ... ) and I think you have got things wrong.
sgt101··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
This - the economy rode on financialisation and north sea oil for the two decades before 2008. Since 2008 there has been no real action to resolve the core issue of unlocking the potential of the North of England - everyone knows that that is low hanging fruit (human capital, regional infrastructure etc) but no one will actually take the risk and go for it.
sgt101··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
“To do so, it need simply remove the barriers that stop the private sector from doing what it already wants to do.”

Which is fine if resources were infinite or distribution was equal, but neither are true and the private sector will not safe guard the public sphere of the environment.

In any case, plain as day, the big problem with the UK economy was and is the 2008 financial crisis that chopped 5% of GDP off the economy. Since then every government has been faced with either doing what would be needed to make things right, or doing what is needed to get reelected. They have all picked the second option apart from Boris Johnson's administration through to Truss, who picked electoral destruction through magical thinking (on Northern Ireland and then by raising spending without raising tax to pay for it, precipitating first a crisis of politics and second a crisis of finance).

sgt101··on A Path to Scalable Quantum Computers
>>A future step is to incorporate transparent conducting windows in the trap to enable light transmission while screening unwanted charging effects. A future problem to tackle is how to integrate necessary ultraviolet beams into the trap, for which charging effects have proved even more challenging.

So at least two scientific breakthroughs required before scaling.

It's great research, really fun - but years away from (doubtful) application

sgt101··on Germany's Water Consumption Down 17% Following Nuclear Reactor Shutdowns
well - more Russian oligarch funding to be fair.
sgt101··on Germany's Water Consumption Down 17% Following Nuclear Reactor Shutdowns
I think that they are importing much more gas, and that's been very painful, economically, because it was expected to come from Russia... but it hasn't (directly).

I also think that there has been an increase in wind and solar - but Germany isn't in the greatest place for either of these geographically.

The French people are getting a bad deal, having subsidized their nuclear fleet for fifty years it's now being heavily used to provide high cost export electricity to Germany and the UK, meaning that the French grid price is also high despite their probity and sense in building out nuclear.

sgt101··on The XB-70 (2019)
Does anyone know why they went for six engines rather than four bigger ones? Was there a specific reason for that config?
sgt101··on Strategic Wealth Accumulation Under Transformative AI Expectations
I think she's quite open with the clients about what she's charging for and how she's delivering.

I think "quite possibly malpractice" does a lot of work. It's "quite possibly malpractice" to use an associate to draft an opinion. The associate could secretly take photos of the document and sell them to the opposition or the press, the associate could make stuff up, the associate could get drunk in a bar and tell everyone what they are doing. Who knows. You better have appropriate management controls, working practices and training in place! Even partners do this stuff sometimes though...

It could also be malpractice to use a networked computer to prepare documents - that could be hacked into and your duty of care could be shown to be breached.

If there's no deception and appropriate care is taken then is there an issue?

sgt101··on Strategic Wealth Accumulation Under Transformative AI Expectations
I know one !

She's got international experience and connections but moved to a small town. She was a magic circle partner years ago. Now she has a FTTP connection and has picked up a bunch of contracts that she can deliver on with AI. She underbid some big firms on these because their business model was traditional rates, and hers is her cost * x (she didn't say but >1.0 I think)

Basically she uses AI for document processing (discovery) and drafting. Then treats it as the output of associates and puts the polish on herself. She does the client meetings too obviously.

I don't think her model will last long - my guess is that there will be a transformation in the next 5 years across the big firms and then she will be out of luck (maybe not at the margin though). She won't care - she'll be on the beach before then.

sgt101··on New horizons for Julia
well done that man
sgt101··on New horizons for Julia
Yes - the error reporting has always been one of my complaints about Julia (although it's hugely improved). I think that the Julia dev community are really really interested in cool language features and optimisations but much less empathic with numpties like me that can't understand why their code crashes. More work on this would be much better.

Although it's a bit of an challenge to get the interpreter to understand which thing that's out of scope should be in scope for the code to work (because it's all out of scope..)

sgt101··on You can’t build a moat with AI (redux)
Yeah - these are not moats though.

Moats are the logistic network that Amazon has.. ok spend $10bn over 5 years and then come at me - if I didn't sit still...

Moats are what Google has in advertising... ok, pull 3% of the market for more money than god and see if it works..

brand/ux is not a moat, it's table stakes.

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →