HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shanusmagnus

1,401 karma · joined April 8, 2012

submissionscomments
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
I'm not the author, but obligatory "not sure why this is being down-voted." I've been wondering about Graeber for a while, since his work seems suspiciously close to "messages certain people desperately want to hear" and I have strong priors against those accounts, regardless of which "side" they come from.

Would love to hear perspective on this. The book would be a serious investment.

shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
This was like the perfect HN recommendation -- something I never would have thought of, with enough context to show why I should care. Will read both these, thank you.
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
I tried to read The Goal and bounced off due in part to the aforementioned writing style, which seemed super trite and straw-mannish. Does the fact that you keep re-reading the books suggests that you haven't found a better way to re-approach that material?
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
Thank you for teaching me a new word! (limerence)
shanusmagnus··on Ask HN: Any interesting books you have read lately?
Obligatory critique about Why We Sleep, in case you haven't seen it.

https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/

shanusmagnus··on Vim Boss
I guess you're right, the logic you describe is simple, but I submit that there's a more fundamental logic: If the folks who split away pull people out of the original community, it means there was demand for the things that prompted the split in the first place.

If Neovim had nothing to offer vs vanilla Vim, nobody would have followed them. This seems like efficient exploration of an idea space, to me, and something to be celebrated.

shanusmagnus··on Many people in finance, sales and management feel their jobs are pointless
Haha, yeah, that's not a bad comparison. Adults intoxicated to a helpful degree behave kind of like children before the modern world grinds away their joy.
shanusmagnus··on Many people in finance, sales and management feel their jobs are pointless
FIRE is a good cautionary example, but I think it makes the point I wanted to get at: people start out as little meaning-making machines. They connect deeply with each other, interact easily, enjoy their lives. Then we ruin that.

The FIRE community have won the ruined game -- they're what you get when you remove the financial need, but keep the same psychological objective function, keep the same screwed-up sociality. They might be lounging by the pool but they're still stuck in the old mode of being. The ones who transcend the old workday-grind-mode are doing great. But that's non-trivial.

There was a really good article on this that I found recently ... Ah yes, here it is [1]. This is a thought-provoking take on a similar topic.

[1] https://charleseisenstein.substack.com/p/notes-on-privilege

shanusmagnus··on Many people in finance, sales and management feel their jobs are pointless
My conviction is that there are literally infinite ways to be useful, and always will be, even if the robot overlords work perfectly, which they won't.

My other conviction is that people find their own meaning with absurd ease when they're children. Then that becomes non-viable. If it ever were to become viable again -- if they didn't have to work at the gas station to cling to existence that keeps them from sleeping under a bridge -- then their ability to find meaning will come back.

shanusmagnus··on Ed Yong is leaving The Atlantic
I hope you find someone to love you.
shanusmagnus··on Critical theory is radicalizing high school debate
This strikes me as a similar technique to trying to jailbreak an LLM to answer your questions without all the safety neutering -- you're trying to convince the judges to eval your new rules of debate, and then interpret your utterances in that new context.
shanusmagnus··on LLaMA2 Chat 70B outperformed ChatGPT
Just one of many problems :)
shanusmagnus··on LLaMA2 Chat 70B outperformed ChatGPT
I don't (and didn't) think creativity was simple, but the task was super simple (alternate uses task). The fact that people couldn't agree on how creative the answers were to such a simple task was the insight, although maybe it was only an insight because I was naive.
shanusmagnus··on Ed Yong is leaving The Atlantic
Another way to think about it is that up till now, if you had subscribed to The Atlantic, you would have got him + a bunch of other writers in the bundle. To me, what the a-la-carte model has revealed is what media-savvy people had always said it would reveal: a bunch of individual writers who all want me to pay $70 a year to get their periodic newsletter updates.

"If only my five favorites would get together and do something collectively, I'd pay $100 a year," I thought to myself. "And I'd bet they'd get vastly more subscribers and come out way ahead."

Whoever said there are only two business models, bundling and un-bundling, seems to be right, as far as I can tell. I'm looking forward to the next bundling cycle.

shanusmagnus··on Fabricated data in research about honesty
Good paper on this topic:

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4046264

Chater, N., & Loewenstein, G. (2022). The i-frame and the s-frame: How focusing on individual-level solutions has led behavioral public policy astray. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 1–60. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X22002023

shanusmagnus··on LLaMA2 Chat 70B outperformed ChatGPT
I get more excited at the prospect of popping into some random cafe, SSHing from my iPad into some vast.ai server and setting loose this giant AI brain on whatever stuff. Feels badass.
shanusmagnus··on LLaMA2 Chat 70B outperformed ChatGPT
Ugh, when I was doing my PhD work we were studying creativity in an experiment, and we needed an assessment for how creative different solutions were, and trying to get inter-rater reliability on this quite simple thing was just agonizing.

I wound up abandoning the experiment because getting enough reliability would have required screwing down the standards so tightly that it would have ruined the underlying point of the thing.

shanusmagnus··on Cultivating a state of mind where new ideas are born
A lot of random noise, for sure. But also as much signal as there is to be had in this world. And even noise is usually interesting when it's so highly personalized. Which maybe means there is far less noise than people think?
shanusmagnus··on Cultivating a state of mind where new ideas are born
I've stumbled onto a similar algorithm, trying to pay attention to when I feel strongly about things, good things and bad things. Then I try to dig into what's under there (if it's bad) and figure out how to go further into it (if good). It's been helpful so far. "Follow your nose" for sure.
shanusmagnus··on A relatively small amount of force applied at just the right place
Can you say more about this? Why Welch specifically, vs other important execs over time?
shanusmagnus··on You Suck at Excel (2015) [video]
I've gotten a long way in life never using Excel except to type things in cells for my idiot former company which used it as a word processor, which made me hate it with all my heart.

And yet I assume, based on the slavish devotion to it by others, that it is actually great if you know how to use it effectively. Aside from this video, where can I learn the foundations as quickly as possible so that I can do cool things with it?

shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
You're very welcome. I'm jealous of you, having James to look forward to!
shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
Well my friend:

Everything (really) by Erving Goffman. A beautiful synthesis is [1] which I might recommend over the original material (sacrilege!) if you were only going to read one thing.

We (as Western Civilization, maybe) have still (imo) not come to terms with the bounty that is William James. I had negligible interest in religion, but if you're into the weird mix of psychoanalysis, sociology, and deep thought, I cannot recommend [2] enough. I read it over the course of a year, annotated the margins like the faithful annotate their holy texts (do they do that?) and many evenings still open a page, read randomly, and ponder.

I had never really considered what an institution really was, or how it came to be, or what was implicit / assumed in interacting with it. This classic prompted much fruitful imagining [3] although it's the most difficult reading of them all.

Given your tastes, you may have slogged through a bunch of philosophy and hated it. The good news (or maybe the bad news) is that this is super fun and easy to read and gives you most of the same nutrients [4] as certain schools, and has obvious contemporary relevance besides.

This scratches a proximate itch [5].

I'm a little sheepish bc all of these (except for maybe [5]) are deep classics and are, in a sense, obvious for that reason. And yet I have a PhD in a related field and never actually _read_ any of them, so maybe they won't be obvious to you either :)

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Goffman-Reader-Charles-Lemert/dp/1557...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Varieties_of_Religious_Exp...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Social_Construction_of_Rea...

[4] https://www.amazon.com/Supersizing-Mind-Embodiment-Cognitive...

[5] https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/alien-phenome...

shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
On a similar journey, just came across sociocracy as one such trying to keep the flame alive [1]. What was interesting for me was to recognize the pieces of such a structure informally existing, in a giant mega-company I worked for. In a vast bureaucratic ecosystem, way down at the forest floor interesting things can happen that the canopy dwellers have no idea about. Of course, being informal, it can only go so far, as the OA describes.

[1] https://www.sociocracyforall.org/sociocracy/

shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
I read an article on exactly that premise -- how to destroy a group by making sure that it accomplished nothing -- and your strategy was implicit in there. I tried to link it but I can't -- oh wait, it's part of a CIA field manual [1]. Simple but containing deep wisdom.

[1] https://www.openculture.com/2022/01/read-the-cias-simple-sab...

shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
This kind of thing is exactly my jam. I read Becker about a year ago and it set off a landslide that has still not settled. Much appreciate the others, I have made note of them.
shanusmagnus··on The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
Thanks so much for this list! I'm always on the prowl for things to read that changed how people see the world, but explicit attempts to solicit examples have proved surprisingly unsuccessful. And here you just volunteered it :)
shanusmagnus··on Apple Vision
The fact that "the author" is Ben Thompson is worth something.
shanusmagnus··on Everything you always wanted to know about mathematics (2013) [pdf]
I've been very interested in this method for a while. How do you find the math that would solve them? Is it well-understood, or is it easy to figure out in practice? Would love to hear more about how this looks for you practically.
shanusmagnus··on Kanboard: free and open source Kanban project management software
LogSeq has suffered a lot, imo, since they took venture funding. Their focus has wavered drastically since then, shipping features nobody is asking for that I can only assume are viewed to be differentiating for other PKMs (e.g., canvas) vs making the thing performant, improving the wretched UI, fixing bugs, etc.

Obsidian may not be open source, but it reflects a sane approach to product: small, focused team, profitable company, delivering useful stuff. Clean and tight. It's got a different set of abstractions at its core (document model vs block model) but if you're indifferent to that, Obsidian is where I'd start.

← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →