HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shutupalready

429 karma · joined October 2, 2013

submissionscomments
shutupalready··on What Do We Want, Really?
We need to be thankful that pockets of extreme nonconformity exist to show an alternative to groupthink. People are so eager to mock or crush any diversity. Average people can't stand the idea that there are places in the world with extreme differences like (a) much higher or lower tax (using the U.S. as reference point), (b) drug attitudes far softer or much worse, (c) political structures (even the "evil" ones, speaking from the American POV), (d) far different cultural attitudes about sex, marriage, drinking, and every other moral issue. If the world didn't have all this diversity, we'd never know that there's an alternative to what we thought was the best way.
shutupalready··on Virtually all TV comedies, from Seinfeld to South Park, follow a simple formula
> television has developed increasingly dense visual shorthand

What are some examples of this "visual shorthand"? Preferably examples from a popular show (like The Simpsons) so I can really understand what you mean.

Would a 1950's audience understand the visual shorthand if they saw today's TV, or is this something you have to grow up with?

shutupalready··on The Rise of Men Who Don’t Work – And What They Do Instead
> companies hoarding cash instead of spending it

I've heard this sentiment many times but I've wondered if there's an economic fallacy there. Would the economy be better off if lots of companies stopped hoarding cash and hired lots of new employees? Or would there be side-effects like inflation, or some effect of pulling out cash from whatever it was invested in, etc.?

Serious question.

shutupalready··on Keurig 2.0 DRM Bypass
Wouldn't it be deliciously funny if the adapter was engineered such that all third-party k-cups worked, but Keurig's own k-cups ceased working. It should be possible; I thought of ways using electronics or a prism, but nothing simple yet.
shutupalready··on Keurig 2.0 DRM Bypass
I applaud the fact that they don't seem worried about the Digital Millennium Copyright Act that makes it illegal to create devices that bypass DRM. DMCA is supposed to apply only to protecting copyrighted works, but prosecutors and lawyers in general try to extend the laws in all sort of crafty ways, and usually companies are too fearful to try anything proactive.
shutupalready··on The Huge, Unseen Operation Behind the Accuracy of Google Maps
St. Louis streetwalker serial killer, Maury Travis, sent the local newspaper a computer generated map giving the intersection where he left a body.

Investigators determined that web-based mapping software Expedia was used--based on symbols used to mark highways and such--ruling out Mapquest, Yahoo, and others.

A single person had clicked on that intersection in Expedia in the 5 days before the map was received by the newspaper. They traced the person presumably using the IP address.

This was back in 2001.

It's odd that we still have unsolved street crime given that everyone today carries a tracking device sending back real-time geolocation data.

shutupalready··on Stop giving Wikipedia money
So you're bellyaching about Wikipedia having $51 million in the bank and spending $684,000 on furniture (if true)?

Don't you realize how tiny those numbers are compared to the incredibly wasteful spending by any governmental agency at any level of government, or by any organization or company with monopoly status, or hell, just any really large company?

For something I use every single day for free (unless I choose to contribute), I think Wikipedia is astonishingly great value.

I think it would be great value even if it had the budget of, say, the US Department of Labor ($13 billion -- billion with a "B").

Why do you pick on Wikipedia when there are things 250 times worse?

shutupalready··on Should the U.S. Make Standardized Tests Harder?
> The biggest factors in predicting long-term success are intelligence, knowledge, and conscientiousness

I wouldn't dispute that those are important factors, but what about:

- initiative and/or risk-taking (which is very different from conscientiousness)

- attractiveness (either physical or non-physical things like charm or schmoozing)

- starting capital (it's easier turn $1 million into $2 million than starting with $0 and getting to $1 million)

- general health and fitness (successful people are rarely sickly or unfit)

- leadership

- number and quality of connections

Looking at the tech sector, it seems that a high level of intelligence, knowledge, and conscientiousness will get you a good job. But the most successful people in tech are not those with even higher levels of intelligence, knowledge, and conscientiousness -- for those people it's the other factors that dominate.

shutupalready··on Youtube-dl
I tried Google Chrome (v29 on Windows, fwiw), and it behaves just like Firefox; i.e., it'll render local text or image files but won't play local videos. I didn't try Chromium.
shutupalready··on Youtube-dl
> I vastly prefer offline media players to browser-based tools

Why don't browsers provide some way to play local video files, for example by typing "file:///c:/my_video.flv" into the address bar. After all, the browser certainly includes the ability to play the video being downloaded off the web.

If you try "file:///c:/my_video.flv" with Firefox, it opens a dialog box offering to pass the video file to whatever external media players you have installed.

In what seems inconsistent to me, "file:///c:/my_notes.txt" and "file:///c:/my_pic.jpg" will be rendered correctly by Firefox -- it won't offer to open an external text editor or photo viewer. Why is video different?

shutupalready··on The Cat Went Over Radioactive Mountain
That brings up another thing that the average Joe doesn't think about: that nuclear weapons are transported on unmarked trucks right along major highway routes. For all we know, a couple shipments might pass certain cities every day for months or years on end. Nuclear weapons have to be initially deployed, moved for repositioning, maintained, repaired, upgraded, and retired. All this is done in secret.

If only nuclear waste had also been handled in secret, the masses would have turned their attention to protesting chemtrails or something, rather than derailing the well-thought-out Yucca plan.

shutupalready··on The Cat Went Over Radioactive Mountain
A far more important issue that the article doesn't explain is why the Yucca Mountain repository was shut down. It had nothing to do with technology or safety, or even money.

It was the NIMBY-mentality -- Not In My BackYard -- of a population that can't assess or compare risks[1]. I wonder which the average Joe in Nevada thinks is worse: nuclear weapons (of which Nevada has plenty and a history of unreported accidents) or Yucca?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_re...

shutupalready··on SF Engineer Dan Ha Has Been Missing Since 10/31
The blog says that a 9-year-old girl saw a man matching Luk's description wearing a purple hoodie jump off the Golden Gate bridge on the very afternoon he disappeared. The police report about this incident was tracked down months later by a private detective hired by Yahoo.

Unless I'm misreading the article, it took months to unearth this police report. (The blog explicitly says that without Yahoo's help he would likely still be "missing" as he was for several months.)

This is terrible!

How is it possible that we have an NSA that is so wickedly super-competent that they can listen live to any phone conversation in the U.S.A. by clicking a few keys on the keyboard (per Snowden's claims), and yet the police department is so utterly incompetent (or uncaring) that they can't do the equivalent of a grep on the incident reports for Jan. 1 2014.

search 'purple|violet|red' + 'hoodie|sweatshirt|hooded' + male + radius(Oakland,25miles) in incident_reports_2014-01-01

shutupalready··on Ask HN: Real reason why phone companies can't shut down phone scams
Sorry, but that explanation doesn't hold up.

Long distance calls in bulk are so cheap that the phone companies might be making a fraction of one cent for each call. On the other hand, this creates so tremendous ill will against the phone companies that it's hardly worth it.

The other day I spent 10 minutes complaining to my local phone company about scam calls. Even at minimum wage for the customer support person, dealing with my single complaint probably cost them more money than they made carrying many hundreds of scam calls.

Some Caribbean phone companies have been known to profit handsomely from operators of 900 and 976 pay-per-call scams in which the customers are billed hundreds of dollars directly by the phone company. Maybe you're thinking of those. But that's a different matter.

shutupalready··on Ask HN: Making money with ebooks and video courses vs. writing apps?
> do not teach non-technical people how to make a software business (expected success rate of people who buy that book: < 1%, if that) [but for example] write the book on Ruby on Rails developer integration testing, there is at least a 50% chance that I will be at least somewhat successful

You need to have certain ratios to give that advice.

For each Ruby on Rails developer who wants to learn about integration testing there are probably 10,000 non-technical people wanting to break into the software business where there think that they can becomes software millionaires working part-time in their basement. So, bigger audience for the latter book.

On the other hand, for each book about Ruby on Rails integration testing, there are probably hundreds of books that teach non-technical people how to make a software business. So, more competition for the latter book.

I don't know the ratios involved. Unless you have actual statistical information, I think we're both just speculating about which might be the better strategy.

I'd much prefer to write a good technical book rather than delude non-technical people into thinking they can become software millionaires. But looking at the cold hard rate-of-return, I don't know which makes more money.

shutupalready··on A tiny group of people can see ‘invisible’ colours that no-one else can perceive
> Jordan’s “acid test” involved coloured discs showing different mixtures of pigment, such as a green made of yellow and blue. The mixtures were too subtle for most people to notice: almost all people would see the same shade of olive green, but each combination should give out a subtly different spectrum of light that would be perceptible to someone with a fourth cone.

From what I understand, a modern monitor is capable of displaying the entire range of colors perceptible to the human eye. Am I mistaken about that?

So would it not be possible to create a web-based version of these "coloured discs", and then we can test ourselves.

shutupalready··on The Satoshi Nakamoto Email Hacker Says He's Negotiating with the Bitcoin Founder
> even if the original Satoshi steps forward ... nobody will believe it's really him

I beg to differ. If the real Satoshi actually wanted to identify himself, he'd have no trouble convincing us beyond a reasonable doubt even without his original keys.

This situation is not like trying to decide if you believe a person who says he bought the winning lottery ticket for cash but then lost it.

This situation is more like trying to decide if you believe a person who says he's a thoracic surgeon who's an expert in US Constitutional law, speaks Finnish, and can do somersaults while skiing. Ask him to explain in Finnish how to do laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication.

Just look at all the things that Satoshi has to answer correctly:

- expert level C++ programmer

- fluent English, excellent grammar

- deep knowledge of cryptography

- extensive knowledge of mathematics (maybe not a PhD, but he's no slouch)

- totally intimate with the original Bitcoin code

- familiar with all the history of Bitcoin (at least the history pre-2010)

- plausible explanations for all his actions

- etc.

We're talking about about a miniscule fraction of the world's population that could convincingly fake all of this knowledge and ability -- maybe a few hundred people at most on the entire Earth.

Suppose Bruce Schneier claimed to be Satoshi, then you could look at other things in Bruce background to rebuff it. (Example: Bruce was on a commercial airplane flying over the Atlantic when one of the Satoshi emails was sent.)

shutupalready··on Why Stealing Cars Went Out of Fashion
So those 85 detectives and supervisors, formerly working on auto crime, now work on auto crime -- a subset of auto crime to be precise.

The grandparent's comment has merit. Government has stayed exactly the same size.

shutupalready··on The end of neighbours
When I worked a few months in Silicon Valley, I noticed something similar there:

There's a McDonalds in an area dominated by software and engineering companies. At lunch, people would go through the drive-thru, park in the McDonalds' parking lot, and eat in their cars. The parking lot was full; the large dining area inside was usually empty.

The saddest part is that I myself started doing the same thing after a while. Although Silicon Valley is the center of the universe for my profession, I found that it is also a lonely experience compared to other cities/countries.

shutupalready··on Almost perfect: the rise and fall of WordPerfect Corporation (1993)
> My dad is a lawyer and his firm still uses it today. I've shown him Google Docs

I'm wondering if a lawyer's use of Google Docs or other web-based document storage app would be considered a breach of client privacy or violation of some confidentiality laws?

Yes, I know that lawyers (and doctors, etc.) use email, but email is at least 30 years older than could-based apps like Google Docs, so more allowance has been made for it. In other words, a lawyer might fear getting into trouble for using web-based storage, but won't fear sending the same thing by email.

Yes, I also know that proper use of cryptography can solve all of these issues, but we all know that virtually no lawyer (or doctor or similar professional) ever uses encryption.

shutupalready··on The ship that failed to change the world
Speaking of nuclear-powered aircraft, care to guess who holds the patent on that?

It's none other than Richard Feynman, as related in this hilarious passage from his famous biography:

--- quote ---

One time when I happened to be home, the telephone rings: it's LONG DISTANCE, from California. In those days, a long distance call meant it was something very important, especially a long distance call from this marvelous place, California, a million miles away.

The guy on the other end says, "Is this Professor Feynman, of Cornell University?"

"That's right."

"This is Mr. So-and-so from the Such-and-such Aircraft Company." It was one of the big airplane companies in California, but unfortunately I can't remember which one. The guy continues: "We're planning to start a laboratory on nuclear-propelled rocket airplanes. It will have an annual budget of so-and-so-many million dollars . . ." Big numbers.

I said, "Just a moment, sir; I don't know why you're telling me all this."

"Just let me speak to you," he says; "just let me explain everything. Please let me do it my way." So he goes on a little more, and says how many people are going to be in the laboratory, so-and-so-many people at this level, and so-and-so many Ph.D's at that level . . .

"Excuse me, sir," I say, "but I think you have the wrong fella."

"Am I talking to Richard Feynman, Richard P. Feynman?"

"Yes, but you're..

"Would you please let me present what I have to say, sir, and then we'll discuss it."

"All right!" I sit down and sort of close my eyes to listen to all this stuff, all these details about this big project, and I still haven't the slightest idea why he's giving me all this information.

Finally, when he's all finished, he says, "I'm telling you about our plans because we want to know if you would like to be the director of the laboratory."

"Have you really got the right fella?" I say. "I'm a professor of theoretical physics. I'm not a rocket engineer, or an airplane engineer, or anything like that."

"We're sure we have the right fellow.'

"Where did you get my name then? Why did you decide to call me?"

"Sir, your name is on the patent for nuclear-powered, rocket-propelled airplanes."

"Oh," I said, and I realized why my name was on the patent, and I'll have to tell you the story. I told the man, "I'm sorry, but I would like to continue as a professor at Cornell University."

What had happened was, during the war, at Los Alamos, there was a very nice fella in charge of the patent office for the government, named Captain Smith. Smith sent around a notice to everybody that said something like, "We in the patent office would like to patent every idea you have for the United States government, for which you are working now. Any idea you have on nuclear energy or its application that you may think everybody knows about, everybody doesn't know about: Just come to my office and tell me the idea."

I see Smith at lunch, and as we're walking back to the technical area, I say to him, "That note you sent around: That's kind of crazy to have us come in and tell you every idea."

We discussed it back and forth--by this time we're in his office--and I say, "There are so many ideas about nuclear energy that are so perfectly obvious, that I'd be here all day telling you stuff."

"LIKE WHAT?"

"Nothin' to it!" I say. "Example: nuclear reactor . . . under water. . water goes in . . . steam goes out the other side . . . Pshshshsht--it's a submarine. Or: nuclear reactor . . . air comes rushing in the front. . . heated up by nuclear reaction . . . out the back it goes . . . Boom! Through the air--it's an airplane. Or: nuclear reactor . . you have hydrogen go through the thing . . . Zoom!--it's a rocket. Or: nuclear reactor . . . only instead of using ordinary uranium, you use enriched uranium with beryllium oxide at high temperature to make it more efficient . . . It's an electrical power plant. There's a million ideas!" I said, as I went out the door.

Nothing happened.

About three months later, Smith calls me in the office and says, "Feynman, the submarine has already been taken. But the other three are yours."

So when the guys at the airplane company in California are planning their laboratory, and try to find out who's an expert in rocket-propelled whatnots, there's nothing to it: They look at who's got the patent on it!

shutupalready··on In Sweden, Sverker Johansson and His 'Bot' Have Created 2.7M Wikipedia Articles
Why is he doing this in Swedish and two versions of Filipino? He apparently speaks English, so I assume he could adapt his code to do English entries as well.
shutupalready··on In Sweden, Sverker Johansson and His 'Bot' Have Created 2.7M Wikipedia Articles
Unless there's some nuance that I'm missing, it sounds like that that is exactly what he's doing.
shutupalready··on Image Protection on the Web
Your final demo is easily defeated because a link to cat.png appears right in the page source:

I mean this line:

<img id="cat" src="cat.png" width="237" height="235" />

in the source code to this page:

  http://www.patrick-wied.at/talks/image-protection/demos/demo-interlacing.html
Am I correct in assuming that for demo purposes you didn't worry about that, but if you had intended to do this in practice, you would have to feed the data in cat.png to client in some non-obvious way?
shutupalready··on A Sound You Can't Unhear (And What It Says About Your Brain)
Yes, thousands of them in the context of listening to songs:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondegreen

shutupalready··on That wild ass recruiting idea
I'm going to offer the contrary advice that hiring by employee referral is not a good approach, for these reasons:

1. Your genius employee does not necessarily know lots of other geniuses. In fact, he might not know anybody. Yes, there are brilliant programmers and engineers who are well-connected, but there are ten times as many brilliant programmers and engineers who are solitary, independent types. If you press them for a referral, you'll get a referral to his brother-in-law who took some computer courses or the guy that was nice to him in university but hasn't found a job yet.

2. Friends hiring friends leads to cliques. For a startup, two or three friends working together is ideal. But for a larger enterprise, you want to avoid that. Of course, cliques will form by themselves, but why create them from day 1.

3. It's very cynical to say this, but chances are that your employee is not going to recommend someone smarter or harder working than he is. Why make himself look bad? (One of Paul Graham's articles says that this is true of mediocre programmers, but not of the top ones. Perhaps when you're starting out, you want to work in a room full of geniuses, but what if you are the top dog in the room? Are you going to bring in someone that can obviously show you up?)

Many hiring methods lead to negative quality direction. Example: Making all your hires from Monster.com would be a negative trend. But a lot of people seem to believe that hiring based on employee referral is a positive. I'm sure it's not the worst way--and it's probably much better than relying on Monster.com for instance--but I think that employee referrals lead to quality loss over time.

shutupalready··on Help Shut the Government's Surveillance Backdoors
> The amendment would block the NSA from using any of its funding...

Why is the legislation is written to cut off funding as opposed to making the act itself illegal?

In fact, why not do both, i.e., deny the use of funds and make the action (warrantless searches and backdoors) illegal?

shutupalready··on TrueCrypt developer says no to license change for forking
May I ask how much cash--more or less--you were prepared to throw at him?

Also, did they guy who contacted the TrueCrypt author mention any dollar amounts?

shutupalready··on David Braben has been appointed OBE in the Queen's Birthday Honours list
> where are all the success stories about RPI in the educational arena

You're right; I don't see success stories in education.

But so what? The RPi is a huge success as a prototyping tool, as a platform for one-off devices or small productions runs, and as a hacker appliance (in the good sense of "hacker").

So what if the Raspberry Pi Foundation's original intention was to advance computer education? They achieved success in a different and highly positive way. There's nothing to regret.

shutupalready··on The Man Who Introduced the World to Flying Saucers
tl;dr: Pilot in 1947 sees unidentified objects that fly in a saucer-like fashion, i.e., flew "like a saucer if you skip it across the water", and reporters are chastised for inventing the term "flying saucer".

But if look at the pilot's actual drawing from the article, here:

http://cdn.theatlantic.com/newsroom/img/posts/2014/06/Arnold...

What common household object would be a good metaphor for what he saw?

  a donut
  a pencil
  a loaf of bread
  a teapot
  a balloon
  a cigar
  or, a saucer
Looking around my own kitchen and garage, I can't find a better one-word description than saucer. (Maybe Frisbee but did that even exist in 1947?)

The reporter(s) saw the saucer-shaped drawing, and the pilot did talk about saucer-like flight, hence "flying saucer".

It's crazy to call this "one of the most significant reporter misquotes in history".

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →