HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sigilis

245 karma · joined July 5, 2023

submissionscomments
sigilis··on Why I Threw Away My Apple Watch
Wear two watches and your problems are largely solved. You can even take off the Apple one for fancy events where you want to look like less of a… two watch wearer.
sigilis··on The valve at the end of the world
If that is what that phrase means, then I do not love life. I love living. I know nothing of death, and cannot help but dread its inevitable embrace.

All that I am now, all the things I do and could do, will change. It may be a part of life, but it is the end of living.

sigilis··on AI and Mass Spying
It may be a common phrase, but I’ve never seen such a road myself. Mostly bad outcomes are preceded by bad intentions, or lazy ones, or selfish ones.

I’d be interested in a couple of examples, if anyone has good ones, but I’m pretty sure that if we put stuff like 737MAX MCAS, the Texas power grid fiasco, etc the count of badly paved roads would be greater.

sigilis··on Analyzing the historical rate of catastrophes
Has there been a single instance of a self replicating ai? The article seems to think so, but try as I might none of the image generators, chess engines, llms, or linear regression models I’ve used or seen has even once copied itself to another location let alone run itself.

The idea of ai as a novel self replicator is cool and appears in movies and books, but doesn’t seem to exist outside of fiction. The other article referenced seems to dream of a future 2030 AI with all the capabilities one can imagine isn’t supported by any reasonable projections for AI technology. It might as well be a warning about all the dangerously weaponizable portable fusion reactors that could exist if ITER development is super successful. In this respect, AI seems like an unlikely driver of catastrophe as defined in the near term.

Putting even a 5-10% increase in rates of calamity due to this technology, which has no evidence to support it, while discounting all other technologies including nuclear weapons claiming there’s too little data is not reasonable. The reality is, we don’t know what risk value to assign. We won’t know for some time.

Just leave out the AI bit from the otherwise reasonable looking statistical analysis, and you’ll be left with a more intellectually rigorous and useful work.

sigilis··on D Programming Language
Developers probably don’t make choices based on the emotional valence of the name of a programming language.

Although, perhaps my decision to learn C# was a reaction to my desire to no longer be myopic…

sigilis··on Outsmart Your Brain: Why Learning Is Hard and How You Can Make It Easy
People in the subway are just people waiting to get somewhere, being on your phone in that situation is no more dystopian than reading a book which may be what’s on some of those screens.

Not saying phone use isn’t a distraction, but sometimes distractions are okay.

sigilis··on Spotify will reduce total headcount by approximately 17%
In addition to the technical work of keeping the servers running and the infra reliable, there is probably a great deal of work getting content licensing deals, working on marketing, managing the whole edifice, and stuff like that. They need a huge number of content “suppliers” to get basically every song in every country. They undoubtedly have a large number of developers working on apps for every platform, keeping up with all that attendant complexity.

On top of that, the company wants to innovate and probably has teams working on hardware and whatnot.

Whether it’s efficient is not clear, but most people there probably work hard on their particular daily grind.

sigilis··on UAW Launches Largest Organizing Drive in Modern American History
If people don’t buy foreign cars because they are too expensive, then no one. For the union there’s no intrinsic downside to such a protectionist action.
sigilis··on ChatGPT, Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love AI
I think he understands that, he just is refreshed by being able to interact with an apparently reasonable intelligent agent rather than a lawyer.
sigilis··on Training for one trillion parameter model backed by Intel and US govt has begun
The more accurate term I’ve seen floating around is “confabulation”. It’s also a human phenomenon, but it doesn’t bring all the baggage of hallucinations.
sigilis··on Fire TV now also displays full-screen video ads on its homescreen
It is unlikely that Apple would make a worse product in this category to enter a price war that they cannot win. Part of the Apple strategy is to be seen as the best option, and pricing is a part of that.

You’re paying to have an experience that is about serving you rather than advertisers. If that’s worth money to you, buy it. Otherwise, you get what you pay for: as crappy a device they can get away with, subsidized by ads.

sigilis··on Some observations on the final text of the European Digital Identity framework
The proposed certificate authorities can generate certificates for any entity, not just EU sites and not just new ones. They would have to be treated as valid, per the regulation.

Trust is the critical component in the PKI infrastructure. When it’s subverted and you can’t just remove the offending authorities, then it’s not really working properly anymore.

sigilis··on Killer found guilty after hidden devices record her watching her own case on TV
Nice try UK undercover cop.
sigilis··on Cities file objections to $13B PFAS settlements with 3M and DuPont
Deterrence works on corporations.

How much time is spent complying with HIPPA, GDPR, and other regulations that have huge penalties? A lot.

How much time is spent on piddling little fines for laws you've never heard of, but are vitally important? They came up with the term "cost of doing business" specifically to cover how little corporations care about these.

Financial penalties are incredibly effective when consistently applied via regulation. Money is the blood of a corporation, losing it can lead to radical therapies from the shareholders including replacement of the leadership. Leadership fears this outcome. When settlements like these go forward that minimize the culpability of a corporation, they are being told that there is a cost to using harmful chemicals, but it will be a fraction of the gain and exacted a long time after the money is made. What possible reason would they have to think twice in the future about hiding chemical spills and hoping the bill just doesn't come due if the consequences aren't at least enough to clean up the problem?

The issue of piercing the corporate veil is a secondary one, really. People who act with malice against society should have criminal penalties assessed against them regardless of how exalted their position is. The problem is, proving that they personally did X or Y and what that contributed to the overall problem, etc. Our legal system is not set up to deal with this by design and no one in the position to make the changes required is interested in signing the laws that would put their donors in prison.

There's only one viable means of disincentivizing bad behavior for corporations in our current system, which is the one we are stuck with. The threat of large financial penalties are making tech companies come to heel in the EU, whether we like that outcome or not. We could pass laws like that in the US to deal with real physical harms if there was a will as well.

sigilis··on Gut epithelial barrier damage caused by dishwasher detergents and rinse aids
It’s a reasonable thing to try for someone who doesn’t know how to cook a steak and may have been expressly forbidden from using the stove.

Plus he was twelve, definitely in the age range where such errors are the expected product of experimentation in an unfamiliar world.

sigilis··on Ask HN: What are you reading these days?
It’s on the list of things I want to change about myself. I’m a work in progress.

Dietary control is not something I have been able to exercise in the past. I’m attempting to obtain pharmaceutical help on that front, so maybe I will be able to execute on being a better person in that dimension in the coming months.

sigilis··on Ask HN: What are you reading these days?
Meat eating should also plummet if meat eating is banned in restaurants and there’s a minimum meat eating age that increases a year at a time. Bonus if there’s a health insurance question about meat eating and special meat taxes.

There is no societal structure to disincentivize meat eating. Social pressure from vegetarians (which is so very slight) and logical arguments are the only thing we’ve got. Tradition, convenience, identity, and preferences are all arrayed against the reasonable thing.

For now meat consumption is probably going to be somewhat inversely correlated to meat prices, as per usual.

sigilis··on Ask HN: What are you reading these days?
People still smoke cigarettes despite decades of clear evidence that they will lead to a horrible death in many cases. Society has built so many disincentives to doing so, and yet they persist.

Animal products will continue to be consumed no matter how obvious it is that their production is morally repugnant and environmentally destructive.

I am sorry to say that I am one of those consumers despite knowing better.

sigilis··on Hash matching proposals for the Online Safety Act's implementation are dangerous
In this case, a false positive might be a good thing from their perspective. If they can show that you have a close match it means they have an excuse to investigate you more thoroughly should they desire even if the real reason is that they suspect you of something else.
sigilis··on How Wikipedia became the last good place on the internet
You're commenting on a discovery engine right now. HN surfaces stuff you never searched for but find interesting all the time. Still, you can't expect for there to be the kind of traffic we see on the big sites today for all the little blogs and whatnot, but that means there would be different motivations behind these more personal spaces. It wouldn't be about driving more clicks, but about expressing oneself to, sharing with, or informing people. Not sure what the economic model for sharing your passion is, but maybe it doesn't always need one.

The constant drive to draw up all of human attention so that those people can be sold something or the other is probably still going to win out in terms of volume, but maybe there can be some more nice things in the world.

sigilis··on Regarding Proposed US Restrictions on RISC-V
By definition, yes. The government are reducing the costs of doing something through a special dispensation, which is a subsidy.
sigilis··on Nuclear Conversion for Starship
You would assemble such a craft in orbit. Some of the proposed designs for nuclear pulse propulsion conceive of a spacecraft of truly astounding proportions. The wikipedia article on Project Orion mentions an Alpha Centauri bound design that would be 20km in diameter and 10Mt in mass.

However, now that I think about it, cyclers would only need to use the NPP engines (bombs) to get into their cycling orbits, so you might be able to get away with accelerating them while unmanned. You could design such a craft with much less radiation shielding, but still include enough to prevent cosmic rays from killing (or more accurately, increasing their cancer risk) the passengers giving such a craft a significantly larger fraction of usable mass for other purposes. Initially accelerating a Mars cycler with unmanned landers with supplies and materials for an initial colony with humans to follow could be an interesting design.

All of this is more expensive than anyone is willing to pay for, even if there was an appetite for the nuclear proliferation risk of making and then putting a thousand compact bombs on a spacecraft. Not even mentioning the risk of the bomb carrier rockets exploding and causing a 100x Broken Arrow situation.

It is for this reason that I must urge the government to immediately fund the writing of several novels about how this can go wrong and right for me to read.

sigilis··on Bentham's Mugging (2022)
The mugger has a lapel pin denoting himself as a deontological agent. Lapel pins in these fantasies cannot be forged, I guess.
sigilis··on What companies offer noteworthy discounts or startup programs for bootstrappers?
Was I supposed to be paying to rsync data?
sigilis··on How did Qualcomm snatch defeat from the jaws of victory with their Oryon SoC?
Apple isn’t making WiFi/bt precisely because it’s not that hard. There are a number of potential companies they can partner with so they can negotiate better rates. CPUs and modems are different, they effectively had a single supplier that will work for their requirements which meant that they couldn’t differentiate their products from other companies and had to deal with a third party supplier who essentially had them over a barrel at the negotiating table.

If they can pull off making their own modem, Qualcomm can’t charge them like they’re the only option even if not all iPhones use the new modem. The makers of various easier to make ICs already know they are not the only option and charge accordingly.

sigilis··on Users report iPhone 15 is overheating
It needs to identify each dog in your photos library to put them in their own album and figure out which dogs or people to suggest for the photo widget.

Which is to say it’s not unimaginable that photo indexing is part of it.

sigilis··on French regulators order Apple to halt sales of the iPhone 12
What makes you say things like this that are easily verifiably false? I am reaching over and touching my WiFi router’s antennas right now and I’m not being “painfully burned from the inside out.”

I’m hoping the answer is a desire to make a joke and not something that indicates a disconnection with reality.

sigilis··on Texas paid Bitcoin miner Riot $31.7M to shut down in August
But they are increasing demand, not supply. You are theorizing that somewhere someone will build more supply because the increased demand is increasing the price to consumers, which is not what I would call a consumer benefit while they wait for that someone to get their giant power plant built to offset the completely useless bitcoin mining.
sigilis··on The Busy Worker’s Handbook to the Apocalypse
That last article indicates that the proposed structure will have to solve the sort of problems that a space elevator would take. We may as well pin our hopes on a pallet of umbrellas launched towards L1.

Has there been any test solar shade hardware launched?

sigilis··on I Have Blocked OpenAI
You should take down the documentation entirely, if you want to prevent incorrect interpretations of things. The LLMs won’t be the ones emailing you, the people who would get things wrong if the LLM provided some kind of confident wrong answer would probably simply not read your documentation as the vast majority of users do not. You’re just shifting some, but not all, misunderstandings into totally uninformed questions that will mean an additional email pointing them to RTFM.

All of these “we’re not letting bots crawl our site!” posts make me feel like I’ve travelled back in time to when having web spiders crawl your site was a big deal. You can’t really prevent people from using tools wrong, and it is odd that so many people care about this futile attempt to insulate yourself from stupid users that I managed to see it on the front page of HN.

The worst part is, if an LLM has already read in your docs and the interaction you fear your users having with LLMs comes to pass: they will have misapprehensions about the old version of your docs which will be even more wrong.

Allow me to prepare you for the future now before you have to hear it from someone else, you will be getting email spam about LLM Algorithm Optimization soon. LLMAO firms are probably already organizing around the bend of time, we’re just a little before they become visible.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →