HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smogcutter

2,923 karma · joined October 6, 2016

submissionscomments
smogcutter··on On 17th century "cocaine"
Yes, anyone who’s ever been trapped in a conversation with someone yakked to the gills can tell you all about singleminded focus as an effect of cocaine.
smogcutter··on Nearly all of the Google images results for "baby peacock" are AI generated
That’s orthogonal to the point though, which is about the social value of private chats etc. Not whether they’re truly technologically “private”.
smogcutter··on It's Time to Stop Taking Sam Altman at His Word
Yes, you’ve rediscovered the curriculum of a journalism 101 class.
smogcutter··on The True Weight of Medieval Weapons – Fact and Fiction
In fairness, that misconception doesn’t just spring from imagination. Prop weapons generally are heavy, because they need to be thick to have blunt edges.
smogcutter··on Hachette vs. Internet Archive: We're Still Fighting for Fair Use
> Similar to a photocopy or resale of a book

I mean, right there is the attempted rhetorical trick that gives the game away. A photocopy is completely unlike resale of a used book, and is only considered “fair use” under specific, practical circumstances.

It’s hard to seriously argue that you could lawfully photocopy books whole, then make a lending library out of the copies, or that such a thing has any similarity to reselling used books.

smogcutter··on Why use metaphors in conflicts? Because understanding is remembering in disguise (2009)
Naively, doesn’t it seem likely that pancakes and panquecas are unrelated “false friends”?

Pancakes are “cakes” made in a pan. It’s not a Latin-derived word, so the only way they could be related is if panquecas is a loan word that took on a life if its own.

The simpler explanation is that pan means bread, -quecas definitely doesn’t mean cakes, and the foods are so different because the words are unrelated coincidental soundalikes.

smogcutter··on Unconventional Case Study of Neoadjuvant Oncolytic Virotherapy for Breast Cancer
> But if people can't choose for themselves then 100% of the time they die.

This is only true for a certain set of cases, and in those cases people generally can choose for themselves.

smogcutter··on Dogs can remember names of toys years after not seeing them, study shows
In Rao’s model, the sociopaths and losers share an understanding that the organization exists for the benefit of the sociopaths, they just respond to it differently. It’s only the clueless who are bamboozled.

So idk if it’s a great lens for AF, where all the proletarian animals are more or less equally taken in.

But anyway, Benjamin is definitely a loser, not a sociopath! He comes closest to understanding what’s happening, and his response is to put his head down, so his job, and seek meaning outside the political game. A Ryan-type sociopath candidate would ditch work to make a political play. Benjamin is Stanley.

smogcutter··on Dogs can remember names of toys years after not seeing them, study shows
In the case of animal farm, it’s not so much that the dogs are more intelligent than the other animals as that Napoleon takes advantage of their disposition to unshakeable loyalty and need for a master. Likewise, unfortunately, in life.

If you have to rank the animals by intelligence, second (or first, even?) is certainly Benjamin the donkey.

smogcutter··on Greece announces new rules banning mobile phones in schools from September
Aside from the hundred and one obvious reasons that’s a pointlessly complex solution that would cause it’s own problems, if you think about it for even a moment I bet you can come up with some ways for a pocket camera and video game to be disruptive in school even without signal.
smogcutter··on Judge rules $400M algorithmic system illegally denied Medicaid benefits
The application process parent is talking about is Medicaid, not Medicare.

Medicare is pretty ironclad, because the recipients are elderly and vote. Medicaid recipients tend to be marginalized and high need, so they’re used as a punching bag by local governments in states where that’s a good way to score political points.

smogcutter··on Euphemisms are best changed frequently (2016)
If you frame changing vocabulary as a shibboleth that point of view is inevitable, but that doesn’t make it accurate. This is a view of other people on the same spectrum as accusing them of “virtue signaling”, and is equally worth ignoring.
smogcutter··on A Better Light Source for Scanning Color Negative Film
There are also rotoscoping and analysis projectors designed to hold on a frame.
smogcutter··on Starting Hospice
I think it’s worth drawing a distinction between guilt, which can be positive, and shame, almost never. Guilt is feeling badly because you know you’ve done wrong. Shame is feeling badly because other people know you’ve done wrong.
smogcutter··on What happens in a mind that can't 'see' mental images
Thats just called imagination. Do you think that when other people picture something it literally replaced their vision?
smogcutter··on DIY, 8mm film scanner Kotokino Mark IV (2020)
Correct, it’s like a mirrored fan blade and rotates continuously.

Ironically, with mirror reflex system what you see through the finder are precisely the moments not captured on film. Very quick events, muzzle flashes for example, can be missed entirely.

Notably, some Bolex cameras (and others?) used a beam splitter system where you do see what the film sees, with no flicker from the shutter. The tradeoff is a dimmer image in the finder, and you’d need to overexpose to compensate for the lost light.

smogcutter··on Teaching general problem-solving skills is not a substitute for teaching math [pdf] (2010)
Well, sure. But very few formal educational settings are purely active/unguided. Unfortunately passive/direct is much more common.

To me though the more interesting result isn’t really about pedagogy, it’s that people’s (undergrad physics students, in the case of the specific study I’m thinking of) subjective impressions of the effectiveness of instruction are unreliable.

smogcutter··on Teaching general problem-solving skills is not a substitute for teaching math [pdf] (2010)
Interestingly, there have been studies that show that students lectured to feel like they’ve learned more, and self-report that they have, while students learning the same material in self-guided labs report feeling like they’ve learned less but perform better on assessments.
smogcutter··on VPN ban is strangling communication in Myanmar
But if people generally believe the folk version of the law, does it really help to be technically in the clear? You can still easily find yourself in an really unpleasant and pointless confrontation.
smogcutter··on The impact of Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" on Noam Chomsky's path to anarchism
This is where conversations about anarchism often break down.

Forgetting the language about everyone being for themselves, parent’s question boils down to “what happens when people don’t cooperate?”. The answer to that can’t be “people will cooperate”.

I think when you’re thinking about social structures of all kinds a useful perspective is to ask whether you’re creating a prisoner’s dilemma, and what the consequences of that could be.

smogcutter··on Pattern of brain damage is pervasive in Navy SEALs who died by suicide
Go try some violence and get back to us.
smogcutter··on An Anatomy of Algorithm Aversion
You’re missing the point. Of course there are (enormous, life-ruining) mistakes, but that’s not it.

With software, generally the only people with the means to demonstrate the software is flawed are the people in control of the software and associated data.

smogcutter··on An Anatomy of Algorithm Aversion
https://www.bbc.com/news/business-56718036.amp
smogcutter··on The Moral Economy of the Shire
> being a wholesome person is largely orthogonal to being a good king

Tolkien would disagree. So strongly in fact that he wrote an entire fantasy series about it!

smogcutter··on How do our brains adapt to control an extra body part?
Developing that automaticity with a physical skill also unlocks the brain to do other parts that are conscious.

After a game, Lebron James can explain what happened in a play moment by moment for every player on the floor, and everything he was thinking and planning as the play developed. He’s done it in post game press conferences off the top of his head.

Granted he’s maybe the all time greatest, but it’s illustrative. He’s not thinking at all about how his body is going to do what it does. That’s completely automatic. He’s thinking a lot about the higher level strategy of the game.

smogcutter··on Encountering Strangers in Public Places: Goffman and Civil Inattention (2011)
Not sure why this is posted here, but the concept seems accurate enough.

The discussion of attention in premodern society makes me think of Oedipus: a chance meeting between strangers on the road ends in violence, and this is taken as at least unsurprising, if not routine.

smogcutter··on Legal models hallucinate in 1 out of 6 (or more) benchmarking queries
> But to the LLM, the token with the highest probability will be the most likely correct answer

This is precisely what people are identifying as problematic

smogcutter··on Google releases smart watch for kids
I don’t care if my wife knows my location either. She’s my partner, not my parent. Thankfully, I’m not a teen trying to develop a sense of autonomy and self reliance independent of my wife’s supervision.

As other posters have pointed out, no one really knows anything about anyone else’s life from an HN post.

That said, the whole point of the panopticon is that if the prisoner doesn’t know when they’re being observed, they’re effectively always observed. It’s a concern that’s at least worth giving serious consideration, not dismissing out of hand because it happens to work for you and your wife.

smogcutter··on The Nonprofit Industrial Complex and the Corruption of the American City
Meanwhile in Orange County, County supervisor Andrew Do has apparently stolen millions in Covid relief funds via the “Viet America Society”, a do-nothing nonprofit nominally run by his daughter.

https://laist.com/news/politics/orange-county-andrew-do-supe...

smogcutter··on Helen Keller on her life before self-consciousness (1908)
I also distantly remembered this example from something in school and found a reference.

https://www.sciencenews.org/article/cultures-reason

If you’re actually interested, it’s a little different than what OP was told/remembers and what’s being discussed here.

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →