HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sobriquet9

256 karma · joined January 1, 2021

submissionscomments
sobriquet9··on MIT abandons requirement of DEI statements for hiring and promotions
Those distinctions are irrelevant. Education was free in USSR. Access to math circles and specialized math schools was also free. It was not necessary to hire a tutor or pay for advanced classes to get admitted, unless we’re talking about the Conservatory or MGIMO.

Source: I was born and received education in USSR, so can tell Soviet propaganda from reality.

sobriquet9··on MIT abandons requirement of DEI statements for hiring and promotions
Class based admission meant discrimination against Jews.
sobriquet9··on MIT abandons requirement of DEI statements for hiring and promotions
In USSR, nobody was rich.
sobriquet9··on MIT abandons requirement of DEI statements for hiring and promotions
> every policy that wants to promote equality should revolve solely around class.

That was the case in USSR. There were university admission quotas for workers, peasants, etc. In practice, they resulted in discrimination agains Jewish applicants.

To fulfill the class quotas, the examiners had to fail a disproportionate number of some of the strongest applicants. A whole set of "Jewish problems", colloquially known as " coffins", was developed. At MIT, Tanya Khovanova has written on this subject.

sobriquet9··on Histograms for Probability Density Estimation: A Primer
Why estimate PDF through histogram then convert to CDF, when one can estimate CDF directly? Doing so also avoids having to choose bin width that can have substantial impact.
sobriquet9··on Mathematician who made sense of the universe's randomness wins Abel Prize
Are you saying there is some classified science also called history that makes quantitative, testable, falsifiable predictions?

Maybe so, but I have no clearance and have not seen it. And it would be completely different from history I studied in school. There wasn’t a single prediction, let alone quantitative prediction with time horizon and confidence interval in any of the history books I’ve read.

sobriquet9··on Mathematician who made sense of the universe's randomness wins Abel Prize
Weather forecasts can easily be compared to actuals, and distribution of residuals can be calculated. That’s how weather forecast models are quantitatively evaluated. A seven day weather forecast has 95% confidence interval of around plus-minus 10 degrees Fahrenheit, way better than “it’ll be like today”.

Your prediction about the war in Ukraine is not falsifiable.

sobriquet9··on Mathematician who made sense of the universe's randomness wins Abel Prize
If history was about making the connections, those connections could be used to make predictions that could be tested.
sobriquet9··on Mathematician who made sense of the universe's randomness wins Abel Prize
History is not abstract. It does not give you generalizations, abstractions and models, just historical facts. Many of those facts are useful in understanding why things around you are the way they are.

The attempts to make history more "scientific", usually for religious or political reasons (e.g., explaining past events throgh class struggle), end up looking like propaganda.

sobriquet9··on Mathematician who made sense of the universe's randomness wins Abel Prize
Because history, biology, or foreign languages have easier to understand practical uses.

Many math teachers do not know math, and cannot answer the question "what will I need it for?"

sobriquet9··on Radios, how do they work?
Transmitting and receiving antennas work the same way. Flip the sign of time in Maxwell’s equations, and radio waves will run perfectly backwards.
sobriquet9··on Ask HN: Why do recommender systems not seem good?
Because to make good, personalized recommendations they need to know what you don't know, and there isn't a good source of information about it.

For example, if you have not seen The Shawshank Redemption, chances are you will like it. It's #1 among IMDB top 250 list. But a recommender does not know if you've seen it. If you've seen it already, it's a bad recommendation.

So the same recommendation for the same person can be good today and bad tomorrow, depending on something recommender engine does not see. That makes it very difficult to tune and measure performance.

sobriquet9··on Cellular outage in U.S. hits AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon users
No, it's not paired to the phone, and there is no Garmin app on the phone either.
sobriquet9··on Our Company Is Doing So Well That You're All Fired
You can fire half the commercial pilots, and planes will continue to fly without a hitch. Why have two pilots, when one will do. Trucks have one driver and work just fine.

Eventually some planes will crash, but it's ok as long as it happens after effective management gets their bonus and moves on to optimise another company.

sobriquet9··on Cellular outage in U.S. hits AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon users
From cold start. Most starts are not cold. The phone knows where it is, approximately, what time it is (within a second or so, from built-in RTC), and orbital parameters of the satellites overhead (maybe without the latest corrections).

My Garmin watch gets a GPS lock in way less than 5 minutes without any cellular connection.

sobriquet9··on Forecasts need to have error bars
That's not a solution, but more like lots of different solutions, many too complicated to understand.

I would suggest split conformal first.

sobriquet9··on Forecasts need to have error bars
If you keep doing that for a long time, actuals will fall within the error bars about 95% of the time.
sobriquet9··on Forecasts need to have error bars
Conformal prediction solves that problem. Split conformal and Jackknife+ are two simplest examples.
sobriquet9··on A Brief Introduction to Military Pillboxes
The muzzle is outside the enclosed space, so I don't think it should be particulatly bad.
sobriquet9··on Scientists unveil fire-safe fuel
Not the only problem. Internal combustion engines use oxygen from the air, so vehicles do not have to carry it. The reduction in mass is substantial, and directly translates to less tire and road wear. EVs carry all their chemistry all the time.
sobriquet9··on NSO group iPhone zero-click, zero-day exploit captured in the wild
Of all the apps that I ran, only one banking app has failed in Lockdown mode. Everything else works just fine.
sobriquet9··on What is residual vector quantization?
A lot of that footage is originated on smartphones, GoPro, drone cameras, etc. where hardware and power limitations do not allow one to run expensive encoding algorithms.
sobriquet9··on The curious case of hybrids in watchmaking
Second hand on Grand Seiko quartz watches moves once per second, but makes two jumps. You can see it in slow motion video, but not with a naked eye.
sobriquet9··on Far Manager: files and archives in Windows
That's correct, at some point magic license "xUSSR регистрация" (ex-USSR registration) allowed you to register for free. Quoting from memory, the exact text may have been slightly different. The idea was to let people from former Soviet Union use the fully-featured version without paying shareware price they generally could not afford back then.
sobriquet9··on Math for kids outside of the Calculus Sequence
Calculus is not heavy math. It describes everyday physics - coordinate, velocity, acceleration, curvature. Stuff you can touch. And it describes unrelated abstract concepts like PDF and CDF, in a way you can intuitively understand by rearranging stacks of Lego bricks.

I agree that a degree in a quantitative field other than computer science is better. A CS degree is like saying "I can drive a car and use Microsoft Excel". You need to either be a really good driver, or be ready to work harder than many others to get ahead.

sobriquet9··on Math for kids outside of the Calculus Sequence
If you are talking about CRUD, sure. But there is software in self-driving cars, 3D printers, drones, etc. that uses vector calculus and differential equations heavily.

Same with applied statistics. For example, if your software has anything to do with quantitative models used in trading, it would be pretty hard to work on it without calculus.

Even reading a paper on effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines requires one to know what p value is and isn't, which in turn requires PDF and CDF (calculus again).

sobriquet9··on Math for kids outside of the Calculus Sequence
It's only true for integration, and not even all of it. Differentiation can be done mechanically, and killer app of calculus (finding maximum) only requires differentiation.
sobriquet9··on Math for kids outside of the Calculus Sequence
I don't get why calculus is considered to be so hard that a new education path around it should be built. Sure, if you do rigorous development from axioms up it might be, but that's not the way one should start. After all, we teach kids to count without number theory and Peano axioms.

After skipping calculus, the article recommends to do statistics, probability, game theory, and mathematical finance. Yeah, right. You may Monte Carlo your way through some problems, but it would be really hard to get understanding of those subjects.

sobriquet9··on The infamous coin toss
If you have no money to bet, the example is not applicable.
sobriquet9··on The infamous coin toss
Kelly criterion defines the optimum ratio.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →