HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sobriquet9

256 karma · joined January 1, 2021

submissionscomments
sobriquet9··on What are the odds we are living in a computer simulation? (2016)
Planck constant in uncertainty principle does look like pixel pitch on the screen or mesh of finite element method.
sobriquet9··on Suppose I wanted to kill a lot of pilots
This is a common pattern, also found in proofs by contradiction and optimization techniques. If you know how to find the minimum, you may be able to use that knowledge to find the maximum.

The problem with using this pattern in real life is that it rarely applies. Unlike the one-dimensional toy examples, in real life there are many more ways to fail than there are to succeed. Eliminating or even enumerating all possible ways to fail may be prohibitively expensive. Even if you do that, you only found a way to maintain status quo, not necessarily to improve.

This can be said about the rest of TRIZ/TIPS. I learned about it a long time ago, but can't remember a single time I solved a practical problem by applying it. I may be able to find examples that can be classified under one of TRIZ rules, but only in hindsight. It's not like you can look at a new problem, apply TRIZ approaches one by one, and find a solution faster than you normally would.

sobriquet9··on CompCert – Formally-verified C compiler
Not completely:

> about 90% of the compiler’s algorithms (including all optimizations and all code generation algorithms) are proved correct in Coq, but the remaining 10% (including elaboration, presimplifications, assembling and linking) are not verified

sobriquet9··on Voltage, Amps, Resistance and LEDs
Of course not. One can use carrier pigeons instead.
sobriquet9··on Voltage, Amps, Resistance and LEDs
My problem with the way the topic is being presented here is not just that the mental model is too simple, but that it is so much simplified that it becomes internally inconsistent.

Resistance is voltage over current, here's LED, it does not have resistance. Or maybe it has more than one resistance, depending on voltage.

Battery is a voltage source, wait, no it's not, it has internal resistance.

sobriquet9··on Voltage, Amps, Resistance and LEDs
How else can you get other people to comment on it, if they can't see it?

Once you fix the mistakes, what's wrong with leaving it up?

sobriquet9··on Voltage, Amps, Resistance and LEDs
Fixed voltage drop on an LED is too much of a simplification for this application. A better mental model is to imagine a piecewise linear approximation of current–voltage characteristic aka I–V curve.

I-V curve of a resistor is a straight line that goes through (0,0) point, with slope inversely proportional to resistance. The curve for LED has a bend somewhere between 1.5V and 2V, where its slope changes from low to high.

sobriquet9··on Voltage, Amps, Resistance and LEDs
Writing an article about a subject that you are studying and getting other people to point out the mistakes is actually a pretty good way to learn.
sobriquet9··on Survey shows people no longer believe working hard will lead to a better life
Starting conditions are not orthogonal to hard work. Educated parents are more likely to teach their kids work ethics, and once you are hired your parents are not helping you with your job.

It's not enough to be lucky. Most people still need to work hard to get ahead.

sobriquet9··on Beware of Tight Feedback Loops (2020)
Basic probability (coin flipping, events over trials) by itself is just as useless as basic trigonometry.

It only becomes useful as you move from simple combinatorics to continuous distributions, at which point you need differentiation and integration to switch between CDF and PDF. Much in the same way trigonometry becomes useful in physics once you need to deal with vectors and waves.

sobriquet9··on How fighter jets lock on, and how the targets know (2014)
There is no way to know. An actual operational system deployed anywhere would be impossible to detect. It does not transmit anything, and can use existing antennas for receiving the signals. Can be as simple as software update.
sobriquet9··on Beware of Tight Feedback Loops (2020)
It's not easy to learn statistics without calculus.
sobriquet9··on How fighter jets lock on, and how the targets know (2014)
You don't need to go to HF to detect stealth aircraft. Even VHF will work. But it's not going to be accurate enough for targeting.

Another approach is to passively listen for reflections of cell tower or FM radio signals. Stealth aircraft do not reflect much radio energy straight back at the source, but they do reflect it in other directions.

sobriquet9··on How fighter jets lock on, and how the targets know (2014)
This part looks rather dated:

> A digital signal processor looks for recognizable radio "chirps" that correspond to known radars, and displays their azimuth on the scope. A chirp is a distinctive waveform that a radio uses.

These days it should be pretty easy to use pseudorandom waveforms, unique each time. LPI radars existed for a while.

sobriquet9··on Resistor Noise Can Be Deafening, and Hard to Reduce (2007)
It's relatively easy to make a headphone amp quiet because its input is typically already quite strong.

Noise is more of a problem for microphone preamps, guitar pickups, etc., where the input signal is weak.

sobriquet9··on Is Euler’s Identity Beautiful? and If So, How?
In hindsight, and if you know Mclaurin series.

Complex numbers were known and used for many years before Euler found this obvious result.

sobriquet9··on Is Euler’s Identity Beautiful? and If So, How?
I don't find identity itself to be beautiful. It's just a special case of (much more useful) Euler formula. That I do find beautiful.
sobriquet9··on The most expensive number in engineering
The definition is

> breaking force divided by the expected force

Note force being used here, not energy or speed.

sobriquet9··on US investigates second suspected case of mystery 'syndrome' near White House
Only within certain frequency ranges. There are filters that block everything else.
sobriquet9··on Security Breach at US Universities
SSNs are used as unique identifiers. If you start re-using them, they're no longer unique.
sobriquet9··on Security Breach at US Universities
SSNs are not reused. About 450 million have already been issued. If people in a breach are issued new SSNs, we'll run out of numbers rather quickly.
sobriquet9··on Yes, experts will lie to you sometimes
I'm not saying that Dr. Fauci wasn't lying. He was, about masks, about washing hands, about "no evidence" of virus being airborne, about length of lockdown, etc.

I'm just saying that this particular argument, about cycle count and false positives, is not one of those cases.

sobriquet9··on Yes, experts will lie to you sometimes
That's why COVID-19 is diagnosed not only by rt-PCR, but also on the basis of symptoms, chest CT scans, and other nucleic acid testing.
sobriquet9··on Yes, experts will lie to you sometimes
Here Dr. Fauci is answering a different question: whether a patient with positive rt-PCR test result is still infectious (shedding virus that is replication capable).

rt-PCR test cannot distinguish between live, replication-capable SARS-CoV-2 and its remains, or inactivated copies. It detects short snippets of genetic material, not the entire virus.

sobriquet9··on Yes, experts will lie to you sometimes
> Anything over 35 is a worthless test that's a false positive.

That's not a false positive. False positive happens when there are no viral particles in the sample, but the test comes back positive. Those are very rare with rt-PCR and can usually be tracked down to cross-contamination. Cycle count has nothing to with those.

If there is no SARS-CoV-2 genetic material in the sample, there's nothing for rt-PCR to amplify.

sobriquet9··on How U.S. media lost the trust of the public
But there are alternatives. Even in the Soviet Union where the government controlled all press and TV, it was possible to find other sources of information: short wave broadcasts, samizdat, word of mouth, etc.

The most important thing is the habit of not trusting any sources, official or not, and ability to recognize propaganda.

sobriquet9··on How U.S. media lost the trust of the public
Biased towards factual information would be unbiased.

Do you really need examples of NYT's bias?

sobriquet9··on How U.S. media lost the trust of the public
I think this is good in the long run.

People in the US have not been exposed to much propaganda from the media before, so tended to trust the news. That's why fake news and biased reporting had such an adverse effect.

Now this is changing, as more people realize that New York Times or Fox News are not much different from Pravda, and that it's not a good idea to blindly trust talking heads on TV.

sobriquet9··on How to implement a hash table in C
Will this expression correctly handle overflow?

size_t mid = (low + high) / 2;

sobriquet9··on The virus that causes the common cold can effectively boot the Covid virus out
You augment your memory with Google searches and your running speed with cars, why not augment your natural immune system with vaccines.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →