HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sorcerer-mar

2,266 karma · joined March 20, 2025

submissionscomments
sorcerer-mar··on Psilocybin decreases depression and anxiety in cancer patients (2016)
The issue with relying on placebo effects is not that they aren't real/don't work (everything you said also applies to e.g. a painkiller), but that they are very context-sensitive. Deploy that drug to an individual or population with a different belief framework or contextual information about the therapy or their condition, and you won't get the desired results.

The design you mention is really interesting! Have you seen this done anywhere?

sorcerer-mar··on Psilocybin decreases depression and anxiety in cancer patients (2016)
There are also studies that test against placebo. There have been lots and lots of trials on these things with different designs that make different cost/benefit tradeoffs.

A difficult one with psychedelics is as-mentioned: people can easily "break the blind". But if you want to eliminate that problem you can instead do a micro vs macro dose, in which case you're measuring a slightly different thing.

sorcerer-mar··on Psilocybin decreases depression and anxiety in cancer patients (2016)
That isn't how these studies are being done... because yeah, it'd probably confound the results.
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Honestly I get the sense that you're not even reading these links. They do not substantiate the argument that you're making.

I have at least skimmed every one of the links you've shared (except the Atlanta BizJournal since I don't have the nationwide subscription) and none of them say what you're suggesting they do.

I agree there's a problem here. I agree that these risks kill many projects before they are birthed. I do not agree they come anywhere close to the costs of land, material, and especially labor for any actual construction project. Nothing you have posted even attempts to argue that, AFAICT.

sorcerer-mar··on “Reading Rainbow” was created to combat summer reading slumps
Residency slots are not capped. Common misconception.

Private parties are welcome to create and fund residency slots if they want. They typically don’t because it’s a totally nonsense investment — perfect example of a problem that private investment markets would fail to solve.

The “cap” refers to the fact that CMS doesn’t fund an infinite number of residency slots.

So you and I are saying similar things, which is that the government needs to fund more MD training.

sorcerer-mar··on “Reading Rainbow” was created to combat summer reading slumps
Pharma companies already aren't very profitable and it's getting worse and worse every year (called "Eroom's Law" for the reverse of Moore's).

The US's uniquely fucked healthcare situation is thanks to 1) administrative overhead of tons of competitive and extremely complex distinct health plans, and 2) the labor cost of doctors, much of which gets captured by the extremely consolidated health systems that employ them.

The US needs to dump money into training a lot more doctors. Not by subsidizing student loans, but by directly creating public medical schools that train doctors on the cheap and let them escape with no student debt.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Okay then, please demonstrate it and/or provide evidence.

Otherwise you're on a thread where someone is pooh-poohing an effort to improve costs where we know they exist (labor) and suggesting it is meaningless compared to costs that you can't substantiate.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
No it doesn't. Any publicly funded construction is rife with tons of additional regulations designed to limit (but sometimes perpetuating) corrupt contracting, and transit projects in particular have very unique needs around land acquisition.

Even still, the linked website doesn't really seem to say permitting is a major driver. And it certainly doesn't dwarf labor and materials.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
I don't know what point you think you're arguing against.

I am not denying permitting exists and it slows things down. The original point was that this is a major contributor to cost of construction, which it's not. They specifically said "a small cost seems to be the actual labor and materials [compared to permitting etc]"-- this is absolutely not true. It is not even close to reality in the US.

Here you're just pointing out two facts:

1) Permitting exists (and slows things down)

2) We have a housing shortage

No argument there! But what you are failing to do is demonstrate that (1) is the major driver of (2).

The actual drivers are the cost of well-situated land, cost of labor, and cost of materials. This is evident in ANY actual budget from ANY actual construction project.

Add to that the fact that large scale homebuilders are petrified of creating a 2008-style oversupply so they've been chronically underbuilding since then -- and will continue to do so regardless of permitting reform. This is evident in the housing starts compared to population growth since the GFC.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Is there a reason you're pointing out San Francisco and New York in particular? Is it because we both know they're by far the most absurd instances of this problem and quite obviously unique in how absurd they are?
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Maybe! But it still does not comport with the original post that I replied to which said that permitting etc are the major driver of cost of any construction project. It is not.
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
You're referring to the delta in material and labor between project start and project permission? That's also a fraction of overall costs.
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Transit costs are a small fraction of "construction". I agree our transit development costs are insane though this has a lot more to do with America's very strong concept of property rights (and the weaponization of other apparatus to defend property rights) than simply "red tape." I.e. it's more political than bureaucratic.
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
That's not analysis
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Could you link to some analysis on this?
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
The carrying cost of land is very low compared to any overall project.

The issue is that extended timelines drive down the IRR and add risk which is not the same as being expensive to carry.

> All of the local large projects around me are expensive because of massive amounts of red tape

This just isn’t true. There are projects that could be happening but aren’t because of red tape, but no, a project that’s happening is spending a tiny portion of its capital on red tape.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
I am not saying costly in direct “money being spent” terms. I mean costly in “adversely affecting project investment profile.”

This is not the same as costing a bunch of money.

sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
The time component isn’t draining bank accounts…
sorcerer-mar··on Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction
Permitting, zoning, etc are all like <3% of a construction project’s cost. This is a meme with no basis in reality.

All of the cost is labor and materials.

That said, the time component of the zoning, permitting etc is very costly due to how real estate projects are funded and evaluated.

sorcerer-mar··on My Family and the Flood
Extreme precipitation events are also getting more common.
sorcerer-mar··on Claude for Financial Services
Sure. I'm not saying it's a good idea. It was a glaring omission from the provided list.
sorcerer-mar··on Claude for Financial Services
Reading tons of reports, no?
sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
How is that relevant to my point?

Despite its failures (however many you want to point out), our regulatory regime converts a pipeline of almost universally ineffective and/or dangerous compounds into a marketplace of almost universally safe and/or effective compounds. This is a fact.

Unless you think no one is trying to, would try to, or would deceive themselves into accidentally releasing a dangerous or ineffective compound to consumers?

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
The point is that it's nowhere close to a crapshoot.

99.99999% of drugs ever created are unsafe or ineffective.

99%+ of the drugs you will ever encounter in your life are both safe and effective.

That is not a crapshoot. Obviously.

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
What incentive does an insurance company with an expected coverage period of 4 years have to prevent a drug with long term harm from reaching its patients?

What about drugs that people do not buy via insurance? Just have a free for all there?

Why wouldn't pharma just release the drug to the public at very low cost to use the unwitting public as its test subjects instead of running trials to satisfy insurance companies? If a bunch of people die then welp, you know not to pursue "insurance approval?"

Can't see how we could go wrong by making it very difficult to sell a working, expensive drug, and make it extremely cheap to sell a mass-market ineffective/unsafe drug...

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
We know for a fact (like actual empirical fact) that FDA prevents vast numbers of unsafe and ineffective drugs from reaching the market. This is absolutely indisputable.

So uhhh, maybe we think in reality instead of offloading to metaphor.

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
Challenge: Answer basic question with anything other than slogans

Difficulty level: Impossible

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
It seems to me they were referring to FDA as a member among other "oppressive regimes" that fail in this way.
sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
Tell me: how do you prove that a drug hurt you?

Spoiler alert: you cannot.

The reason clinical trials are so expensive and complicated is because it's extremely hard to isolate signal of "what is this drug doing to people."

So on what basis would you possibly sue a company?

As another commenter said, we have an entire industry of the form you desire: supplements. Go take them to treat your next illness so you can really experience the creme de la creme that FDA is apparently keeping from you. Good luck suing for lack of effectiveness or for any harms you encounter.

sorcerer-mar··on The Collapse of the FDA
Anyone who has worked in drug development knows how vital FDA is.

The FDA costs taxpayers less than $4 billion per year.

If FDA is a net negative, next time you need a medication you're aware you can go participate in a Phase I study, and get paid to take a cutting edge drug for it? Why bother looking at the stuff on the medicine shelf that costs you money?

Can you give us all an idea of your experience working with government, and especially FDA?

← PreviousPage 3 of 28Next →