HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

soylentnewsorg

306 karma · joined September 29, 2021

ding dang little dong. an incel basement dweller high school student trapped in an adult body.
submissionscomments
soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
>Do you also run all your programs as root on desktop? Wtf.

yes. always have. same in windows where I also don't use antivirus. and this is what most tech people do for their personal equipment. because the one issue I had, in my 30+ years of using computers, and 20+ years of doing it professionally as a dev, sysadmin, and storage admin, I only once got a virus.

i'll tell you a little secret too. yes, it's wtf to people who don't know what they're doing and need the safeguard against when they screw up. I know enough to not screw up. now go pipe a bash script from a webpage to sh to install something, because that's what the installation manual for your game said to do.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
for those times when I run that terminal application on my phone. which is already rooted, so it's doesn't need the kernel bug to get root. it can just run.
soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
your phone is not a linux server. yes, if you install a virus or an outdated app, someone can daisychain a priv escalation using a kernel bug. no need for that though - my phone is already rooted.

Your car has pieces that run linux too. Guess an attacker can make you crash.

> drivers

since this is about iphone and android comparison, guess what has those same driver blobs form those same exact manufacturers. apple doesn't make their own bluetooth chips. oh, btw, the drivers get updated just fine, since that's part of the kernel and os, which all get updated just fine.

google supports kernel 4.1 till 2024 for android 11. the nexus from 2014 runs 4.9. so probably 2026 kernel and android, fully patched - 12 years.

oh, sorry, did you forget this thread started with a guy claiming ios is great because you can put later versions of the OS on there? where's that iphone from 12 years ago running the latest version of ios, and still performing fast? because that's what this thread is about.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
It is different for phones made by the people who also make Android. Google. Which is why I was specifically talking about the pixel and the nexus phones sold by google. For example, kernel version 4.9.3 - the latest one (yes, originally released in november of 2017) supports up to the latest Android. In fact, since 4.1 supports the latest Android, and will till June 2024 according to google. I'm going to go on a limb here, and given the current timeline, project 4.9.3 is going to be supported for probably whatever android is released in 2026.

So, Nexus6 released in 2014 will be able to run the latest android, fully security patched including kernel (which is not that important), till about 2026.

Now let's keep in mind that I replied to a guy who said how great it is that ios has more longevity.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
I'll start by saying I spent a full 5 minutes reading through those and gave up. I asked for an example, you pasted twenty pages of random garbage and said "here, maybe you'll find something in this dump I took - why don't you spend some time and maybe I'll prove you wrong."

In those five minutes of looking through your garbage dump, I found Zero vulnerabilities that do not need either you installing a virus, which then gets root (the vulnerability), or a bug in an application running as root that's out of date, which then of course gives the attacker of the application root. None of those are valid examples, and I'm now bored digging through random garbage.

Any hack, in Any application, will give the attacker root - we're running rooted phones (for the extra functionality).

If you want to make a point, note the actual bug listed that does not need a compromised application. You installing a virus then the virus getting root does not count. The thread is about a kernel bug giving a remote attacker control of your phone. Applications and drivers like your modem can be updated without you updating the kernel. The latest N6 kernel is 4.9.3, with updates from the end of 2019.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
We are not talking about datacenter servers - we are talking about smartphones. you can run a 4.9 kernel with all security patches applied, just like you can run windows10 with all security patches applied. You can update bluetooth and wifi modems without going to a later kernel version. We call those drivers, not kernels.

The issue you note is only exploitable via a bug if you have an outdated version of the chrome browser. You don't need to update the kernel, in order to update an application.

Seriously, I feel like I'm talking to my wife here, who is not a tech person. Why are you and the other couple of people being purposely dense, and purposely ignoring the content of your own links that doesn't fit your viewpoint?

BTW, after you said smartphones aren't servers, you go on to talk about why an older kernel is bad on servers.

But since you asked, the latest 4.9.3 kernel running on that nexus6 from 2014, that's been compiled appears to be from the end of the year 2019.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
You're ok w/ a pixel5 size (6" screen) but you're not ok w/ s10 size (6.1" and has headphone jack)? And the actual phone size of the S10 is smaller than the nexus 5 you mentioned.
soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
I completely agree with you. If you want simple, if you want OTA updates from the people who made your phone, if you don't want to worry about it - iphone is perfect, i buy them for my wife.

But the discussion in this thread was specifically about the claim that iphones unlike android have a long life of updates. That's like saying "my dell from 2010 came with windows vista, windows vista is not supported, the computer has a short support life. Umm, no, you put Win10 or Linux on it, and can probably put win11 on it, and in 30 years still put the newest linux on it.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
Alright - I'll bite. This is a smartphone, not a windows PC with a bunch of services. There is Zero listening on any port. There is no attack surface for any kernel - the only thing there would be a bug in mms. Please share your source for kernel attacks, on any android version, that's not an attack on an app - but on the kernel. No, this is not a google play attack, or an attack on an outdated app - which are updated fine.

In addition, I'm unsure why you think you can't update the kernel on a phone. In fact, updating the kernel is standard procedure for... pretty much all directions on flashing a custom ROM. I had my nexus6 on kernel 4.9.3. There are literally new phones, right now, selling with that kernel version and earlier, with android11.

This is like saying windows server 2016 has a kernel that's outdated, or that windows 10 which came out in 2015 is outdated.

I think you are extremely confused.

>I really don’t recommend

Which is a good thing, because you should not be recommending about things you do not understand on even a basic level.

>After that, it’s probably left up to the community.

right. the entire point of my post. you can load stuff from the community. which includes the community of things like lineage - a big official community that's an llc - a corporation like redhat.

A phone is not a server. It is not a security risk to run an outdated kernel. there are no services running a hacker can connect to. You don't connect to a kernel over the internet. A kernel which is by no means out of date, and is currently running in many datacenters.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
it's def not for the iphone crowd though. also the crappiest lineageOS support ever - but lots of other roms.

I got the panda version. after 2 months in my side pocket, the white paint that for some reason the google geniuses decided should cover the also white plastic, started peeling off. From rubbing with my leather wallet. completely irrelevant to the functionality, which is the good part about it. searched it and everyone w/o a case is having the paint peeling issue. but... it's a much better issue than the entire phone, front and back being made of glass that breaks and costs $100+ to replace, and falls frequently because it's too slippery to hold in one hand.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
Samsung S10 and S10+ looks to me like the place to be, flashed w/ a custom degoogled ROM. Nokia Maps (here wego), Open Camera, something like Aptoide, K9 mail.

https://forum.xda-developers.com/c/samsung-galaxy-s10.8693/

I did a lot of research earlier, because I don't use a case, dropped my pixel 2xl, and the glass on the corner cracked. I ended up just putting a dab of epoxy on it instead though. I use the carbonOS ROM on the pixel, which os only for pixels I think. You do have to go through a lot of system services and turn off the unneeded ones though. Lots of useless stuff like "carrier services" and "sprint dm" and a bunch of other crap - just google them one by one. An app like Fibers is great too - I use it to do things like display percentages instead of icons, and when I need turn off half the screen pixels. You can do that in low brightness situations like reading this site in bed w/ the lights off, and you can't tell it's half the resolution. Adguard is great too - blocking ads at the DNS level saves quite a bit of battery when online.

Now here's the main thing - I do spend a couple of hours per day using it - either for email or reading sites. I get about 4 days from 90% to 25%. I never go below 25% or above 90% - my battery is like new 3+ years later. Another feature that an iphone can't have - an app having access to limit your max charge limit. I'm just guessing that 100%-0% is going to be about 7 days, so I can't fully promise that.

Also, a couple of banking apps don't work. The Uber app doesn't work either - you have to use the website versions.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
I love the iphone. I get my wife the latest and greatest every two years, and I forget about it. If she had an Android anything, I'd be spending at least an hour per week on tech support. It's absolutely worth the inflated price for me, and the fact that it's extremely limited in possible features is a bonus. Just like I used to love stick, but now an automatic tranny is great, as my enjoyment is the destination not the trip.

Now as far as the iphone 6s being usable - that's my point. It is usable, on the old OS it was designed for. Because you can't load your own OS on it, it will never run the latest. While the Nexus does run the latest, and is completely usable. I do remember when my brother loaded some latest ios on his iphone 5S, and it literally became too slow to answer a phonecall.

Apple's lock-in is in my opinion a feature for its target market. That's why they get like $1200 from me every two years. Me, my concern was battery life. For that I needed to not have crap that keeps phoning home and waking up the phone. Imagine charging once per week. While not an issue now, I used to travel a lot. Country-hopping trips. Yes, you can charge at the airport, tied to a full charing pole for an hour. Yes you can charge while sleeping on the plane and have a usb cable hanging in six inches in front of your face getting in the way. Or... You can literally not worry about it for a week.

There are of course other things - I want to chromecast my screen or cast a movie from a pirate streaming site (not the youtube app). I want toggles on my lock screen and home screen to turn off data/wifi/bluetooth. I want to turn on the flashlight if I press both power buttons when the phone screen is off. I more importantly need a filesystem that I can store OVAs on that I can take to customer sites for demos - why would I carry a usb stick when my phone is always with me. I want a web server running on it and my laptop to dump a backup of itself onto the phone daily. This means the phone phone software needs to recognize that the phone hardware is a computer, not a toy for 5yo kids. My wife on the other hand needs it to be a toy, because if it wasn't, she'd do everything possible to get viruses, delete everything, and screw something up. So I got an android, she has an iphone.

Now, you think I'm complaining about longevity. Let's see the reality though.

The post I'm replying to touts the iphone's longevity compared to Android. I point out Android has much, much longer longevity and he has it backwards. You then declare I'm complaining about the iphone's longevity.

Now, normally I would normally unload on you with all kinds of funny (for me) things at this point, because you now fit into a certain category of people, but this isn't the place.

soylentnewsorg··on Google Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro
One doesn't have to dream. Flashing a rom on google-branded phones is so simple, a non-tech person can follow a 5min youtube video to do it. The Nexus 6 from 2014 can have the latest android running on it - not just security updates. And unlike an iphone, it has a build that disables some eyecandy that keeps it actually usable and fast. As I understand it if you run the last supported ios on an iphone 5s, with all the patches, you can take a nap while waiting for the answer slider to draw when you get a call. IS that the dreaming you're talking about? During the nap?

I'm a tech guy though. had a nexus 6, now got a pixel2. all custom roms, completely degoogled. In addition to phone tasks, I use the phone for solitaire, basic web reading, and email. I charge once per week. Both phones are extremely easy to flash. No hacking or exploits required.

soylentnewsorg··on The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without a prescription
...which will simply make you more deaf. hearing aids do not simply amplify volume. you know, because they're not headphones and a microphone.

but your idea is great too. if you can't hear one frequency, let's amplify all frequencies till the one you need gets loud enough, and go deaf to the other ones in a year. when you get old and need a hearing aid, you should stick with your method.

soylentnewsorg··on MacBook Pro 14-inch and MacBook Pro 16-inch
The RTX 3090 - literally the top performing card available, that doubles as a space heater has 24GB of VRAM. Either you're wrong, or Apple built a Civic with a huge exhaust. Which will sound like a vacuum cleaner...

Here are the top Dell specs to compare. 128GB ECC RAM. 6 core Xeon. NVIDIA RTX a5k. Huge exhaust panel on the back (keep the CPU clocked high longterm instead of for burst). 120Hz 4k display (the 4k they've had for many years now). 14TB storage.

And you know what? It's pretty thin. And very sturdy.

Now, I'm not crapping on Apple's new laptop. I'm sure it's awesome, and can compete very well with the mid tier laptops from other vendors, at twice the price and half the durability. And it's always been that way. From keyboards that break from typing, to keyboards leaving key imprints on the screen. Can't expect much from a looks-first company that can't get a keyboard right, and builds their phones out of slippery fragile glass.

My issue is with their constant misleading meaningless marketing garbage. They are the orange clown of computers. If they made an umbrella, they'd build it out of laser-drilled ice, in the shape of a beautiful swan, and melting would be the built-in cleaning feature.

soylentnewsorg··on MacBook Pro 14-inch and MacBook Pro 16-inch
Ok, I believe you're being sarcastic, because this little paragraph is ridiculous, so I'll address it as if you are - because then you have a very good point.

This is Apple's Pro line. There is no more performant laptop that they make. It's a portable workstation - a home tower that you can take with you. If people want battery life of 10+ hours or a light weight, they get the model optimized for that. Apple seems to not offer a real pro laptop (portable workstation) - period. People who use these pro laptops are either compiling code or doing heavy graphics.

Work gives us Dell Precision laptops with 9 hours battery life during casual use, a pretty dang powerful discreet GPU, and oh - Xeon CPUs. No offense apple, but this "pro" laptop is a toy in comparison.

So I don't get it - apple's plan. I couldn't seriously use their products for work unless I want to lose productivity. Why don't they make something that's actually "pro" instead of calling what everyone else calls mid-tier a "pro" and then completely excluding the actual pro target market all together. Do they just not want more money?

As a developer, waiting less time for your device to finish an operation, while sitting there reading HN, makes you not need as much battery life. And the Dell seems designed for a full workday plus an hour. Now, I'm not a dev - did that for a year of my 20+ year career, too much sitting looking at code. I do however script a lot - with gigs of text output from data collection of logs and performance data, usually doing basic calculations or transformations. I look a lot at large datasets and graph them. I need a big GPU, I need fast CPUs. I mount up a 20G RAM drive because the disk is too slow.

Now yeah - when compared to another Apple laptop w/ a Xeon, the M1 is faster for single threaded specialized workloads. Because Apple uses CPUs a generation behind everyone else, has worse cooling, and still loses on multicore. In real life, when I run a shell script on my laptop, and a coworker runs it on the same dataset on an M1, his is an all day run - he does it overnight. I do it over a long lunch - it's not even a real comparison.

Now yes - My laptop gets hot, fans are blasting, and if my charge is at 80%, it literally won't charge while the script is running. But... that's what I want from a "pro." Now, his isn't a pro, and it stays barely warm. But we're talking the difference between 7 hours and 2 hours here. I don't think the "pro" is going to be all that much better.

So I get the apples to old apples comparison. However apples to flagships from others - I highly doubt apple a serious contender for the portable workstation. Which is what "pro" should be.

soylentnewsorg··on [dead]
Yeah, the entire piece reads like it was written by a who took AP Econ in high school, majored in Philosophy, then joined superbonk or whatever on reddit two decades later. This article is him telling the apes why they're wrong.

Inflation isn't making the poor poorer, but it is making the middle class poorer, while turning the rich into the wealthy.

Poor people don't have money, nothing to lose value. Poor people don't have property or stocks - nothing to hold/grow value. The rich got all their cash invested (percentage-wise), so their stuff isn't affected by inflation. It's that middle class, where half their savings are in mutual funds and half in cash type assets like a CD or a savings account - that's who get the shaft here.

But that AP econ class - I took that too, and I'm an expert in economics because I got edumacation in it, and have a schwab account for my 401k. So I'm a fully qualified expert on global economics, and I say inflation is great for a country, on a global scale. Other countries buy your bonds, your cash loses value, you now owe them less value. China does this a lot to screw other countries - artificially inflate their currency, and now their external debts are less. Now, the end result is who the hell would give them credit - that's like giving the orange clow credit. But they were at that level even before their fake inflation.

We have other tools for redistributing wealth. Laws, regulations, tax codes. We don't need that feature to be built into the currency. Especially the way it's built in to the currency in reality - redistributing it to the rich every time the fed prints more of it.

Crypto is crap for one simple fact. There's no large army with nukes making its value stable. All a crypto-rich person has to do to increase its value is sell a lot of it, to himself, at a high price.

soylentnewsorg··on HTTP is obsolete – it's time for the distributed, permanent web (2015)
This only sounds ridiculous because you replaced the things the OP was talking about, with your own, to make it sound ridiculous.

"Is it about being a decentralized caching layer? Is it about permanently storing content? Is it about replacing my web server? Is it about replacing DNS? Is it about censorship resistance?"

websites at the beginning did not decide to be a caching layer - they decided to be websites. they did decide to permanently store content. they did decide to use web servers. they did not decide to replace dns. they did decide to be about censorship resistance.

now imagine you put up a website, put some time into it, and it may or may not be up at a random time in the future. not a product that's usable.

soylentnewsorg··on Dislike button would improve Spotify's recommendations
Based on assuming I talk at the office to my coworkers the way I talk to some stranger with a really bad opinion online, you have deduced that coworkers at my presales job in data storage are not treated well.

Based on how you talk here, you sound like you paint a fake little world around yourself full of straw men to make you feel better. Which goes well in line with your opinion you know better than the user of a product, what that user wants. Living in a fake little world where you da man, courtesy of your brain.

This is called deep seeded insecurity - where your brain makes subconscious coping mechanisms to avoid depression. Bullied a lot in high school?

soylentnewsorg··on Dislike button would improve Spotify's recommendations
I am speaking as if I have no idea about your work and what you do. I am speaking as if I am addressing the specific incredibly stupid thing you said, from a user point of view. You know who does not care about your music "industry" or your "work?" The users of spotify. They care about listening to music they want to listen to. My background is I listen to music using things that play it. Spotify is absolute crap because the people that make it do exactly how you said. The fact that you think you know better than the user is why I put that last paragraph in. You still don't get it, and you never will, and that's the whole point. People who think like you shouldn't be allowed to have any input on features or product, because you make inferior products, and destroy good ones. It happens a lot, with a lot of stuff. Because of you.
soylentnewsorg··on Dislike button would improve Spotify's recommendations
I did not suggest anything. I very clearly stated what I stated, in plain English that is very easy to understand. Your qualifications are irrelevant. Your point of view on the issue we are discussing is wrong for long-term product success, and destroys the hard work others have put into the idea, in order to feel personally superior to your users. I don't know how more plainly I can put it for you if you had trouble understanding that. I do believe however that not understanding something, is not something that has ever prevented you from action or strong and wrong opinions on a subject matter.
soylentnewsorg··on Dislike button would improve Spotify's recommendations
That last part is the most important point - the main point. Your comment shows the exact issue as the "you don't need a dislike button because our AI knows better." You read my post, you read all the comments on here with users either jumping through hoops or ditching the product, you read the comment like what I replied to saying "we know what you need better than you do."

That last bit is a person thinking some crap code they wrote can figure out why someone doesn't want to listen to a song at a particular time. They ignore all the inputs into that decision - how tired they are, what day they had, are they angry at something, have they heard it on another medium recently. Then ignore all that data they don't have, and have the AI make the decision: did you skip after 20 seconds? If you did, let's cut this genre out of your playlist.

This little thing, destroyed spotify's recommendation product. The people in charge of this, are going to destroy everything they touch, because they think their little piece of code, is smarter than the user, about what the user wants. You know, because the user can't code.

People making these decisions - well all I can say is I've met them. I've been personal friends with some. They have been passed up for jobs when I get called for a reference check. Because once they're on your team, they'll destroy your product, so they can feel personally superior.

So that last part is very necessary, because it's an extremely serious issue, exactly as I put it. But in your opinion it's not, so let's cut that part out because it's not necessary for what I was saying. Because you know better than me what I was trying to say.

<dislike>

soylentnewsorg··on Dislike button would improve Spotify's recommendations
You are exhibiting google's mistake, caused by over educated people with zero real experience thinking they know better. Or, I should correct that - some code they wrote knows better than the complex brain of the actual person. This results in "AI" (big if/then loop) trying to figure it out, and completely blocking any input from the customer.

Here's the issue with "inferred from other activity." You know how you can find out? Give the customer a way to tell you. And no - you cannot "infer from other activity."

>Skipping a song after less then 20 seconds for example can train a model...

..to be wrong. You know when I usually skip a song after 20 seconds? When I've heard it too much, or just heard it on youtube on my laptop an hour ago. In a couple of days I'll want to hear it again. The reason I heard it too much, is I like the song. Your AI though - if I skip this favorite song of mine a couple of times, will now block it and all other songs like it. The literal opposite of what I want.

What this results in, is you have an inferior product, your customers leave, then you leave and go screw up another company's product without ever learning your lesson.

soylentnewsorg··on Wearable Microphone Jamming
> why aren't our ears affected

they're affected listening to the raw microphone capture. that's because the noise generated is much louder than the speech. so listening to raw microphone capture with this thing on, you can't make out words at all - just a few syllables here and there. the key is that the full voice signal is still captured by the microphone. you then filter out the additional noise (your conference software and laptop microphone does that at a shitty level, rtx voice is the top consumer product for this). once the noise is gone, you have only the original voice. due to the filtering, the original voice is very lightly garbled, which is enough to confuse voice recognition software, not your ears.

notice how they're using voice recognition to measure success? that's misleading and on purpose. if they used a person to see if this product is effective, the result would be - the product is literally nothing but a loud noisemaker which in zero ways does what it says it does.

now, I don't have an rtx. if you want to screw around, here's a very shitty two megabyte software version of what rtx voice does, it's open source and just a couple of meg. https://antlionaudio.com/blogs/news/free-active-noise-suppre...

a low pass filter, or a nice microphone would not help you at all here - the white noise is in the vocal range and no simple frequency filter is going to remove it. their product makes ultrasonic noise, which (probably due to microphone resonance) makes the mic vibrate in the audible range. again, not affecting the original voice signal, so it's loud white noise overlaid on top of the voice.

it does seem putting something in front of the mic that absorbs ultrasonic frequency but not lower voice frequencies works well to block this. which is why the thin plastic waterproofing film over the phone microphone completely blocks this product - no noise removal filter needed.

So literally any smartphone with water resistance bypasses this thing and records fine. for the rest, just run a noise removal filter on the recording and listen to it. for governments, I'm sure their spy mics are waterproof and immune, and if not, their voice recognition is better than whatever consumer tech these guys tested it on.

soylentnewsorg··on Wearable Microphone Jamming
No, I'm saying that does literally nothing but add noise. It does not block or change the original signal in any significant way for human ears - only for consumer-level voice recognition software. Which is extremely crappy even without noise for anything more complex than "hey google play some ads in the middle of this song."

Once you take the noise out, the voice recognition software has problems recognizing the words. People do not. You can take the noise out at home with lots of different software or hardware. Skype/teams/zoom do this on a very basic level by default - as do most microphone audio drivers in windows. Once it's taken out, distortion from the noise is just enough to make the voice recognition miss a bunch of words. Human ears do just fine though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u3zdGza5zeI

soylentnewsorg··on Wearable Microphone Jamming
No one is going to buy this. It doesn't jam your voice at all. It introduces enough distortion and noise so that computer speech recognition software gets 4/5 words wrong.

Let me make a comparison. Claim: Those capchas with "type in the word you see" have an error rate of 4/5 letters when read by a computer. Yet here we are, humans, reading them just fine.

Now, if you're a conspiracy theory fake elected moon landing virus hoax person who is afraid of the government having microphones everywhere, running a keyword search on microphones placed around the park.... Still not a jammer - I'm sure whatever voice recognition software this thing confuses, the government has much better ones. Simply from the fact that most of the people they're interested in have accents so thick it's worse than some added "jammer" noise.

But to answer your question, "sounds" like they're trying to go commercial soon, because their announcement of this dirt simple product sounds like a cheap advertisement for some dick enlarging pills. meanwhile, your phone speaker can make sonic sounds since they support a sample rate of over 44khz. So can your computer.

here you go. you can google and download some files to play too. https://mynoise.net/NoiseMachines/audioJammerNoiseGenerator....

soylentnewsorg··on Governor vows criminal prosecution of reporter who found flaw in state website
I never claimed page 346 was breaking the law. I claimed after you discover that the action reveals private data, and you repeat that action a bunch of times for the explicit purpose of getting more private data, you are now a criminal. This is what the OP very clearly stated he did.

He did not report the issue after finding it. He abused the security hole for his own benefit. He is a criminal.

Low severity? In civil court, they can take every penny he has, every penny he'll ever earn, and his house. In criminal court, he can be charged with unauthorized access to a computer system, one charge each time he did it. And he did it a lot, and they have logs. Which is all literally in his post.

Viewing other people's medical information is not a low severity crime btw.

soylentnewsorg··on Former Boeing 737 Max Chief Technical Pilot Indicted for Fraud
So as to not discourage people - right to work does not prevent you from going after a company that mistreated you in a civil lawsuit. If they ask you to do something unreasonable that was not in the job description, you can sue them for things like lost wages while you look for a new job, any relocation expenses to the new job, and to a harder extent emotional suffering an punitive damages.

Let me give a clearer example. Your boss tells you "shoot that old lady or you're fired." you refuse, he fires you. You can sue him, you will win, it has nothing to do with right to work or not. In my case it was asking me things to endanger patients, and refusing to put the request in writing so there's a record of it.

The issue with that is it's a civil suit, in court, and your law firm is now fighting a huge corporation for the amount equivalent to a couple of months' salary. It's not worth it in most cases, and they know that. But if you want to break even, and the huge amount of time and added stress of the lawsuit is worth revenge - not cash - absolutely do it, and punish those assholes. Except they're not really punished. The payout disappears in a database and becomes a rounding error somewhere, and the management responsible never gets punished. They don't have the stress and time waste of the lawsuit - there are zero consequences to them, and it's yet more loss to you.

Unless you're willing to find a lawyer who'll just take part of the settlement if you win and guarantee you it won't take up a lot of your time. I contacted a bunch of attorneys, and that was a no-go. Contrary to popular belief, getting the guilty party to pay the attorney bills of the winner almost never happens in real life. Even if you get awarded those costs (doubtful) - they will simply refuse to pay. You can then show up and take their office furniture and put it on ebay.

soylentnewsorg··on Governor vows criminal prosecution of reporter who found flaw in state website
..and you're not allowed to walk into someone's house if they only have a door frame instead of a locked door. they are for preventing criminals from forcefully breaking in. but you don't have to break in to commit the crime. that's why it's called "breaking and entering" - there are two criminal acts committed.
soylentnewsorg··on Governor vows criminal prosecution of reporter who found flaw in state website
It's interesting you completely omit the part where he figures out the string in the URL that's a company's ID, and uses that to request a file. In your example it would be "I'm this other person, can you share my own files with me?" Except he's lying, and he's not the other person.

Tell me, what happens if you, heavyset_go, send an invoice to Apple, and the invoice says you're "Cisco" and they pay it. Do you get to keep the money, or does the prison get to keep you?

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →