I wonder if any of these theologians will ever change the direction of their logic. It's funny that things like this are said, “How could he be God and leave extraterrestrials in sin?”, and not "if there are extraterrestrials, is there really a god?".
What's the point on logically arguing from a position of faith anyway? Doesn't that defeat the point?
Maybe we should just stop believing the stories of people who quite clearly tripped during a fasting high (or similar) in the desert over 2000 years ago.