HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Low Doses of LSD Acutely Increase BDNF Blood Plasma Levels in Healthy Volunteers
I used it at a birthday party a few years ago. My main takeaways were twofold:

First, it made me understand the concept of good and bad "vibes" w.r.t. to drug use. It was clear that the experience of taking LSD recreationally in a group of people was a much a social experience as a chemical one. Keeping the "vibe" positive, by playing the right kind of music, staying chill, and saying and doing the right things, was important not to break the spell. Unfortunately, as somebody who suffers from social anxiety, this awareness made things quite stressful for me at times, as I felt I had to constantly maintain some level of self-regulation, which was not made easier by how intoxicated I was. I have the same problem when smoking weed in company.

Second, while I hoped for the kind of psychological breakthroughs and revelations that some people describe having using LSD, I didn't experience them. I never felt connected to the universe or some greater purpose. I certainly had periods of intense introspection, but they didn't reveal anything to my about my character I wasn't already aware of. I think part of that was that I was already in my mid-thirties at the time, and had done plenty of introspection over the years. I already had a good understanding of my own character — my strengths, weaknesses, hopes, fears and regrets — and I suspect anybody with a similar disposition won't have any breakthroughs using LSD.

Ultimately, I didn't regret trying LSD, but it didn't leave me with any desire to try it again. Despite its reputation, it just seemed like another drug to me. Stronger in its effect than most, but I never felt like a child of the universe, I just felt high.

stupidcar··on How two British orthodontists became celebrities to incels
AFAIK, some do advocate having surgery. But plastic surgery is expensive and scary, whereas "Mewing" is a pretty basic set of exercises you can do for free.

If you want to get more psychological about it, perhaps there's a difference in attitude between surgery, which could be said to be constructing a falsehood to cover up the (literally) ugly truth of your own relative inferiority, versus Mewing, which is pitched as more akin to a workout regime to fix something that was unwittingly done to you by modern living. As such, your current face becomes the falsehood, and Mewing is how you reveal the real truth of how you should look.

This might seem to be over-analysis, but I think, in these kinds of communities, narratives matter just as much, perhaps more, than actions. The problem these people have isn't just their situation, but how they feel about the situation. The depression, sense of inadequacy, etc. These feelings can be relieved by explanations that say it isn't you that's wrong, it's the world that's wrong, but that you retain control enough to fix things through the application of will.

stupidcar··on The cult of the free must die
People can and do pay for "free" web services like Firefox. They pay with their personal data. This is exchanged into regular currency via the advertising industry. Services that cannot or will not exploit this income stream will inevitably run into financial trouble.

Economically, spending personal data makes sense for a lot of people. Unlike money, you generate personal data continuously and effortlessly. You can spend it multiple times, many people spend it with little obvious downside, and the process is completely frictionless. Consider the effort involved with setting up, maintaining and eventually cancelling a subscription to a money-financed service, vs. a data-financed one, which you simply start and stop using at your leisure.

Some people do not like this situation. They object to the entire notion of personal data being used as a currency. They attempt to prevent it via advocacy and legislation. Advocacy does not seem to work, at least on its own. Many people, if you explain the situation to them in terms of privacy, will express a theoretical desire not to trade away their personal data. However, their behaviour is not consistent with this. Faced with a choice between using data-financed and money-financed services, the majority chooses the former.

Legislation attempts to resolve this dilemma, either by outlawing the use of personal data as a currency at all, or more often by making the spending of personal data more a onerous and explicit process, in the hope that a closer equivalence in terms of convenience combined with repeated reminders of people's stated preference to maintain their privacy will alter their behaviour.

Personally, I'm skeptical this type of legislation will succeed. Clicking a few checkboxes and cookie banners is still far more convenient than giving my credit card details to every single website or app I want to use. And most humans act in opposition to their stated ideals and desires in myriad ways, every single day.

stupidcar··on Are Humans Intelligent? An AI Op-Ed
Despite the supposed "mystery" of consciousness, it won't be hard to reproduce in an AI. Take a general intelligence system, give it the ability to sense its own mental state (e.g. by feeding the output of its intermediate layers back into its inputs). Pretty soon it will start building a conceptual representation of itself and the evolution of that representation over time will be conscious self-awareness.
stupidcar··on Wakaresaseya: private agents hired to end relationships
The UK too has only just introduced the concept of "no-fault divorce": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-fault_divorce#United_Kingdo...

Previously couples had to apportion blame for the marriage breakdown, which encouraged it to be an adversarial and rancorous process.

stupidcar··on μPlot v1.1 – now with log scales support
uPlot really is amazing. My dream is that one day all the CSS Houdini[1] tech will be finished and widely supported and someone will create a version of it on top of the layout/painting/font-metrics APIs that is equally performant while fully responsive w.r.t. to container size and dynamic data.

[1] https://ishoudinireadyyet.com/

stupidcar··on Why forgiving someone else is about you
False dichotomy.

Taking steps to heal yourself from damage, such as a physical burn or a psychological wound, doesn't necessarily mean not taking the threat seriously in future. Pain is a signal that teaches us a lesson. Once the lesson is learned, holding onto the pain can just be needless suffering.

stupidcar··on Are we in an AI Overhang?
I've seen this objection raised a lot, but I think it betrays a misunderstanding of what GPT-3 is capable of doing.

The best, in fact the only way to generate truly convincing text output on most subjects is to understand, on some level, what you're writing about. In other words, to create a higher level abstraction than simply "statistically speaking, this word seems to follow that one". Once you start to encode that words map to concepts, you can use the resulting conceptual model to create output which is conceptually consistent, then map it backwards to words. There is what humans do with sensory data, and there is good evidence that GPT-3 is doing this too, to some degree.

Take simple arithmetic, such as adding two and three digit numbers. GPT-2 could not do this very successfully. It did indeed look like it was treating it as a "find the textual pattern" problem.

But GPT-3 is much more successful, including at giving correct answers to arithmetic problems that weren't in its training set.

So what changed? We aren't sure, but the speculation is that in the process of training, GPT-3 found that the best strategy to correctly predicting the continuation of arithmetic expressions was to figure out the rules of basic arithmetic and encode them in some portion of its neural network, then apply them whenever the prompt suggested to do so.

If this is the case, and it remains speculation at this point, would you still argue that GPT-3 doesn't "understand" arithmetic, on some level? I would argue that this abstraction, this mapping of words onto higher-level concepts, which can then be manipulated to solve more complex problems, is exactly what intelligence is, once you strip away biologically-biased assumptions.

Certainly, at this point GPT-3's conceptual understanding remains somewhat primitive and unstable, but the fact that it exhibits it at all, and sometimes in spookily impressive ways, is what has people excited and worried. We have produced AIs that can perhaps think conceptually about relatively narrow topics like playing Go, but we have never before created one that can do so one such a wide range of topics. And there is no suggestion that GPT-3's level of ability represents a maximum. GPT-4 and beyond will be more powerful, meaning that it can mine more and more powerful conceptual understanding from their training data.

stupidcar··on Boy, 16, was given estrogen at L.A. juvenile hall, suit says
This reads like the plot of a dystopian young adult sci-fi novel. Children who resist authority being diagnosed with a "behavioural disorder" and being forcibly given hormones by an evil doctor. Yet apparently this is the reality of modern society.
stupidcar··on Everything you need to know about OAuth 2.0
Agreed. I recommend this video to every new dev joining our team.
stupidcar··on Letting Robots Manipulate Cables
Although brains cannot do it "out of the box". Most kids take years of practice to achieve decent dexterity in even simple manipulation tasks. And learning a new skill like guitar in adulthood makes it very clear that, however sophisticated your capabilities in other areas, you have no innate ability to perform complex physical tasks well without a long grind of practice.

So yes, brains are incredible in what they can eventually achieve, and the fact that the calculation involved becomes hidden from conscious awareness can make it seem "effortless", but when you consider the sum of time and effort spent practicing physical tasks over a typical human lifespan, it's really anything but.

stupidcar··on Göbekli Tepe
I became aware of Hancock by listening to the Our Fake History podcast series about him and his claims:

https://ourfakehistory.com/index.php/season-4/episode-78-who...

The impression I got is... not good, to to say the least.

stupidcar··on The modern web makes me want to throw up (2016)
Can you provide some examples of complex web apps you consider to be substantially slower than their native equivalents?

[Edit] I'll take the downvotes as evidence you can't.

For example, I use https://app.diagrams.net/ for diagramming. I don't find it to be any slower than native equivalents like Visio.

I use https://www.figma.com/ for UI design. I don't find it to be any slower than native equivalents like Sketch.

I use Google Docs for word processing. I don't find it to be any slower than native equivalents like Word.

stupidcar··on The modern web makes me want to throw up (2016)
It's perfectly possible to write a performant app with the web. If the author thinks it isn't, the problem is their ignorance, not the web.
stupidcar··on GitHub was down
Or it could be some of the older employees decided to cash out after the acquisition, and they've lost some institutional knowledge about how to keep things running smoothly?
stupidcar··on Software should be designed to last
What this article really boils down to is the usual coder arrogance: Thinking that most problems are inherently simple[1], thinking they are a better coder than average, and thinking that the answer is always to do more yourself, so that more of the codebase will benefit from your superior skills.

The truth is, there are no easy problems in programming. There are always a thousand corner cases and unexpected complexities. And all those buggy, unmaintained libraries you find in your language's package repository are still probably better than anything you're going to roll yourself. Look into the source code of such libraries and alongside the hacks and outdated code, you'll find hundreds of subtle problems avoided, because the author spent a long time and effort on the problem you've spent ten minutes thinking about.

The answer to quality problems in software engineering is not less libraries, it's more and better libraries. In the same way that the high-quality civil engineering the author admires is not achieved by having one person do everything themselves, but by the successful collaboration of a large number of skilled and specialised subcontractors.

Right now, we're still in the infancy of our industry. This, combined with continued the evolution of hardware capabilities has meant that software engineering has never had the long-term, stable base on which to build repeatable, reliable routes to success. That's fine. If we're in the same position in a couple of centuries, it's a problem, but right now we should be experimenting and failing.

Even today, the situation is not as bleak as if often portrayed in articles like this. There are a huge number of robust and high-quality libraries and frameworks providing extremely complex capabilities in an easily reusable way. If a programmer from the mid-nineties were to be transported to the present, I suspect they'd be amazed by what off-the-shelf libraries enable even a single programmer to do. The undeniable quality problems that do affect much modern software often have more to do with the hugely increased scope of ambition in what we expect software to do for us.

[1] Outside a handful, like encryption, that are acknowledged as hard for the purpose of being the exception that proves the rule.

stupidcar··on DeepMind AI reading list [pdf]
I'd echo one of their recommendations: Robert Mile's YouTube channel focussing on AI safety. He presents the material in a very interesting and accessible way. For example, this video on whether or not corporations can be considered a form of superintelligence: https://youtu.be/L5pUA3LsEaw
stupidcar··on Writing, Reading, Writing
It seems pretty clear from this that, had the pandemic not intervened, he would never have finished. He completed three chapters in the space of a week, and yet still doesn't anticipate being finished until next year. Ironic that the jokes fans made about locking him in a cell until he finished the book have sort of come true.
stupidcar··on Towards an Untrepreneurial Economy? Rise of the Veblenian Entrepreneur (2019)
It's weird to see stuff like this published as a "paper", as if it were a scientific endeavour, when there doesn't seem to be any experiment, mathematics, or even data involved. Just a lot of conjecture sprinkled with citations. It seems like the epitome of Feynman's cargo cult science. I'm actually very sympathetic with the idea being advanced, I'm just not sure what really separates this and a blog post.
stupidcar··on Covid-19: The T Cell Story
Just because the choir couldn't select its members on the basis of lower immunity, doesn't it mean it didn't select them (or they self-selected on) the basis of some characteristic(s) that happened to correlate with lower immunity, e.g. age, biological gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, etc.

The same is true of any other sub-population this is not a true random sample of the global population, like prisons, care homes, even settlements like towns and villages. If you can make any prediction about their members with greater confidence than you could with a random member of the whole population, then they are not random in the sense that matters.

Explaining how and why the characteristics of those sub-populations could correlate with greater natural immunity is certainly a challenge to those advocating for the idea of some level of latent immunity. But, likewise, substantially different outcomes in sub-populations that engaged in similar interventions is a challenge for those advocating that only interventions matter. For example, I've not heard a convincing explanation for Germany's relative success based only on the quality of its healthcare system and interventions. That isn't to deny that they played an important role, just that they may not have been the whole story.

stupidcar··on Trying something again
The frustrating thing is, all the assumptions here really should be true. Big corps should be the best place to do focussed, meaningful work on a product you believe in. And start-ups, with all their constraints in terms of budget, personnel, brand recognition, sales, etc. should be the worst.

I still hold out hope than some day someone will crack how to structure large organisations in a way that eliminates or minimises the politics and dysfunction while retaining the economies of scale. I feel like this will require a radically different approach, with innovative legal and technical structures to enforce the right incentives.

stupidcar··on Ask HN: A way to adblock “we're using cookies” popups?
I absolutely blame the EU for this. The job of any political organisation isn't just to blindly regulate, but to predict the likely response of the regulated industry, including in a worst case scenario.

I worked in web dev when these regulations were introduced, and any idiot could see that most companies would take the laziest, safest route to complying with them, in a way that would put a massive burden of inconvenience on the user.

If the EU was competent, they wouldn't have needed warning about this outcome. But they were warned, again and again and again. They chose to ignore it and screwed over their constituents for nothing.

stupidcar··on Jim Keller Resigns from Intel, Effective Immediately
Maybe the reason he was doing so much media was because he was encountering resistance to his ideas internally at Intel. Talking publicly about them and becoming the public face of Intel's CPU design program might have been his way to get more intellectual leverage. If it was, I guess it didn't work.
stupidcar··on How London Transport Is Preparing for Life After Lockdown
The post I was replying to was saying that masks are not 100% effective when worn properly. Now you're talking about people not wearing masks properly. What's your point?
stupidcar··on How London Transport Is Preparing for Life After Lockdown
The point is, in Japan's case masks appear to be 100% effective, or very close to it, in eliminating transmission on public transport.

Do you have a reason to believe greater prevalence of the virus is linked to lower mask effectiveness in this specific context?

stupidcar··on How London Transport Is Preparing for Life After Lockdown
https://usa.streetsblog.org/2020/05/29/feds-seek-incentives-...

"Japan, which has the third highest rate of transit ridership in the world, found no infection events linked to commuter trains after performing rigorous contact tracing on almost 17,000 confirmed cases."

stupidcar··on A tech stack should be a well-balanced portfolio
I disagree with respect to frameworks like React, Angular and Vue. Yes, they all "do the same thing" when viewed from a distance, but up close the details of say, managing state with hooks in React, is very different from managing state with services and RxJS observables in Angular.

These differences aren't always sexy, but understanding them is usually the difference between a developer who can deliver a high-quality solution and solve difficult problems and one who can hack together something that sort-of works with enough Googling. In my experience, a lot of "overengineering" in these kind of frameworks is really devs with insufficient understanding of their details inventing unnecessary workarounds and abstractions.

So, yes, devs flitting between frameworks is a problem, but not because they're doing the wrong kind of learning, but because they never learn enough to be truly effective. And I don't think this is a result of some pervasive attentional deficit, but because hiring practices, especially in consultancy, favour direct commercial experience above everything, and devs are economically incentivised to maximise their earning potential and pool of job opportunities by working with as many technologies as possible.

stupidcar··on In Great Silence there is Great Hope (2007) [pdf]
As I said, we already have technology to colonise space. Not to spread throughout the galaxy, no, but at least to get to multiple places in our solar system. At that point the feasibility of a single event like a genetic accident always occurring and always wiping out the entirety of every species seems unlikely.

Not impossible, of course, but my argument wasn't about possibility vs impossibility, but probability.

stupidcar··on In Great Silence there is Great Hope (2007) [pdf]
If you're arguing it may not be possible to colonise space at all, that may be true but isn't germane to this discussion. The idea of Fermi paradox and the "great filter" presupposes that it is possible, and that there is some other, civilisation-ending event that stops it.

My argument is that, within the context of a debate that accepts the precepts of the Fermi paradox and great filter, the likelihood of where the great filter can be placed is constrained by probability. Within that context, even a limited colonisation of our own solar system would be sufficient to drastically reduce the likelihood of a single event to wipe out humanity entirely.

stupidcar··on In Great Silence there is Great Hope (2007) [pdf]
The idea that the "great filter", if there really is one, remains in our future seems to me to be extremely improbable. The fact is, we already have the ability, just about, to colonise space. That we haven't yet has more to do with economic reasons than technological ones, and it's entirely conceivable that we'll see substantial non-Earth settlements in our lifetime.

Now, that isn't to say we won't nuke ourselves get turn into grey goo or something before that happens, but the point is, but we're close enough to it that, even being pessimistic, there's got to be a reasonable chance we'll make it (over 0.01, say). And that's not good enough for a great filter. Any catastrophe that happens so close to the point of becoming a multi-planetary civilisation simply wouldn't catch enough species. There'd be too many who would make it through.

← PreviousPage 4 of 26Next →