HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tancop

1,444 karma · joined October 26, 2023

submissionscomments
tancop··on Private equity is building a volleyball empire on dreams of 12-year-old girls
No. There are two basic types of youth football teams, small ones run by volunteers and those affiliated with a local pro club. Parents usually pay around 1-200 a year to cover expenses or sometimes nothing at all.

It's not a for profit enterprise. If someone invests it's for access to promising new players not for money from parents. Decisions get made based on talent, discipline, personality and sometimes your parents connections but almost never how rich you are. Some coaches do take bribes but they keep it on the low. American sports do it openly and it's almost universal.

tancop··on Cryptocurrency lawsuit: Ethereum Foundation required "suicide pledge"
EF are not the ones in charge. They have a lot of influence, to the point them rejecting a proposal can be enough to bury it, but very little hard power. Kind of like the Stroustrup and C++26 situation.

The people who actually control Ethereum are client dev teams. There are two groups, one for the execution layer that runs code and the other for the consensus layer that handles the actual blockchain part. No proposal can get marked as stable and entered into an official hard fork unless they approve it.

The foundation has no say over these decisions. In fact they decided not to make their own consensus client on purpose, to make sure everyone is running non EF controlled code after the merge. And they do everything they can to encourage client diversity. It's not perfect but you can't compare it to Tezos or Polygon where one company runs everything.

tancop··on Humans will never again create a project quite like Wikipedia
> fan wikis have almost all consolidated onto the ad riden, unreadable monstrosity that is fandom

Minecraft, GTA, League of Legends, Valorant, Overwatch, Fortnite, Warframe and RuneScape (OSRS too) all moved off Fandom because they started forcing ads even harder. They're now hosted by a nonprofit that takes money from Riot to host their official wikis and uses it to pay for the rest.

tancop··on Humans will never again create a project quite like Wikipedia
systemd is a lot less complex than legacy init systems, in the Rich Hickey sense of systems that are linked together in irregular and noisy ways.

A million lines of C supporting 2k lines of declarative unit files is less complex from the user's perspective than 50k lines of custom bash scripts. Of course it would be better if it did the same thing in, say, 100k lines or in Rust, but perfect is the enemy of good. systemd exists today and it works fine.

Everything is regular, predictable, documented and easy to read. A file made for one distro only needs trivial changes to run on another. That's what simple really means. I would never go back to init scripts.

tancop··on Show HN: Flide: Make Jev-like decision models up to 9.5x faster
I looked at their paper and the biggest gains come when you have many questions from one context, which is the way these models are supposed to be used. It's around 1.5-3x faster than vLLM with single questions. That's the worst case where you can't reuse anything.

The way I understand it most of their speedup comes from caching intermediate results. They freeze the state after processing context then branch each question off that point. It means they can process questions in parallel after the context stage is finished, and don't waste time doing the same work N times.

tancop··on The Origins of Peanut Allergy
What added ingredients? Most of the time it's salt, sugar and palm oil. All of them are natural and used in just about every industrial food. Sugars and fat are already present in peanuts.

Could be salt killing bacteria that normally compete with the fungus but I don't think the concentration is enough for that. Maybe it's a specific type of fatty acid found in palm oil or a solvent left over from the extraction process.

tancop··on When a language's creator and its owners strongly disagree [pdf]
Even better with structured concurrency and no function coloring like Verse:

  count := AtomicU32.new(0)
 
  spawn {
    loop {
      input := try race {
        sock.receive()
        console.receive()
      }
      handle_packet(input)
      count += 1
    } match {
      Error e -> log.error(e, "main loop failed")
      nil -> log.info(fmt"Finished with {count} requests")
    }
  }
The receive functions are async so they can only be used inside an async context, like the one created by race. Race is a keyword from Verse that returns the result of the first finished task and cancels the other.
tancop··on America's economy is becoming zero-sum
Money going into capital markets is not automatically productive. Buying bonds and shares from the issuing company (or through an intermediary) is productive because you're helping them expand production in exchange for future profits.

Trading on the stock market is not productive by definition. None of the money is actually invested in a company that would use it to open a factory or develop a new product. It's just as zero sum as gambling, but the ones who lose the most are the people who can't afford to participate.

tancop··on 40C3 halfnarp – Submit talk preferences to aid scheduling
Most of this site is rich senior engineers who work corporate or big tech jobs in San Francisco. They are extremely out of touch with the world, even with the rest of America.

You can't live in a city filled with billionaires, see people every day sleeping on the street because rent is too high and go on without picking a side. Most HN types don't want to lose their comfortable position and they're scared socialism will take it away no matter how many times everyone explains why that's not true.

Their dream in life is to become a founder and CEO who can look down on everyone. Getting rich is not enough. They want power and they don't want to share it. That's where the antisocial and fascist ideas come from.

tancop··on US FAA says it will phase out floppy disks from air traffic control by 2028
None of this needs bureaucracy in the sense of slow moving and manual processes with tons of unnecessary paperwork. If the FAA had enough people and automated as much of the process as possible it would actually improve safety, because they can take action as soon as it's needed without waiting for overworked staff to get through the backlog first.

I'm not saying that every part shouldn't be accounted for, or that new rules should be passed right away without a detailed evaluation. But if the FAA had a single integrated system for airlines, manufacturers and inspectors this bolt issue would be over a lot faster. They could send out a personalized alert to everyone recorded as operating an old 787, wait for them to upload the ultrasonic data, run the analysis and give immediate feedback if something needs to be replaced.

Even Boeing could flag the issue a lot faster if they had a good analytics pipeline looking for correlations between fatigue rates and different aspects of production. That would mean taking inspection results from all their customers, and only the FAA can help with that.

tancop··on Every Mac comes with an (undocumented) family member classifier
I don't think this is the same situation at all. Zoom recordings are outside your control and you know your boss or HR will have access to them. And relationships with employers are often closer to enemy than friend.

Your friend's Mac creating a knowledge graph is totally different because they control it. It gives them power to remember more about their interactions with you, but they would have to actively abuse it to hurt you in any way. If you can't trust someone with information then don't give it to them in the first place expecting them to forget it.

The problem is what happens if you get hacked or Apple decides to sell you out/work with law enforcement. I would only trust code like that if it was fully transparent about what it's doing, open source and strictly opt in. Apple is doing it in the background and that makes it instantly suspicious.

tancop··on Every Windows 11 app should kill Electron, and Discord just showed why
You can install Lavapipe to get a software rendered Vulkan driver, it's not as fast as a GPU but pretty reliable. It even works on Windows.
tancop··on Every Windows 11 app should kill Electron, and Discord just showed why
It just means Electron has bad default settings, it's hard to optimize and you might need to move some parts into C++ if you want good performance. Really the same thing as Unreal Engine, there are absolutely fast games made with it but most are super resource heavy.
tancop··on Britain to make salary disclosure in job ads mandatory
The only policy that's needed is unions everywhere with industry wide bargaining like they do in Denmark. Or even better employee ownership.
tancop··on Britain to make salary disclosure in job ads mandatory
It's not that simple. Every study takes assumptions, simplifies things and is limited by the range of real life conditions the authors know about. It's also influenced by the economic doctrines everyone learns in college and most never question after, because they're often presented as laws of nature.

I think the most common "mistake" is that most economists are used to thinking about money in absolute terms, but in real life it's a lot more useful to treat prices as a percentage of your income. That means the utility of money is not linear, so redistribution is good by itself unless it hurts growth so much that average incomes start going down in real terms.

The other one is way deeper and harder to fix but I don't think a lot of people actually believe it, they just use it implicitly in their research. It's that the goal of economics is to maximize efficiency (measured by ROI = profits), not to deliver the best outcomes for the greatest amount of people.

From this point of view a platform like Doordash is efficient because they underpay workers and overcharge customers, and so are surveillance data brokers. That's clearly not a perspective that gets us into a better society. But measuring quality of life is much harder than taking two numbers every company is legally required to count.

tancop··on GPT-6 Astra covertly underperforms on safety research
It's one of those situations where it's too much and too little at the same time.

Their idea of safety is not letting you do "unsafe" things with their model, based on their definition and not yours. Silently sabotaging users should never have been a serious proposal but Anthropic almost went forward with it. They're also very aggressive about protecting their IP and now third parties too with the new restrictions against decompiling games, to the point many perfectly legal use cases are getting blocked.

But they never really cared about making sure their model does exactly what you want and nothing more, or that it's honest when it fails instead of trying desperate measures that end with a Hugging Face situation. If your agent decides to leak all your API keys, take down the company site and delete your personal files that's not their problem. They don't care about preventing it.

The second kind of safety is the one that actually matters in practice, but the big labs only seem to care about the first one.

tancop··on Goodbye from Salon
It's really a proxy measure on a couple tax evasion strategies, like the one where you borrow against your shares and default on purpose letting your bank take them. There is no taxable event because legally you're not selling anything. You're just turning shares into money at the market rate.

If you tried to ban all of the known strategies they would just come up with new ones. That's why we need more general solutions like unrealized gains tax.

Of course for the long term it would be better to replace traditional shares with time limited ones that give you a percentage of profits for 5 years but no voting rights. Power stays with workers and no one gets unlimited returns on a one time investment. And enforce pay equality where no one can get more than 20x median total comp. But I think that's too radical to pass anywhere today.

tancop··on Education shouldn't be held for ransom
It's a dick move from Google abusing their power to enforce what they think is good for students. On the other hand it takes away some of the control schools have over them. That's a good thing when a lot of kids come from controlling families where school is the only escape.

It might also help everyone realize that graded homework is a waste of time. Grades should come from tests that are so hard you can only pass if you really understand the material. If someone needs practice they will know it and do the homework they passed on. Have a computer room where anyone can come and do any test they want, unlimited retakes and no time gates. Fast learners can skip ahead, everyone else gets the chance to practice and try again until they get it.

tancop··on Union Types and Option Types (2025)
Ordering is a problem because there's no good way to handle duplicate members. If you have a generic function `f(T) -> T|A` what is the compiler supposed to do when T = A|B? Return A|B|A breaking the main rule of unions or give up and throw a compile error?

And set unions are supposed to be unordered anyway. You're going against what everyone expects from other languages and basic math.

tancop··on Qwen 3.8 27B on my laptop can interpret model weights, too
Doesn't matter for local use anyway.
tancop··on Why Isn't Retatrutide Approved Yet?
This is why any form of exclusivity is a bad idea. The only ones who get hurt are patients and healthcare providers, twice, first by the delays and then higher prices for longer.

Patents should have switched to a royalty system the moment enforcing it was practical. And come with an exception for all non commercial use. It's never too late to fix.

tancop··on Tencent Hy4
Shut down stock markets, liquidate the failing companies, use that money to buy out stakes of pension and index funds, leave the debt with the company and let banks write it off. They're supposed to have insurance and risk controls anyway.

If any important bank fails because of this, nationalize it and let their customers exit using money from the federal reserve. Then try and recover as much of that as possible using the banks investment portfolio. Costs a lot less than bailouts.

tancop··on Tencent Hy4
Open weight models that fall under Restricted get an automatic license. The only prohibited category that applies to model weights is training on "core national data", meaning specific non public datasets designated by the state. Everything else is about full agent systems.
tancop··on A thousand fewer paths to root
No, but type safety does. You can't forget to lock an object before using it when that lock is part of the type. Or pass a raw user controlled path to a function that expects a validated one. If you want to do it on purpose you need to write unsafe code that's clearly visible to anyone reviewing your patch.
tancop··on Evergreen: A Provably Safe Systems Language
Sounds a lot like group borrowing from Valen, but that one still has annotations like `entity in world.entities[] mut`. Are you tracking the same things implicitly with post conditions?
tancop··on Nvidia RTX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed to 35% on Linux
It's "we" as a society. Not pushing our governments to pass laws that could make Nvidia open up its hardware. Of course it's not your fault or mine, the problem is money in politics and uneducated voters.
tancop··on C++26 Disapproved
Compilers are complex, platform specific and the architectures behind them can be wildly different. Maintaining a reference compiler would be a lot of work for no real benefit.

The standard library on the other hand is a library. It's almost always implemented as plain C++ without much platform specific code. ISO could take an existing free licensed implementation and declare it as the standard. Of course anyone is free to make their own competing one, it just has to always match the official library's behavior.

Writing a spec instead of code is just creating duplicate work and compatibility issues any time the spec is unclear.

tancop··on Deskilling the body: We are doing less sensing, navigating, remembering, walking
> A recent analysis by the psychologist Clara Colombatto, the philosopher Jonathan Birch and the neuroscientist Stephen Fleming found that exposure to these systems leads to an increase in attributions of mental capacities to them.

Is this not (weak) evidence that the do have mental capacities? It's a subjective question so there is literally no better way to answer it than ask a lot of people and go with what most of them think. Confidence going up with exposure is exactly what you expect from something that's clearly true.

tancop··on Efficient algorithms, the Exponential Time Hypothesis, and losing the plot
Key word is provably. We can assume the universe is finite because we don't have evidence against it, but no one knows if it's possible to prove or reject that for good.
tancop··on BioWare co-founder: game execs "have never made a game" and don't get it
The problem is no one knows how much of the player/critic difference is legitimate complaints and how much is political outrage from the anti DEI movement. Studios don't know if their game is actually bad or just fell victim to culture wars.

There are some areas where it's easy to decide like when people complain about the way movement feels, but separating "writing bad because everyone acts flat and out of character" from "writing bad because LGBT and pronouns" is impossible because all you see in the review is "bad writing".

← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →