HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on Biden says haters won't have 'last word'; wants to end social media immunity
> Biden was introduced by Susan Bro, mother of Heather Heyer, who was killed during an August 2017 white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia. "Her murder resonated around the world, but the hate did not begin or end there," Bro said.

Not quite as resonant was the murder of Jessica Doty Whitaker [1], or the victims of Kori Ali Muhammad [2], the injured in the NY subway attack [3], or the killed in the Waukesha parade attack [4].

By pure coincidence, no such cases were so much as alluded to in this speech. But, since this is coincidence, the situation may well be reversed in the next speech Biden gives on hate. Or if not that one, then the one after it.

Because focusing on crimes committed by only one group, and ignoring crimes committed against that group, is something one would expect from hate-peddling tabloids, or 3rd world dictators getting ready for ethnic cleansing, and is certainly not something the leader of the free world would ever stoop to.

[1] Indiana woman shot, killed after argument with Black Lives Matter supporters - https://www.foxnews.com/us/indiana-woman-shot-killed-argumen...

[2] We’ve all heard the phrase “an eye for an eye,” and after enduring a lifetime of racism, that was the exact justification that accused killer Kori Ali Muhammad gave authorities for his decision to allegedly murder four people in 2017. - https://www.theroot.com/fresno-man-accused-of-four-murders-a...

[3] James had posted, "O black Jesus, please kill all the whiteys" on social media. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_New_York_City_Subway_atta...

[4] Brooks had a history of social media posts advocating for violence against white people and Jews. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waukesha_Christmas_parade_atta...

tarakat··on The Koh-i-Noor diamond, and why the British won’t give it back (2017)
Anything bad they did they did with full malicious desire and intent, and anything good they did is either ignored or, as I said, discredited ("they only did it because they were forced!")

If they give up the Koh-I-Noor to whomever plundered it before them, ten years later someone like you will be claiming that it is hilariously naive to believe they just gave it up.

tarakat··on The Koh-i-Noor diamond, and why the British won’t give it back (2017)
> decolonization has to cost it something to mean something

Didn't they, you know, give up their empire? And invite their former colonies to colonize them, to the point that they are now a minority in their own capital?

If anything this should have taught them that, not only will it never be enough, but every act of atonement will count for nothing and be immediately forgotten and discredited.

tarakat··on The Authoritarian Personality and the Rising Far Right – History News Network
> “What this country needs is fewer laws and agencies, and more courageous, tireless, devoted leaders whom the people can put their faith in.”

So fewer laws and agencies restricting personal liberty, and those politicians that remain should be.. well I don't even have to re-word it, do I? It is "submissive" to want brave, tireless, devoted, trustworthy leaders? We should desire cowardly, lazy, corrupt, lying ones?

> Once the individual has convinced himself that there are people who ought to be punished, he is provided with a channel through which his deepest aggressive impulses may be expressed, even while he thinks of himself as thoroughly moral.

How White Women Use Themselves as Instruments of Terror - https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/27/opinion/racism-white-wome...

Seattle BLM protesters demand white people ‘give up’ their homes - https://nypost.com/2020/08/14/seattle-blm-protesters-demand-...

Who was Jessica Doty Whitaker? The woman shot and killed for saying ‘all lives matter’ - https://www.the-sun.com/news/1129367/jessica-doty-whitaker-a...

> Yet another crucial variable was power and “toughness,” or a penchant to identify with strong figures of authority who dominate the weak, “a disposition to view all relations among people in terms of such categories as strong-weak, dominant-submissive, leader-follower…”

..oppressed-oppressor? Vibrant diversity vs. white fragility?

> “There are some activities so flagrantly un-American that, when responsible officials won’t take the proper steps, the wide-awake citizen should take the law into his own hands.”

The 'punch a Nazi' meme: what are the ethics of punching Nazis? - https://www.theguardian.com/science/brain-flapping/2017/jan/...

US anti-fascists: ‘We can make racists afraid again’ - https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2017/2/21/us-anti-fascist...

And on the other side of the coin, entire so-called "sanctuary cities" deliberately impede immigration law - you could even say they are taking it into their own hands, because it is so un-American.

> It is worth reminding ourselves of the antisemitic chant of the fascists in during the “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, August 12, 2017: “The Jews will not replace us,”

By the same logic, is claiming “an unrelenting stream of immigration, nonstop, nonstop [..] Folks like me who are Caucasian, of European descent, for the first time in 2017 we’ll be in an absolute minority in the United States of America, absolute minority [..] Fewer than 50% of the people in America from then and on will be white European stock. That’s not a bad thing, that’s a source of our strength.” anti-white? - https://www.foxnews.com/politics/flashback-joe-biden-constan...

> This inclination to punish violators of sexual norms still looms large among the ever-more mainstream QAnon, which “picked up where Pizzagate left off.” Indeed, QAnon’s followers tenaciously cling to fantastical ideas about Satan-worshiping Democratic pedophiles that Trump alone will defeat.

Or the right's obsession with Muslim grooming gangs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sexual_abuses_perpetra... (no, not all of them are Muslim)

Or the firing of a professor for a consensual relationship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Katz_(classicist)

As usual, sociology is an exercise in subtly encoding researcher's biases into a study, not objective science. And when that isn't enough, plain old selective blindness.

tarakat··on The Koh-i-Noor diamond, and why the British won’t give it back (2017)
Why not? Almost everyone that had it before won it through conquest, but only Britain is being held to a standard where that is forbidden.
tarakat··on Sweden election: How an ex neo-Nazi movement became kingmakers
Isn't it interesting that as soon as one suggests Swedes are indigenous, i.e. have the same claim to their lands and cultures that peoples usually referred to as "indigenous" by the media have, suddenly the conversation turns extremely technical and only the most rigorous, water-tight definitions will do.

This never seems to happen if one would say that the Dakota Indians are "indigenous" - one wouldn't ask "well how precisely can you define a Dakota compared to some other Sioux tribe? Exactly which regions are they indigenous to? They migrated and intermarried a lot - what about half-Dakota? How long, precisely, do they have to have inhabited an area before they can be called indigenous to it?"

No, such rigor is demanded only when the wrong people try to claim they have a homeland or identity.

tarakat··on Sweden election: How an ex neo-Nazi movement became kingmakers
That Swedes are not considered indigenous to Sweden perfectly encapsulates how insane and hostile to their own people their government has become.
tarakat··on Sweden election: How an ex neo-Nazi movement became kingmakers
> radical anti-immigration Sweden Democrats

What does "radical" mean? A return to pre-1975 immigration policy? - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Sweden#1968%E2%...

> The party has also undergone an extensive rebranding: replacing its burning flame logo with a more innocent-looking flower and scrapping its "Keep Sweden Swedish" slogan.

The Overton window has shifted so far that an indigenous people cannot even keep one small corner of the world to themselves without being called "radical". Anything short of enthusiastically cheering for your country to be reduced to an economic zone for the global population to compete in is now far right.

tarakat··on Works of Art That Define the Contemporary Age
Archive if paywalled: http://archive.ph/x8U9B
tarakat··on “No politics” Coinbase rolls out feature to promote crypto-friendly politicians
> In the blog post she references (but, tellingly, does not link)

This is standard procedure for most journalists - they prefer to present only their interpretation (or spin) of events, rather than let their audience form their own opinion.

See for example how many stories of someone making offensive statements omit quoting those statements. And if you'll allow me to reach a bit, it seems the cruder and more unpersuasive the statements are, the more likely they are to be quoted, while any more intellectual, compelling reasoning gets omitted.

Edit: Flimm points out that in this instance, there is a link. So the article merely misrepresents it, and does not also omit it, which I maintain is the norm.

tarakat··on Twilio promises ‘anti-racist’ layoffs
A predictable result of allowing (even encouraging) all groups but one to organize and lobby for their ethnic self-interest.
tarakat··on The definitive guide to “modulo bias” and how to avoid it (2020)
> You shouldn’t rely on these claims, because even 1 bit of bias on a 256 bit nonce value can be enough to attack certain cryptographic schemes!

This seems like a very high bar for a random generator to clear. It also raises a question: would using a larger nonce size actually increase risk, if the additional bits were biased?

tarakat··on Ask HN: What is your opinion on electronic voting?
Not even formally verified open-source compilers can be trusted (and for the record, in practice, voting machine software does not reach anywhere near such level of security): https://cs.cmu.edu/~rdriley/487/papers/Thompson_1984_Reflect...

Then you also have to trust the entire supply chain (software AND hardware): https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2018/03/adding_backdo...

Because the prize is so great, the system has to withstand decades-long attacks by global superpower-level actors. And unlike a bank account, you don't know when you've been hacked.

Once compromised, a smart attacker will stay within the public poll's margin of error - which is much greater for small, local elections through which most politicians have to pass. Think 30% or more, in countries where people have little to fear from answering such polls truthfully. Or venture outside of it, deliberately making the election look stolen to throw a country into chaos.

No system that relies on an un-auditable black box for security can be trusted with elections. This is so blindingly obvious, anyone that says otherwise, no matter how credentialed, is either deluded, corrupt, or malicious.

All this risk, and the benefit is.. what? Countries all over the world manage to vote and tally the results quickly using nothing but paper.

> I'm only referring to electronic machines used to vote, without any internet connection.

If you don't trust the chip fab, how do you check there is no connection? I suspect antennas can be hidden incredibly well, and there are countless side-channels that can be used for communication. And even without antennas, machines are not safe: It is typically introduced to the target environment via an infected USB flash drive, thus crossing any air gap. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuxnet

Do you trust every PC and every USB drive that comes into contact with the voting machine? And every PC that PC came into contact with, and so on?

Edit: To clarify, paper isn't immune to tampering. But crucially, tampering with it is much harder to hide, and it doesn't scale. Not unless you already have loyal agents controlling most polling stations in a country - at which point, no voting system can save you. But even then, hiding your activity will be hard, unlike if you only have to flip a few bits.

tarakat··on “the Earth Will Be Fine, It's Humanity That Needs Saving” Not
> And humanity viewed *as a species* does not need saving because in the event of a major extinction, we are the most stubbornly adaptable species ever.

That remains to be tested.

tarakat··on Hating What They Love – Search Data Analysis of Republican Trans Porn Obsession
I see a correlation, but no way to assess actual prevalence. E.g. is it 20% of Democrats that are into trans porn, vs. 30% of Republicans, or 0.2% vs 0.3%?

I realize this may be difficult to determine from the data Google exposes, but one could compare search volume vs. other terms like "milf" or "lesbian".

tarakat··on Do University Diversity Statement Requirements Violate the Constitution?
> is this time telling the truth

The 1st Amendment and various diversity pledges are all public - you can verify them yourself, you don't have to take Reason's word for it. Or do you mean that the hypothetical example given by Volokh in the article is... a lie?

> You'd think after the first few of your writers deny the Holocaust

This article was written by Eugene Volokh, who is Jewish: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Volokh

Since this is your second post on the topic, and again the only objections you gave are ad hominem, may I therefore assume that you have no objections to the substance of the article?

tarakat··on Do University Diversity Statement Requirements Violate the Constitution?
And that is why this article is wrong, I see, yes, well put. In fact, all the countries and universities that don't require diversity pledges (i.e. the great majority of them) are in fact morally equivalent to apartheid.
tarakat··on Do University Diversity Statement Requirements Violate the Constitution?
There's a second, usually unaddressed question: given these diversity pledge requirements, how should we recalibrate our view of universities?

Suppose universities, as in Volokh's example, required candidates to show what they did to support the war, or required membership in the Party. Later, those universities produce research concluding that the war is justified, and the Party is good. Should we trust those conclusions?

Someone says "universities are overwhelmingly pro-war/Party because those things are true, and smart people are better at finding the truth" - should we find that inference justified?

tarakat··on “Secrets” about the consumer audio business you may find interesting
> whatever voodoo the S&M team is up to

Those teams rarely justify their cost, especially if you factor in all the sexual harassment lawsuits that they're a breeding ground for.

tarakat··on Halle Bailey Turns White in Little Mermaid Remake Video Altered by AI
I didn't mention accuracy because it's not about accuracy. E.g. casting whites as Mezoamerican or Indian deities wouldn't go over well, despite those deities not being real.
tarakat··on Halle Bailey Turns White in Little Mermaid Remake Video Altered by AI
Some argue that such race-swapped casting would be called cultural colonization if e.g. whites were cast into roles from Chinese, Indian, African, or Native American folk tales. In fact even media where whites wore make-up to try and pass as a different race (blackface, redface,..) is now rightly criticized.

But such arguments are misguided because, unlike those places, Europe has always been diverse - so-called "native" Europeans don't have any special claim on their folk tales or culture, so it makes perfect sense to update them to reflect the growing diversity of our society.

tarakat··on A hacker bought a voting machine on eBay. Michigan officials are investigating
> Paper ballot design can tip elections -- most famously in 2000, and elsewhere.

Voting machines also suffer from myriad issues - e.g. unresponsive touchscreens. And there are countless paper voting systems without the issues of the 2000 election - in fact they are the norm. Framing this as an inherent problem of paper that can only be solved by computers is dishonest.

> Physical security is standard practice for computer systems. It's widely understood that somebody with physical access can make changes far beyond what anybody can do remotely.

My point exactly. No black box can be trusted.

> Is it worth the tradeoff?

Let me remind you that the tradeoff is having elections silently and near-undetectably [1] stolen, and sow enough justifiable doubt to destabilize a democracy.

[1] Exit polls have been as much as 30% off, especially in smaller elections through which nearly all politicians must pass, and that just passes the buck to securing polls. To dispel any naive ideas that polls would tell us about tampering. And that's in countries where people can answer those polls with relatively little worry. Imagine the disparity if they feared a militia would find they voted wrong and execute them. That's not a hypothetical. Voting systems must be resistant to such circumstances, because they may befall your country as well.

tarakat··on Software fees to make up 10% of John Deere's revenues by 2030
If by "that" you mean gene transfer technology, then I agree. But they also want to patent the result - they do not want a different lab with access to that same technology to be allowed to take a naturally occurring gene and transfer it into crops.
tarakat··on Software fees to make up 10% of John Deere's revenues by 2030
> just like any other _novel_ invention--plants are no different.

They are. E.g. Monsanto didn't invent the glyphosate-resistance gene for their Roundup Ready GM crops. The gene was already present in nature, and Monsanto merely copied it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roundup_Ready#Genetic_engineer...

tarakat··on Evidence says Wikipedia is accurate, reliable. When will we take it seriously?
Being accurate and reliable on average is what makes the bias on select topics effective. And bias of omission is most effective.

E.g. the complete absence of any demographics vs. time graph (and near-complete absence of demographic information in general) on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Replacement

One can take a look at the talk page of that article to see the fervent resistance of editors to include more demographic information. One person compared it to debunking JFK assassination conspiracy theories without mentioning that JFK was in fact killed.

The entire "Demographic statistics" section is only a reference to the 8-12% Muslim population in France, which can charitably be described as misleading, since, in addition to giving no information on the rate of change or past statistics, is a very low estimate:

[Sickle cell] screening suggests that in 2000, 19% of all newborn babies in Metropolitan France had at least one parent originating from one of the risk regions. The figure for [..] 2015 [is] 38.9 %. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_France#Statist...

tarakat··on A hacker bought a voting machine on eBay. Michigan officials are investigating
> The U.S. Election Assistance Commission says voting machines should be meticulously inventoried and kept under lock and key "in a tamper-proof location, preferably within the election office."

A tacit admission that election machines, after coming into contact with the wrong person, are no longer trustworthy. Meaning they were never trustworthy. But they keep being used for the massive advantages they provide over paper ballots and manual counting that make the trade-off worth it. Those advantages being...

tarakat··on [dead]
Also covered by NPR, in case you don't trust Alphanews: https://www.npr.org/2022/09/02/1120798679/a-new-minneapolis-...

Though NPR couched it in much more delicate, far less direct words (and a largely uninformative title): The new contract has a clause designed to protect teachers of color from seniority-based layoffs.

tarakat··on Education and Indoctrination
> Returning to culture-wars territory, the claim that “our public schools are full of … teachers who abuse their positions of trust to engage in political activism and political indoctrination,” as Kevin Williamson wrote earlier this year in the National Review, strikes me as an insulting exaggeration.

the National Education Association (NEA), the largest teacher's union and largest union in the US, holds explicit left-biased activist stances and officially advocates for social justice agendas - https://www.nea.org/advocating-for-change/racial-social-just...

Ontario teachers' union implements controversial weighted voting system to increase minority representation. The new system will ensure that Indigenous, Black and racialized teachers always represent 50 per cent of the votes at the bargaining unit - https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/ontario-teachers-union-...

California Community College Promises to Pre-Screen Job Applicants to Ensure They Are ‘Anti-racist’ - https://www.yaf.org/news/california-college-adopts-anti-raci...

Minneapolis teachers union contract calls for layoffs of white teachers first - https://alphanews.org/minneapolis-teachers-union-contract-ca... (Or as NPR more delicately put it: "The new contract has a clause designed to protect teachers of color from seniority-based layoffs." - https://www.npr.org/2022/09/02/1120798679/a-new-minneapolis-...)

> An especially corrosive feature of these bills is how they erode trust in public education itself.

As I hope the above sources make clear, public educators are eroding trust perfectly well on their own.

tarakat··on Twitter Censored Professor’s Post for “Abusive Behaviour” Toward the Queen
Random twitter bans (not just post removals, but whole account bans) are nothing unusual, even for the most politely worded posts [1], so I don't understand why this particular instance merits the Intercept's attention.

[1] https://thepostmillennial.com/twitter-keeps-banning-savanah-...

tarakat··on Atom: An EDSL for embedded hard realtime applications
There is a little more information on its github page: https://github.com/tomahawkins/atom
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →