HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on SEC Gag Orders Silence the Accused
Your examples are contracts between private parties, entered freely. This is a contract with the government, signed under threat of prosecution.
tarakat··on SEC Gag Orders Silence the Accused
Since the SEC is the government, doesn't this practice run afoul of the 1st Amendment?

Taking away rights may be an essential part of punishment, but the rights taken should be only in pursuit of that punishment (e.g. imprisonment takes away the right of free movement).

Then there is also the public's right to know about how government agencies act in their name. Imagine if prosecutors routinely demanded gag orders as part of plea deals, forbidding convicts from discussing their trial or prison conditions. The SEC practice is less egregious, but qualitatively equivalent.

tarakat··on Google is setting caps on white and Asian students for a prestigious fellowship
Google's 2022 US workforce is 48.3% white [1]. The US is 57% white [2]. Why is Google setting caps on an already underrepresented group?

[1] https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/about.google/en//... page 31

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...

tarakat··on Library director resigns over intimidation and 'atmosphere of extremism'
Extremist populists that want to have a say in their children's educations. They should have employed some clever sophistry to defend their censorship, like the "paradox of tolerance", and be applauded for their nuanced and pragmatic understanding of the balance between rights and responsibilities, instead of being condemned for hateful, unthinking bigotry.
tarakat··on India forced Twitter to put agent on payroll, whistleblower says
Meanwhile Twitter seemingly voluntarily put a British psyops officer in charge of the Middle East [1]. And for all their hand-wringing about state-backed social media disinformation campaigns, no western mainstream media have reported on this - not Reuters, not the BBC, not the NY Times, not CNN, not Fox News, not the Guardian.

[1] https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/twitter-executive-also-pa...

tarakat··on YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams speech
Meanwhile if Youtube/Google decide to downrank something into oblivion, nobody will know, and proving it is near-impossible.

A foreign corporation has more control over speech in Pakistan than Pakistan itself.

tarakat··on Audible feedback on just how much your browsing feeds into Google
> tracking doesn't seem to negatively impact my quality of life at all but it keeps the many free services I value greatly running

"My leash is long enough to reach all the places I care to visit, and the food is good."

Look at China for a glimpse of what will happen when they shorten the leash. But you didn't bother to remove the leash while you still could.

> But that's the State, not Google!

Will it matter? The State will use Google, and Google will use the State.

tarakat··on Ask HN: Should a 'no side projects' policy be taken seriously?
The text of the contract isn't limited by 'intent'. Relying on what they might have intended, but not written, is legally throwing yourself at their mercy.

That is assuming the clause is enforceable in Cyprus, and isn't just legal intimidation.

tarakat··on A bike tour of Dresden, the heart of Germany’s semiconductor industry
> This in combination with the already existing labor shortages severely limit the region's potential.

The potential comes not from the region, but the people living there.

tarakat··on Risk Everything (2007)
Was it? Perhaps I misunderstood, but when the author found them, they were less than a day from Cancun, and on the right course. They would have made it even without her help.
tarakat··on The Google Pixel 6a highlights the problem with the U.S. phone market
> A SW update bricked mine, and if it was not for that I can't see myself replacing it.

And that's why they don't make them like that anymore.

tarakat··on The Affair Rekindled: Dreyfus and the effect it had on a young Marcel Proust
And do other groups, besides the French, that have member criteria other than allegiance to abstract principles, also "deify unreason", as that quote put it? You didn't have such a laissez-faire attitude to member criteria when it came to deconstructing the French identity.

> you're trying to have an argument about it, and I'm not really interested in having it

You were hoping your absurd near-total negation of French identity would go unchallenged.

tarakat··on The Affair Rekindled: Dreyfus and the effect it had on a young Marcel Proust
Such a funny coincidence that Native American, Indian, Chinese, African, or Jewish identity are never attacked this way. They somehow remain legitimate and valid, despite being composed of smaller groups that changed through history.

Nobody bats an eye when they organize based on shared history and interests. But god forbid the French do it, then all of a sudden they have nothing in common, and the only identity they are allowed, if any, is the most Balkanized and irrelevant one.

tarakat··on The Affair Rekindled: Dreyfus and the effect it had on a young Marcel Proust
> Are you claiming that jews can't also be french?

Okay, so Jews can be Jewish and also French, since French is something anyone can be. And the French can be French and also... what? French identity can be claimed by anyone, but you shy away from applying that logic to the Jewish identity.

tarakat··on The Affair Rekindled: Dreyfus and the effect it had on a young Marcel Proust
> the Dreyfusards who defended reason and believed that France’s identity was defined by the abstract principles of equality and liberty.

This makes sense as long as you don't think about it for longer than 30 seconds. Is every country, every person, striving towards the abstract principles of equality and liberty then "French"? Did being French hold no meaning when they were still a monarchy? Was everyone on the wrong side of the French revolution then not French, but some other nationality?

And is Jewish identity likewise meaningless outside of a commitment to some abstract principles (and if so, which ones?), or do they, unlike the French, get to define it with other criteria, such as kinship and shared history?

← PreviousPage 8 of 8