HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tehchromic

210 karma · joined June 18, 2014

art in theory, in practice beekeeping and UIX
submissionscomments
tehchromic··on Illegal CFC emissions have stopped since scientists raised alarm
I like this topic especially with the theory that wars are never fought over resources, they are always fought over status. These two can appear to be the same thing especially when it's impossible to separate the resource from the status it symbolizes in the conflicted parties. Add it's often the practical case, in which case war is inevitable.

For this reason I like the project of ecological wealth-making as a planetary concern and a sort of pan-cultural tonic. I'm not sure it can apply in time to these particular cases - if someone takes your water, that's a fight. But I do think it's really the only global solution to resource wars. And it's a problem with both a technical and aesthetic solutions.

Not gonna be easy tho.

tehchromic··on Honeybees found using tools to repel giant hornet attacks
Humans are also causing a planet scale extinction event. That's the opposite of intelligence by any philosophical definition.
tehchromic··on Honeybees found using tools to repel giant hornet attacks
What gives is the extra status we automatically pad to the idea of human intelligence to make ourselves feel special. Anthropomorphic padding.
tehchromic··on Honeybees found using tools to repel giant hornet attacks
a first? not so sure about that. What is propolis if not a tool? The little bugs dig out tree sap, mix it with saliva, and plug up holes in their homes to keep out cold and bugs and we have known about it forever. It's in our hippy shampoo and cosmetics!
tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Fair. And agreed it's a weak argument to pick on zealots. I like your argument that all cultures have things in common. I don't argue that are all the same as in not a simpleton. I say that to me there are more similarities than differences between secular and religious culture. I say that the similarities are critically instructive.

Some say there are no novel insights. But we still try. Here's one effort: suppose we hypothesize that fiction is more effective at building political consensus. When I say "fiction" I don't say falsehood. I say fiction to mean representation of reality that aim to be convincing rather than truthful. We all have seen this in action.

Suppose I say this is what religion looks like to me: the ancient study of social and political fiction.

I think modern science has lost its way. It has lost moral context. I think it looks a lot like the advanced institutions of the Roman Catholic Church near the time of the Reformation. Not exactly mind you, but in that it's existing to maintain itself rather than as a responsive, living language of healthy communal culture.

I think it's language that fascilitates rapid change in cultural realities. It's this form of religious realism that interests me in critique of modern science institution. That's not because I like to argue with people on the internet, but because I think there's a novel, applied approach that emerges in looking at the problem that way.

But I don't expect that to be clear, and while it's been interesting I'm not much for basic arguing!

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Agreed, science excels are building objective reality. However I'd propose that it does come at the expense of subjective reality. So most people believe in God while most reject climate change.

To your second point, it was similar when monks were the only ones who could read. But everyone can own a lighter or watch a tv - these are the artifacts and participatory culture of the scientific "religion". I'd argue that they are superior in some ways but inferior in others.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Here: the scientufic world view is pretty clear on the abortion issue, yet whole voting blocks reject right to choose and often scientific discourse altogether simply on this issue. And we know it as fact: people don't vote based on scientific evidence.

So why not?

My argument is simple. Modern science does not concern itself with telling people what they want to hear to maintain authoritative reality. Religion was a science of telling people what they wanted to hear to maintain authoritative reality. Same methodology, different paradigm. Different objective.

My point is that either way, you area generating reality. So we say, yes but science is more accurate as true, so we have washers and dryers and cars and medicine. But we also have atom bombs and given extinction event and multiple potential ways to wipe ourselves out. We are also more ideologically divided than in any period in history, I'd argue, and precisely when it is most necessary that we be informed and unified.

So science is a more powerful paradigm for building certain technocultural realities at the expense of others. I would say it fails in ways that the older science of cultural uniformity and authority succeeded.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Agreed. What I'm saying to ask tho is what are the strengths if religion? Because science is failing us very seriously in certain cultural regards.
tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
I understand this full well. I'm speaking in the context of that you'd are calling scientism because I think it's the dominant religion of our times. An example is this slogan: "I believe in science". We might say well, this person is saying they have faith that the scientific method produces ... But I would argue that this person (in aggregate in modern society) is actually much more like a religious believer. They believe without any real idea of what science is.

I don't dispute the difference between the scientific method and the mythological one. All I'm saying is that religion had at it's heart a hard science and mythology was it's product. I am sorry saying that modern science produces mostly mythodology as well. I don't claim that everyone has to agree, but this is how it looks to me.

So I see a world around me made of scientism. Yet you never hear the word, and certainly it's not a legitimate sounding word. So I go a step further and say, our modern religion is science which produces the mythodology which we consume. I think it's a valid position. But of course no dominant paradigm likes to consider it's falacies.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Well enjoy the discussion. I don't find it disagreeable.

I'd say that as a science of authority the theory is clear to those who seek to benefit from the cultural practice. A hypothesis such as "there is only one God" isn't powerful because it's true in the modern sense of having been through a rigorous scientfic process, it's powerful because it results in greater authority relative to other cultural symbolisms. Religion is a science that tests narratives and symbols and cultural signs for effective ability to leverage and maintain authority.

I don't dispute that modern science generates more factual reality, but I think there's a big question around the idea of truth and belief you raise. Truth and belief are difficult to quantify. I understand that you mean when you say "generate true belief", but it's a philosophically tough position to hold. If I claim that "God is love" you will have an impossible time proving that is not true, or that I don't believe it. You might say "the earth is a sphere" is the more true, scientfic statement, but until you have a lot of definitive context for each statement relative to the believer you don't really know how accurate either is.

I think the argument falls apart further in any attempt to evaluate the value of belief. If 90% of people believe in God but 60% reject climate change, does that make climate change less real? I would say no, but I'm the same token you would have to agree that scientfic speaking it is easier to believe in God than climate change. My question is, what makes God so easy to believe in? I would say one could produce a sound theory about why it's so easy to believe in God, and the folks who made him up were thoroughly versed in that theory. These were the scientific minds of their times.

As I understand it in the classical definition science is a branch of art as art is the more general term.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Spoken like a true believer!

I'm teasing you and I'm sorry if it is offensive. But your are right that a characteristic of scientific culture is relative flexibility. What I'm saying attention to is where that famous ability to reflect and change fails, and nowhere is that more evident than in confronting the evidence that scientific culture behaves a lot more like religious culture than otherwise. And nowhere is that similarity more evident than in the piles of scientfic cultural proponents who attack anyone who dares to point out the commonality.

In fact, to me the most radical characteristic of science as a cultural reality (a religion) and the most clear proof of it is science's ability to deny that it produces cultural realism. I can sum it up:

Science is the god that claims to not exists.

So when I say something like "your science produces monsters", which is a mythological type language, a science proponent will often freak the fuck out and hide behind the fact that science is only a method. Yet science has birthed multiple technologies with the power to obliviate the planet, and mythology predicted it.

All I'm saying is that it's time to call science what it is: a god.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Well I'm not joking.

Religious methodology in building a belief generating technology was more organic than we like to think of science today, however it followed the same format as all scientific methodology: observation, question, hypothesis, experiment, modification and repeat. It also was recorded, often in aural memory but also in text, which I would say is the critical feature that differentiates modern science from more traditional scientific practices which we tend to dismiss as not science but which meet the criteria in strict methodological terms.

I don't think I'll be capable of convincing you or anyone who has built their idea of science on the rejection of mythology, however it's worth considering that religious believers made the same assumption about previous cultural realities: theirs was the only right reality.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
I don't mean to argue with you. If you say religion can't be fact based and aren't open to any alternate view that's scientific cultural dogma, in my opinion but also that's dogma by definition. If science can have dogma, then it has at least one similarity to religion which establishes a resemblance.

I'll give an alternate definition of religion that I think is compatible with a scientific world view rather than oppositional: religion is an ancient applied science of managing authority and consent in large groups of people. That's the reality it dealt with, just as modern science might deal with materials or biology.

I don't mean to give you a hard time. This topic is very difficult to talk about given the intense factions around it. But that's why it's important to talk about it even if it makes folks mad at you initial. Sorry if I irritated you.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
True in a very general sense, although you'd have to exclude religions where such things are allowed to say that accurately.

Agreed that this is the dominant narrative in global culture. However my point is that science appears to be fairly poor at building universal belief, which is something religion excelled at with scientific precision. There are advantages and disadvantages to both cultures. One disadvantage is organizing ourselves around something like global climate change where scientific consensus is near unanimous, but the culture at large is very slow to heed. Religion is very good at getting masses of people to do what they are told regardless of their best interest. Look at the American religious voter for example.

My point is that if science is more than a methodology, if it is a cultural spectacle, then it's probably wise for us all to admit that it is in fact very much like a religion. I am saying that science as a cultural reality can benefit from dropping the claim to be better than, or something other than a religion.

Don't stone me for saying so.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Wwll, same for religion. What I'm saying is, what's wrong with a circus? I think they are pretty interesting.
tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
Respectfully I'd say you've underscored my point. Your statement that "scientific worldview, which is diametrically opposed to religious culture" is itself a dogma, which is one of the features of religion you claim to have surpassed as a scientific person.

It is true that modern society contains pretty fundamentally opposed religious vs scientific factions. My point isn't to take sides but to point out that what you are calling religion is some kind of oppositional faction defined by rejecting scientific fact. It wasn't always the case. But you should judge the nature of religious culture objectively and scientifically, not by it's worst modern manifestations.

Religious reality was originally and for thousands of years the only reality, and it's proponents would have argued as strongly against any alternating philosophy, just at you proclaim that scientific realism is reality and reject any other.

My argument is that scientific culture resemblance to religious culture isn't coincidence, it's the nature of belief in social systems. Meanwhile science culture could learn worlds from religious culture which in my view was very much a science of authority and social unification. That's to say that religious cultural realism was more effective at generating belief and that's because it was a science of generating belief.

tehchromic··on When science was the best show in America
What's completely senseless to me is how absolutely proponents of the scientific world-view reject it's similarity to religious culture. To me it looks exactly the same, and this article while excellent and amusing fits perfectly in that dominant theme of science as a above and apart from mythology.

Here's an amusing quote:

“Mr. Peale’s animals reminded me of Noah’s Ark, into which was received every kind of beast and creeping thing in which there was life. But I can hardly conceive that even Noah could have boasted of a better collection.”

The idea that a there is a golden age of pure truth and reason against which the forces of chaos rallied is as old as time. That itself is the myth of excoriation by which we organize classes of the cognoscenti: there are those who know the original truth and those who do not.

I think rather than pit reason and truth against the circus of spectacle we have to embrace the latter as the former and include everyone in the know, with a laugh.

tehchromic··on Changes of Mind – The Pattern Seekers: A New Theory of Human Invention
I know and it caused me to think about this whole article in terms of Sacha's art which is surely an extraordinary synthesis of systematic and emotional thinking in the field of comedy.
tehchromic··on Scientists discover how a common mutation leads to ‘night owl’ sleep disorder
Call it a mutational disorder if you will, I think I'm nocturnal mutant and proud of it.

Use of the the word "disorder" throughout is highly retrograde and silly. It's part of the human genome and like all genetic mutation it's value is relative to selective pressure. But why should we not value individuals who have nocturnal tendencies as strategic advantage in the spectrum of human ability?

Personality I must have inherited an extreme form of this mutation from my grandmother, who always seemed very proud of her nightowlishness. We often encountered eachother happily up to something or other past 2am.

On the other hand the outside world has been a challenge. I'm not really awake until 11am. Highschool was pure hell. I was always late to class and always in trouble for it. In college I worked night jobs and took late classes. A few times I made up my mind to let go of making myself wake up or go to bed at certain times and let my natural cycle happen. Within two weeks I was very happily awake until almost dawn every night and up at 2ish.

tehchromic··on It’s dangerous to think humans have a destiny outside Earth
I can appreciate that no one wants to hear cautionary words about our loftiest ambitions. However, I believe it's worth reflecting carefully on the topic.

One way to look at the dream of escaping the planet and colonizing space is in mythological terms. One comparison in particular is good and this is the idea of the afterlife or heaven which for centuries were as real and attainable as a Mars colony to you and I.

For advanced technocultural civilizations and the religious institutions that hold them together it seems that an imaginary place of escape automatically becomes normalized into existence.

The illusion grows proportionally to the sense of futility that individuals feel as a social structure calcifies around the protection of class hierarchy. The consequent protective buffer against meaningful experience of complex ecology and culture that results is the proverbial bottle which constrains the human spirit, until it is ready to explode in unrealistic directions.

So the suffering and anxiety of individuals trapped in a top-heavy social structure lends energy and reality to unrealistic visions.

Thus we dream of terraforming mars while in the midst of terrastroying earth into an unlivable nightmare, mass extinction, unbalanced population growth, global chemistry change, etc.

Like, we can't even prevent our rainforests from being raised, losing countless complex organic systems forever, yet we imagine ourselves spawning new life on distant planets.

And the destruction of our own planet is made possible with only the tiny drops of energy we can dig out of the ground. What will become of our planet surface when we have tapped the energy of the sun in earnest?

That said, if we do survive the current paradigm, and do manage to protect our surface biofilm or otherwise survive the next few hundred years, nothing will prevent us from colonizing the solar system and beyond. But we are ahead of ourselves, and that's the result of poor social/cultural order.

There's some irony there. The engine of malcontent that destroys us also propels is forward.

However it's safe to say that most of the energy and excitement we feel for terraforming planets and exploring space right now ought to be redirected towards building a conservationist earth culture that can support slow technological accretion and a long-term template for extra planetary adventures. Heaven is real but it takes real work to get there.

tehchromic··on “Fungi Can Teach Us a New Way of Looking at the World”
And yet it's a compelling point in part due to the uncertainty of it's reference
tehchromic··on DARPA's “Unhackable” Computer
It sounds like an oxymoron. Given the meaning of hacking today it seems a computer by definition is hackable - if you can't hack it what's the point? There's surely some mathematical way to prove that the usefulness of a computing system declines in proportion to it's hackability, such that the least hackable system resembles more or less a rock.
tehchromic··on What the Industrial Revolution Tells Us about the Future of Automation
"We should listen not only to economists when it comes to predicting the future of work; we should listen also to historians, who often bring a deeper historical perspective to their predictions."

We should also listen to ecologists.

tehchromic··on Why Ever Stop Playing Video Games
Because beekeeping and ping pong are more fun!

That said, I'm interested in farm integrated gaming. I think there are ways to make automation adventurous. Properly this will be different than what we call gaming today, however I think the answer to your question is that when tech assisted activities are diversion from reality they tend to go out if style. When they amend it and make it cooler they tend to become it!

tehchromic··on Entropy in Social Networks [pdf]
keeping in mind that certain forms of inflexibility are vital to the structure of an organism. Bones for example. Or in the case of the human super organism, ecological stewardship, which was the original subject of the religious sciences.
tehchromic··on CSS Grid – Table layout is back. Be there and be square
IMhumbleO the redundancy is at issue, because CSS is simply nested key pairs and so say that HTML should handle only text and tagged divisions in text with IDs and classes, and leave all the semantics up to the sheets. Folks who point out that style is semantic are correct, so it's redundant to allow all these structural tags in HTML that are intended to give semantic formatting to text, and instead CSS should be reliably the only source of semantic formatting. Therefore, only one HTML element and everything else attributes or key pairs in the sheets.

Also I find js2css works well to keep component style in place with MVC web components.

(This comment is a response to the multiple inevitable discussions on the merits of HTML/CSS and what is bad or good and how it all should be different, great stuff, thanks for it)

tehchromic··on Open-RethinkDB meeting notes #4
Awrsome!
tehchromic··on What If Time Really Exists? (2008)
haha, I had the exact opposite conclusion: good thing it's all an illusion so I carry on laughing about it all! :P
tehchromic··on The strange effects of thinking healthy food is costlier
http://foodful.ly/foodwaste_app.html

http://www.thegivinggardensproject.com/

These projects are attempting something along those lines. They're local to Davis CA, home of the UC which was once a dedicated agricultural school.

tehchromic··on The Great A.I. Awakening
I am not sure we are going to be able to understand each other. I find your thoughts to be completely missing a foundation that I'm thinking would be necessary to understand what I'm saying. I don't mean to be rude ...

Yes of course a single celled organisim is conscious.

Exactly the way an amoeba is self aware is how an self-conscious intelligence system would need to be to pose any kind of threat: organized to find energy sources and metabolize, replicate, etc.

I'll tell you: a single celled organism is way more self aware, and way more functionally complex than any computer or software - in fact it's orders of magnitude more complex of a machine.

That's my point: solving problems that make a machine capable of producing intelligence that is sensible to you and I is not solving the and problems that make a machine like a single cell organism, which is to say vertically integrated from the atom upwards to be a self-sustaining, self propagating, energy trap.

A self-aware human who is disabled and can't live without intervention of other humans, can't self-sustain without others and therefore will not pass the test of being able to self-sustain. It's a test, and so one failure isn't validation of hypothesis. It can still be a great test affairs fail a percentage of the time.

In general we know that all self conscious organisms self-sustain, even social, super-organism ones that need each other to survive so a criteria for a self aware organism is that it be capable of self sustaining. We don't even have a good test for that yet. But a test that would fail a perfectly self-aware disabled human wouldn't be a good one.

We could very well administer a Turing Test to an artificial consciousness, but my point is that it wouldn't be a very accurate test. A Turing Test only proves the accuracy of a facsimile of human intelligence. It proves nothing about self consciousness systems. An amoeba would fail it in an instant as would a parrot or dolphin - and if you tell me these organisms aren't self-aware and conscious then we are definitely not on the same page.

I could be wrong. I'm absolutely interested in anyone who can make a convincing argument otherwise, however until then I'm pretty certain that no emerging conscious machine will happen by accident. Rather it would take a Manhattan project or greater to produce an artificial consciousness on par for sophistication with an amoeba. And we don't have much motive to attempt it either, so I'm doubting we will do it anytime soon.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →