HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

theluketaylor

2,182 karma · joined February 10, 2015

submissionscomments
theluketaylor··on The US Housing Market Has Become an Impossible Mess
Public housing doesn't fundamentally require income restrictions. Most locations place limits on eligibility for public housing, but that's simply because there isn't that much public housing so it's prioritized for those most in need.

Part of Vienna's success is building so much public housing there is plenty to go around, so all sorts of people live in public housing. There isn't a stigma associated with public housing since using it doesn't imply any specific trait.

I'm a big fan of building all sorts of non-market housing all over cities to avoid the slum problem. Charge means-tested rent, so someone will low income pays very little rent. Someone with a good job pays closer to market rent (and that extra revenue helps pay for the overall housing program).

One of the huge successes of Vienna's public housing model is mixing people of different socioeconomic backgrounds. People connect with people with all sorts of different backgrounds and experiences resulting in much strong social cohesion.

theluketaylor··on Car Owners Fall Behind on Payments at Highest Rate on Record
> People really, really do not understand what living rural is like.

The same criticism applies equally well to rural dwellers about urban life which is why someone rural could be shocked by the idea someone might actively choose to to travel by high quality public transportation.

I have lived both rural and urban and actively choose urban. Rural is a fine choice too, but rural dwellers shouldn't expect their energy intensive and economically expensive lifestyle to be subsidized by urban dwellers forever. Maintaining a huge road network with relatively low utilization is massively expensive and western rural life is currently among the most carbon intensive lifestyles.

theluketaylor··on Car Owners Fall Behind on Payments at Highest Rate on Record
Which is fine, but I'm sick of those same people consistently voting against high quality public transport inside cities while insisting on urban highways and tons of parking for when they come to the city. Untold billions have been spent creating a road network to support their rural lifestyle and then they object to any money being spent on transportation modes other than driving.

Farmers get a pass since they are producing things on the land. Everyone else who chooses to live rural or exurban doesn't get to object to urban dwellers wanting quality transit or to reduce the prominence of cars in urban spaces.

theluketaylor··on Car Owners Fall Behind on Payments at Highest Rate on Record
And public roads are free? The streets inside a city and highways connecting them are massively expensive and no one bats an eye. Even toll highways often don't really pay for themselves.

Transportation infrastructure of any mode is massively expensive and is undertaken to facilitate all sorts of economic activity. Public transportation being held to a standard of direct profit is something no other public infrastructure is expected to achieve.

theluketaylor··on Car Owners Fall Behind on Payments at Highest Rate on Record
A single subway line in Toronto is 38 km / 24 miles long. A single regional rail line passing through downtown is 114 km / 71 miles long. A 15 mile commute is perfectly achievable on public transit when the facilities exist.
theluketaylor··on Car Owners Fall Behind on Payments at Highest Rate on Record
There are a few different things all combining to create 100K+ trucks

1) Many people just like driving a truck as their vehicle. Many of those people are wealthy enough to drive 100k+ vehicles. They like a truck, they just want one with a fancy interior.

2) High value trucks are extremely profitable for OEMs. The margins are huge since the engineering and tooling is amortized across a ton of lower cost and fleet trucks, so there is big incentive to have the best luxury truck as it's a license to print money

3) Tax incentives for 6000+lb vehicles that were intended for truly commercial vehicles. Didn't envision Escalades and luxury trucks being used by regular people and not for hauling goods.

4) Buying vehicles based on monthly cost rather than total. 7-8 year loans keep the monthly cost on huge value trucks pretty reasonable

theluketaylor··on Ending Junk Fees, the Most Annoying Thing in American Commerce
Prices are done without taxes in the US and Canada due to the anti-tax lobby. The theory goes if people have to see the figure they are taxed each transaction they will more loudly complain about the rates and more strongly resist raising the rate. In practice all it does it make it annoying to figure out what something costs.
theluketaylor··on Maui County sues Hawaiian Electric Company for damages from disastrous fires
I like co-ops in general but I think they have a fairly low ceiling of effectiveness and efficiency. Once they cover too much territory or have too many members they tend to lose their way a little.

I like our crown corporation model here in Canada for huge infrastructure that has to serve millions of citizens across millions of sq km. Crown corps are fully owned by the relevant legislature, created by a specific act, but are shielded from the daily management that government ministries are subject to. They can side step the public servant salary restrictions that often prevent hiring domain exert public servants, but the crown corp remains fully accountable to cabinet and any profits are returned to citizens. It’s a good mixture of the best benefits of public ownership and private enterprise that usually minimizes the worst downsides of both. Most provinces have their electricity generator and provider as a crown corp, but cities often have their own corporation that handles residential grid connections and billing. Certainly not perfect, but it’s been a generally successful model and it’s fairly rare for a crown corporation to need rescuing.

Since Canada is so vast we have a natural risk of monopoly or duopoly for anything involving huge infrastructure buildout like the energy grid or telecommunications. We didn’t learn our lesson well enough with the grid and are really suffering from not having provincial crown corps handling cell networks and internet connectivity.

theluketaylor··on Data centres account for between 1.5% and 2% of global electricity consumption
Plus data centers are low hanging fruit for decarbonization. Everything (apart from diesel backup generators) is already electric, so as the grid de-carbonizes so do data centers.

As you mention, DC operators are already highly incentivized to reduce energy costs, so as wind and solar power continue to drop in costs DC operators will want to fund or buy green power as often as possible.

Getting backup power to be carbon neutral will be a little more challenging in a DC, but it's a walk in the park compared to many sectors. Shelf-stable biofuel is already fairly accessible and using grid scale batteries can reduce the need to combust anything (plus open power arbitrage opportunities).

theluketaylor··on Without belief in a god, but never without belief in a devil
> respecting Chesterton's Fence

Chesterton's Fence is about ensuring you understand the reason a specific choice was made in the past before undoing it. The modern right has no interest in understanding that choice and then making carefully considered improvements. The modern right yearns for a fictional past, one that if it ever existed benefited only the most elite members of society.

In the past in my home country of Canada the Tory party roughly represented this idealized view of conservatism. I believe the UK Tories have been like this during parts of their history, but I'm much less familiar with their history. Here in Canada the red tories merged with social conservatives in the early 2000s. It was a hostile takeover, with all the party members who embraced rational, considered progress pushed out by the modern right, who have increasingly embraced conspiracy theories and populist positions.

Climate change has been decisively shown to be the result of human-caused emissions. Chesterton's Fence has been satisfied; clearly emitting greenhouses gases cannot continue, yet the right is, if anything, gaining hostility to efforts to reduce emissions. A last-gasp red tory style leader was recently pushed out of Canada's conservative party for, among other things, daring to acknowledge climate change required action in the official party platform.

Many social policies were demonstrably enacted to limit opportunities for people of colour, like red-lining in the US. There are perfectly reasonable debates to be had about the best way to correct this historic injustice, but many on the modern right deny these policies had any detrimental impact, or if they did, the effects are no longer being felt.

I can respect leaders who want to carefully consider change before enacting it, but once the science is in, denying the problem exists is not leadership, nor is it respecting Chesterton's Fence. That's just painting your own reality.

theluketaylor··on Can we please just go back to using smaller wheels and tires?
50R17 wheels would be fine if that was what cars actually had. Instead the fitments are like 40R19 and 45R20. The trend of bigger wheels and smaller sidewalls is not going away either. 19s and 20s are giving way to 21s and 22s.

Around 5-6 years ago we passed better grip and handling and moved well into harsh ride, bent wheels, and higher unsprung mass territory.

I’m convinced one the the major factors driving the SUV revolution along with high driving position and CAFE light truck regs is higher aspect ratio tires compared with the equivalent sedan or wagon. The SUV has huge wheels but also has higher aspect tires, so you still get some sidewall flex and acceptable ride. The sedan equivalent has rubber band tires that crash on even reasonably maintained pavement (a bar many cities cannot reach), so of course the better ride wins even if the vehicle is far heavier and more expensive.

theluketaylor··on Utah and Oregon Now Require GPS Trackers on EVs, Tax Drivers by the Mile
NZ has the advantage that all vehicle miles travelled are within their jurisdiction. US states, Canadian provinces, and EU countries all have drivers travelling significant distances out of jurisdiction, likely resulting in inefficient taxation. With a simple odometer reading Utah would collect taxes on road miles that took place in Colorado, whereas Colorado has no mechanism to collect taxes on the wear and tear on its road network by Utah citizens.

On the other hand, the idea of having a government tracker in my car all the time is beyond icky. I'd much rather overspend a little via a simple annual odometer reading than have a government agency with access to detailed location logging.

A federal annual odometer reading that then distributes funds to states based on vehicle miles travelled and road network size solves the jurisdiction problem, but would never fly in the US as federal overreach.

theluketaylor··on Texas couple dies in home after air conditioning failure
Phoenix, AZ has an office of heat response: https://www.phoenix.gov/heat

I think it will become a necessity in many places

theluketaylor··on The Boring Company will dig a 68-mile tunnel network under Las Vegas
The boring company could pay Las Vegas billions to install this thing and it would still be a bad deal. They are putting in awful tunnels to ruin (perhaps forever) the prospects of mass transit in what is likely the single lowest-hanging fruit currently available in the US.

The tiny tunnels can't support any real sustained people movement, so even if this system does see adoption the capacity limits are so low it won't make any real difference in Las Vegas traffic patterns. Re-constructing or modifying the tunnels into something useful will almost certainly be cost prohibitive or too dangerous to attempt (likely both). Boring company will take the most ideal route a proper system could have used, making a proper metro use either sub-optimal routing or make it so cost prohibitive the project is never approved.

If the project goes perfectly to plan Las Vegas gets a weird gadget bahn that can't ever grow beyond a weird curiosity, something they already have in their monorail. If it were in the middle of the desert in no one way then it's fine it doesn't cost the city anything. The fact it will permanently steal incredibly prime routing for a real metro is bordering on theft of a public good.

theluketaylor··on The Boring Company will dig a 68-mile tunnel network under Las Vegas
It's only cheaper because it's demonstrably worse in every way. The tunnels are too small for a proper metro, it's incredibly inaccessible, loading and unloading passengers takes forever, and in the event of an issue the safety is abysmal.

The expensive part of underground metros is not really the tunnels; stations suck up all the time and budget since they can't be done by TBM and require extensive excavation. This solution doesn't do anything to address the real problem; they need the exact same giant, expensive underground caverns a real metro would need.

Montreal just opened the first phase of 67 km of grade separated, fully automated metro that can handle 2-3 minute headways all for a price tag around $7 billion CDN ($5 billion US). The REM can handle 14,000 people per per hour; this Vegas plan can only handle 4500 in a fanciful future with vehicles that don't even exist yet. REM solves real regional transportation issues. This boring company project is just a distraction from real solutions.

theluketaylor··on Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features
> The manufacturing cost between a car with heated seats and without headset seats is functioningaflly meaningful

I don't believe that is the case. BMW determined it was more expensive to have the supply chain, inventory, and manufacturing management to build both heated and non-heated versions of their seats. Rather than just make heated seats a standard feature they saw an opportunity to maintain and even expand their highest margin revenue stream: options.

theluketaylor··on Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features
I don’t mind hardware shipping locked and being an optional fee to unlock. I have paid for the rear heated seats in my model 3.

What I’m vehemently opposed to is ongoing fees for things that don’t have ongoing costs. BMW wants to charge monthly for seat heaters or carplay, but those things are not a service and don’t have ongoing costs for BMW to provide. If anything creating an ongoing software lock creates an availability risk. If BMW’s authorization service is unavailable do you lose heated seats?

Several manufacturers are offering either monthly or one time costs for certain features. I’m less clear how I feel about that. Maybe quite valuable for someone who lives somewhere warm and only needs seat heat one month a year. It would take many years of paying for a single month to justify paying for the fully unlocked feature. I think I can live with optional monthly fees for things as long as you can always pay once and just have something that stays for her life of the car.

theluketaylor··on Driver says he was 'trapped' in hot Tesla after battery died
I haven't had a single passenger in my model 3 who can find the door release button without prompting, usually multiple different times. It's about 50/50 going for the manual release and staring at the door looking for a way out.

Plenty of people have been able to figure out how to get into the car without help. No one has been able to get out.

theluketaylor··on Plans develop for high-speed rail in the PNW
The Ontario’s are funny. I often get something shipped and think it’s close at hand for southern Ontario, only to be disappointed when I realize it’s in California and it’ll be a few days before it even hits the border.

Saint John NB and St John’s NL is one I find endlessly funny. On paper it should not be a collision, and even out loud it really isn’t one, yet I know multiple people who have independently flown to the wrong one.

theluketaylor··on Wind and solar will be 25% of U.S. generating capacity within three years
Small engines are awful for emissions of lots of nasty things other than carbon. Converting small engines to battery electric is a huge win for health outcomes far beyond climate change.

E-bikes and electric scooters have tons of daily range. For cases where you need more range quick swap stations like gogoro make it fast, cheap, and simple. Unlike cars where the battery is huge personal mobility batteries are pretty small and don’t need special tools or lifting capabilities.

https://www.gogoro.com/

theluketaylor··on EVs Fall Much Shorter of EPA Estimates Than Gas Cars in Our Real-World Testing
Long distance at high speed is the worst case scenario for an EV, so it's a pretty useful figure to know, especially when cross-shopping cars. A fixed speed range test gives you a solid floor for range, with all other uses pretty much guaranteed to meet or exceed that number. The lone exception being cold weather performance, but the easy solution there is conduct the test at multiple temperatures.

Most drivers in an ICE car can get pretty close to the EPA fuel economy in the real world, but in EVs there are some pretty wild swings. Some EVs outperform their EPA number and others can't achieve it, making the EPA number not especially helpful.

theluketaylor··on By 2028 there must be fast chargers every 60 km on the EU’s key motorways
Can draw being a key. Cars can only sustain their max draw for a short portion of the charging curve, so it would extremely rare (if not impossible) to actually draw 2.5 MW. 10 cars with under 15% state of charge would all have to pull in within 2-3 minutes to a supercharger that started empty.

Many charging locations are getting dedicated batteries to smooth off the peaks and valleys of fast charging, turning it into a much more constant draw. When a peak is needed the battery fills in. When the site is more idle, instead of a valley, power is diverted to the battery to ready it for the next peak.

Another strategy companies like kempower are using is 25 or 50 kW modules that can be dynamically allocated across the whole site. At the peak of the curve a car gets many modules. As the power a car can take decreases deeper into the curve the extra modules can be assigned to a different plug. If everyone pulls in at low state of charge at the same time the site hits the limits and cars have the throttle. A more typical usage pattern of cars pulling in and out at different times means cars can maximize their charge curve while capping the total draw of the site.

theluketaylor··on Cities are ending fares on transit. Here’s why
Who then turn around and pass those costs along to renters as landlords. Or they take transit and get value. Or they drive and benefit from every vehicle not on the road since someone else took transit.
theluketaylor··on Tokyo Is the New Paris
Every place even a little bit exburan/suburban/urban in Canada and the US has highly regulated planning restrictions. It's unavoidable, so the fact people who criticize current planning rules live under them isn't a choice; it's a necessity.

Planning restrictions are also highly bipartisian. Both sides favour restrictions, often for different reasons and with different intent, and the result is no supply.

People like to point to Houston as not having zoning laws, but they have deed restrictions that behave in much the same way (and are even harder to undo). Houston does have some of the least restrictive planning rules and also has some of the lowest housing costs. This is not a coincidence.

theluketaylor··on How to register a Kei truck in Pennsylvania
A notable difference being in Canada you can import vehicles at 15 years old rather than 25. There is a decent flipping trade in Vancouver to import JDM vehicles while they are Canadian eligible but not US, hang on to them for a while, then sell them south once the 25 years are up.
theluketaylor··on An Airbnb collapse won’t fix America’s housing shortage
Agreed. The housing crisis has been decades in the making and we are so far past any one solution being able to make any meaningful progress. We need 15 solutions applied consistently over the next few decades, including making sure housing units are not taken off the market to be used as short term rentals on Airbnb. I have no problem with people making some extra cash renting their place while they are away for a few weeks a year to offset their vacation costs, but housing shouldn’t be locked away from a long term resident.
theluketaylor··on Oil Is Hard to Quit, Even in Norway Where Electric Cars Rule
Overhead only. But 3rd rail for long distances is really dangerous. Subways and metros use it since they typically strongly control access to the tracks and tunnels, but that really isn't possible when crossing whole countries.
theluketaylor··on Oil Is Hard to Quit, Even in Norway Where Electric Cars Rule
The most expensive part of electrifying existing track is bridges and tunnels since they often have to be rebuilt to have enough clearance (especially in places like the UK where bridges are old and therefore very low. If all the trains have enough battery to move a short distance without the overhead wires suddenly the electrification project becomes pretty simple and non-disruptive and costs are really reasonable.
theluketaylor··on A reason for high housing prices: restrictive land-use regulations
NYC is an excellent case of restrictive zoning driving housing prices. A shocking number of pre-war apartment buildings in Manhattan would be illegal to build today. Not just for changes in fire escape design, but also the basic shape and height of the building. Despite being illegal designs these buildings remain highly desirable and command high prices, indicating there is a large gap between what the market wants from housing in NYC and what is permitted.

NYC doesn't have uniform extreme density, with places in Queens and Staten Island having large swaths of single family homes. The popularity of NYC should mean the city is getting even more dense, but the restrictive zoning means units are being added at a much lower rate than demand. Of course prices are going to rise.

theluketaylor··on Why are there no startups in the real estate construction sector?
Stuff like SIPs (structural insulated panels) and CLT (cross laminated timber) are kind of changing the game on prefabrication offsite for homes. The components are small enough for trucking but assembling each lego blocks onsite gets you far closer to a completed house per unit time compared to stick framing. I've even seen some smaller SIP houses that don't need a crane onsite. You also don't end up with the modular house stigma.

It's still a small % of houses built, but it's very cost effective and getting better (and more common)

← PreviousPage 6 of 22Next →