It's character-driven pure speculation on big ideas.
2,541 karma · joined June 17, 2014
It's character-driven pure speculation on big ideas.
Today.
Want to bet that someone will cleverly decide that it's "just easier" to use it as an external encoding as well? This kind of cat always gets out of the bag eventually.
It is a matter of perfectly ordinary empirical fact that we live in a universe that, so far as we can tell, is translationally, temporally and rotationally invariant. There is absolutely nothing in Noether's theorem that forbids us from having theories that violate momentum, energy or angular momentum conservation if they happen to describe a universe that has aspects that violate those invariance conditions.
There have been theories that do so, like Dirac's weird large number thing. These are completely legitimate theories, and are entirely subject to absolutely ordinary observational, experimental and inferential verifiability (which is why we know Dirac's large number thing is likely false.)
Employees with allergies, employees who use heavy scents (especially in combination with employees with allergies) and various food smells can all be problems even in cubicles.
Employees who sing, hum, and make other (often unconscious) sounds are likewise problematic in full distraction office layouts.
The claim that there is a cost savings is irrelevant, as "costs less" is never a justification for anything in business. What matters is productivity per dollar spent, so if you can hire four developers with private offices to do the work of five in an open plan, it's a wash.
People who run businesses based on cost savings and not productivity per dollar aren't the kind of people you want to work for if you can help it.
To make this claim convincing you're going to have to come up with some data. For developers, the data show clearly open offices are productivity killers. Some people may like them, but that doesn't make those people more productive.
So what are the areas where open offices plausibly improve business function?
Employee retention? This is possible, as some people clearly have a preference for them, but based on comments in this and other threads the people who hate them hate the a lot, while the people who like them aren't nearly so zealous.
Productivity? The data show this is clearly not the case.
"Communication"? I put this in quotes because I'm not sure what it means, although it gets touted as a benefit of open offices. Private offices and short meetings with small numbers of people result in good communications within and across teams, and I'm not sure what barrier to communication is imposed by being unable to interrupt the person three desks over (and distract everyone in between) that can't be solved by a simple messenger app.
Scalability? Almost by definition open offices don't scale. Maybe opponents of open offices should start hitting on this idea hard: "Your architecture scales, why doesn't your workplace?"
Secondly, naming a function "json" requires the user read the code or the comments to figure out what it does, and blocks the user of the name for anything else that returns json. Suppose rather than a string you have a list that you need translated to json... what do you name the function?
There are three levels of documenting code: naming, comments, and the code itself. Function names should be chosen such that other developers can reasonably guess at a glance what the function does, because the two most comon use-cases for names are:
1) reading someone else's code, where digging in to find out what "json" does is orders of magnitude more work than reading "json_from_string"
and
2) figuring out how to do something in a given codebase, where skimming over a list of function names and picking out one or two that look likely for deeper investigation is orders of magnitude faster than reading the docs or the code for every function to find out which obscurely-named function does the job you want.
Longer, more fully descriptive names aid the user in the excecution of these use cases.
Think carefully and explicitly about the decision-making processes that could have plausibly created this situation where people doing the same stuff get paid substantially different amounts. Think about the values reflected by those processes, and the odds that the company does not have some major storms ahead given the people at the helm.
Amongst undergraduates it is not implausible that when you tell them "this is a logic problem" they will tend to assume--based on the norms of undergraduate thought--that the researcher means "iff" when they say "if". I certainly would have as an undergrad.
To pretend that interpreting "if" as "iff" in an unusual situation is an error, is an error. The test subject is forced to guess what the researcher means, and for all kinds of reasons (not wanting to look stupid, etc) is unlikely to simply ask, "Do you mean if-and-only-if or not?"
Almost all supposed "logic problems" are in fact psychological problems of this kind. Any problem of the form, "What is the next number in this sequence..." for example, has an infinite number of valid answers, since no finite sequence deteremines its next element. Solving such problems requires making an informed guess about the state of mind of the person who designed the sequence, and infering which of the infinite number of possible patterns they thought was the obvious one.
Year GDP Pop Spending £ bln 2005
2008 MW gdp 61.548 582.23
2009 MW gdp 61.904 623.50
2010 1564.9 62.262 697.65
2011 1600.2 62.649 699.89
2012 1621.6 63.067 692.43
2013 1632 63.488 661.32
2014 1665.6 63.912 525.22
There's a huge drop 2013-2014, but before that the spend-up was pretty considerable, and economic growth has been solid since the start of 2013, so if this be "austerity", make the most of it!EDIT: the drop in 2014 is due to local government not being added in. If I look at just "Central Government" from the same source:
2008 MW gdp 61.548 427.07
2009 MW gdp 61.904 458.29
2010 1564.9 62.262 516.99
2011 1600.2 62.649 517.16
2012 1621.6 63.067 522.42
2013 1632 63.488 496.97
2014 1665.6 63.912 525.22
Again, hard to claim much "austerity" in these data.Economic growth in the UK was about 0.5% quarterly for all of 2013 and 2014, and actually dropped to one of the lowest rates in the past two years in the quarter before the election. So unless you broaden "coincide" to mean "the two years preceding an election", or almost half the currently fixed term of Parliament it is not posisble to sustain the claim you make. And if governments can reliably provide economic expansion over two years it isn't clear why they wouldn't do so all the time.
The social construction of "neo-cons" and "distaster capitalists" as the hated Other by the Left cannot mask the underlying objective reality that austerity policies have not been anything like the disaster that was confidently predicted, and may have even done some good, although I'm sure the proper economic analysis of the effect of these policies is a good deal more nuanced than the simple post hoc ergo propter hoc claim that pundits will be making, although the pundits on the Right do have the slight advantage of not having to actually make up facts to support their view in this case.
EDIT: in an equally contrarian reply to another comment above I did some digging into government expenditures in the UK and your claim fails on that basis as well. Government expenditures are mostly up between 2008 and 2014 inclusive.
Terms that seem too good to be true, are. Borrowers know this. Nation-state borrowers certainly know this.
So sure, easy money was available. No one forced anyone to take it.
There were political considerations involved, obviously: parties that were willing to mortgage the future of their nation were more likely to get elected than parties that were willing to be fiscally responsible (to the extent that it would be astonishing if there even were parties willing to be fiscally responsible.)
So leaders offered terms, but that meant nothing without borrowers being willing to take them. I don't see how, despite politics, that the lenders bear any blame for that because national governments are presumed to be mature stewards of the state, able to say "No" to enticing but ill-advised offers. To argue otherwise is to suggest that the Greeks et al are simply not ready or able to govern themselves, which I have difficulty accepting.
I was a senior developer but it was my first commerical job--I'd been in academia previously. I ran the change by the the most senior technical people in the company, all the way up to the guy who'd written the original application as employee #1. He OK'd it because, as he said, "strlen returns as short on the Mac anyway, and since our code runs on Mac as well as Windows it's a limitation we have to respect anyways."
A few years later the company stopped supporting the Mac.
A few years after that (and well after I'd left the company) one user site started getting crashes. I heard later that it took four senior devs a week to track down the cause, and much head-scratching because strlen was documented to return an int. They eventually found my #define, along with a comment that this eliminated so-many hundred warnings in the build, and that the change had been approved by the most senior people (I wasn't totally naive).
It turned out the problem at the specific site having the issue was users putting the entire contents of files into what amounted to tool-tips. It was totally unexpected user behaviour, but they'd found a place they could cache some useful data and we let them do it, so it should have worked.
Today I'd write a script that auto-edited all the cases where the problem occured, and regression test the hell out of it, but yeah: the '90's were a different time!
That answer exposes the deeper answer, too: "My job as a developer is to understand user needs so that our software can help them fulfill them, so if I don't understand why someone needs a feature I should dig in further before implementing it so I don't implement the wrong thing or the right thing in the wrong way." Not always possible given shedule constraints, though.
Admitedly, those rules don't seem to apply in this case, since if the OS allows you to do something that corrupts data, that's a problem no matter why the user wants to do it. If it can corrupt data, the OS shouldn't allow you to do it, end of story.
TED suffers from the same malaise as all "cutting edge" forums: it has no apparent effect on the world, other than transfering money from attendees to speakers and organizers. Which is great: taking money from willing dupes is as old a humanity, but as the years role by it becomes increasingly difficult to maintain that anything more interesting than the release of the latest forumlaic blockbuster is going on.
Refuting this claim is easy: all you have to do is show a dozen or two cases of people who came away from TED changed in a some permenant and actionable way. People who didn't just go back to the same jobs doing the same thing in pretty much the same way. Does anyone have any data rather than anecdotes on this? It would be easy to prove my judgement wrong using it.
1) jump 2) go down with the ship 3) get pushed
There is also the mythical "startup hits the bigtime and you get rich", but the odds of that happening are so low as to be not worth talking about.
So if you join a startup you should be prepared to experience one of those exits. Jumping may be worth it if the startup is going sideways in a variety of ways, including but not limited to:
1) persistent low traction
2) anyone in the company ever says anything resembling "we must educate the customer"
3) frequent pivots (one or two is OK, after that it's probably just flailing before failing)
The bad culture and poor pay issues aren't as likely to come up if you've chosen well in the first place, and are reasons why you should leave sooner rather than later, but startups are mostly experiments aimed at answering two questions:
1) Can we build this thing?
2) Do enough people want to pay for this thing to make it worth our while?
The answer to the first question is usually--but not always--yes. The answer to the second question is almost always "no".
However, the causal account is easily tested: http://web.stanford.edu/group/knowledgebase/cgi-bin/2010/09/...
From the paper: "Based on a sample of 4,000 publicly traded U.S. companies, the average (median) CEO stands to gain roughly $58,000 in wealth for every 1 percent increase in stock price. Among the largest 100 companies, this figure approaches $640,000.6"
So the hypothesis the observed correlation was used to generate appears to be plausible given the further evidence that CEO wealth really is tied to stock price, whether directly through options or other means.
This is how we actually use statistical analysis, as part of a dialog between reality and propositions, rather than repeating the empty matra "correlation is not causation", which while true is something I too often see deployed to denigrate interesting and potentially fertile observations.
Whenever we have the urge to say "correlation is not causation" we should step back and ask, "How can I investigate the question more deeply?" Often more fruitful avenues will present themselves to the inquring mind.
Very few of us are lucky enough to come across our
soulmate within our lifetimes. We tend to choose our
friends and spouses from the limited pool of people
available in our immediate vicinity: students at our
schools, people who live in our neighborhoods,
colleagues at our workplaces. Statistically, it is
extremely unlikely that we will come across our
soulmate.
First off, the notion of "soulmate" is bogus romantic nonsense, and the notion that the person most compatible with us is just like us is demonstrably false. My father and I were very similar to each other and fought and argued all the time, because we were both cantankerous, ornery and contrary.My life-partner and I--who are as close to "soulmates" as anyone can be to that basically ridiculous idea--are very similar in some respects, very different in others. The areas where we complement each other are as important as the ones where we reinforce each other.
More importantly, the claim that there is some great unexplored mass of humanity where our "soulmate" lurks is bogus. There are only 5000 people in the world. Maybe fewer. If there were more we wouldn't keep running into each other all the time.
That is, the number of people in our tribe is surprisingly small, and anyone who is sufficiently similar to us to answer the questions the same way is already almost certainly a member of it, so dipping into the pool of random strangers across the world is unlikely to improve the odds much in most cases, and citing an anecdote or three--which some people will be tempted to do--does not change this fact. The human social graph is full of islands.
Finally, to work as advertised the test requires that answers to the questions are uncorrelated, which is almost certainly not the case. So most people will find themselves with hundreds of "soulmates", a very few will have none. Unique matches will be extremely rare.
It's a superficially fun idea that turns out to be more of a monument to the failure to understand probability than anything else.
But while the benefits of standing desks are plausible, it is very important to remember that they have an unequivocal, well-documented, peer-reviewed, scientifically solid set of risks associated with them: http://www.hazards.org/standing/
That is, there are well-documented health issues with standing all day, and of course, putting desk after standing doesn't change the physics or the physiology of the process. This does not mean your standing desk or mine will kill us, just that it's worth paying attention to any potential downsides developing.
Electron-positron pairs require an energy of just over 1 MeV to be created (the energy of a single electron charge dropping through a potential of 1 MV). So there is more than enough energy kicking around to generate pairs fairly copiously (positrons are always produced with a companion electron in this kind of process, although they may be produced alone in certain types of radioactive decay.)
The interesting part of this work is it seems there was a large volume where there were a lot of positrons, and the specific mechanism capable of producing that situation is not known. Really interesting science in an extreme and transient environment!
"In computer science, functional programming is a programming paradigm—a style of building the structure and elements of computer programs—that treats computation as the evaluation of mathematical functions and avoids changing-state and mutable data." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_programming
So the answer to the question "Who said you can't have state in functional programming?" is: "Every introduction to functional programming ever."
This is why people hate Haskell and make fun of Haskellers. In their quest to appear more clever than the rest of us, they engage in utterly disingenous rhetoric. Which is too bad, because I'm pretty sure they are actually more clever than the rest of us--certainly more clever than me--and don't need this nonsense.
Haskell is an amazingly cool language, and I've talked to people at meetups who are using it for interesting things, and learning a bit of it myself has been an interesting and educational challenge. But getting around to learning it took five years longer than it should have because I was so put off by the rhetorical nonsense the language community engages in.
For what I do for a living it isn't, and Mercurial is a nice alternative that for whatever reason doesn't have any scary warnings in the docs about how I can destroy everything if I revert or rebase inappropriately, or whatever. Mercurial also seems a lot more aggressive about checking if I'm doing something stupid or dangerous and warning me about it, whereas git takes more of the traditional Unix "You Asked For It You Got It" philosophy.
Again: I understand why this is the case, but it's not the optimal tradeoff for me.
From that link, which discusses psychologist David Lisak's studies of rapists: "The last time I discussed Lisak’s work, I focused on the proportion of the population are the serial predators: a limited group within the population who are recidivist rapists, and who account for the overwhelming majority of rapes, and for a large portion of the child abuse and molestation and the intimate partner violence."
Do you have studies to cite that back up the opposite claim? It's perfectly possible the reality is unclear, but everything I've read about the issue supports the idea that the majority of rapes are commited by significantly than 10% of the male population.
This suggests a view in which rape is seen as a "predator/citizen" problem rather than a "men/women" problem, given that male rapists are about as rare as false rape reports (FBI data suggests that 8% of all rape reports are false, and Lisak and other's work suggests that about 8% of men are rapists, with as few as 4% accounting for 75-80% of rapes).
As well as having the potential to open up new ways of addressing rape (and maybe identifying serial rapists early) this change in perspective would allow a more equal focus on male victims, whose numbers are not well-known (male under-reporting rates are almost completely unstudied and plausibly higher than women's).
Which kind of explains why communism always leads to tyranny: it is based on the essentially tyrannical assumption that communists alone have the knowledge to decide how everyone else should be spending thier time, and the moral authority to impose that judgement on others by force.
The problem is that no one has ever found a way of granting such power of central decision making in such a way that either:
a) central planners have access to the information and computing power distributed in the market such that they can make well-judged decisions even by the theoretically pure criteria they claim to be using (that is, communism is inefficient)
b) central planners have no incentive not to make decisions that serve their own interests to the detriment of all others (that is, communism is corrupt).
Given that theses results are incredibly robust and widely known, it is weird that anyone would suggest communism is an interesting alternative to anything. Reform capitalism all you want, but why bring up the political equivalent of a perpetual motion machine as the solution?