HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tominous

1,196 karma · joined February 11, 2016

submissionscomments
tominous··on Ask HN: How to manage my bookmarking habit?
Don't worry about the bookmark collection you already have. There's no pressure to read through it and no pressure to throw it away. That's the great thing about a digital hoarding habit -- it doesn't fill up your house and disrupt your life like physical junk would.

If you're concerned about the time you spend scanning through HN and creating the bookmarks in the first place, what you should do is replace that activity with something else. Concrete example: I decided to eat less junk food, and the way I did it was by filling the fridge with healthy foods which I could eat whenever I got the urge for a snack. It's much easier to replace than abstain.

tominous··on Higher-level causation exists (but I wish it didn’t)
That took a sudden turn! Normally I just go to Slate Star Codex when I want a mixture of sparkling insight and teleological fiction -- though at least there the fiction is clearly labelled.

Back in 2010 I made the prediction that (regardless of the truth) climate change would look increasingly like religion by 2020. Looks like my prediction is right on track.

tominous··on Research Debt
Isaac Asimov anticipated the idea of a research distiller in "The Dead Past" with the character of Nimmo, a professional science writer:

"Nimmo received his first assignment at the age of twenty-five, after he had completed his apprenticeship and been out in the field for less than three months. It came in the shape of a clotted manuscript whose language would impart no glimmering of understanding to any reader, however qualified, without careful study and some inspired guesswork. Nimmo took it apart and put it together again (after five long and exasperating interviews with the authors, who were biophysicists), making the language taut and meaningful and smoothing the style to a pleasant gloss."

In the story Nimmo has less prestige than a "real researcher" but the role pays well and he is in high demand.

tominous··on The CIA uses board games to train officers
Meanwhile Snowden allegedly got access to classified info by convincing 20 people he needed their passwords for his job as sysadmin.
tominous··on Chat Systems
This was a solved problem 15 years ago with multi-protocol clients like LICQ, Gaim/Pidgin and Trillian. Maybe it's harder these days to keep up with the engineers at Facebook, Google and Microsoft but surely simple texting can't be that hard.

I note that the Slashdot submission [1] of this link suggests we need a new, universal protocol, to which the only answer is another XKCD comic [2].

[1] https://yro.slashdot.org/story/17/03/13/2054207/ask-slashdot...

[2] https://xkcd.com/927/

tominous··on Ethereum price goes up nearly 50 percent in under a week
See prospect theory [1]. But I think GP is approaching it in the right way to avoid these suboptimal biases: set reasonable limits up-front but otherwise treat it as a game.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prospect_theory

tominous··on I bought my daughter heroin
I just want to add another story, albeit second hand. My wife went through surgery three times. The first times, pain relief (after the initial nerve block) was mainly via a Norspan patch. The patch was great except it took so long to ramp up (maybe they should have applied it 12-24 hours before the nerve block wore off). There was also no real withdrawal even after two weeks of patches.

The third time (for chest surgery) was via a fentanyl pump, but when that was removed she had severe stomach pains, and soon was in the routine of IV morphine once a day as the stomach pains came back like clockwork. She had the option of coming home but was too frightened of the pain and not having a nurse nearby to help immediately.

I could be wrong but it seemed to me the stomach pains were withdrawal from the painkillers. I'm glad they were effective for her pain but I wish there had been a better path that avoided all the nausea and sleepiness.

tominous··on The Economics of Status (2006)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Blaine
tominous··on Cancer World: The making of a modern disease (2010)
I think it's a bit misleading to put your advice (which is good advice) in the context of experimental treatment. In my experience the cruelty is more likely to come from applying standard treatment that is either hopeless or unnecessary.

In our case it was (a) returning to a line of chemo that had most likely already failed, and (b) a pleurodesis when repeat aspirations would have been more appropriate given what the doctors had said about life expectancy.

On the other hand there were novel treatments that were relatively non-invasive, safe and had a chance (I guessed about 15%) of 6+ months of benefit: (a) copying the Brighter trial and (b) low-dose intralesional immunotherapy on a palpable lesion. Both were turned out to be too hard to get access to even with the support of our physician.

Yes, at some point you have to accept that the only thing left is palliative care. Beware that the window between "still trying all the standard options" and "too late to try something new" may be vanishingly small.

tominous··on Engineers Should Blog
Embrace it like Philip Greenspun. The tag line to his blog: "A posting every day; an interesting idea every three months..." (Which is about right. Most of his posts these days are trolling but there are still gems in there.)
tominous··on The importance of upvoting
True -- at the right threshold one upvote can mean the difference between a post sinking without a trace or making it to the front page and gaining many more votes and views. In that way one upvote can trigger much more than 100 views.
tominous··on Bias in the ER
Your comment is basically Anselm's ontological argument. Very strange to see it applied to medical imaging!
tominous··on Three Qualities Nordic Founders Lack
As a counterpoint to Finland being a consensus culture, they also have "management by perkele" [1]. In particular Linus Torvalds has said his direct style is part of Finnish culture [2].

[1] http://www.rmci.ase.ro/no11vol1/Vol11_No1_Article13.pdf

[2] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/linus...

tominous··on A change to the sell-by dates on food
This is a huge deal with drugs that can cost $10k per vial.

The manufacturers have no incentive to test for longer periods: it would just mean less revenue and more risk. And as I've mentioned before, physicians are very conservative and don't like stepping outside what other people do even if the basic research is there.

For example, the ability to pool leftover amounts of Yervoy (ipilimumab) among patients could save thousands of dollars each. The research so far shows that cancer drug Yervoy remains sterile, stable and effective for at least a month [1] but the manufacturer's guidelines say to use immediately after opening and throw away the rest. (Ironically the independent researchers couldn't afford to do a larger study because the vials were so expensive in the first place!)

It also limits how the drugs are delivered. For example, IL-2 (as a cancer immunotherapy) might be safer, more effective and more convenient as a single continuous infusion over a few weeks [2]. But the guidelines say to use immediately and throw away the excess.

It also limits research into what I think is the most promising near-term approach to cancer: intra-tumoral immunotherapy (with frequent low doses of e.g. ipi, nivo, IL-2 into lesions). Unfortunately this is way too expensive if you have to throw away 99% of a vial for each injection.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/26922168/

[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/10996039/

tominous··on Why is this job not handled by a machine yet?
I love the way you write, very entertaining.

As a consumer, as long as there is one good self-service option I'm happy. When I'm in the car with two kids and need to get petrol, I'll drive the extra distance to pay at the pump rather than having to go into the store.

I don't think all companies need to go down this route. There's value in segmentation for those customers who can't or won't embrace technology. Take the recent OECD survey on computer skills [1]: only a third of people can complete medium-complexity tasks.

[1] https://www.nngroup.com/articles/computer-skill-levels/

tominous··on Why many Indian politicians have a criminal record
Johnny Depp would disagree with you that the laws simply don't apply:

https://youtu.be/ORpBAIB9j64

tominous··on Death by Tactile Paving
Not to take away from the specific challenges of blind people, but this is a broad problem whenever there is a mismatch between the map and the territory. The mismatch can come from sloppy work or just from the way the world changes over time and the map doesn't keep up.

I've seen plenty of cases in IT systems where bad documentation is much worse than no documentation. For example, there are the ubiquitous handover docs (demanded by project managers everywhere) filled with pages of cable connectivity, MAC addresses, WWNs, LUNs, etc in Word tables or manually-edited spreadsheets. They should all read "For historical purposes only" because you will inevitably trip over reality if you rely on them for live systems.

Similarly, there are those that insist on beautiful, meaningful patterns for naming all components. This works great until the pattern can no longer continue, or someone is sloppy, and then the pattern is just a tactile strip leading to a hole in the ground.

The solution I've settled on is live, automatic documentation in the form of scripts that generate a bunch of CSVs (or populate a table somewhere to drive a dashboard). CSVs are nice because they are easy to generate and version. I guess JSON would be more trendy these days.

I avoid manually-edited living documents and put clear warnings on any historical documents. And as much as possible I avoid patterns in naming and numbering, although that's a hard sell for a few clients.

Taking it back to the tactile indicators, I'm reminded of the (apocryphal?) story of what one university did when they landscaped their campus. In the first year they didn't put any paving down. In the second year they paved the worn-down paths in the grass. If only there were some universal way to "grow" tactile strips based on the actual movements of pedestrians.

tominous··on His Doctors Were Stumped, Then He Took Over
I wrote my thoughts about how to work with your doctor here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12266170

My wife has since passed away unfortunately. I really need to write this all up at some point to close it off.

Anyway, I've come to understand that most doctors look at the scientific evidence indirectly.

They often have an excellent ability to follow a decision tree and work through the differential diagnosis. However, that decision tree is based on (a) observations and (b) what other doctors have tried. There's no attempt to look at the underlying mechanism to find novel solutions. So new basic research (e.g. on mTOR and VEGF as in the article) will have no effect on practice until it is proven in trials or until enough mavericks (like the patient in the article) have created a precedent.

It does make sense in terms of avoiding cost and harm -- biology is very complicated -- but I do think this conservative bias goes too far in cases where the treatments have been already proven safe in other contexts, or in cases where the alternative is already bleak.

tominous··on How travel tech evolved over three decades during my three trips to Russia
Funny, just last night I re-read my diary from a bus trip to St Petersburg and Moscow as a student in 2002.

Just before we left St Petersburg we heard rumours of the theatre siege which had just started in Moscow. A few people on the bus had studied Russian in high school so the news filtered around. Even so, we had basically no idea what was going on.

Being poor students we didn't want to waste money on phone calls home, but we did find an internet cafe and wrote a quick email to say we were ok. The people at home knew more about what was going on in Moscow than we did.

We navigated around by paper map (in Cyrillic) and often took wrong turns. If we split off from other groups there'd be no way to meet up again until the evening. (I don't remember anyone having a roaming mobile phone.)

These days I feel vulnerable navigating in my own town without a phone, and people get worried if you aren't reachable within 30 minutes.

Even though it was a very busy trip there was still time to write the diary. On later holidays with a phone and wi-fi there was a lot more to do back at the hotels and much less time was spent writing!

So the big changes I've seen are in communicating home, navigating, and filling the time.

I suspect the next big thing will be usable real-time voice translation, which will make things easier but take some of the fun out of things like ordering a meal and playing "guess the mystery meat!"

tominous··on Misophonia: Scientists crack why eating sounds can make people angry
> it's the fight or flight response

One time I was watching TV, a nature documentary, with my pet rabbit hopping around nearby. You should have seen her reaction when they played the sound of a rattlesnake on TV! Poor bunny was out of the room in no time and stayed quivering and stamping for quite a while.

So when I read about things like misphonia or even food aversion, my first thought is that these people may be showing the rough outline of genetic variants that may, in the right circumstances, be advantageous. (Of course most times it's maladaptive, but you need that initial variance for evolution to act on).

Lo and behold: https://blog.23andme.com/23andme-research/something-to-chew-...

tominous··on One Percent Stake
The cool thing about being a founder is that you get to choose what to do with the equity in your company. So if Stephanie Hurlburt wants to offer a greater share to late employees for reasons of fairness or justice then more power to her. As a side benefit she may attract more talented, loyal employees.

On the other hand there are probably more effective forms of philanthropy than giving your employees more money and equity than the market-clearing amount.

In the end I think the talk about what people "deserve" is a red herring, on both sides. The way I'd look at it is that a business creates value, spends some of it to grow and keep the wheels turning, and the rest is surplus which the owners get to keep, spend or give away as they see fit.

tominous··on Volkswagen overtakes Toyota as the world's biggest carmaker
It's easy to talk about a corporate death penalty, but that's not really in the interest of society.

Take Arthur Andersen. After the Enron scandal, Arthur Andersen was basically split up and absorbed into the other accounting firms, especially Deloitte and EY. Are we really better off having the Big Four accounting firms instead of the Big Five? I'd say we need more competition, not less.

Not to mention the many innocent parties around the world who lost out due to the actions of a few.

I'd be in favour of sanctions that target those responsible and the chain upwards to the top, rather than a business as a whole. Even clawbacks of past bonuses, although that would be logistically very difficult.

tominous··on Box Breathing
Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence, the third time it's enemy action. -- Ian Fleming
tominous··on Solaris 12 removed from Oracle roadmap, Solaris 11.next planned as next release
I can think of four reasons for Oracle staying at Solaris 11.x instead of planning a new Solaris 12 release:

1. Some enterprises have a general policy of only running versions N and N-1 of software. The release of Solaris 12 would trigger a review of Solaris 10 in those environments, which would accelerate the trend away from Solaris. (The Solaris 10 to Solaris 11 upgrade is particularly disruptive due to the switch to IPS packaging and the networking changes, so migration to Linux is of comparable complexity.) Immediate loss of legacy support revenue for both Solaris and SPARC hardware.

2. Solaris 11 support is promised until at least 2031, or 2034 if customers pay for extended support [1]. A new release would just add another stream to support with at least 15 years of overlap.

3. The old SVR4 packaging was so slow and Live Upgrade so unreliable that new releases were required to stop patch bundles from getting too unwieldy. IPS is much faster and safer so it is more technically feasible to stick with the same major release.

4. I'd tend to agree with Adrian Cockcroft that the interesting things are happening elsewhere now [2]. There may not be enough reason for customers to upgrade. Oracle can avoid the story of a failed release by not doing the release in the first place.

[1] http://www.oracle.com/us/support/library/lifetime-support-ha...

[2] http://perfcap.blogspot.com.au/2010/08/open-letter-to-my-sun...

tominous··on Depression as hard on the heart as obesity and cholesterol
Recent research suggests that chronic inflammation may cause depression [1]. Therefore the root cause may be inflammation, leading to both depression and heart disease. (Of course biology is never that simple and there are probably loops and feedbacks.)

[1] Summary: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/01/05/chronic-psychitis/

tominous··on What’s really causing the prescription drug crisis?
From eyeballing exhibits 2 and 3 in the paper, it looks like pain medication doses dropped 5-10%. That seems like a lot in only a couple of years.
tominous··on What’s really causing the prescription drug crisis?
People do turn to weed when it is legal [1]:

"The researchers found that doctors in a state where marijuana is legal ended up prescribing an average of 1,826 fewer doses of painkillers per year"

[1] http://time.com/4404697/marijuana-opioid-epidemic/

tominous··on [dead]
You're right, it is a stretch. I think Thiel was saying something a bit less strong: that in the pursuit of a boring administration with no conflict-of-interest scandals, you can be too conservative. You risk having no-one who actually knows what they are doing.

By the way, if you think becoming a close advisor to a new president is unimpressive then I'd like to know what would impress you!

tominous··on [dead]
I can't read Thiel's mind, but his point reminded me of Mancur Olson's description of roving bandits vs stationary bandits [1].

a "roving bandit" only has the incentive to steal and destroy, whilst a "stationary bandit"—a tyrant—has an incentive to encourage some degree of economic success

The same point could be made for having no interest vs having a conflict of interest.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mancur_Olson

tominous··on The widowhood effect: What it’s like to lose a spouse in your 30s
My wife was diagnosed with cancer in May/June 2015 and moved into the hospice last week. We have two young kids and I'm 33.

I have a lot to say, but for now two things. One, she organised health and life insurance for both of us, and increased them before each child. She's always been the sensible one. Two, having the kids to look after has made things incredibly difficult but I don't know where I'd be without them. Children constantly pull you into the here-and-now. It is so terribly sad that they'll miss out on their mother and she'll miss out on them.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →