HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vezzy-fnord

16,839 karma · joined September 9, 2013

submissionscomments
vezzy-fnord··on Fuck the Cloud (2009)
The reason they are is because of their intrinsic propensity to destabilization, vis-a-vis Minsky and the Financial Instability Hypothesis.

Of course, how you structure your regulatory framework can have adverse consequences, as well (i.e. implicit guarantees by GSEs on mortgage-backed securities). It is further arguable whether or not fractional reserve exacerbates these effects.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
"Falling" is of little analytical meaning without a relative benchmark.

You weren't displaying critical thought, you were engaging in a trite dismissal and then extrapolating an outlandish motive.

vezzy-fnord··on Ulix – a Literate Unix
GPL uses the term "Free" in a twisted, marxist way.

How, pray tell, is it Marxist?

vezzy-fnord··on MkLinux: Apple-Funded Port of Linux to the Power Mac / Mach Microkernel
XPC is a layer on top of Mach ports, however.
vezzy-fnord··on MkLinux: Apple-Funded Port of Linux to the Power Mac / Mach Microkernel
Mach had an unusually large amount of fanfare starting from its introduction at USENIX circa 1985 up to the mid-90s. It was envisioned as a generic resource multiplexer to build all sorts of platforms on top of, and particularly for emulating Unix. You had single-server Unixes like Lites and OSF/1 (the latter sold commercially by DEC as Tru64 UNIX), plus multi-server systems like Mach-US, MASIX, MK++ (for high assurance) and GNU Hurd.

In the late 80s, the Open Software Foundation (OSF) was founded as a consortium of seven major tech companies spearheaded by DEC to standardize Unix in response to AT&T and Sun's adoption of SVR4. They adopted Mach as part of this and ended up extending it to add locksets, semaphores and resource ledgers. MkLinux was then a joint effort in 1996 by Apple and the OSF to both have Linux on the PPC and exploit Mach features in the single-server emulation.

As such, the history is convoluted. It's not that Mach is so great, but rather that circumstances made it creep in various places.

vezzy-fnord··on MkLinux: Apple-Funded Port of Linux to the Power Mac / Mach Microkernel
Survives to this day, as the OSF Mach sources in MkLinux were the alleged basis for Mach kernel module emulation in the NextBSD project. This according to Kip Macy's testimony over IRC, at least.
vezzy-fnord··on Obama Signs CISA Bill into Law
That it does, along with consumer licensing agreements (presumably EULAs).

"Cybersecurity purpose" is itself mostly a pointer contingent to the meaning of "cybersecurity threat":

   Except as provided in subparagraph (B), the term 
   cybersecurity threat means an action, not protected by
   the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United
   States, on or through an information system that may 
   result in an unauthorized effort to adversely impact the
   security, availability, confidentiality, or integrity of
   an information system or information that is stored on,
   processed by, or transiting an information system.
(6) Cyber threat indicator is rather loose with F, G and H. B drops the term "security control". A seems to be legitimately trying to address automated scanning, but might seem to let through legitimate scraping since it doesn't further qualify.

If this is, as you say, one of the least egregious definitions, then I'm not sure whether this is a cause for concern or hope.

vezzy-fnord··on Obama Signs CISA Bill into Law
The bill itself reads mostly mundane, which I think is part of the intention. The main issues are the liberal definitions of "cybersecurity purpose," "cybersecurity threat" and "cyber threat indicator," along with the really half-assed integrity requirements ("Make sure you scrub out personally identifiable information, but only if you're aware of it, so no big deal.") and a repeated insistence on the data being "shared as quickly as operationally practicable".

As such, it strikes me as a try-hard and forced attempt to implement private-to-governmental-entity data sharing with little assurance, and cloaked as a seemingly routine bill. It thus makes perfect tactical sense to bundle it with an omnibus, since it blends in well.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
On a non-geologic time scale, "they're not making any more of it."

But that's the same with all other production. You're rearranging matter.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
The rent, then, is the value the possessor can extract from the property as a result of not having to take those costs.

But the nature of uncertainty of action means that such a cost isn't really quantifiable. It seems like you're trying to say that the rent is the value derived during idling. But idling can serve a valid social purpose in conferring availability of something, or when land is converted for a purpose only on occasion but must necessarily remain available by idling.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
Trading services does not involve property, so no.

It does. Everyone has self-ownership, and as such services can only be sold in the units contracted. A contract for a single indefinite unit service (slavery) would be logically consistent, but a property rights violation and therefore invalid.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
"Trading of private property rights" is redundant, because it's literally just trade. That's not rent-seeking.
vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
The Georgist ideal is problematic because it exalts "land" as being this special component of the general welfare over another factor of production. Yet, all production of capital goods and consumer goods must start from nature-given resources (thus land) mixed with labor. A land value tax would then be a penalty on the entire time structure of production.

I'd wager a government levying an LVT would negate its benefits since such an undertaking would give it sufficient velocity to expand its actions and thus be able to collude with the private sector in all the other, more damaging I'd think, forms of rent-seeking.

The progressive income tax has become a failure due to the wealth elasticity of demand being higher amongst those with more assets (thus being least sensitive to it), along with them finding it easier to avoid it. I don't see an LVT as faring much better.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
That apparently doesn't stop self interested economists going on an academia-themed anti-union rant.

Your promotion of this odd conspiracy about bourgeoisie capitalist economists being bought out by think tanks and promoting anti-labor, pro-capitalist propaganda is just completely baffling to me. You did the same in a previous thread about minimum wages and here again you insinuated in a different post about how Dean Baker's motivation for this paper (being an ACA supporter) must be conspiring to drive down wages of the medical profession to make ACA cheaper.

I just don't know how one can respond to you.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
But it gets kind of interesting if you realize that all property titles are state-granted exclusionary privileges.

Insofar as current arrangements of a state holding eminent domain, yes. Not intrinsically.

Property rents, as a result of exclusive rights to scarce resources, could be seen as an externality, as a result of everybody else accepting those exclusive rights without compensation for being excluded.

A property owner may extend easement or some other non-possessory right to usage, so to immediately classify all property as an "externality" is flat out wrong. If anything, private property rights are a necessary (if not the primary) precondition to resolving externalities.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
we can't just decide that property rights can be ignored when they're cheap to exploit (like copyright or patent infringement)

Copyrights and patents are state-granted exclusionary privileges, not property titles.

If you want to improve wealth distribution, messing with the mechanics of how things are bought and sold, as always, isn't going to get you very far.

What are you talking about? Abolishing and reforming institutions is one of the most powerful tools there is.

Maybe just raise taxes, you know?

The whole point of this paper is that simplistic fiscal shenanigans like this don't work.

vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
Rent-seeking is relatively agnostic of any particular economic order. To some extent, the Marxist-Leninist planned economies were nothing but that.
vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
What do you intend to say by this?
vezzy-fnord··on The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
I picked this study up from Mark Thoma's blog. FWIW, Dean Baker (founder of the CEPR and author of the paper here) has a well-established record as an economist and his credentials can be looked up.

I'm not sure what your implication is, though. Are you afraid of a liberal bias, conservative bias, pro-capitalist or anti-capitalist bias?

If I posted a paper from the Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, I doubt that you would consider the "journal" part to be a consolation.

vezzy-fnord··on Why Free Markets Make Fools of Us
Free markets don't require perfect information, I'm not sure where you came up with that. Perfect information is an assumption used in general equilibrium models, that's really it.

I think you might have meant perfect competition. Free markets don't need perfect competition, either. That's just a neoclassical assumption, again for modeling convenience.

vezzy-fnord··on Why Free Markets Make Fools of Us
The reason his proposed solution of a "nose attachment" sounds ridiculous is because the original complaint by Akerlof and Shiller of "pastries that just smell so good consumers can't resist them" is a complete non-issue that is straight out of Poe's law.

To quote Alex Tabarrok: "Cinnabon pastries are hard to resist. Advertising can be deceptive. Humans sometimes act in foolish ways. If these statements strike you as anodyne then there is no need to read George Akerlof and Robert Shiller’s new book Phishing for Phools, a disappointing foray into behavioral economics from two recent Nobel Prize winners."

vezzy-fnord··on Why Free Markets Make Fools of Us
Probably the closest measure is the Index of Economic Freedom, with the caveat that the ranking method is imprecise: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom

Interestingly, Denmark and Canada surpass the United States, according to the IEF. I was aware the former has the least regulated banking sector, but not much beyond that.

vezzy-fnord··on Why Free Markets Make Fools of Us
Any time something in the public sector goes wrong, people are quick to blame it on the government.

This is a tautology.

vezzy-fnord··on Why Free Markets Make Fools of Us
Don Boudreaux has done a reasonable job of highlighting Akerlof and Shiller's dishonesty in their latest book:

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/phoolishly-against-phreedom-of-...

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/a-baseless-charge.html

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/daffy-elitists.html

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/mostly-exaggerated.html

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/more-on-phishing-for-phools.htm...

http://cafehayek.com/2015/12/the-role-of-market-forces-in-pr...

I would also like to note that anyone criticizing neoclassical economics (and it's full of dubious assumptions, don't get me wrong) based on straw men about "rationality" is fighting windmills. But don't take it from me, take it from a heterodox post-Keynesian: https://unlearningeconomics.wordpress.com/2012/06/29/how-not...

And, unsurprisingly, Akerlof and Shiller stop at yelling "market failure" without proposing a theory of government and ignoring the very fruitful area of government failures.

Anyone who argues for intervention on basis of asymmetrical information without having read up on public choice is in no position to speak of anything, since their model is stuck in assuming government is a mystical exogenous equilibrator and that all of its constituents have virtually no expectations whatsoever (which is an even worse assumption than full rationality).

Akerlof and Shiller are obviously well aware, but their book is little more than a political polemic.

vezzy-fnord··on My positive experience as a woman in tech
it was lame European pacifist politicians that let Hitler get so far

I'm not sure what gives certain Americans such a knack for injecting Anti-European sentiment. Is this what they're taught in history classes, or something else?

vezzy-fnord··on Legalising pot in Canada will not be easy
The blueprint seems to imply that anything less than the regulation thresholds for pharmaceutical drugs is tantamount to "unfettered free market anarchy". I'm not sure if this is a political strategy to appease prohibitionists, but the statements that such an "unregulated" environment would be a worse outcome than prohibition strikes me as paternalism that is debunked by most of human history of drug consumption.
vezzy-fnord··on Martin Shkreli indictment [pdf]
I'm not sure how incarcerating people deemed to prove a "net social loss" by some nebulous criteria promotes social stability. Hell, if we're going to be this loose, why not just kill them so no resources are spent for prisoner care?
vezzy-fnord··on Martin Shkreli indictment [pdf]
it's a net gain for society and that's what's important

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_monster

(Assumes cardinal utility, but it still works.)

vezzy-fnord··on Martin Shkreli Arrested on Securities Fraud Charges
They already do:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Institutes_of_Health

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_and_Drug_Administration#S...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agency_for_Healthcare_Research...

It clearly ain't working.

vezzy-fnord··on I was denied admission to a PhD program because of my perceived political views
It's not a No True Scotsman when there's inherent vagueness.

People define themselves by these terms and the terms are also widely used. If you can't figure them out, that's on you.

Is that so? Because I've heard definitions of "right" as variously economically liberal, economically protectionist, socially conservative, socially liberal (as in classical liberalism), non-interventionist in foreign policy, interventionist in foreign policy, anti-statist, statist and so forth.

In fact, all of these contradictory views have belonged or continue to belong to various movements categorized as "right-wing".

So I'm asking about what you mean. Or perhaps you don't mean anything and are simply looking for an ax to grind.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →