HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vincent-toups

691 karma · joined January 14, 2019

submissionscomments
vincent-toups··on Signs of the Times
Something like a fuzzball:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuzzball_(string_theory)

But there I think most physicists think something like the solution to the Einstein field equations does obtain within most of the interior region of the objects we call black holes. They just believe that the region of the singularity may have some other physics so that it doesn't become singular.

vincent-toups··on New books mount aggressive but ultimately unpersuasive defenses of multiverses
This guy doesn't come across as all that literate about the interpretation of quantum mechanics.
vincent-toups··on ACM signed letter opposing open access
I think in the grand tradition of western government going all the way back to the greeks there is ample consideration given to the good as it pertains to the entire human race, not just nationals.

Read Nussbaum's book about cosmopolitanism - the introductory chapters provide plenty of evidence that historically speaking, elites have conceived of governments has having at least some obligation to all human beings, regardless of state.

vincent-toups··on ACM signed letter opposing open access
The presumption you're making is that a country would never spend money for the public good, where that is defined to include the entire human race, rather than just nationals.

Weird assumption! Generally speaking, academic research is considered to be an international, or super-national, cooperative effort in most fields.

vincent-toups··on “Don’t Try”: The Philosophy of the Hardworking Charles Bukowski
Super important to be ultra careful about how many times this man hit a woman.
vincent-toups··on “Don’t Try”: The Philosophy of the Hardworking Charles Bukowski
He really struck his girlfriends too, I hear.
vincent-toups··on Why Taxpayers Pay McKinsey $3M a Year for a Recent College Graduate Contractor
These qualities are not incompatible with being hatchet-men or giving shitty advice.
vincent-toups··on A Reality Check on Quantum Computers
Read Quantum Computing Since Democritus. Its the best you can do as a lay person.
vincent-toups··on I'm not burned out, I'm pissed off
Almost everything anyone does in business, as far as I can tell, is dramatically optimized for speed at the expense of almost everything else.

This is a natural result of a very competitive market place and, as far as I can tell, its rational if you take that circumstance to be an immutable state of affairs. Its no good stopping to dot the i's and cross the t's if, in doing so, you get completely edged out of the market by a competitor who isn't doing so. And you haven't even made the world a better, safer, nicer place by doing so. You've just left the door open for someone less scrupulous to beat you with a shittier product.

The solutions aren't palatable in the current philosophical mode: much more aggressive penalties (corporate death penalties, for instance, in which shareholders literally lose all their money) or much tighter and well enforced regulations. Move fast and break stuff truly is the philosophy of the day.

If you don't want to break stuff, you have to make moving fast less competitive. As far as I can tell, that's the only way.

vincent-toups··on Shrinkflation
This clip. Christ.

There are many ways for the conversation to go if you want to get try an understanding of gauge theory. Joe Rogan is not on any of those many branching paths.

vincent-toups··on Trigger warnings don’t help people cope with distressing material
I don't think lectures need to do all that much work. They just need to think for a bit and warn people "Hey, this could be disturbing." That's pretty much it.

Its not like trigger warnings impose an onerous responsibility on teachers. There isn't any suggestion that they tell their students to get help. Its literally just a "heads up, I'm about to talk about X".

I'm not on a campus, and when I was in was in physics and math classrooms, but its hard to imagine this is that big of a deal.

vincent-toups··on Trigger warnings don’t help people cope with distressing material
My point wasn't about whether or not you can train people. My point is that you shouldn't, in general, think of human beings as things upon which you perform training.

There may be certain contexts in which training is an acceptable thing for a person to do or have done to them, but that typically doesn't apply to normal interactions between adult human beings.

vincent-toups··on Trigger warnings don’t help people cope with distressing material
People aren't dogs to be trained. To an extent, to be human and to recognize other people's humanity is to accept and accommodate their irrationality where doing so isn't particularly onerous to you.
vincent-toups··on Trigger warnings don’t help people cope with distressing material
Right, avoidance may not be a good coping strategy at large, but that doesn't mean people shouldn't be extended the courtesy of being able to choose to avoid exposure in certain contexts. Ideally exposure therapy for trauma should be done in a controlled setting, like therapy.

Heck, I don't have PTSD but I don't particularly like seeing sexual violence in movies or television shows and more than once I wish I had been warned about it ahead of time.

From my point of view, trigger warnings are courteous. Its not my job to tell people how to live their lives. If someone asks me in good faith to let them know before I talk about something that might disturb them, I take that seriously because I'm not a jerk.

The idea that trigger warnings constitute some kind of creeping Orwellian thing is nuts to me. The whole point of them is "I'm going to say this!"

try not to be one.

vincent-toups··on Alan Moore on superhero culture
If all important experiences were universal then communication would be superfluous, if not, in some sense, impossible.

We don't need to do much work to explain what we all experience. There is no virtuosity of the obvious. Communicating those things we don't share is the province of skill and a particular kind of value not present in the immediate and universal.

vincent-toups··on Alan Moore on superhero culture
I'm not advocating for any sort of prescriptive definition of art, obviously. There are certainly lots of ways to talk about art, and in many respects the Marvel movies meet the definition.

But just as it would be absurd to be totalitarian about the definition art, it would be absurd to suggest that The Avengers 12 or whatever is identical to, for instance, Cinema Paradiso, and that there isn't something in the latter film that is missing from the former.

From there its not a leap to ask broader questions about what sorts of films dominate popular culture and whether that state of affairs is good or not.

This is a discussion of art, and thus the human condition. We're unlikely to find anything like a concrete conclusion. But its note futile either.

vincent-toups··on Alan Moore on superhero culture
Bad cinema can (and arguably must) stimulate the emotions, but I don't think that is what Scorsese is trying to get across here.

The marvel movies or whatever may stimulate emotions in us, but they do so primarily by dramatizing conditions which are so universal that we can all identify with them. That has limited artistic potential.

The critical phrase in Scorcese's quote, up there, is "to another human being". Literally almost anyone with a dead father misses their father. You aren't learning anything about the human condition by being reminded of the fact that you loved him. Being so reminded isn't bad by any means, or valueless. These movies help us process our emotions and live in the world.

But they aren't necessarily doing the hard artistic work of carrying you into the mind of someone else whose experiences, desires, pains, might be quite different than your own. They definitely aren't doing the artistic work of offering serious critique of the world.

These films are definitely escapists. I don't think Alan Moore is against escapism. I think he is worried by its total domination as a cultural form.

vincent-toups··on Your throat hurts, your brain hurts: the life of the audiobook star
Shouldn't your contempt be saved for the devs who are dumb enough to work without royalties or a union contract? It seems like the voice actors are the ones who have it figured out and we are the dumb ones.
vincent-toups··on Lessons from APL, a “Lost” Language
When I started my current job as a data scientist I spent the first three months or so doing all my work in J (a descendant of APL that doesn't need a funny keyboard).

I'm a long term Lisper (prefer Scheme) and so I have a high tolerance for languages with weird syntax and small communities, and I had to write a lot of code to get a working environment in J (for instance, I hand wrote my own simple system for interfacing with Hive, which I used a lot back then).

The main thing I did was implement Naive Bayesian inference on some internal data and lots of plotting.

J is fun and it gives you that special feeling of doing something hard and weird which sometimes motivates me, but in the end I gave up on it in favor of R and Python. Surprisingly, the main thing that won me over to these languages is that they were faster and required less care. I'm not stranger to vectorization (did Matlab for 6 years during my PhD) and I liked doing it in J, but in the end I could do less work and get sometimes much better performance out of R.

Plus, even after many months of doing J full time, I still have to get into a whole headspace to even _read_ my J code. R and Python are at least legible in a way that you can come back to after awhile.

Finally, I started to really miss the uniformity of simple, first order functions with lexical scope.

Still miss the notion of verb rank, though. Wish it was part of modern languages.

vincent-toups··on [dead]
Just calling it like I see it.
vincent-toups··on [dead]
So this user only posts content from one place, which I assume is their blog. That blog says its explicit purpose is to generate interest in their novels on Amazon.

So I think this is spam?

vincent-toups··on PeerTube v2
I've started to see _engagement_ as a mal-feature. One thing I prefer about Mastodon is that its much less engaging than twitter, which is psychotically optimized to keep my eyeballs on it.
vincent-toups··on SimplyThick: A Tragedy No One Saw Coming (2013)
Move fast and break stuff.
vincent-toups··on Economics Needs a Post-Crash Revolution
I don't know, ask someone whose kid can't get medical treatment because they lost their job in a downturn.
vincent-toups··on Double Slit Experiment No Mystery
There isn't any consensus on what aspects of our classical ontology are the right ones to get rid of. You can preserve local realism if you have superdeterminism, for instance.
vincent-toups··on Double Slit Experiment No Mystery
This is as good a description of the ontological limitations of pilot wave theory as any, but many of the criticisms apply to almost literally any interpretation of quantum mechanics whatsoever.

As a physicist with a passing interesting the subject of foundations, its my feeling that what quantum mechanics tells us is that at least one aspect of our classical ontologies is not correct. My personal bet is that its locality which is the problem, but as far as I understand it the question is still wide open.

de Broglie-Bohm merely casts the ontological tensions with classical physics in one particular light, but I'm aware of no interpretation which is free of the tension.

vincent-toups··on Estonia is running its country like a tech company
Countries have a different purpose than companies. It hardly makes sense to compare them.

Companies can fire people. Countries cannot. Companies are typically not democratically controlled whereas countries should be. Companies are not obligated to meet the basic needs of their employees, protect their rights even if it isn't profitable, defend against foreign adversaries.

Companies have one, very narrow, purpose and efficiency is one property which is induced by that arrangement. States, on the other hand, are human institutions constituted to much broader purpose and scope. I'd actually argue its deeply inhuman to expect efficiency to be a primary property of a state.

vincent-toups··on Estonia is running its country like a tech company
So with the expectation that it will either succeed wildly and they'll sell it to google or it will flame the fuck out and take years off of its employee's lives?
vincent-toups··on Elite MBA Programs Report Steep Drop in Applications
Everyone I've ever met who went to one of these schools strikes me either as a straight-psychopath or someone who really wants to be one.
vincent-toups··on Show HN: Bel
Seems goofy, but ok. I'll just use Scheme.
← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →