HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

vitriol83

68 karma · joined November 2, 2014

submissionscomments
vitriol83··on 8K TVs Are Coming to Market
i don't doubt for a minute that people can tell the difference. however would just make the point that a proper controlled experiment would be to change the source from 720p to 1080p or 4k, rather than the tv (assuming the tv supports the maximum res!).
vitriol83··on 8K TVs Are Coming to Market
i have a 46" TV. I suspect the x.264 compression artifacts were becoming a limiting factor (and my eye sight)
vitriol83··on 8K TVs Are Coming to Market
maybe i'm old, but I can't tell the difference between 720p and 1080p on my ludicrously oversized flat screen tv
vitriol83··on OCamlScript – a JavaScript back end for OCaml
I would say the main problem with the OCaml community is it's too small. More projects are welcome imo, even if it inevitably means some duplication of effort. After all js_of_ocaml is free to take some of the more desirable features.
vitriol83··on Libor trial
I believe this is a test case, as it's not entirely clear if manipulating libor was against UK laws, as they were at the time.
vitriol83··on Wall Street's New Financial Product: Your Rent Check
In general you're right it's unfair to say that real estate investment is always unproductive and rent-seeking. However for major cities like London with tight supply, the flows of real estate investment that followed QE and zero interest rates haven't been matched by appropriate levels of home building. As a result affordability and ownership levels have reached historic lows, and many more people are becoming 'unwilling' renters, only able to service the financing costs of real estate investors. At this stage it becomes rent-seeking and unproductive, in my view, and there ought to be appropriate policy responses from government.
vitriol83··on Wall Street's New Financial Product: Your Rent Check
i would be slightly more targeted- abolish tax incentives for investment in real estate. investment in real estate is literally rent-seeking, unproductive and is widening inequality , particularly between young and old.
vitriol83··on The IRS seized a businessman’s life savings without charging him with a crime
having lived in the US and UK for a long time, it's struck me that the relationship between the US government and its citizens is unusually suspicious and hostile, which I really can't find a parallel in any other developed countries. As distrust of government is nearly universal in the US, I'm continually surprised the situation manages to sustain itself.
vitriol83··on Arq for Windows finally available
seconded, i think it would be a good alternative to duplicity
vitriol83··on In Mathematics, Mistakes Aren’t What They Used to Be
the article seems to be based on the presentation by Voevodsky himself,

http://www.math.ias.edu/~vladimir/Site3/Univalent_Foundation...

vitriol83··on Go crypto: bridging the performance gap
Sure, that's why I think there's an argument to use ones which are more 'battle tested'.
vitriol83··on Go crypto: bridging the performance gap
without formal methods it's impossible to fully test crypto implementations, such as ECDH, because the number of possible inputs are enormous. bugs in small proportion of inputs can lead to fault attacks. and furthermore side channel attacks are very common.
vitriol83··on Go crypto: bridging the performance gap
I agree, ECDH and AES-GCM are sufficiently complex to implement it makes sense to call into OpenSSL. OpenSSL has had its problems, but these tend to be with TLS protocol handling. The underlying cryptographic constructions have had a lot of attention.
vitriol83··on 1ML – unifying ML into one language
Not sure if this mirrors his approach exactly, but ocaml does now offer 'first-class modules'

https://realworldocaml.org/v1/en/html/first-class-modules.ht...

vitriol83··on New Hacker News Guideline: Avoid Gratuitous Negativity
good idea. perhaps we should abolish downvoting too- isn't that the very definition of gratuitous negativity?
vitriol83··on Why are interest rates so low?
> The Fed does, of course, set the benchmark nominal short-term interest rate....The Fed’s ability to affect real rates of return, especially longer-term real rates, is transitory and limited.

this would be a plausible argument if the us treasury weren't the biggest buyer of long-term government debt.

vitriol83··on OWebl v0.1 Release Candidate Now on OPAM
this is a neat idea, as ocsigen is rather intimidating to use for the simple case.

are there any plans to make use of cohttp and/or lwt as the underlying network abstraction ? my concern with hand-rolled http is it may not handle the edge cases correctly and cohttp is more battle tested. also i believe it's more idiomatic ocaml to include interface files to hide the implementation details.

vitriol83··on Gov.uk isn’t finished
I like gov.uk. However I think they are overselling the value of centralising and modernising existing government websites, which are generally speaking quite good (albeit perhaps not on an ipad).
vitriol83··on Gov.uk isn’t finished
GDS claim to be 'leading the digital transformation of government'. If their spec is to perform routine modernisation of websites, then this hype is completely unwarranted.
vitriol83··on Gov.uk isn’t finished
This blog post is worryingly vague about anything of concrete value for users. It suggests a large reengineering effort without any idea of what they really want to achieve. For example, one of the blog posts it links to, they introduce the new VAT manual

https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-government-and-...

vs old

http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/vatgpbmanual/index.htm

It's identical, except for a modified stylesheet. This may be 'unapologetically unifying and simplifying the experience of interacting with government', but this is not very much to show for all the time that has been spent on GDS.

vitriol83··on The Outsiders – Homelessness in San Francisco
empathy fail
vitriol83··on Why OCaml, why now? (2014)
IMO key advantage OCaml is easier to learn and much more pragmatic.
vitriol83··on Show HN: The Silicon C++14 Web Framework
the requirement for pre-processing makes me a bit suspicious, it's going to be a pain to interact with other parts of the toolchain, so i would hope there's a very good reason for it. i would make this at the top of the README.md.

The same comments apply to a lesser extent to the C++14 requirement- does your framework really benefit from using C++14 features over say C++11 ? Again I would make this clear at the top of the README.

vitriol83··on Secure Secure Shell
Implementing a truly constant-time GCM in software without CLMUL is sufficiently hard that noone has managed to create a remotely competitive implementation. They're all either an order of magnitude slower or vulnerable to cache-timing attacks.

Poly1305 isn't a walk in the park, but doesn't need special hardware support for fast constant-time implementation. Though I will agree something like HMAC is much simpler.

vitriol83··on Ask HN: Can we talk about FreeBSD vs. Linux?
i use it mainly as a soho nas. the things i like about it are

1) userland and kernel owned by the same group. this lends consistency to the experience, that is absent in linux, where it's clear that it's an amalgamation of many different tools.

2) (largely) one way of doing things

3) package management system (pkg-ng) that is a cross between gentoo portage and debian apt-get

4) extremely good documentation for an open source project (https://www.freebsd.org/doc/handbook/)

5) configuration is very simple (mostly driven from rc.conf)

6) excellent full-disk encryption support (geli)

driver support always lags a bit behind linux, on the other hand the drivers that do exist i'm confident are stable. i make sure to buy hardware which i know is supported.

vitriol83··on Please remove mitsuhiko/*
The objection is you're committing fraud. You're soliciting 'donations' for a third party (everyone committing to a project) without their consent. Unbeknownst to the donaters you're then keeping these 'donations' because the third-party has no interest in taking them. This is pretty shaky ground to be on, and it only takes one person to decide to take legal action against you.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2