HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wamatt

2,899 karma · joined February 21, 2012

username at Buchheit’s beta bunker
submissionscomments
wamatt··on I've got 10 btc for the best CoffeeScript/JavaScript Nodewar bot
Um, there was definitely DDOS'ing going on. I witnessed it myself with a bunch of other sites (bitcointalk, bitstamp, bitcoincharts etc). Mt Gox was trying to do damage control and spin it positively. That failed and now they are reporting DDOS again.[1][2]

"@MtGox Maintenance Over however we are now under a DDoS attack." [1]

Mt Gox has taken a credibility knock, which has a ripple effect on the BTC pricing right now.

Overall it probably a temporary setback, but does bring to light irrational exuberance voices ignoring others that were calling for a more decentralized ingress/egress between USD and BTC. IOW bitcoin needs more exchanges to drive competition, and perhaps even meta-exchanges too.

[1] https://twitter.com/MtGox/status/322281690309468160

[2] https://www.facebook.com/MtGox/posts/456123227805423

wamatt··on Bitcoin falls from $266
>The bitcointalk forums and /r/bitcoin are full of paranoia like this.

'The HN forums is full of smug dismissiveness like this'

It's a blip on the radar in the grand scheme of things, and tons of sites were DDOS'd and simultaneously going slow or down (bitcointalk, mtgox, bitcoincharts, bitstamp). The evidence is my own eyes and refreshing browser timeouts. Everything back to normal now.

Highly unlikely that all those sites would be bought down by "panicked" users alone.

Given profiteering DDOS attacks against casino operators are commonplace, I find it a stretch to think these attacks are not happening regularly against bitcoin sites.

wamatt··on Bitcoin falls from $266
..and this is probably going to look foolish when it goes to $1000 later this year. Your actions looks like someone trying to pat themselves on the back and reassure the "right decision".

I wish online P2P wagers were legal in the US :) I was watching everything during the "crash". It's already back up to 170 in a few hours. Previous crash took months to recover.

I've been around the block and the same tired and worn arguments were being used at $10 then $20 and $100.

wamatt··on What Bitcoin Is Teaching Us
Two issues:

1)Having insights and owning bitcoins can be mutually independent variables.

In other words, it's entirely possibly you have it completely backward, and that upon arriving at a lengthy deliberation, some rational actors, are therefore choosing to take a position.

2) >"that the recent rise in Bitcoin value will continue forever."

That's a pretty decent sized strawman you've rustled up. Most people in that camp are not arguing that bitcoin will rise forever.

The discussion is about the shape of the graph. I believe both an s-curve (slow adoption, exponential growth, maturity) and [perhaps multiple] sawtooth (crash scenario) are plausible.

wamatt··on Coinsetter raises $500k to bring leverage, shorting to Bitcoins
The implicit assumption that there is a bitcoin bubble, is not a fact.

Was the .com speculation the last two decades a bubble? Is Facebook stock circa 2007 a bubble? etc

Rational arguments can be both ways and I'd be wary of anyone selling certitude on either side the fence.

wamatt··on Realtime Bitcoin Stats
The difference between a normal currency and bitcoin with regards to deflation is that bitcoin is almost infinitely divisible, whereas traditional currencies are not.

Divisibility acts in opposition to deflation to create liquidity.

The idea is in the future you don't trade bitcoins per se, but microbits, or picobits etc (or whatever they will be called).

wamatt··on Realtime Bitcoin Stats
>"It seems there's a hesitation of spending bitcoins knowing if you just wait a day it will go up"

So this argument seems to be rather popular, and on the surface it does seems to make sense. However, it glosses over an important consideration.

Are you buying goods in USD or BTC?

Now if it's the latter, then yes there may be stronger psychological pressure (even though rationally there is not much difference).

However, increasingly goods are being traded in USD using BTC as a backing, in which case it would make little difference if you spend in USD from a bank account, or USD with a bitcoin wallet. Because it is possible to trade USD for BTC almost instantly. (Let's ignore the issue of wire transfer delays for now, because that doesn't change the overall argument).

Consider the person holding say 200 bitcoins today. In this situation, if the transaction is a small amount (say a cup of coffee ($3), at 180USD/BTC is about 0.016 BTC at todays rate. I'd have no problem spending that.

In fact psychologically it may be more likely that people trade with their BTC "winnings", because like a casino it has been shown that that is treated as more disposable than "real money".

Thus if one is spending a fraction of a bitcoin priced in USD, and this amounts to a small percentage of your overall position, it's unlikely to endure as a significant purchasing disincentive.

wamatt··on How I Busted a Thief Who Tried to Sell My Camera on Craigslist
Curious, but why would Target care too much if the credit card was stolen? My understanding (which could be wrong) was the credit card companies or end users absorb the losses (depending on circumstances).
wamatt··on One Drug to Shrink All Tumors
"no one has the ability to make the distinction between a quack and real medicine" (paraphrasing OP)

What utter nonsense. If someone presented you with a homeopathic dropper [1] saying it would cure cancer vs a new gold nanoparticle experimental therapy [2], "no one" would be able to tell the difference?

While the new treatment may turn out to have issues (no one was suggesting experiments were risk free), to imply it's indistinguishable from quackery, is false.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

[2] http://bjr.birjournals.org/content/85/1010/101.full.pdf

wamatt··on One Drug to Shrink All Tumors
Snark aside, we are somewhat in agreement.

I tend to dislike elitist thinking (or though I'm still guilty of it at times), not for moral reasons, but simply because empiricism, in my admittedly subjective opinion, is routinely lauded over common sense in nerdy communities (HN, slashdot, SO etc), and is often a form of bias. Having a bias doesn't mean one is wrong necessarily, but it can be problematic too, especially if one lacks cognizance of said bias.

For example, my gf is the furthest thing from a computer scientist, but is routinely more observant socially and can spot bullshitting better than I in certain contexts (among other superior cognitive skills).

However in the past I've tried to pick too many battles in one post, and that makes it difficult for someone to upvote, as they may agree with some, or one point, but not another and creates a mixed cognitive dissonance. Hence I didn't want to launch into a large foray of intellectual elitism.

Hence the aim was, for the most part was to try to leave epistemological disputes (how do we know what we know, who knows what etc, do all groups have equally justified beliefs?), out of the debate and focus on the regulatory side of things and empowering the individual to be allowed follow their own life and death decisions.

That said, perhaps I could have left the opening paragraph off altogether in retrospect.

wamatt··on One Drug to Shrink All Tumors
>"lay people have essentially no ability to distinguish between potential 'last shots'"

I'm sure you mean well, but this type of thinking really bothers me.

For example, many of us here on HN, possess the critical reasoning skills to determine snake oil from a credible research lab. Given that there are almost no practicing oncologists present, we'd all likely qualify as lay people.

However the central issue is a medical doctor is not even qualified enough to choose, due to malpractice liability. On top of that even a specialist can find difficulty prescribing experimental treatment lawfully, unless it's part of an FDA trial. This is in addition to the incentives drug companies push. [1]

I speak from first hand experience dealing with Psoriatic Arthritis and establishment CYA (cover your ass) thinking. After spending $1000+ per month on Anti-TNF blockers [2], I'm doing just fine on lifestyle changes and have seen no disease progression after 3 years of being off meds. I wouldn't bother mentioning it if it weren't for the thousands of credible patient stories that point to fixing what we eat as a means to being healthy. Yet the paradigm for the last 30 years is one of treatment, not prevention.

Guess which makes more money for Pfizer, GSK etc? Hint: it's not vaccines (prevention). Chronic treatment (autoimmune, psych drugs, cvd etc) are dominating the top 10 sales charts. [3]

I would feel incredibly angry and upset if myself or someone close to me, were in a position to try an experimental cancer treatment, but were unable to, because of regulatory snakes and ladders.

I'm not saying the FDA is useless or provides no public benefit, but I would question the wisdom behind entrusting authority of one's life, to a single decision making body.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/25/us/payments-to-doctors-by-...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etanercept

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_selling_pharmac...

wamatt··on A scientific accident that could change the world
>That said, I immediately dug an old LightScribe CD recorder out of my junk bin to start playing around with making graphene sheets :-)

You serious? Sounds interesting, do tell us more.

wamatt··on DIY Email Referrals with MailChimp, Zapier, and Mailgun
Agreed.

Additionally one might go as far to suggest false positives are more problematic than the occasional spam mail.

wamatt··on Facebook Cuts Off MessageMe’s Access To Its Social Graph
I welcome your additional precision and those those are good points.

However, I think that you should hold the word "never" to the same standard.

I certainly used to preach the same view as you to anyone that would listen, but over the years I've seen many successes that violate the rule. Rationally speaking "never" does not make sense.

One needs to evaluate (among many things) the risk of being shut down, how much benefit can be extracted before termination, and what the overall cost (money, opportunity cost etc) and benefit is etc.

"Zynga's first game, Texas Hold'Em Poker, now known as Zynga Poker, was released on Facebook in July 2007." [1]

Yes Zynga suffered immense hardships because of the Facebook reliance, but Pincus still built a billon dollar company which would not have happened if he'd taken your advice to heart in 2007.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zynga

wamatt··on Facebook Cuts Off MessageMe’s Access To Its Social Graph
Never?

The does seems like a strong word. It could be argued that there exists quite a few businesses built almost soley around credit cards for transactions and hence income.

This in turn requires playing by Visa/Mastercard's rules, which is a situation not too dissimilar from the one described above.

wamatt··on Bacn is the New Spam
Nice to see more competition in this space. I've found newsletter email filtering to be a godsend and it's changed how I deal with email.

I used to setup tons of filter rules manually, but now I just subscribe to anything of interest, and don't worry about the consequences.

Sanebox[1] allowed me to do this. It uses a ML algo over any Imap account (I'm using it on Gmail) so it's email client independent. It works incredibly well.

No affiliation with SB, just a happy customer and it's 1/4 the monthly price to boot.

[1] http://www.sanebox.com/

wamatt··on This Man Thinks He Never Has to Eat Again
The author himself shows a little more humility: "You’re exactly right. This is a risk, an experiment. " -rob [1].

I find it incredible that you will not concede any significant difference between D3 and D2 or between K1 and K2 groups. When the facts show the opposite. [2] Have you actually read the book on K2 and the evidence that it reduces arterial calcification?

You act like it's perfectly reasonable to dismiss studies and because of your preconceived notion that this diet is a perfect and "very complete" and "100% completely and totally covering all vitamins" (your words) and therefore any counterclaims means <insert strawman attack>.

I like this Rob fellow. I'm a huge supporter of ground up approaches, but this is simply not a black and white issue, and no amount of bullying from your quarter is going to change that.

[1] http://robrhinehart.com/?p=424#comments

[2] http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/05/120531102338.ht...

wamatt··on This Man Thinks He Never Has to Eat Again
>And I am saying that just because you want to pretend there's magic pixie dust that we need to live, doesn't mean it is actually true.

Another misrepresentation. I started the thread by saying that the human body can take a lot of abuse for many years without apparent ill-effects. That said, many would argue the difference between "living" (or surviving over a certain time period) and optimal health, is not an insignificant consideration.

It's quite possible to develop chronic conditions, that are not apparent at first, and only manifest themselves after years of nutritional deficiency.

wamatt··on This Man Thinks He Never Has to Eat Again
>"No, it is arrogant to claim that you know everything and this guy is a total moron because he did a great job of 100% completely and totally covering all vitamins "

Emotionally charged strawman. He's done some homework. My argument is that it's simply not enough. IE it's possible to be ignorant of how much one is ignorant of. There are also unknown unknowns that exist.

>Pretending a single study is evidence that there's an entire family of vitamins we know noting about is so incredibly stupid I refuse to believe you are actually doing that.

Another misrepresentation. I'm saying that the Vitamin K2 group is not widely understood and only recently gaining more attention in the last few years. [1]

Also there is no pretending going on, simply advocating skepticism and that it's an extremely complex topic with ongoing studies often refuting "obviousness" of a prior generation of thought.

I haven't even started on the role the microbiome plays in our health. The fact that there are 10x more non-human cells (100 trillion cells) in our bodies should be pause for concern and a little humbleness. We literally carry around thousands of different strands of bacteria and are only now in this decade starting to map the genetic material to figure out new advances and how these interact with the food we ingest and their systemic effects. [2][3][4]

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Vitamin-K2-Calcium-Paradox-Little-Know...

[2] http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/ubiome-sequencing-your-mic...

[3] http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/american-gut-what-s-in-you...

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Microbiome_Project

wamatt··on This Man Thinks He Never Has to Eat Again
Not as far as nutrition is concerned. Some studies have indicated that D2 is slightly less potent, but the majority have shown equal efficacy.

The evidence does not support that claim. If anything we don't know, and that's my point. [1][2]

>Your whole argument seems to be an attempt at pointless pedantry, when the pedantry presented doesn't even matter to the subject at hand.

No I'm saying similar to "Vitamin B". You body may be lacking in pyridoxine or cobalamin or one of the other B vitamins. They are not equivalent. The B group has been studied in far greater depth, compared to say the menaquiniones (K2 group), and there simply does not exist the same level of research. Similarly K and D are groups too, and treating them like it's a single chemical with a specific effect is just plain wrong.

If you want to continue to argue please backup your claims with studies indicating K2 (any form) is equivalent to K1.

A study of 11000+ men by a German cancer research center found this:

"Our results suggest an inverse association between the intake of menaquinones, but not that of phylloquinone, and prostate cancer. Further studies of dietary vitamin K and prostate cancer are warranted." [3]

In other words K2 intake was correlated with reduced levels of prostate cancer, and K1 was not.

They are NOT the same thing and it's arrogant to dismiss this them as being functionally equivalent or assume one's body will perfectly convert between various forms as needed.

[1] http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/84/4/694.full

[2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21289249

[3] Dietary intake of vitamin K and risk of prostate cancer in the Heidelberg cohort of the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18400723

wamatt··on This Man Thinks He Never Has to Eat Again
>When in reality, the human GI evolved to support an extremely broad range of inputs as it's most significant factor.

While we can agree that innovation should not be stifled, the idea that we can determine the processes by which the body utilizes nutrients and their interdependent effects, after a few months of research, is utterly hubristic.

I often make the claim that the human body (other animals are close too) exhibits one of the highest levels of complexity out of all the known systems in the universe, far exceeding the complexity of man mad systems. I challenge anyone to put forward a counter-example...

I've been researching nutrition for 5 years and read hundreds of papers on PubMed and, involved with QS (quantified self) and life extension movements, track my bloodwork in Google Spreadsheets etc.

You may be wondering, why would someone invest such an extraordinary amount of time (1000+ man hours) an energy in this topic? Well I used to think very differently about my health. As a young strong-willed software developer, I arrogantly assumed like many before I knew it all in my teenage years. My mental model of the body, was not dissimilar to your current views on GI (the body will just handle whatever you throw at it). As a result after 10 years of eating badly I ended up with a chronic disease (Psoriatic Arthritis).

Being a teenager I knew better and ate anything I wanted, which specifically was an extreme diet consisting entirely of pasta, milk and coke. Because that's what my body "wanted". Now I'm in my 30's and undoing the damage, but I've learned that this system really is complicated, more so than a rocket or microprocessor. You're right in the sense that the body can tolerate it for a while, but it's not designed to cope with abuse over a period of many years. Eventually you will pay the price.

Even now though, I wouldn't consider myself an "expert", although some of my peers might. But I have learned enough know when someone is out of their depth. This guy is well intentioned but that does not mean he's justified in making such grandiose claims.

For example he says "Vitamin D" and "Vitamin K", without acknowledging various forms exist.

For example he says he takes "Vitamin D(400IU):"

What exactly is 'Vitamin D'? Cholecalciferol (D3) [1] is quite different from Ergocalciferol (D2)[2]

D3 levels are particularly important when talking about overall health.

Or take "Vitamin K" for example, are we talking about the philoquinone (K1) [3] or the menaquinone (K2) [4] group?

Even if then, if one is talking Vitamin K2, there are various menaquinones forms so is he suggesting Mk4, mk7 or some other form? [5].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cholecalciferol

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergocalciferol

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phylloquinone

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_k2

[5] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10084398

wamatt··on We'll Be Circling Back
So it's obviously satire, and I'm a huge PG/YC supporter, although consider this: PG (through the voice of another YC faithful) is in a way attacking the "dullard VC", lampooning them for being formulaic and unimaginative.

But, in a sense he too is using subtlety to obfuscate the real message and the reader is left to fill in the blanks. It's probably meant in good humor, but usually there is a little truth and sore feelings behind these sort of jests.

Now maybe the VC's are arrogant or whatever, although this does seem like tit-for-tat in my book.

I'll go out on a limb here and say I don't think YC-style is going to "take over" and obliterate the traditional VC model, nor do I believe traditional VC's should dismiss YC-style investing as chump-change or unimportant.

wamatt··on Einstein’s ‘spooky action at a distance’: 10,000 times faster than light
>Physicists would hardly be intimidated by being shown the algebra of Bayes's Theorem.

Well no they probably wouldn't, but my point wasn't about intimidation and not sure how it's relevant.

Personally I'm a huge fan of Bayes theory both theoretically and practically speaking, I'm using it in two side projects I'm currently working on. My only issue was a stylistic quibble with the author, and I will have to accept it if you frame it as humor. I'll grant I probably should have left it out in retrospect, since it deals with interpersonal subject matter.

>Regarding the rest of your comment, this is addressed in the second linked post.

No you haven't I was specifically referring to the second post.

I made two central claims, neither were responded to.[1]

1. Decoherence is not a thing on the macro scale.

2. Physicists do not take your claim that MWI is falsifiable seriously.

[1] http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

wamatt··on Einstein’s ‘spooky action at a distance’: 10,000 times faster than light
>MWI certainly does make falsifiable claims.

Would you mind stating an example of such a claim?

wamatt··on Einstein’s ‘spooky action at a distance’: 10,000 times faster than light
From your link: "This is Bayes's Theorem. I own at least two distinct items of clothing printed with this theorem, so it must be important." - Eliezer

cringe. "Here's a bunch of math so I must be really smart. Trust me guys." Math is awesome, but waving it around as if to automatically lends credibility to your argument is a poor showing IMHO.

Specifically, quantum decoherence is simply not accepted as a thing that exists on a macro scale. You're post presents no claim that is testable, despite the bold headline to the contrary.

Lets look at an example of a what physicists consider to be a falsifiable claim: The Standard Model predicts the existence of a new elementary particle, the Higgs Boson. This could be tested experimentally in theory, and later it was tested in practice, once the capability existed (LHC).

Or another example: orbital mechanics predicts the location of the asteroid Apophis will pass unusually close (<100 000KM) to earth in 2029.[1]

Now of course if Apophis fails to show up, or shows up overly late or in the wrong place etc, that doesn't necessarily invalidate the theory, but there does eventually need to be a credible explanation.

The simplest is usually measurement error, or silly human error etc. But every now and then, there are discrepancies that just don't go away, and those are often the ones that lead interesting new theories pushing science forward.

TBH I don't think your post does that.

The failing of physicists to take your above link seriously, does not epistemically speaking invalidate the claim of course, but it should be pause for concern.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/99942_Apophis

wamatt··on Einstein’s ‘spooky action at a distance’: 10,000 times faster than light
> Since the Many Worlds Interpretation is the simplest one, it is also the most likely one

The simplest defeasible claim in 2013, is still: "we don't know".

Consider, 'How does the sun come up every day?'

Answer A: God makes it happen.

Answer B: The earth is a spinning geoid that rotates eastwards, once about it's axis, roughly every 24 hours. However most of the effect is not related to the orbits of either the sun or earth, with respect to each other. The sun "rises" is more an observational effect of a stationary observer on the surface of the earth, having their field of view rotated.

(For the record, answer B can be improved of course, though that's not the point here)

"Simplicity" does not mean a catchall (Answer A). It also does not necessarily mean linguistic brevity either. There is debate around what it means and it's beyond the scope of my comment[1]. This is the problem with string theory, that also tends to be popular among the MWI crowd too. It's overly broad and the math looks pretty, but those are not sufficient conditions for a good scientific theory. (Oblig xkcd [1])

MWI, like string theory, makes little if any falsifiable and testable claims.

[1]http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicity/

[2]http://xkcd.com/171/

wamatt··on Ask HN: Webdevs, designers: what devtools should we (Mozilla) build in Firefox?
Neat. Out of interest, how does Tincr compare to LiveReload or CodeKit?
wamatt··on How I ended up with Mac
I've used Macs for 5+ years and can safely say "It just works" is pretty much BS.

At least the pain in respect of Finder can be almost totally mitigated by XtraFinder. [1] It's a truly useful addition to Finder.

Think cut&paste, tabs etc, without the slow bulk of CocoaTech's Path Finder. And it's free too! I mostly use the terminal, but nowadays I no longer dread having to fire up Finder when the situation arises.

[1]http://www.trankynam.com/xtrafinder/

wamatt··on Equity for code: Late Labs
Well I don't have any opinion at this stage. Also, I'm more on the strategic side of things these days, than career programming, so might be hard to give you a representative answer.

Was kinda hoping HN would pick it up so we could get some discussion going, as I think it's potentially an interesting/novel idea.

Does it have legs? No idea. Sorry. Heh.

wamatt··on Moshpits Simulation
>Does this qualify as science?

That's a surprisingly common, yet elusive and involved inquiry in the philosophy of science.

Rather, than attempting to reach consensus on what "Science" is, perhaps we should be interested in research that aims to follow the scientific method and related principles, irrespective of the subject matter?

← PreviousPage 6 of 16Next →