HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wcarey

494 karma · joined August 26, 2010

submissionscomments
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Alas for the lack of breakout rooms when hosting from an iPad.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
As I’ve said, tradeoffs. The raspis I’m talking about run about $100 for a complete system. Not nothing, but accessible to many people in Apple’s target demographic. They’re ideally suited for what you’re aiming at.

One example jumps to mind - wasn’t Facebook running a side loaded VPN that was doing some unsavory things until Apple banned it? I think the place to look for that sort of thing right now would be companies abusing the enterprise development system.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
My argument is that some harm does befall at least some consumers. You might judge that harm worth the other tradeoffs, but it’s not zero.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Perhaps it benefits Apple, but it also benefits me in ways I’m happy to pay for (and would be unable to pay for absent the collective bargaining).
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
I’ve been a part of a small group of users not offered that choice (essentially, install remote access on your personal device or terminate you employment), so I appreciate Apple negotiating for me.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Broadly gym subscriptions aren't handled through apps. I'm assuming that there will be a tragedy of the commons, something Apple has only been moderately effective at preventing, that will reduce the quality of terms-of-service for users.

I too used to create small apps and games and share them with my friends. I still do that on a headless raspberry pi, which is a vastly superior environment than the one I had access to as a child. As the economic value of data on computers rises, I think we'll see a split between the device you use to conduct modern digital life and the device you do "old fashioned" computer stuff on. For people inclined to tinker, there will be platforms that enable that. But you won't do your banking on that platform because, as you say, idiots will side load malware. I've certainly made that split in my life (and in my classroom where we use the raspi as a teaching computer and every student has root on their own box), and it works out really well.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
What it it's essential to the life of a relatively small group of users? It seems like the rights of smaller groups like that are the ones that most need collectively bargained, as they'll be in a relatively poor position to negotiate with the organization compelling them to use the app?
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
For some definition of "app business", sure. But there are plenty of companies making plenty of money in software without touching any app store. To be sure, Apple's popularity puts them in a really good negotiating position with respect to developers who want to sell certain kinds of software.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Would you support compelling developers who have a monopoly on a particular app to support all available app stores? It seems like a developer who held a monopoly in a particular app would be the in the same position Apple is in with the app store writ large?

For example, if the only way to fill out my employer's timecard is via an iOS app, should they be compelled to offer the app in all the available app stores?

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
I'd say that I'm less defending absolute monarchy, and more defending the rule of law against the Hobbesean state of nature, with all its caprice and cruelty.

For example, if Apple conducted plebiscites of its users and used those plebiscites in informing its collective bargaining with developers, I think that'd be fine. That would force Apple to articulate the value proposition of the positions it takes.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
In the same way, though, that you can suggest I work somewhere else, I can suggest that you run your app business on another platform, so that doesn't seem to advance the argument very much? Plenty of folks make a living on the web or by selling Windows or Linux software.

Having choice about some things is better than not having one, all around. But some people choose (!) to delegate their choosing to others in certain fields. For example, the choice of whether to purchase safe meat or unsafe meat is a bad choice to have. It's doubly bad if you aren't skilled at determining the safety quality of meat. That's a choice I'm happy to outsource to a third party. Similarly, I'm happy to outsource a variety of choices about app terms of use to Apple.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
That seems like a concession that people who currently enjoy the first-party-only app store situation may indeed lose something if third-party-app-stores become a thing.

You can argue (as I think you are) that those losses are outweighed by the gains of a more open ecosystem, but to many users they are meaningful losses.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Part of the reason I pay Apple for their devices is that they have offered to solve this problem for me. It's part of the value proposition of their device.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
The bargaining is between users and developers. Developers have increasingly taken adversarial positions with their users, who have accepted increasingly onerous terms and privacy policies because individual users are not in a good bargaining position. Apple, in contrast, is in a bargaining position to negotiate terms of use on behalf of its users with developers.

For example, if I purchase a subscription to a language learning app on an iOS device, my ability to seamlessly cancel that subscription has been collectively bargained by Apple (via the terms of service of their payment processing system). That's valuable to me, particularly given the absurd difficulty of canceling subscriptions that are not collectively bargained like gym memberships.

How would Apple impose that same term of use, that subscriptions can be cancelled on device with one click, for a sideloaded app? If they can't do that, developers would offer their app only via sideloading so as to be able to take advantage of that stream of revenue, like gyms. Now there's less competition for language learning apps in the first party app store, and I, a user of that store, suffer.

That's not to say there aren't tradeoffs for that collective bargaining; there are. As you say, we have much less control over iOS devices than we've historically had over our computing devices. Similarly, workers who collectively bargain have much less control over their terms of employment than workers who individually negotiate. But for many workers (and many users), that tradeoff is a good one. Apple is currently the only organization offering it.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
It seems like there are two assumptions underlying your argument:

1. Users have perfect choice in which apps they install.

2. Developers will release their apps on all available app stores.

But many users are compelled to install apps that they would prefer not to and it's not at all obvious that developers would support two app stores instead of one given the choice. The net result of that combination is that some (many?) people would be compelled to use both app stores against their inclination.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
That wasn't a comparison. If 3rd party app stores are a thing, you might be compelled to use them by yet other third parties, contrary to your claim that no one would force you to use third party app stores.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
> Nobody is forcing you to use a 3rd party app store, but Apple is forcing everyone to go through their store.

Many employers do that very thing. How many people have been compelled by employment circumstances to install Zoom despite its dubious pedigree? What happens when a corporate timecard app exists only in a 3rd party app store?

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
I wonder whether people's opinions about Apple's behavior here are isomorphic to their opinions about collective bargaining writ large?

If you're the sort of person who releases iOS apps, you're far more technically inclined than the median user and perhaps more willing to engage in individual negotiation of terms of service and privacy (as you'll be plausibly good at it). The median user of an iPhone is in a hopeless bargaining position in the face of dark patterns, and for that user, perhaps the collective bargaining Apple engages in is more valuable.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Delegating that control is, in effect, a form of collective bargaining. Whereas Epic could convince individual users to accept whatever terms of use they wanted to impose, effectively Apple collectively bargains for all those users. That means that, if you like the way Apple negotiates and are comfortable with the trade offs they make, you have much more leverage than if you were negotiating as an individual.
wcarey··on GCD and the magic of subtraction
If you enjoy thinking about that, book VII of Euclid would be right up your alley: https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookVII/book...

The algorithm you describe is VII Proposition 1.

wcarey··on Satellite warfare: An arms race is brewing in orbit
Ruggedization is a vast understatement given the energies involved. On top of that, your payload needs to be able to circularize from a negative perigee, so it would need lots of onboard delta-v. You’d also either have an aimable cannon or deal with expensive plane change maneuvers.
wcarey··on Veteran submariner on how sonar crews tirelessly hunt enemies they can't see
I think there's a new paperback printing under way. Happily, it's not the end of the world acquiring them piecemeal, as each volume tells a coherent story and takes some time to read through!
wcarey··on Veteran submariner on how sonar crews tirelessly hunt enemies they can't see
And Greyhound depicts a relatively calm series of engagements, compared to what actually happened. Consider the U.S.S. Borie:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Borie_(DD-215)

which rammed (!) a U-Boat in high seas, was repeatedly picked up by waves and dropped on top of the surfaced U-boat, whereupon a small arms engagement broke out (!) until the U-boat attempted to disengage and was damaged by the Borie's main guns. Both ships sinking, the Borie attempted to rescue the German submariners until a torpedo from another nearby submarine caused them to reconsider. The Borie then promptly sank from seams opened by being repeatedly bounced off the top of a submarine and most of the crew were rescued.

wcarey··on Veteran submariner on how sonar crews tirelessly hunt enemies they can't see
If you enjoy The Good Shepherd, The Ship is a similar book about surface combat in the Med.
wcarey··on Veteran submariner on how sonar crews tirelessly hunt enemies they can't see
It's surprisingly readable. Good history is storytelling, and Morison was there for much of the history he relates. You could get a great picture of the variety of modern naval warfare by picking up the volumes on Midway and the Struggle for Guadalcanal.

C.S. Forester's novels, while historical fiction, are also excellent.

I'd also recommend Japanese Destroyer Captain by Tameichi Hara, another powerful first hand account. Reading Hara and Morison's accounts of a battle in which both participated is really interesting.

wcarey··on Veteran submariner on how sonar crews tirelessly hunt enemies they can't see
The book by C.S. Forester that the movie is based on is even more realistic, though the movie is pretty good.

To really dig into it, Samuel Eliot Morison's magisterial History of Naval Operations in World War II does a good job talking through the development of both the technology and organization of naval operations.

Not all communication was by morse code. We did use ship to ship voice radio, but it was a tradeoff. RDF allowed the enemy to triangular the position of the broadcasting ship, and (often) the enemy could overhear messages and infer some tactical details.

Sensor systems changed wildly throughout the war. Sonar improved markedly, and radar went from non-existent to able to identify altitude and distance to individual planes. The weight of the additional sensor systems and controls systems made some ships unstable, so we removed weapon systems from them.

Being a captain (or, heaven forbid) and admiral, was very demanding. Sleep was hard to come by, and the fog of war was intense. We had meaningful problems with friendly fire in night engagements even with radar and radio communications.

wcarey··on Montreal is taxing churches (2017)
There are an enormous number of (small) churches that don't function as business entities in the way you describe. Taxing churches would adversely select against these, encouraging all churches to behave more like businesses. It's unlikely to me that that's the outcome that anyone wants.

If you think Christianity is broadly good and correct, the trend towards business-like megachurches and celebrity pastors is deeply corrosive to the faith.

If you think Christianity is broadly bad and corrupt, the trend towards business-like megachurches and celebrity pastors entrenches and effectively promulgates many of the religious ideas that you abhor.

wcarey··on The Four Quadrants of Conformism
Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France is a great read. I wonder which quadrant Graham would put Burke in?
wcarey··on Candy Land was invented for polio wards (2019)
I think the term is a zero player game, where the initial configuration of the game determines the outcome. The card game War is another one. They’re good for teaching the mechanics of game playing without requiring the cognitive burden of strategic choice.
wcarey··on Bible API
Which critical edition do you prefer?
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →