HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

woah

11,504 karma · joined July 6, 2012

submissionscomments
woah··on Promising results from DeepSeek R1 for code
Seems like the exact opposite. The very example you are replying to is the mechanistic translation of one low level language to another, maybe one of the most boring tasks imaginable.
woah··on Promising results from DeepSeek R1 for code
LLMs excel at tasks with very clear instructions and parameters. Porting from one language to another is something that is one step away from being done by a compiler. Another place that I've used them is for initial scaffolding of React components.
woah··on Black Swan's Taleb Says Nvidia Rout Is Hint of What's Coming
In your opinion, what "money" is not "funny"? Land? Gold?
woah··on Black Swan's Taleb Says Nvidia Rout Is Hint of What's Coming
Or move the whole outfit to the US and get access to plentiful chips and electricity... unfortunately I think the CCP might have something to say about that
woah··on Nvidia’s $589B DeepSeek rout
It could have been great for IBM if they had done things differently
woah··on YC Graveyard: 821 inactive Y Combinator startups
> Very low cash flow only with no growth

This is very typical in startups, where making revenue at all may be rare in many categories (social media for example), and a startup is either wildly successful or nobody uses it.

Hopefully, the startup is about to be wildly successful, but it's easy to end up in a situation where some funding was raised, the product has reached a dead end, but the founders continue to "try to make it work". Whether they are doing this to "draw a salary", are earnestly trying to make it work, or a little bit of both, there isn't much legal recourse for investors if they aren't doing anything worse than not being very successful.

woah··on Is the world becoming uninsurable?
The reality is the fires didn't make it far into the city grid sections of LA proper. This is because these areas have less flammable material, and are more defensible.
woah··on Is the world becoming uninsurable?
Public insurance would provide no benefit. The issue in California is that people have built their houses in dangerous areas and have not taken any measures to reduce fire risk. The state has already set limits to how much insurance costs can be increased (from a past generation of economic illiterates who wanted to stop "middlemen siphoning value"). Therefore, insurance companies are just pulling out, which disproves the entire idea that they are "siphoning value", since obviously there is no value there to siphon.

The only thing that public insurance would do is to provide a way for the state to incur another massive unfunded liability. Except, unlike healthcare or pensions which have the somewhat laudable goal of taking care of poor people and old people, this would go to bailing out rich homeowners who made a bad investment of a house in a flammable area and then refused to spend money on fire safety measures, either in their home or their municipality.

Of course these fire zone bag holders are now clamoring for the state to take on their bad investments by pushing conspiracy theories about the evil insurance companies.

woah··on I've acquired a new superpower
Do people not know about this?
woah··on Intel Inside, Gelsinger Outside
I think it looks cool
woah··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
> You forgot the Irak war and Afghanistan and the fake WMDs. It's funny how people are quick to point that Russia is the aggressor but when the US was invading countries, few people opposed them.

Pretty facetious comparison. Iraq and Afghanistan were on the whole a mistake, but completely different from Ukraine. There was never any idea that the US would take the territory. It was just a huge waste of money for the US.

The very best case scenario for the US (which everyone realized was never going to happen within 2 years) was something like Japan and South Korea, setting up US-friendly democratic governments and corporations. There was absolutely no element of expansionism. Ask the Japanese and the South Koreans whether they are mad about being oppressed under the thumb of "US imperialism".

Contrast this with Russia's actions in Ukraine. They are taking over economically and militarily valuable lands, directly expanding their borders, expelling or re-educating Ukrainians who won't pretend to be Russian, and nakedly pursuing the revanchist fantasy of reclaiming lands that were ruled brutally by a totalitarian Muscovite empire for hundreds of years.

Conflating the two situations betrays an extremely shallow understanding of current events and a complete ignorance of history.

woah··on Gitlab names Bill Staples as new CEO
What needs to be done to prepare it for sale?
woah··on Forced to upgrade
I also suspect that (at least on HN), the loud minority are heavy users of laptops and desktops. For the average person who has an old laptop for writing reports for school, or a crappy locked down laptop from their job, the phone is their main computing interface, so they want it to be bigger and nicer.
woah··on Engineers do not get to make startup mistakes when they build ledgers
The original meaning of engineer was an idle British aristocrat who liked to tinker with things that went whiz and bang in the garden shed. Just a guy who really liked to mess around with engines.
woah··on Starlink Direct to Cell
A temporarily embarrassed Elon Musk
woah··on 3 years ago, VCs in Bay Area tech were thriving. Now, they're 'bleeding cash.'
The majority of 2010 startups were kids with no business experience banging out basic CRMs and marketplaces on Ruby. See for yourself: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies?batch=W10

Compare that to one of this year's YC batches, which IMO sounds much more sci-fi and interesting: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies?batch=W24

It seems like it's popular today to try to adopt a very salty and jaded attitude about everything with the idea that it's "calling BS" or bringing some kind of subversive viewpoint. In fact, nothing is more common, and it brings very little to the discussion.

woah··on Oasis: A Universe in a Transformer
The point of this paper is to demonstrate a method of training an AI to output interactive game footage. They could have trained it for similar results with DOOM videos. Presumably the footage they trained on was OK to train on (I don't think a video of someone playing a video game is copyrighted by the video game's author), but they could have used a variety of other games.
woah··on GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
A developer will spend far more time in the IDE than the version control system so I wouldn't discount it that easily. That being said, there are no network effects for an IDE and Cursor is basically just a VSCode plugin. Maybe Cursor gets a nice acquihire deal
woah··on Boeing 787s must be reset every 51 days or 'misleading data' is shown (2020)
With that framing, this sounds like one of the easiest maintenance tasks imaginable. No wrenches or grease involved.
woah··on Boeing 787s must be reset every 51 days or 'misleading data' is shown (2020)
If something goes wrong, does it matter whether you are asleep or awake?
woah··on Adobe's new image rotation tool is one of the most impressive AI tools seen
Even if the open source option is only slightly worse, why would a professional allow that to impact how they earn a living?
woah··on Bike Manufacturers Are Making Bikes Less Repairable
AAs aren't user repairable either. When was the last time you repaired an AA? What the article is asking for is just a standardized connector and voltage for Li-ion batteries.
woah··on Cisco is abandoning the LoRaWAN space, and there's no lifeboat for IoT customers
Don't companies with large deployments build in some kind of support deal with their supplier?
woah··on Response to WP Engine’s Meritless Lawsuit
# A Statement from Automattic

Last night, WP Engine filed a baseless lawsuit against Automattic and Matt Mullenweg. Their complaint is flawed, start to finish. We vehemently deny WP Engine’s allegations—which are gross mischaracterizations of reality—and reserve all of our rights. Automattic is confident in our legal position, and will vigorously litigate against this absurd filing, as well as pursue all remedies against WP Engine. Automattic has retained Neal Katyal, former Acting Solicitor General of the United States, and his firm Hogan Lovells, LLP, to represent us. Mr. Katyal stated, “I stayed up last night reading WP Engine’s Complaint, trying to find any merit anywhere to it. The whole thing is meritless, and we look forward to the federal court’s consideration of their lawsuit.”

Our focus is and has always been protecting the integrity of WordPress and our mission to democratize publishing. From our earliest days, our highest priority has always been our customers. WP Engine can hardly say the same.

woah··on Were RNNs all we needed?
For paper titles, the law is that the answer is always "yes"
woah··on Gavin Newsom vetoes SB 1047
> The immediate danger of large AI models isn't that they'll turn the earth to paperclips it's that we'll create fraud as a service and have a society where nothing can be trusted. I'd be all for a law (however clumsy) that made image, audio or video content produced by models with over X parameters to be marked with metadata saying it's AI generated.

Just make a law that makes it so that AI content has to be tagged if it is being used for fraud

woah··on Binance founder 'CZ' leaves prison on Friday
There's nothing wrong with PoS as long as it is understood as a mechanism for diffusion of power and trust, like a multisig or a corporation. Probably PoS protocols do not need to have in-protocol slashing. Solana has already thought of this and does not have slashing IIRC.

It just shouldn't try to pretend to be a trustless protocol like PoW. Some of the smarter PoS researchers are already catching on to this: https://dba.mirror.xyz/UTPfxWe65dYrUu_RJX-5VkAJypFRyw3AZh6m0...

PoW has its own problems. It is likely to be unstable for various reasons in the absence of inflation. I don't have time to find all the citations but there have been many papers about this subject. It's also not great for the environment, and there is something unfortunate about the fact that the best trustless protocol we can come up with as a species requires massive waste. Maybe it is currently the best we have but trying to come up with reasons that the waste is actually OK is a waste of time IMO.

woah··on Binance founder 'CZ' leaves prison on Friday
Proof of stake is no different than most traditional governance structures such as corporations in that it relies on a committee with an honest majority to keep the system secure. Validators are supposed to act like some kind of completely neutral, decentralized system, but they are not.

For example, the fundamental principle of PoS is slashing for equivocation: when validators present two alternate versions of history (this could be part of a "double spend" attack), they are supposed to be slashed and have their stake taken away.

It takes 1/3 of validators to successfully pass off two versions of history to a double spend victim. However, 1/3 of validators can censor this slashing transaction. So if a double spend attack happens, the perpetrators of the attack are in charge of punishing themselves.

So, the fundamental security mechanism of PoS, equivocation slashing, can in fact never work in practice to punish an actual attack!

Another example is the idea that participation in a PoS chain is permissionless. This is the case in PoW. However, in PoS, 1/3 of the existing validator set could censor any new validators that would like to join, maintaining complete control of the chain. The existing validators only act as if the system is permissionless.

There has been a large amount of thought put into this paradox, and the PoS research community has settled on the idea that if the validator set breaks these norms, then users can just use a new chain with the same state, and a new, more trustworthy validator set. This has several problems:

- Philosophically, what is the point of creating a system that obviously doesn't work as intended, and then when this is pointed out saying "that's not a problem because users don't have to use the system"?

- The coordination of this hypothetical switch to a better validator set is completely unexplored since it is totally outside of the PoS protocol. It may be very disruptive to users and result in downtime, loss of funds sent during the switchover period, multiple new blockchains, or other issues and confusion.

- The fact that the system does not work, and there must always be the possibility of human operators sorting things out based on an undefined recovery procedure means that truly autonomous and truly secure clients are not possible in PoS. This is a problem for both far-out concepts like self-owned self-driving cars, and for bridges between blockchains, which must always rely on either trusting the validators, or a multisig made of trusted people who can stop or reconfigure the bridge.

In fact, there is no clear dividing line between a PoS blockchain, a PoA blockchain (this has a predefined validator set), a multisig, and a single entity running a chain. The only differences between these models are a matter degree of diffusion of authority.

This is what Bitcoin people do not like about PoS. PoW has its own problems, but they are different, and PoW chains do not rely on a set of trusted operators in the same way.

woah··on I Am Tired of AI
This is spoken by someone who doesn't know about the huge volume of mediocre work output by art students and hobbyists. Much of it is technically decent (like AI work), but lacking in meaning, impact, and emotional resonance (like AI work). You could find millions of hand drawn portraits of Keauna Reeves on Reddit before AI ever existed.
woah··on I Am Tired of AI
I think there are two types of developers: those who are most excited about building things, and those who are most excited about the craft of programming.

If I can build things faster, then I'm happy to spend most of my time reviewing AI code. That doesn't mean that I never write code. Some things the AI is worse at, or need to be exactly write and its faster to do them manually.

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →