HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

woodandsteel

1,921 karma · joined January 8, 2016

submissionscomments
woodandsteel··on The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have our expectations?
If we let the virus run wild then over a million Americans would die from it. And the hospitals would be vastly overwhelmed, so many more people who need hospitalization from other causes would die. And many millions would suffer severe diseases, like for weeks, and with many of them there would be strong aftereffects lasting for months.

In the countries that have had a strong lockdown and other measures, within a few months they had the disease halted and beaten back, and could go back to mostly normal. I think that is vastly better.

woodandsteel··on The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have our expectations?
It doesn't matter if some other things are more important. If it is helpful, then it should be included in policies. Do you agree?

And this matters because in the US and an a number of other countries, a large proportion of people refuse to wear face masks, and the government doesn't mandate them, and that is bad. And the people who refuse to wear face masks usually also refuse to follow some or all of the other measures. We are talking about a whole bundle of measures here.

woodandsteel··on The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have our expectations?
No, I am not going to give you a reference. If you have been paying attention to the story, you have seen a hundred stories about the various nations and their policies.

I think you are playing dumb.

Also I explained your description of the policies in California was a gross misrepresentation. Will you agree you got it wrong?

And let me ask you yet again, what policies are you for? That's why this whole argument matters.

woodandsteel··on The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have our expectations?
This article has some interesting points, but overall it is click-bait.

The recommendation at the end is, “We don’t know how well cloth masks work, so distancing should come first, but masks are likely to work to some extent and not everyone can distance themselves.” But for most of the article it talks as if the whole matter is so uncertain no recommendation can be made.

Anyway, the whole idea that we should wait until the science is all settled before we make policy decisions is quite impractical. We are learning as we are fighting the epidemic, and so we have to make decisions before we have full evidence. Indeed, the only way we can learn if masks work to help stop the epidemic is to have some countries mandate them and compare the results with countries that don't. Epidemics are very different than individual diseases. You have to make decisions at the group level, and when it is a new disease you have to do so without really good understanding.

And we know that the countries that have pursued a whole set of rigorous policies that includes face masks have been successful, while countries that are lax, include face masks, have failed. So the smart thing to do is pursue the set of policies that includes face masks, and later on find analyse the data and find out exactly how important they are.

woodandsteel··on The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have our expectations?
I live in California, and the mask rules at the state level were not dictated, only recommended, and in most locations where they were law they were not rigorously enforced. And then Gov Newsome relaxed social distancing, and the infection rate shot up.

But tell me, what do you think the policies should be, for masks and everything else?

woodandsteel··on The neoliberal era is ending. What comes next?
During the housing price bubble 2001-2007, the economics profession on the whole, lead by University of Chicago economists (which is where Friedman taught) told us everything was fine, due to efficient market theory.
woodandsteel··on Tesla becomes most valuable automaker in latest stock rally
The valuation makes sense. In the coming years the auto market is going to be moving rapidly to ev's and away from ice's. Demand for ev's is going to outrun supply, in part due to battery shortages.

Tesla is expanding rapidly and is going to be in a better position than any other car maker to take advantage of the situation, though lately VW has also getting very serious about ev's.

woodandsteel··on 'The miracle is over': UCSF doctor on what went wrong in California
No, testing shows none of the countries are anywhere near herd immunity. They beat the disease back with the standard program of testing, contact tracing, quarantine, social isolation, masks, and so on.

The standard program works, and when a region or country doesn't follow it, sooner or later the disease runs wild. If we let that happen in the US, over a million would be dead before the disease was done.

Oh, and I bet you think Trump has been correct for months when he says over and over again there is no shortage of tests. But actually we need twice as many as at present for holding steady, and 8 times as many to beat the disease back.

woodandsteel··on Hong Kong security law: Life sentences for breaking China-imposed law
The Chinese government tells us it is supported by 99.9 % of its citizens, but it acts like it is scared to death the population is on the verge of revolting.
woodandsteel··on A new theory about political polarization
The problem is that when parties are highly polarized, politicians who want to be the sort of leaders you are talking about can't get into leadership positions and often are voted out at the primary election stage.
woodandsteel··on Scandinavian Monitoring Stations Detect Unexplained Radiation Spike over Europe
WMD's are wonderful for keeping other countries from attacking (but who wants to invade Russia?), but of little use for offensive purposes.
woodandsteel··on A new theory about political polarization
The problem is that voters often disagree greatly, and the only positive way forward is a compromise, but strong partisan and ideological polarization makes that impossible.
woodandsteel··on A new theory about political polarization
A very good comment. I would add that the parties used to be more moderate in part because the Democrats included both Northern liberals and Southern racists, and the Republicans included many Northern liberals. But when the civil rights laws were passed by the Democrats back in 1964 and 5, Southern white racists started a slow process of migrating to the Republicans and the Northern liberals to the Democrats.

Also, changes in the primary system lead to party leaders, who tended to nominate moderates who could win a broad range in the middle, losing power, and the nominating process being taking over by people on both extremes who tend to vote more in primaries than the general public does.

woodandsteel··on A visual chronicle of Tokyo’s disappearing jazz bars (2016)
Casiopea is totally wonderful. I learned about them when I got onto the young drummer Kanade Sato. Here she is backing up Mukaiya at a very young age on a wonderful Casiopea song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C3Nml8IBf0

And here she is at a much later age covering Megalith by T-Square https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-BvHJr5OjE

woodandsteel··on The Worst Jazz Solo of All Time
World's best 1 3/4 year old drummer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FzBfjjO34U

woodandsteel··on Ask HN: What is Hacker News's business model?
>The biggest benefit is market manipulation and collusion.

Your claim would be more persuasive if you gave us a few specific examples.

woodandsteel··on Almost 1 in 3 pilots in Pakistan have fake licenses, aviation minister says
Oh dear, you are making the argument that if it is very bad to be wrong in one irrational way, that makes it just fine to be wrong in another irrational way. Wouldn't it be better to be just, you know, right?
woodandsteel··on Why Birds Can Fly over Mount Everest
So you're saying when the Manhattan Project scientists thought the atomic bomb might set the whole atmosphere on fire, they were mistaken.
woodandsteel··on Why Is There Something Instead of Nothing? (2015)
We are trying to answer this question with our minds, so how we think about the question and if it can be answered will depend on how we think about our minds.

If you take the scientific position that are mental processes are the produce of material brains produced through natural forces, you will believe our thinking is limited in power, like anything material. And that being the case, at some point the mind will run into questions it cannot answer, and the question of why there is something rather than nothing would seem to be that sort of question. And if you think of the problem that way then you will just accept the mystery and go on to thinking about matters where your mind might make some useful progress.

If you think our minds are the product of a God that understands everything, but made human minds limited, then you will also accept the mystery.

On the other hand, if you hold, as in Platonism or Hindu mysticism, that the mind is non-material and one with the Infinite, then you will likely believe that humans who grow spiritually enough can at some point come to understand why reality exists.

I think the waitbutwhy guy is philosophically in the first position but hasn't thought it out logically yet.

woodandsteel··on Construction begins on world’s biggest liquid air battery
Making the tanks strong enough to handle the pressure if the liquid turns to gas is very expensive. It is much cheaper to make a tank that just holds a liquid.
woodandsteel··on Construction begins on world’s biggest liquid air battery
This plant is not using compressed air, it's using liquified air.
woodandsteel··on Almost 1 in 3 pilots in Pakistan have fake licenses, aviation minister says
Except if you have a spy in the group that transport the bombs, they just tip off some people with guns to grab it. And given the number of Islamist extremists in Pakistan and how much they would love to have a bomb, it seems rather likely that sooner or later they would get a spy installed.
woodandsteel··on Almost 1 in 3 pilots in Pakistan have fake licenses, aviation minister says
>This is common in all government run systems

No, that is not at all true. There are lots of government run systems, like the health care systems in most developed countries, that are just fine. The problem with Pakistan is it has a highly corrupt culture in general and in government in particular. That is no doubt why so many of the airline pilots were able to get hired without a legal licence.

Your general claim and the fact that you bring up Hillary Clinton as an example makes me think that you believe in the crackpot libertarian view that modern societies would be vastly better if we basically got rid of the government except for a few, narrow areas.

woodandsteel··on In Han Dynasty China, Bisexuality Was the Norm
I disagree. Think of how the gay movement took the word "queer" and turned it from an insult to something neutral or even positive. The way to change peoples minds is to change the meanings of words. In particular, take the most common words and change their connotations, rather than inventing awkward new expressions that very few people will adopt.
woodandsteel··on Tesla leak shows Model 3 with 100 kWh battery would have over 400-mile range
Well it depends. For people who don't have a way to charge up slowly, like at home or at work, fast charging is crucial. But for those who do have a slow option and rarely go long distances, fast charging is a low priority.

But beyond that, Tesla and everyone else is making steady progress with fast charging, so it is no real block to ev's replacing ice's.

woodandsteel··on Latency of Starlink v2 could be as low as 8ms
"Because the FCC doesn't care"

Not at all true. The head of the FCC, Ajit Pai, is very much in the pocket of the telecom industry.

woodandsteel··on Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Electric Vehicle
The larger importance of this is that for a lot of potential ev purchasers, 400 miles is the lower limit of what they consider acceptable range. Yes, I know that is rather arbitrary and irrational, but that's how it is.

400 mile range is also important for political debates about the practicality of ev's and whether or not governments should be promoting them.

woodandsteel··on In Han Dynasty China, Bisexuality Was the Norm
"Propensities toward attraction were recognized, but it never formed a core part of personal identity"

Like many words, "gay" "straight" "bisexual" and so on have more than one meaning. One of those meanings is the idea that who one is attracted to is the core of one's identity. Another common meaning is that it is simply descriptive of attraction, and says little about the rest of one's personality.

woodandsteel··on Engineers find neat way to turn waste carbon dioxide into useful material
Synfuels are very important for saving the climate. Yes, we need to eventually move all transportation to batteries, and we now have the technology to do that with cars and increasingly with trucking.

But for ocean ships and long-range airplanes we are nowhere near ready for that. And hydrogen fuel cells are not nearly good enough. So at least for many years the only way to make some important forms of transportation carbon-neutral will be synfuels

woodandsteel··on Fox News Digitally Alters Images of Seattle’s Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone
I agree. They wanted to fool people into thinking the situation is worse than it really is, so they faked a photograph.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →