HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wynand

467 karma · joined June 23, 2008

I have locked myself out of my account permanently as I spend too much time on HN. I wish I had more self-control.
submissionscomments
wynand··on Using CouchDB to improve healthcare in Africa
Your software will time out long before a packet arrives. You could make your (custom) software never timeout, but your software is likely to become unusable due to pauses whose durations are unknown - what if it takes 5 minutes for a small operation to complete?
wynand··on Benoit Mandelbrot, RIP
"accomplished far, far more than you or I ever will"

This is a common snowclone (X is <far superior in some dimension - often intelligence> than you or I) that really bothers me. It's a kind of hero worship that attributes too much to the hero in question and makes unfounded assertions about "you or I".

I can understand that people become enthuisiastic about their heroes and that exaggeration is even a form of showing respect. But too much is no good for anyone.

wynand··on HN London meetup tonight (New Venue)
Arg. I'm only landing at Gatwick at 20:15.

I can't imagine that I'd be able to get there until around 22:00. I don't suppose that anyone will still be around then?

wynand··on How to kill a company's morale in one easy memo
Wow, I wish I knew which tech companies you are talking about. The world I know is one where people work all the time, are lucky to have half decent computers on which to work and definitely never get any of those cushy benefits.

Thing is, people in aerospace in the 50's to 70's had a mission and they worked on cool things. If you're working for a typical software company you have neither (unless you consider refactoring that enterprise app as a mission),

High ranking people love this kind of moralism, because it feels like they're really doing something. But the proof is in the pudding and guilt-tripping people about having reasonable working spaces is not going to make people do good work.

This CEO is lazy. Building a good working culture is mundane and takes a long time with constant little tweaks. But nothing beats the rush of thinking you've ruffled some feathers.

It's the equivalent of parents doling out corporal punishment to kids: it really seems to work, but at best does nothing over a long period and at worst creates distrust and fear. Real parenting takes effort, as does real management.

wynand··on Mossberg: New iPhone Keeps Apple Top of Class
(I don't mean this comment to criticize you in particular kylec)

I can understand that some on HN have an Apple preference but Apple almost gets free advertising by the way some talk over here.

Why vote up a comment because someone says they're going Apple?

wynand··on Better performance in App Engine with new Lisp language Clojure
Posts like this really make me want to move to Clojure.

Python is now my go-to language, especially because of Scipy, NetworkX and bridges like RPy.

I would definitely put in the time if someone with mathematical modelling experience can support the idea that I'll be more productive in Clojure. Anyone?

I really would love to see a list of testimonials and anti-testimonials of people from various fields that switched to Clojure and either got much more done or got burned.

Sorry, I realise that this is a wee bit off the main topic.

wynand··on What has Apple got against Eastern Europe?
> My guess is it's the 80/20 rule applied to customers and Apple likes profit margins much more than just revenues.

Speculating is one thing...

> Also, it's stereotypical that third world folks abuse store return policies and customer support in general.

...but it's inexcusable when it leads to unsubstantiated claims that tar so many people with the same brush.

Also it's a massive stretch to call any but a very small handful of Eastern European countries "3rd world". (I need not defend Eastern Europe, since I'm South African myself, but it's plain as day that a lot of Eastern Europe is not doing too badly).

wynand··on Blame It on Mr. Rogers: Why Young Adults Feel So Entitled
Black kettles and pots come to mind.

While I cannot be sure that Jeffrey Zaslow is a Boomer or Gen Xer (the fuzzy dates around those eras makes it difficult to decide), this accusation of entitlement seems to be a Boomer message.

We're talking about a generation that, although its members had much less material amenities than us, they had an easier time getting ahead. Try buying a house as a young person now. When my dad was my age, he could support a family on his salary.

And given that the Boomers (and early Gen Xers) have just wrecked the world economy, I think there's more than a little hypocrisy here.

If the later Gen Xers and Gen Yers have a sense of entitlement, it's because they do as their elders do.

wynand··on [dead]
Research wouldn't be necessary if we knew beforehand what we needed to look for. Granted, it doesn't help to glue things together indiscriminately, but I doubt that is that OpenCog is doing.

Someone has to try this and if their idea doesn't work, I will bet good money that they'll stumble upon other interesting results (if they keep going).

wynand··on Barbie Computer Engineer
Nothing would do more for women in engineering than having more well known female engineers. Social proof is a strong thing.

But until we have more of that, cultural items like Barbie might help to bootstrap the process.

I agree that it's a distant second, but it's better than nothing at all.

wynand··on Do you really want to be rich?
I got really angry when I first read this blog post (see my other comment here) and I was thrilled that most people here are as annoyed.

I read maxklein's other story (about how programming is procrastination).

I'm going to give him the benefit of doubt now. To be blunt, he needs to work on how he communicates.

But, I think the gist of what he's trying to say is: there are certain things you need to do if you want to succeed well in business. You have to want to do business (the making money part), but that includes things far beyond programming (for example).

I think I see what he means about working with people who want to make money: they have to be in it for the long haul. But even people who would lose interest when they're rich have a long way to go while they're still (relatively speaking) poor.

You don't want to discount the Woz's of the world just because their hearts are in the tech. If you do, you lose.

wynand··on Do you really want to be rich?
That's an interesting take. At least in the case of Buffett, I think he really likes what he does (I mean, the man still lives in a normal family house).

To me there is a distinction between people who want to make more money and people who want to build things. The former is in it for power, whilst the latter is in it for recognition.

I realize how simplistic that sounds. But many of our current problems came about because people don't care about what's behind the money. We need less indirection in the financial world. If I invest in something, I should give some kind of damn about it.

wynand··on Do you really want to be rich?
Exactly. Group 2+ is also the most valuable to the world in the long run, if only because people's mental health will be much better.

I also wouldn't be surprised if the members of Group 2+ generally hate the control that the typical manager exerts.

wynand··on The Mighty Awesome Power of Scala
I'm no Ruby fanboy (I once wrote a little GUI app in what was probably horribly unidiomatic Ruby). I think that he gave terrible reasons for not using Ruby (fanboyism & not enough code?). Plus he's on the JVM, so JRuby gives you access to tons of code.

If you want to use language X, then use it - there's no need to justify your choice by slating language Y.

wynand··on Why writing software is not like engineering
A while ago I had an argument with a chemical engineer about exactly this. He claimed that software engineering is an immature field and that we will eventually learn how to apply engineering principles to get more reliable programs.

When I countered that you mostly don't even know what you're modelling and that the design state space is much larger in software, he retorted that all sorts of things can go wrong with just a single pipe in a chemical plant but that it doesn't stop reliable plants from being built.

But he didn't get it: that pipe is a component in a well understood framework. It's nothing like the unexpected things you get in software. The software equivalent is that of a buggy component whose specification is well understood - if you rewrite the component, you'll get what you expect. In software, proper specification is the rub.

I have worked with many electrical and electronic engineers (I studied CS) and not one of those engineers was on average better at writing reliable software. They did try hard to specify their systems in advance, but the actual systems soon started diverging from their specifications.

I grant that the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, but it is equally wrong to keep maintaining in full faith (and without convincing evidence) that software development is an engineering discipline.

I have never seen anyone argue convincingly for nor against the engineering approach in software. If anyone has done a study on this, I would love to read it.

wynand··on Responding to jacquesm's challenge
What did you use to compute P(D|Ci)?

This uses your notation from the Dr Dobbs article, so that Ci (a category) is a user and D is a document (a comment?).

Did you use something like trigram signatures?

Also, is P(Ci) equal to #comments made by Ci/total number of users?

Interesting stuff jgrahamc!

wynand··on Project Manager's View vs. Developer's View
The project manager's view includes both the business side and personal fears/biases. And as people are wont to do, a PM will disguise personal doubts as business decisions.

What is also never mentioned is that what employees desire is as much the business of a business as other things.

But suppose we buy 100% into the maximizing shareholder mantra.

If you have programmers that are interested in these technologies, your shop is probably doing some interesting work (since otherwise these programmers would not have bothered working at your shop). In this case, careful leveraging of new technology (that is, choosing something that's not too far right on the curve for your purposes) can give you a leg up on the competition, since the programmers are happier and you can offer things that the competition cannot.

A manager that avoids new technologies in this context is not doing what is good for business.

It is a false dichotomy that what is good for programmers is necessarily unrealistic or bad for business.

wynand··on Top Things That Annoy Programmers
Being thought of as a "subordinate" (I mention this, because he talks about programmers as being subordinates).

Am I the only person on earth that rails against this? I trade my time for money, but I am no-one's "subordinate". To me, a manager is someone who makes sure I can get my work done and checks on the overall progress.

I guess I'm asking for a mighty downvoting but I really want to know if others think its okay and why its okay to be a subordinate (especially when the superordinates are so often less than impressive human beings).

wynand··on Gorbachev: Perestroika Lost
Could you elaborate on that? I think a lot of people here probably don't share your reservations and it would help to say what they are.
wynand··on Ask HN: Is functional programming really worth it?
I'm a functional convert but my colleagues will tell you just how convoluted some of my code has been due my trying to shoehorn everything into a functional mold.

Many in the functional world realize that some things are akward (see Peyton-Jones's talk "Wearing the hair shirt" about Haskell).

To answer the question about loops with recursion: you seldom write recursive functions when programming functionally but instead cast things into maps, filters and reduces. Thus it's not such a big problem (and the cool thing about using map & family is that you can replace them with parallel versions quite easily). With that said, some practical functional languages provide sugar to write seemingly imperative loops.

In terms of libraries, at least Scala, Clojure, F#, CAL, Nemerle (amongst others) ingrate well with either the JVM and/or the .Net platform. You can implement Erlang nodes in any JVM language (which I grant is not as good as calling directly into the JVM from an Erlang function).

There are definitely advantages to writing as much of your code as possible to avoid side effects (obviously ignoring the odd print statement to help with debugging), since your code becomes easy to test and easy to reason about. But in real world apps you will need state management - Clojure and Scala both allow this (in different ways) and I'm sure that F# does too (though I've never worked with F#).

I think that these three languages address many (all?) of your concerns. They all have cool user communities, so give one of them a shot.

wynand··on Is this a good idea of a communication tool to replace the telephone, for sme’s?
I think you really have to live in the Philippines to know (so my opinion is obviously not worth that much), but it seems like a good basic business tool (and those are obviously going to sell well if no-one else has jumped in yet).

Probably the best thing to do, is to put together the simplest thing that will do the task and to try to sign up some alpha testers.

wynand··on Downvotes
This is a cool idea. I'm just wondering how people without credit cards would be able to join (I know quite a few people who don't have credit cards). Perhaps via a premium SMS (very few people have neither a mobile nor a credit card).
wynand··on Downvotes
I think that really hits the nail on the head.

I don't know if people will ever stumble upon a set of interaction constraints that will make people civil if they're not already committed to civility. In that regard HN has always been good (but not perfect, as evidenced by some of the episodes mentioned in this comment section).

If someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling).

wynand··on Do Scientists Really Need Ph.D.s?
The mathematician Stieltjes never completed a PhD, but was first rate. He was given an honorary doctorate so that he could apply for a chair at Groningen university.
wynand··on How to Stay Stressed
As someone whose stress has almost wrecked his life, I can relate to many of these points.

The levels of stress that I have can be debilitating and actually keep me from doing my work. It's useful to see lists like this to remind myself of what I should be avoiding.

wynand··on [dead]
Reminds me of an erstwhile Egyptian colleague of mine who said that he was "randomly selected" for screening every single time that he passed through the check-in gates at an airport.
wynand··on Oil Drop Navigates Complex Maze
I just downloaded his article, and he states that "With the advent of computers, algorithms for maze solving have become automated, but the solution times still scale unfavorably with maze size/complexity" and then references a paper by Dijkstra (Dijkstra, E. W. Numer. Math. 1959, 1, 269.).

That might be true for dense graphs, if you think that O(|V|^2 log|V|) is unfavourable.

A normal maze graph is planar and therefore |V| <= 3|E| - 6. Thus, maze problems can always be solved in O(|V| log|V|) time for a constant number of exits and starting points.

So, while the author made a little mathematical blunder ( single layer maze problems are efficient to solve), he's not the one that implied NP-completeness.

EDIT: Clarified my comment so that no-one can think I'm implying that an O(|V|^2 log|V|) algorithm is an NP problem.

wynand··on Oil Drop Navigates Complex Maze
I don't see anything in the article that shows that he made the statement about NP-completeness. It seems that the quoted chemist made that statement.

For someone who's not a graph theorist, it's an easy mistake to make, since the longest path problem is, in general, NP-complete. He was probably just thinking of this problem.

wynand··on Beware humans bearing gifts.
Perhaps a DNS attack? Try 194.203.155.123/article/mg20427391.400-beware-humans-bearing-gifts.html
wynand··on Beware humans bearing gifts.
The link must have been fixed in the meantime - I didn't have any trouble.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →