HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenophanes

3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009

https://criticalfallibilism.com
submissionscomments
xenophanes··on Nest introduces their Smoke Detector
But someone else might not know and need the alarm to keep going off.
xenophanes··on Fox News Touchscreens are Microsoft Perceptive Pixel Displays Running Windows 8
that's not correct, 55 inches is diagonal.
xenophanes··on Children aren't born smart. They're made smart by conversation
You claim to "demonstrate that it's a lot more complex than just environmental factors". But the correct conclusion from what you said is that you demonstrated that it's a lot more complex than just the environmental factors that you thought of.

You seem to be concluding genetic factors ("always had an intrinsic motivation"). But "not all environment" does not imply "some genetics", that is a false alternative.

There are more possible factors than just environment and genetics. One is human choice (sometimes called "free will", but that term has a lot of baggage). I do not agree with the perspective of attributing everything to factors, rather than a person's own choices.

Genetics certainly have a role in some sense. If you had different genes, you would have been a cat instead of human, and would not have the brain to be a software engineer.

But the general idea that life is very complicated, and the results of people in similar situations vary -- true so far -- simply does not imply (partial) genetic determinism. "Environment", or more generally alternatives to genetic determinism, is/are very subtle and complex. The world is vastly complicated, "environment" refers to a million factors most of which no one documents.

You had, in many respects, a different life and environment than anyone else had. Everyone has a unique environment at high precision. So whatever result you get, what would that prove?

You wonder how a person with several factors against them could be intelligent and successful? You can't think of any ways, besides genetics? There are a million ways. Poverty, non-wonderful discouraging parents, poor teachers, and whatever else are not one's whole life. You met many people, some more helpful than that. You read some books. Even just an ordered list of what books you read up to age 20 might be unique.

People don't start the same, but even if they did, things would quickly branch, again and again. 30 identical students sit in a classroom. The teacher explains something. By sheer randomness, if nothing else, some students understand it today, and some do not understand it yet. Then the next day the teacher gives a second lecture. Everyone hears "the same" lecture, but they have different situations (having understood or not understood yesterday's lesson), so different students experience "the same lecture" in different ways due to their different situations and perspectives. Similarly, in general, people in "the same environment" are not actually having the same experiences.

xenophanes··on Fingerprints are Usernames, not Passwords
> a few attempts to unlock it with a fake fingerprint, and then they'd have to enter my code. And if they fail to enter my code 10 times, the phone is wiped.

Are you saying that random people can pick up your phone when you go to the bathroom, touch the home button 3 times, and then enter "1111" 10 times, and wipe your phone? Is there some protection against this?

xenophanes··on Microsoft's Surface 2 will replace paper manuals on all Delta aircraft
FYI new ios devices come with apple's free office productivity software now (pages, keynote, numbers). they announced that at the iphone event a few weeks ago.

but the airlines don't want the pilots using office software, that's not what these devices are for.

the reason many pilots prefer ipad, i would guess, is because of better/easier UI conventions for ios apps and possibly a better touch screen. that would actually be relevant in the flight related apps the devices are meant for.

xenophanes··on Microsoft's Surface 2 will replace paper manuals on all Delta aircraft
Yep you called it. See:

http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/09/30/delta-pilots-fough...

> "We fought hard for iPad," a pilot working for the airline told AppleInsider. He described the Delta deal as being about money, travel contracts, and Delta's Information Technology staff historically being "in bed" with Microsoft.

Read the rest of the article. It gets worse.

xenophanes··on A negative captcha
my blog just does basically this in js:

  a = "cat"
  b = "dog"
  c = a + integer_to_string(234234) + b
then you have to submit the c value with the form. i get no spam. (a prior somewhat simpler did get some spam). obviously this would do nothing if i was google, but i'm a small blog and no one is going to customize a bot for me, and apparently none of the bots want to run a full js interpreter.

there are lots of simple solutions to spam as long as no one cares about you. and if they do care it's hard.

i do think making you do some math (maybe something serious that takes a quarter second to run) to be able to submit comments is a good approach in general though. basically humans have lots of spare CPU, but i'm not sure spam bots do currently. and if posting in a lot of places required running some math, it would rate limit spam bots.

xenophanes··on Netflix CEO says torrent piracy in Canada down 50 per cent since Netflix
All the sources except piracy, for movies and TV (and books too), are missing features you can use with other software if you have DRM free media. For example, I have amazon video already paid for and never ever use it because of this -- missing features that VLC has.

IMO they should try achieving feature parity -- or better, actually innovate -- to cut down piracy further. (Yes the paid stuff is arguably ahead on certain features like convenience. But not others.)

xenophanes··on Ask HN: How to become smarter?
http://fallibleideas.com/

http://beginningofinfinity.com/

xenophanes··on Why Apple is the cross-section of great hardware, design and shitty software
I didn't say it's a bad thing to fork, I said it requires further explanation how a fork -- with worse UI imo -- is better. Worse UI and similar internals -- where is the way better part?

I don't wish to defend windows safari, only mac.

xenophanes··on Why Apple is the cross-section of great hardware, design and shitty software
The OS is supposed to use memory. That's what it's for: to be used. Using memory is a feature, not a bug. Let the OS manage memory instead of demanding a lot should be left in an used state.

You also didn't make much effort to argue your points. Consider Safari vs Chrome. Safari has better UI IMO, and Chrome is a fork of Safari's internals. So what's better about Chrome on Mac? I use both regularly. Chrome's adblock works better but it's not obvious what else is better and you didn't tell me.

xenophanes··on Why Apple is the cross-section of great hardware, design and shitty software
> Apple has to put its cash to work

Throwing cash at it does not make better software. See the Mythical Man Month. Or don't. But Apple is aware of it.

I do not agree Apple's software is "shitty", but there is certainly room for improvement. But the bottleneck isn't cash (nor is the bottleneck desire. they want to improve things and are working on it).

xenophanes··on Please put me back to old My Yahoo
Yahoo just broke Yahoo Groups a few weeks ago. The new UI is god awful and makes some stuff impossible (like posting in plain text with proper quoting). It's also literally rather broken: author search doesn't work at all. Also they are losing and delaying emails at random and have been for weeks, and stopped answering support emails about it.
xenophanes··on A Jewel at the Heart of Quantum Physics
Why do you think there will be or should be a golden age, rather then continuous progress forever?

http://beginningofinfinity.com

xenophanes··on California school district hires firm to monitor students' social media
> Glendale Unified School District is comprised of 31 Schools and over 2,620 employees, serving 27,000 students in grades Kindergarten through 12th grade.

You are very naive about budgets. You should change that if you want to freelance or do a startup. 40k is very little money for them.

xenophanes··on New iPad browser from Opera
can't navigate with arrow keys, spacebar, pageup/down. have to roll mouse? or click the little arrows on edge of page. umm, wtf? no thx? bad website.
xenophanes··on Ask HN: Best paid VPN?
Recommend https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/

Never had any problems and can report the bandwidth they give you is good. It's also quite cheap $40/year.

Had multiple issues including poor bandwidth with a prior VPN whose name i forgot. Was also accused of being an email spammer by prior VPN, which I'm not, lol. Got a refund after that...

xenophanes··on Wild Ideas
While there are level-headed anarchists (e.g. William Godwin), Rothbard is a terrible example. He was an anti-semite and thought children were property. He wrote a letter to Ayn Rand about his serious psychological problems.
xenophanes··on Kathy Sierra: Your app makes me fat
This is so stupid. The experiment can be explained in many different ways and she just picks a trendy one. Another explanation is people who did harder work were more tired and hungry, or felt more like rewarding themselves. I don't particularly favor this explanation; I have no idea what is the right explanation; and that's the point, the experiment doesn't tell us.

She also ignores that for some people it takes more willpower to eat the cake. It can go either way depending on a person's ideas. She just assumes everyone has currently trendy ideas wherein fruit bowls are unpleasant but virtuous and people use willpower to eat them. But many other lifestyles are possible. For example, one might think cake is more delicious but they are scared of getting fat so it requires willpower to enjoy eating it instead of giving in to the fear, whereas the fruit bowl is easy to eat because there's no pressure against it, so it's the easy default.

xenophanes··on Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute
I asked a physicist. The headline and article are both stupid but the science is good. It's like the paint thing except that when light hits paint, the paint affects the light, they interact, the information in the light gets messed up. With the fancy crystal thing they are preserving the information.
xenophanes··on Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute
Wait so is the story basically along the lines of, "Light hits black paint. Absorbed, stops. Comes out later." ?
xenophanes··on Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute
And could also call non-local (faster-than-light) magical thinking.
xenophanes··on How I Cured my RSI Pain (2010)
In short, I relaxed and stopped being scared of it.

FWIW I also took more breaks, got a better chair and posture, stretched regularly, and especially importantly: became a lot more aware of signs of incoming pain and would take breaks before it started hurting not after. (But lately I'm fine and rarely need any breaks. After some success I stopped being scared.)

I think it's completely reasonable that your thoughts have a lot of effect on your body. I don't see anything unscientific about that. Both consciously and unconsciously your brain can move your legs, for example. And a lot of other important stuff.

As a comparison, consider running or some other sport. There's often minor aches and pains involved even if you never get anything people would call an "injury". If you had a bad attitude to them and interpreted them as a dangerous injury, I think they could bother you a huge amount. But if you aren't scared of them at all because you have a good understanding of which ones are danger signs and which are nothing to worry about, then the same pains can be no problem.

I think novices often make mistakes in both directions. Being overly worried about minor pains is common -- many people quickly give up on running. And trying to ignore major pains is also common and gets people injured. I think both types of mistakes happen (a lot) with RSI and typing too.

If you get get your psychology so you don't mind non-dangerous minor pains, but do things about any real problems, then that's good. If you stray to either direction of getting this correct you can cause problems.

Sometimes both issues happen. First you get some real pain. You take some breaks and it soon heals and you're OK but now you're scared and start interpreting non-dangerous minor sensations as scary pain. And if you keep going down that path it can escalate. And also if you try to push through while scared of every minor sensation, and type anyway, you're in no condition to understand whether there's anything dangerous going on that needs a break, some stretching, or more. So it's psychologically unpleasant plus you might hurt yourself again.

I think it's really valuable to build up more awareness and understanding of your hands/wrists, and have the right way of thinking about the topic.

EDIT: i think he deleted while i was writing my post. but basically he just asked for information about the things i talk about.

xenophanes··on How I Cured my RSI Pain (2010)
Never read the book, but psychology changes helped my RSI issues tremendously.

> if you are unconsciously worried about something (including worried about your wrists hurting while you type), then this can cause your wrists to hurt while you type.

This. If you're scared of RSI and scared of typing, that can itself cause problems.

xenophanes··on Things Most Americans Don’t Know About America
Off topic political rant. Flagged.
xenophanes··on [dead]
OMG, some small percentage of the time they send back the wrong form letter. Stop the presses!
xenophanes··on Let's Play Ancient Greek Geometry
I got a triangle made inside a circle. Can someone tell me why the triangle in origin circle thing doesn't complete?

http://www.sciencevsmagic.net/geo/#0A1.1A0.0L2.0L1.1L2.1L6.2...

xenophanes··on California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti-bank messages in chalk
And you call people unhealthy when you disagree with their ideas. This kind of delegitimization of disagreement with specious medical-scientific authority is one of the larger problems facing the country.
xenophanes··on My sister absolutely refuses to learn math
> Watch any fantasy draft or craft and see how much math is going on.

Indeed. Check out my irb history from playing Hero Academy (there's way more above):

  >> 200*2.55+200*0.8
  => 670.0
  >> 200*2.55+200*0.8*2
  => 830.0
  >> 300*2.55
  => 765.0
  >> 300*2.55+399*0.8
  => 1084.2
  >> 300*2.55+300*0.8
  => 1005.0
  >> 0+300*2.55+300*0.8
  => 1005.0
  >> 260*2.55+260*0.8
  => 871.0
  >> 260*2.55+260*0.8*2
  => 1079.0
  >> 260*2.55*1.5+260*0.8*2
  => 1410.5
  >> 260*2.55*1.5
  => 994.5
  >> 260*2.5+260*0.75*2
  => 1040.0
  >> 130+180+230+280
  => 820
  >> 820*0.8
  => 656.0
  >> 1350*0.8
  => 1080.0
xenophanes··on Larry Page addresses PRISM
Of course it's weaseling. Maybe they disclosed such information on a slightly lesser scale. That passage doesn't say.

They all said stuff about "direct access", without discussing what would and wouldn't qualify as "indirect". They didn't deny doing all kinds of different access that could be called indirect in some way.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →