HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xphilter

534 karma · joined June 28, 2011

submissionscomments
xphilter··on An Exam Surveillance Company Is Trying to Silence Critics with Lawsuits
Sorry -- it's in my original question, from the statute (here https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/29/801.2)

"The term lie detector means a polygraph, deceptograph, voice stress analyzer, psychological stress evaluator, or any other similar device (whether mechanical or electrical) that is used, or the results of which are used, for the purpose of rendering a diagnostic opinion regarding the honesty or dishonesty of an individual. Voice stress analyzers, or psychological stress evaluators, include any systems that utilize voice stress analysis, whether or not an opinion on honesty or dishonesty is specifically rendered"

xphilter··on An Exam Surveillance Company Is Trying to Silence Critics with Lawsuits
Right, but the "specific type of device" is defined more broadly than that -- so if I code a "lie detector" that tracks mouse movements during an online interview (my hypothesis would be that liars and cheats move their mouse more sporadically), could I use that code as a part of an interview process?
xphilter··on An Exam Surveillance Company Is Trying to Silence Critics with Lawsuits
Detecting behaviors to assess what though? Isn't that exactly what a lie detector does? It claims to detect electrical signals of behaviors (stress) and then that goes to determine if the person is honest.
xphilter··on An Exam Surveillance Company Is Trying to Silence Critics with Lawsuits
If there are any lawyers here, I'd love thoughts on whether these tools (used in employment/interview settings) violate 29 CFR § 801.4 - Prohibitions on lie detector use. (I know this article is about schools and in Canada). I've been thinking these tools do violate, but never filed a case alleging it (yet). Specifically, these anti-cheat "algorithms" seem to be "a polygraph, deceptograph, voice stress analyzer, psychological stress evaluator, or any other similar device (whether mechanical or electrical) that is used, or the results of which are used, for the purpose of rendering a diagnostic opinion regarding the honesty or dishonesty of an individual." I mean, the entire purpose is to determine if the prospective employee is honest. Any thoughts?
xphilter··on A novel polymer should make 3D printing more effective
I agree. It really opens up a lot of things for people who like to tinker. Started just printing toys, but now am designing and printing useful parts needed during lockdown and School/work from home. I love it.
xphilter··on Tesla dissolves its PR department
Can someone with experience with this help me understand the point of a PR team to talk to press? As an outsider, it just looks like another form of marketing—-never confirm or deny anything and just put out press releases that are filled with business jargon. And when it’s actual a sticky situation, any communication is going to be drafted by legal or execs. Maybe I’m wrong though.
xphilter··on Cities Experiment with Remedy for Poverty: Cash, No Strings Attached
The problem with these experiments is the same for any that provides middle-class-to-poor people with a benefit: they know it's only a short term thing so they will use it up while they have it. I doubt we're going to get any real results with this.

My favorite example is the Rand study that's been used to give Americans high-deductible hell. https://www.rand.org/health-care/projects/hie.html

It's been a while since I dug into it, but essentially the study was filled with logical flaws. In summary, people were enrolled in health insurance plans and studied to see how they would react. If given 'free' health care would they use it more and if given high-deductible, would they use it less.

Two giant flaws I remember. First, no crap if you gave a broken country a short-term solution people will use it up (which supports the conclusion that we should make health care expensive). Second flaw was that if a person was enrolled in high-deductible and had high expenses they could quit! and go back to their normal plan. So of course the data would support that high-deductible folks spent less. Which is why we're all stuck with high-deductible garbage.

xphilter··on Blueberry Compound May Provide New Inflammatory Bowel Disease Therapy
I can’t wait for all the Dr. Oz neutraceuticals to pumped after this: “cure your bowels Witt blueberry extract. Get your first bottle free!”* (only $49.99 for shipping and $100 every two weeks).
xphilter··on Belief in Conspiracy Theories Is a Barrier to Controlling Spread of Covid-19
I get that, but there are differences. With something like the US Open, you have people staying in the same spot for long periods of time in a sheltered building (maybe some have more winds, maybe some don't). You have shared indoor bathrooms, indoor vending, sheltered entrances/exists.

Nevertheless, I agree with the larger point that leadership should have provided more outdoor activities to draw people away from bars and restaurants.

xphilter··on Belief in Conspiracy Theories Is a Barrier to Controlling Spread of Covid-19
"had little effect" is equivalent to no effect; read the paper. "Trends between the treated and non-treated counties are virtually identical prior to the protests. This is reassuring and suggests that the timing of the protests is not correlated with trends in COVID-19 case growth or unobservable determinants of case growth."

I don't know what you're quibbling over. If we're reaching for absolute zero levels of covid spread, then sure protests had a giant effect (just from logic). That's not practical; people need to go outside.

And per the "it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread" is in reference to the article's earlier hypothesis that because people were leaving their homes to protest, you would expect them to get covid at a higher rate than someone who never left their house. The article didn't have any direct evidence that that was actually the case though.

xphilter··on Belief in Conspiracy Theories Is a Barrier to Controlling Spread of Covid-19
I don't really follow your comment. Here's a paper that concludes that BLM protests had (have) no effect on Covid case growth in the population: https://www.nber.org/papers/w27408

"Likewise, while it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread of COVID-19 among those who attended the protests, we demonstrate that the protests had little effect on the spread of COVID- 19 for the entire population of the counties with protests during the more than five weeks following protest onset."

xphilter··on Americans don't feel they can get justice when wronged by their ISP – survey
But this is so limited. AGs can only take on a few cases per year, and they’re politically selected (what will get most press and least criticism). And the state law can be waived (or effectively waived through arbitration clause).
xphilter··on Americans don't feel they can get justice when wronged by their ISP – survey
Awesome point. I keep thinking about this and want to yell at all law professors in the country (who I think have more influence than they recognize): what the hell are you going to be teaching in 20 years? Only cases before AT&T v. Concepcion?
xphilter··on Paris hails victory over short-stay rents
It’s not just housing prices. It’s community and neighborhood. People want to live in a neighborhood with actual people, not a decentralized hotel. I say this as someone who has done short term rentals in Paris—it was nice for me, but I can see how annoying it must be for residents.
xphilter··on Six months in, N95 mask shortages persist
You missed my point; perhaps I wasn’t clear. Manufacturers can charge whatever price. Price gouging is only when you scoop up already made products to sell at a higher price, no value add.
xphilter··on Six months in, N95 mask shortages persist
Again, I call bullshit. What social norm says a company can’t put together a business model of making n95 masks and trying to sell those? The only social norm is against re-selling for massive gains during a pandemic. Not manufacturing and making a profit.
xphilter··on Six months in, N95 mask shortages persist
If that was actually a reason, don’t you think the article would have mentioned it? Also, if it is a reason, can you please cite to which law? I’m not aware of a law saying a manufacturer can’t set the price of n95 mask. A re-seller, however wouldn’t be able to hoard supply and then do a 10x price increase, which would be price gouging. If there was a competent firm that could offer n95 masks at any price to any of the hundreds of hospitals, I’d wager they could charge whatever price they want at this point.
xphilter··on What is the purpose of issuing laws/regulations without penalty? (2017)
It’s to solidify a certain position before someone can. Suppose a state or states have a law that is consumer friendly and has teeth behind it through private right of action and penalties. Businesses don’t like that so they lobby US senators and Reps to pass a law that preempts those state laws it has no enforcement or penalties. Even better, the new law will, on the surface, appear to “take the issue seriously.” But how can it if it has no penalty? This can happen on the state level too—a good example is the Michigan VRPA which sought to limit data sharing through penalty. It started to work, so state legislature took away the penalties. Oh well.
xphilter··on Police-issued "courtesy cards" help friends and family out of minor infractions
Wait till y’all learn about “fraternal order of police” fundraisers and car stickers identifying donors, allowing “discretion” to be used by the cop to let the violation go.
xphilter··on Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account
So there should be a law that says any computing device must be free to load any software? So PS4 must play XBox games? Printers must accept any ink cartridge? Apple Watch should allow any android app? What’s the distinction? (I’m not trying to be obtuse). I buy iPhone specifically for the walled garden. I don’t want to have to worry about malware etc like I do on my PCs/MacBook.

And again—-going back to the Walmart/Target analogy, if you wanted to enter into a business deal with a third party in a Walmart, Walmart would demand a cut too.

xphilter··on Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account
You lost me. I just switched carriers from T-Mobile to ATT last week. I had an easy chance to switch to Android (I didn’t) but the cost to me would have been close to nil—other than time. All my apps are agnostic to iOS/Android (same for the 3 other people on my family plan). So just like I’d have to spend time learning the Layout of a Walmart if I left target, I’d have time costs to switch to Android.

And the example you gave of the Kindle still doesn’t make me question the App Store market: if kindle had a kiosk in a target to sell ebooks, I bet target would demand a cut too.

If what you’re after is data portability then solve for that. I’d rather have a law that covers all digital companies rather than devolve the App Store into some unregulated flee market.

xphilter··on Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account
Honestly, what is the difference between the App Store and Target? Why should a third party (or court) have any control in what the retailer sells?
xphilter··on Toddlers who use touchscreens show attention differences
I don’t think that’s true. As a parent, all my decisions are made by balancing a host of factors. Pre covid I limited screens because they should be talking, reading, playing with other kids, being active, etc. with covid, many of those alternatives were taken away so I’ve had to be flexible in the short term to again balance everything so my kids can interact with other kids and get access to learning opportunities. Post covid, I’ll do my best to limit screens again.
xphilter··on Plasma from exercised mice showed beneficial effects on brains of aged mice
Isn’t that the premise in Silicon Valley where Gavin(?) has the young guy giving him blood/plasma
xphilter··on Microsoft to permanently close its retail stores
I agree, but I kinda feel like the relaxed and comfortable atmosphere was more of an indication that the stores weren’t doing so hot. Every time I went to one is was because it was quieter and lower key than other stores. And I never actually wanted to buy things. Maybe that’s good(ish) marketing but probably doesn’t make good business sense.
xphilter··on Amazon establishes new Counterfeit Crimes Unit
Impossible. Congress has given amazon a get-out-of-jail-free-card in rye form of an arbitration clause with no stare decisis and no public access to the harm or outcome.
xphilter··on America is giving up on the pandemic?
What new rules specifically? And what rules were not in place for the armed all-white protests in Michigan, for instance?
xphilter··on Jobless claims, total unemployment level worse than expected
“I’ll point to states not representative of other stares in density at all.”
xphilter··on I'm resigning from my job at Facebook
You’re sidestepping the discussion though. It is “when you avail yourself to FB, do we want FB to use its algorithms to push certain content.” I see two options: stop any ranking/recommendations and make FB a dumb pipe with no restrictions, or put guard rails on the ranking/recommendations so we don’t end up with extremists.
xphilter··on I'm resigning from my job at Facebook
Which is based on FB’s weighing of those factors...so either stop doing any ranking/recommendations and make FB a dumb pipe with no restrictions, or put guard rails on the ranking/recommendations so we don’t end up with extremists.
← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →