HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yebyen

2,755 karma · joined October 9, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/yebyen; my proof: https://keybase.io/yebyen/sigs/Q4xYtntxlQX51bnJaCqx5ERBtsA-G0clfn1VJVEY2F8 ]
submissionscomments
yebyen··on Broadcom to acquire VMware for $61B
If you're looking for an example of successful monetization of open source addons for K8s, you could do much better than the example of Weave Net.
yebyen··on Minikube quickly sets up a local Kubernetes cluster on macOS, Linux, and Windows
Yeah. So if you don't want to pay Docker/Mirantis for the privilege of using their open source implementation of the open container initiative standard on the MacOS, what else do you do with your Mac to run docker containers?

Are you using Docker Desktop? (Do you pay?) That is the benefit and that's literally all I use Rancher Desktop for. A Docker Desktop replacement. It also works with KinD, that was my whole point. Since one might assume it doesn't work (or maybe they tried in the past and found it didn't work at some point in the past) – today it works great.

If you have another alternative to suggest how you can run KinD on MacOS, I'm all ears. I'm literally using a full stack open source approach, to pay a gatekeeper in order to access it from my MacOS workstation seems like an anti-thesis to me.

yebyen··on Zitadel: The best of Auth0 and Keycloak combined
When I checked this out 9 days ago there was a GitOps installation instructions page! I didn't have a chance to follow it up right away, but now it doesn't resolve anymore. What happened to GitOps support in Zitadel?

https://docs.zitadel.com/docs/guides/installation/gitops

yebyen··on Minikube quickly sets up a local Kubernetes cluster on macOS, Linux, and Windows
KinD requires some docker engine to run it on. That's all I'm using from Rancher. It allows me to switch between containerd and docker-engine.

My options on this physical machine as I see it are: lima, rancher desktop, or Docker Desktop itself. I don't actually use Rancher Desktop for its Kubernetes integration, and in earlier versions it wasn't even possible to do this without weird vague workarounds, but now it has an "Off" switch, and I use it for the rare occasion that I need to run container images locally, or a kind cluster.

I ruled out Docker Desktop because I can't use it alongside of other VMs (not because it doesn't work, which I understood to be true for Windows users, but because it is composed of a virtual machine, with a memory footprint, and one shouldn't have too many of those unless you have a beast of a laptop...) and because it requires paid volume licensing. Don't get me wrong, I like to pay for things, but I also like to evaluate alternatives!

I used this for a while: https://github.com/lima-vm/lima/blob/master/examples/k8s.yam...

It wasn't quite perfectly stable, also not maintained by the Kubernetes core team but externally, so it has to play catch-up a bit when releases are done, rather than in the case of KinD it can enjoy a release on the schedule with Kubernetes.

I am a kubeadm baseline user and I find that Kind is actually the best way to do experiments (I don't use MiniKube at all so can't compare) Some experiments require a bit more control of the VM that runs your CRI and for those there are raw nodes (physical machines) or a Lima VM for a convincing approximation of one.

When there's a need to go to production, I'm generally not using any of these choices, but I am using KinD quite extensively (even on remote nodes!) through tailscale. This is actually really nice.

yebyen··on Minikube quickly sets up a local Kubernetes cluster on macOS, Linux, and Windows
I'm pretty happy with kind on Rancher Desktop on a mac!
yebyen··on Is VISA down everywhere in the US?
Where do you actually use lightning? Does it work for you most of the time?
yebyen··on Department of Justice announces new policy for charging cases under the CFAA
Where do you get that anyone wants to strip anyone's rights away from within this conversation?

We're talking about laws, which generally bind individuals to certain behaviors. Laws do not make rights as far as I'm aware (and IANAL), they are "God-given." At least in US legal tradition, as I understand, the default position of the law is that you are allowed to do anything which does not infringe on anyone else's enumerated rights, and laws can only bind you from doing things which you would otherwise be free to do in the absence of those laws.

If the laws which bind our behaviors are so complex they cannot be read aloud in their totality in any practical time period then how is anyone (let alone anyone whose profession is not "the law" or acting in legislature) ever to be expected to understand them as a whole? (Especially when certain laws have traditionally gone unenforced, to borrow from the original context of this thread.)

The law should be possible to understand. That is a decent aspirational goal. I'm not sure what you think I meant but it's not what you said.

yebyen··on Department of Justice announces new policy for charging cases under the CFAA
> Mandatory sunset clauses would be another good idea, along with a requirement that the entire bill, along with any external documents incorporated by reference (e.g. building codes), must be read into the official record with a quorum of the legislature present before it can be passed or renewed.

This is one of the most sensible things I've heard proposed that will never work. (I'm saying that, if laws are so complicated that no human can learn them well enough to keep themselves in compliance without assistance of a compliance department, or so complicated that even the people who are directly responsible for them cannot be bothered with being made aware of the details and double checking that they still make sense on a somewhat regular basis... then they are too complicated.)

I think it will never work because complex things are complex for a reason on the balance, and because we're already "too deep to dig ourselves out of this hole." But in principle I agree wholeheartedly with this idea.

yebyen··on Senators Urge FTC to Probe ID.me over Selfie Data
I don't know anything personally but I do have a friend who works as an engineer at ID.me and he explained to me that they really don't store any data.

The way it was explained to me, (apologies if there's anything factually inaccurate in here, this is my recollection from a while ago, just before the IRS very notably decided to cancel their contract for the 2021 tax year?) they had an army of people whose job was literally to visually compare the person's selfie to the ID they presented, and if I understood correctly, they also had some facility for verifying the presented ID was genuine. And that was it.

(Edit: I see from clicking through to the CyberScoop article "ID.me CEO backtracks ... on 1:many recognition use claims" that it may not be the case that's all they do with each selfie, and that in reality they do store the selfies, based on a regulatory requirement that they must do so for 7 years.)

I think based on that conversation (and sure, call me biased) the "invasion of privacy" concerns were way overblown. If you think the best way to implement an ID verification system is to hire more permanent government employees and have them do the job in-house, ... I'm on Hacker News, so I'm going to assume that nobody thought that.

If you have concerns about the truthfulness of this scheme (does it really happen without permanently storing any selfies?) I think those are fair concerns, and we should know the answer.

But is there anything to be really concerned about, if there's no permanent storage? I don't understand. Can someone explain it to me? I think that the "invasion of privacy" ship must have already sailed, the government has your photo ID in a database, and it's already on record there forever.

What does it matter if the verification is outsourced to a private company? Is there the capacity to do this already inside of our government? (Would you trust them to implement such a system efficiently and correctly without private help?)

What level of oversight would make this scheme appropriate, I guess is my question? Is there any ID verification system that people who are up in arms would accept here? I'm in favor of probing the questions but I am not surprised that wait times are longer and support staffing was evidently reduced, after the IRS cancelled their contract. "You reap what you sow."

yebyen··on Dokku – Free Heroku Alternative
Thank you. The docs all work, but some paths through the docs do not work on certain form factors (I think this is a mobile issue)

Well, the docs did work, (they're 100% down now...)

yebyen··on Dokku – Free Heroku Alternative
My go-to stack is Prometheus and Grafana with kube-prometheus-stack Helm chart for Kubernetes.

I'm sure I'm not configuring it well.

There are too many leaps I couldn't follow directly in how to make the config, and there's something about how arrays merge in YAML that makes it harder to write a config like this in Helm... so there is a lot of what I've written here that shouldn't need to be in my own config, because they are the standard default alerts, but I wound up having to include them to make my one extra alert join the rest (and this is my excuse for why it is several hundred lines long, when in reality it's mostly stock.)

This config goes so far as making alerts to Slack with Alertmanager that work out of the box!

https://github.com/kingdonb/flux2/blob/monitoring/manifests/...

:sunglasses:

yebyen··on Dokku – Free Heroku Alternative
Congratulations, you all just suggested re-inventing Deis workflow (with a few additional pieces) :)

There are a lot of elements indeed, https://docs.teamhephy.com/understanding-workflow/components...

This is classic literature: https://docs.teamhephy.com/understanding-workflow/architectu...

It is much easier to just use it than to try and re-invent your own: https://docs.teamhephy.com/quickstart/

I cannot guarantee the cloud provider bits all work, I don't use them so I don't maintain them, but if you have Kubernetes with persistent disk provided, which any managed Kubernetes can most certainly do, it's easy enough to hook up generic Minio (which has the added benefit of working just as well on bare metal hosts), and I'm certain that does work as I use it.

yebyen··on Dokku – Free Heroku Alternative
There's also Deis Workflow (Hephy Workflow)

https://web.teamhephy.com

For those worried about a Single Point of Failure, you can't have your cake and eat it too. Docker and Dokku is a single point of failure when you build directly on it, I guess. Kubernetes mitigates that.

We're still here, keeping the tires on. I haven't personally tested K8s 1.24 with Workflow yet, but we are actively seeking maintainers on all of the cloud vendors.

If you find that something is broken and want to see it fixed, talk to me on Slack. I'm aware of at least Azure that has broken their Bucket Storage API since Workflow was originally published by Deis, and it hasn't been quite fixed yet.

Documented support for Google Cloud and AWS are both extant as well, although I've heard one person call into question whether Google Cloud storage will work out of the box, or if it still needs upgrades. We'd like to add DigitalOcean support as well, I already know it basically works, we just need to add documentation and probably also give it a quick spit-shine and polish.

Dokku on the other hand is less heavyweight and does not require as much work for maintenance, since it does not have to be decentralized or protect against any SPOF. It's a wonder that more people do not want to use this. I've heard of at least one more Deis Workflow fork in the wild, possibly in better or worse states of maintenance than Team Hephy, but if you are looking to get off of Heroku then you could certainly do much worse.

We do need volunteers as we do not have time to maintain everything by ourselves, (come talk to us on the Slack if you're interested in joining the fun!)

yebyen··on Web3.0 Must Be Destroyed
There's a lot of wrong ideas out there and we don't get people to have the right idea by shutting down discussion about it. I like your article better than Cory Doctorow's take, how's that for positive feedback? I'm sorry that it got flagged off the front page!
yebyen··on Web3.0 Must Be Destroyed
FWIW I am for sure the one misunderstanding, I get burned by this every time.

Sell low, buy high – that's the name of the game isn't it?

yebyen··on Web3.0 Must Be Destroyed
I am glad someone knows what "laser eyes" mean, I did not get that reference or know that meme. FWIW, I do not have laser eyes and I would not bet against BTC reaching 100k. But that does not mean I believe BTC should be the leader or that it's the best cryptocurrency, so that is not meant as an endorsement in any way.

Great article, by the way. I have just skimmed most of it, I am knee-jerking, but my strongest impression after reading through most of it for the first time is "I'm with Keanu here" with the caveat that I do believe there are a handful of good Web3 projects out there, I'm not going to name one because I don't want to detract from your article, which is actually very good IMHO. (Edit: I guess I mean, I'm with queersamus, whose quote appears under the picture of Keanu...)

yebyen··on Web3.0 Must Be Destroyed
> what happens when BTC does reach 100k? — presumably most will sell including the grifters in Miami, Dubai and so on

LOL – if you think this is true, you don't know anything about greed or emotions. (To be a bit less obscurant, I'm saying they are both either boundless or unquantifiable. There's nothing special about 100K btc, nothing more special than 69K USD BTC.)

yebyen··on Jeffrey Snower was originally demoted over PowerShell
> Observe /r/programming or HN for long enough.

Well, I haven't seen those commenters before, and I'm still not excited about using .NET, (and I'm the type of person who you'd expect to be getting excited about a strongly-typed shell) so either that's not the driving factor here, or...

> Azure, for one. Azure's primary and preferred method of interaction instead of it's UI is with it's API, which is also available fully wrapped up as Powershell cmdlets which again run on all three OS's.

I have been getting into Azure, and I've found the `az cli` somewhat lacking, for example "why is the default 'get' behavior emitting a huge blob of JSON instead of printing a table that humans can read?" and I thought, maybe this is a reflection of the fact that they'd prefer you write an API client and build it into a portal for your customers rather than asking people on your team to use the CLI directly?

Seems you've confirmed this for me here. It would be nice to use a strongly typed interface rather than parsing JSON blobs, maybe I will end up checking that out!

Thanks :)

> > make my customers install the .NET runtime at the proper version and fiddle with .exe files > > You don't, you either get them to install it's APT .deb file or <insert distro packaging format here> or wget the dotnet-install script. OR, you just build your app with .NET runtime packaged in .so file alongside your app.

My point was, they do need to have or obtain the correct version of the runtime to go with your app, and if there are different apps with different maintenance cycles, that might mean you need multiple runtimes installed and a way of switching between them. That's a big deal!

If I want to adopt a runtime, I hope I'm adopting it for more than just one app. Now all of these apps need to be on the treadmill, actively maintained, or some upgrade might break, pinning me to a particular version, and then I'm stuck.

If there was ever a compelling problem to solve, it's here, although based on the breadth of languages and frameworks that still experience this problem in one way or another, I think it's likely unsolvable. You either need someone (a distro) running the compilers and checking that things still work together in concert with the maintainers of the upstream software, or you need to be statically linking, or get yourself something like venv/rvm that makes managing multiple versions of a runtime a low-overhead activity (so you can have 4 versions if that is what is required for your different maintenance cycles across different services, without needing to break those services out onto four separate servers just to accommodate the language runtime differences.)

Not to rule it out, does the .NET ecosystem have a great answer to this already?

(Edit: I guess "the web application" is the answer, broadly speaking! "Users" don't have to install anything besides a browser.)

> Running the applications involves typing ./my-application which then runs the ELF binary. There is no .exe unless it's on Windows. It's the same install and run story that any of the other languages listed mentioned.

So I'm assuming you can also statically link your .NET binaries and emit a fat binary that will work anywhere, but at tremendous cost in terms of disk usage, (but you makes your choices and you takes your chances) – like I was saying, this is not a problem unique to .NET either, Go binaries from the likes of GCloud and Azure for interacting with their APIs are all enormous, because they want to avoid this problem with their users and they have lots of libraries to pull in.

For me, the killer feature that makes Ruby ecosystem "worth adopting" is open source. You know how rare it is to encounter some Ruby gem which is not open to changes and inspection? I can think of exactly one time I found this, it did block me from using some software (AppDynamics bundled a native ext. with their Rubygem, it had wicked thread safety issues if you upgraded Ruby past a certain version... they did not provide the source, so enterprising customers couldn't fix the problem for themselves and contribute it upstream...) I've been using Ruby professionally for about 14 years, and I saw this issue exactly once.

And that was a choice that one vendor made, and such a rare event that I would never think to let it reflect badly on the language. Go does not seem to have these issues as commonly (where somebody distributes a go package as binary-only) even though the language is not interpreted so it can happen and it wouldn't be unusual or even "against the grain."

This is why I thought of Ruby being primarily executable as an interpreted language as "the guard" against this sort of thing happening in Ruby ecosystem.

yebyen··on Jeffrey Snower was originally demoted over PowerShell
I have never heard anyone "spreading FUD that .NET isn't OS" but I have heard plenty of times from Mac and Linux users, "why would you want to use PowerShell" and I am mining this thread for answers, because I honestly don't know for myself.

And it's objectively true that .NET/PowerShell is targeting Windows users, (which if you're Microsoft, why wouldn't you do that?) so, assuming that you don't care about interoperability with Windows users, don't use Windows yourself, don't have any customers asking for PowerShell support for whatever XYZ widget you build... what are the compelling reasons to run PS on Linux or Mac?

Setting up .NET is an investment, and learning to program it is an investment, people invest in the Go, Rust, Ruby, Python, TypeScript, JS ecosystems because they are generally useful, and that extends to Windows people, but if I'm building a product targeting Mac or Linux (servers), what is the incentive for me to make my customers install the .NET runtime at the proper version and fiddle with .exe files (or am I completely off base about how it works?)

yebyen··on Moving a macOS window by clicking anywhere on it
The title bar is small and it gets smaller every time our resolution gets higher. In Linux window managers, alt+click anywhere in the window and drag has been a standard way to move windows with or without handles since probably two decades, I know it doesn't seem like much but this is a major "creature comfort" thing for me, a Linux expat now using mostly MacOS.
yebyen··on Ask HN: Am I going insane or is there genuinely no value in blockchain tech?
Just so you understand me, I have basically zero expectation that anyone is going to choose "my favorite blockchain" for their next big project and send the price soaring. It's just not going to happen.

With that out of the way, what stops the government from implementing their own CBDC and saying "tax revenues SHALL be paid downstream via the US-CBDC Token" and requiring approved vendors to implement it for their US-Gov Receivables? This seems very likely to happen. I would actually bet on it.

You're telling me on one hand, the problem is solved (example TLS) and on the other hand, I need to be realistic about my expectations, since it doesn't solve the whole problem... which seems to indicate to me that your solution is actually not solving the problem you expected me to have, which is there is no effective or continuous transparency about how much money our institutions have in-flight and where it's going or gone, and there is no sponsored route for institutions to "opt in" to such transparency and actually enforce it permanently.

That's what the blockchain is for.

What's un-fixably wrong with the blockchain solution exactly? I fully expect this US-CBDC is going to look nothing like I wanted my blockchain to look (it won't be in any way decentralized at all, it will have some government-sponsored "oracles" instead of user-sponsored nodes, so that it will be a blockchain in name and in function, but you won't be able to mine it, and it won't be "ours" – it might actually go on Ethereum, but I doubt it will and I definitely won't hold my breath. It will probably be super green for the environment, whatever it is.)

So how can you simultaneously believe this is a solved problem, which can't be solved, and yet already has been solved by Blockchain (but we don't need it?)

yebyen··on Ask HN: Am I going insane or is there genuinely no value in blockchain tech?
Don't you want some verifiable continuity in those books?

How do you guarantee that continuity breaches are easy to spot when they're "books" and you can publish as many of them as you want, or skip one if it turns out we don't want transparency somewhere because of "national security"?

This argument always seems to start with "there is no application for blockchain" and then moves the goal post to "that application doesn't NEED a blockchain" when we didn't even want ONLY that one application, we came for the whole package.

Do you really trust the government to publish accurate data if there is no transparent mechanism to keep them accountable for their accuracy? What is your alternative proposed mechanism for ensuring that the books are not cooked? (Is it another law, this time that says "books SHALL be balanced" and links to the RFC that provides specific definitions for modal verbs like MUST, SHALL, MAY, COULD?)

We certainly COULD invent another system that all tax money passes through, which ties out and all tax revenue is required to pass through, but how far will you stretch the spec in the opposite direction just to make sure that we didn't use "blockchain" which I'm assuming you consider as "scam tech" and you are apparently convinced that we don't need?

yebyen··on Ask HN: Am I going insane or is there genuinely no value in blockchain tech?
We're not talking about tax evasion. If you don't have hundreds of thousands of dollars in assets, then banks have all sorts of fees that they ding you for just like the phone company when you travel, and they won't waive them as they have no incentive to keep your business. Folks with lots of money who track every penny are often unaware of the landscape for these fees, because banks actually do have an incentive to keep your business and they do waive them without even asking.

If you think there's something illicit about seeking to pay the least in fees and with the broadest reach, or if you think that paying fees to every company who comes along that gets to play middle-man is exactly the same as paying your fair share in taxes then I'm not sure what I can do to dissuade you of this notion.

yebyen··on Gallium OS: a fast and lightweight Linux distro for ChromeOS devices
I think it's kind of neat the way that it fails. It would be very easy for someone to accidentally poof and it's been factory reset if they didn't know how to handle this. I'm talking four mis-keystrokes easy. And a puzzle to solve in case it has fallen into the wrong hands? Sign me up, I guess!

I miss updates from GalliumOS, I guess it's time to move on, but I don't know if I could ever get all of the nice comfort features they built into their distro to be fully replicated on any other modern Linux distro of any kind that isn't specially focused on being a Linux distro for Chromebooks, like Gallium was!

yebyen··on Gallium OS: a fast and lightweight Linux distro for ChromeOS devices
I was under the impression that is not an option on the Chromebook 14" from HP. But I have never disassembled the thing, so if there is a write-protect screw in there, I won't have seen it anyway...

I don't really mind, it doesn't harm the secondary partition at all, (it's more annoying that it cannot restore from sleep, than what happens if I forget to honor the fact that it cannot go to sleep properly...)

I could configure it so that it just won't go to sleep, but I'd rather have to run a script and restore the functioning firmware, than wake up to a chromebook with completely drained battery (and whatever filesystem corruption might come after ceasing writes to the filesystem in the middle of whatever happens due to an abrupt loss of power and when it's not "going to sleep" at the time.)

yebyen··on Gallium OS: a fast and lightweight Linux distro for ChromeOS devices
My experience with this, and I'll stress that I'm sure it varies by device, is that using the Mr. Chromebox firmware to install GalliumOS works great, until you allow the device to be put to sleep or run out of battery. Then the firmware is restored to the original, without any user request.

This blocks you from booting your Linux environment again but is otherwise non-destructive (you can just run Mr. Chromebox again to get the necessary firmware re-installed)

(My device is a HP Chromebook 14")

yebyen··on Inside the longest Atlassian outage
I think that depends on what you mean by compliance. Some regulations require you to irreversibly destroy data when they prescribe the destruction of that data.

That can mean as much as "you have to encrypt everything with a separate key, so that you can destroy the key for the given (say, personally identifiable) dataset making its retrieval irrecoverable"

I'm not saying that's the particular compliance reason they had here, or that the analysis you're giving is wrong, either. There is an interpretation where either of these ideas could be the correct one.

yebyen··on Twitter accounts dropping “.eth” from usernames
ETH is a public ledger. If you publish your address and put your own name on it, any transfers to or from that address will be associated with your public name. This is not something that can be solved.

At least not in ETH itself; even privacy coins like ZEC may have a way to make your identity public and make your history transparent – and it works as designed when you do this, your transactions are public. (In this sense, neither does using a mixer really help at all. It would just show that you've received some money and sent it to a mixer as yourself, if the mixer is also a public known entity.)

I suppose one way to solve this, is to tell people to look up your ENS name, and then sign a message and share it with them – to present them securely with an address that they can use and verify that it belongs to you, only that it won't be tied to your original identity, except by that message (which you'd have to trust them not to share as well.)

yebyen··on Exit interviews are a trap
> But many (most?) people don't suffer criticism well in my experience - and this seems to be especially true of the people who are most worthy of being criticized.

This is definitely a cultural thing, I brought this up with my team recently, the concept of "negative feedback" and got two different reactions – my feedback to the team was about how we give negative feedback, and nobody at all agreed with that phrasing LOL

Either some people who heard what I said and thought, surely this means when you have done something wrong, and it's not actually negative feedback, but corrective feedback so that you know how to do that thing right in the future.

And the other reaction was, "negative feedback, positive feedback" no such thing it is all just feedback, but watch out for positive feedback because all of it is probably fake, and nobody is fooled by that "compliment sandwich" BS.

I don't think this is a problem for exit interviews, at least not exclusively; the point is that people are either receptive to feedback or they aren't. You can try to candy coat it, but if there's any chance that being direct is going to make the feedback more likely to land, I personally think I prefer the direct approach.

(Then again, I never notice compliment sandwiches, so maybe they work on me.)

yebyen··on GitHub incident 2022-03-23
Sounds like it was a MySQL database:

https://github.blog/2022-03-23-an-update-on-recent-service-d...

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →