HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AlexandrB

29,839 karma · joined November 10, 2010

http://bencz.com
submissionscomments
AlexandrB··on Canadians are running out of time to oppose Bill C-22
> If the courts ruled against them, would you have taken that as evidence for the quality of the charter, and the legal system that stands behind it? Or is this a tails I win, heads you lose situation?

That's a fair point. Though the truckers are just an example.

I just don't think the charter offers guarantees anywhere as strong as the US constitution. For example, Canada's hate speech laws have taken a big chunk out of both the right to free speech and now the freedom of religion[1] set out in the charter.

[1] https://www.cccb.ca/media-release/proposed-restrictions-on-r...

AlexandrB··on Canadians are running out of time to oppose Bill C-22
Politically or economically? Because economically Canada is headed to the bottom of the G20.

https://www.bcbc.com/insight/oecd-predicts-canada-will-be-th...

AlexandrB··on Canadians are running out of time to oppose Bill C-22
> Are there lots of examples in Canada of basic charter rights being violated in such a manner?

Plenty, it's just usually against unpopular targets. The most notable recent one being the trucker protest[1]. And what were the consequences for those in charge for this charter violation? I believe the answer is "nothing".

So what we have in Canada is a charter that theoretically protects citizens, but in practice can be violated by the government with impunity.

[1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/emergencies-act-federal-cou...

AlexandrB··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
I've given up on all streaming services because none of them offer a model where my money goes to the artists I listen to and not to Taylor Swift and other top-40 nonsense. Switching completely to Plex + PlexAmp + Bandcamp + iTunes purchased music (it's DRM free). It helps that I have ~300 CDs to kick start my library.
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
It's a trade-off. You get bigger scope and better production values at the cost of creative control. Often that also means that the gameplay gets diluted or dumbed down to make the game more marketable.
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
Oh absolutely, but fans should not expect good games to continue at that point.
AlexandrB··on MPs moving to restrict gambling ads in Canada
Modern sports gambling ads amount to fraud because winners are prevented from winning more through wager restrictions. The whole industry can only exist because it cheats and lies.
AlexandrB··on No more icons in every menu by default
I don't think you can credit Windows 95 to agile when the agile manifesto was first published in 2001 and the whole sprint nonsense didn't start until sometime later. Iterative development goes back to at least the 80s and doesn't require "scrum masters", "sprints", or "t-shirt sizes".
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
It's definitely a balancing act. There are some great cinematic games (Last of Us), but it's also easy to put all the focus on the cinematic aspects and have a bunch of mediocre gameplay as filler in between. I don't understand why more games didn't go the Half Life 2 route and have the conversation/cinematic play out around you without taking control away completely.
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
I think the core issue is bad writing. All of that other stuff is only a problem because it's written with the subtlety of a sledgehammer to the face. In many cases the writing reduces characters to their identity group instead of being believable humans with believable motivations.
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
I think the best way to keep quality up is to stay small. Supergiant Games is a great example of this approach. Once you have a massive publisher and expectations to ship AAA (or, heaven forbid, AAAA) games it's usually just a matter of time.
AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
The US gaming industry has serious Hollywood envy. There's a constant push to make games "cinematic" and put big name actors in leading roles. This not only bloats budgets but results in barely-interactive monstrosities where gameplay is just a bridge between long, non-interactive cutscenes.

It's ironic because Hollywood is not doing too well at the moment.

AlexandrB··on EA is shutting down BioWare
This is a reach. Not because the Saudis don't want to influence the direction of games, but because Bioware has had such a run of embarrassing flops over the past decade that I'm surprised they stuck around this long. Peak Bioware was probably Mass Effect 2 and it's all been downhill from there.
AlexandrB··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
This is such a common story across different conservation domains that I no longer trust the green movement. I think many of them are motivated by a sense of moral superiority rather than by actual concern for the environment.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00063...

> In 1997, the National Wildlife Institute, in co-operation with the University of Turin, produced an action plan to eradicate the American grey squirrel from Italy, as this introduced species replaces the native red squirrel through competitive exclusion and damages trees through de-barking. The first step, a trial eradication of a small population of grey squirrels at Racconigi (Turin) to evaluate the efficiency of the removal techniques, started in May 1997. Preliminary results showed that eradication was feasible, but the project was opposed by radical animal rights groups which took the National Wildlife Institute to court in June 1997. This legal action caused a suspension of the project and led to a lengthy judicial enquiry that ended in July 2000 with the acquittal of the Institute. Nevertheless, the 3-year suspension of all actions led to a significant expansion of the grey squirrel's range and thus eradication is no longer considered practical.

AlexandrB··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
Good for you. I'm sure that makes you feel really good about yourself.

I wonder though, do you think the animals care about your integrity or whether your message actually affects change?

AlexandrB··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
Plastic straws are simply emblematic of the environmental movement as a whole. "Political capital" is not infinite, folks will only tolerate so much disruption to their lives. Going after plastic straws instead of something more consequential was a mistake.
AlexandrB··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
Why did Alberta ban plastic straws then? There are approximately zero beaches here.
AlexandrB··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
Exactly this. Living standards are closely correlated to energy use and no one is going to volunteer to live in poverty.

The environmental movement does itself no favours either by pursuing high social cost but low impact interventions like paper straws and ignoring (or outright vilifying) nuclear as a viable path forward.

Finally, there's a huge disconnect between the (supposed) low cost of renewables and what people experience on the ground. Countries like Germany are a good example of this. The constant refrain is that solar and wind are super cheap and are running more and more of the country, but those savings (if real) don't make it to the average rate payer. Something is clearly wrong here. Either the cost claims are incomplete and don't factor in something important or the auction mechanism used to set prices must be discarded. But the disparity between claiming massive cost benefits while having people pay more sours the public on the technology and destroys credibility.

AlexandrB··on I no longer care to work on any Ruby gems so I've archived all my repositories
Forget robots, what you're describing already happened in the trades. Modern construction techniques are all about lowering the skill required to build a house and standardizing the process so it can be done with minimal training. E.g. drywall and caulk replacing plaster and precise joinery.

You can find example of this in all of the trades. Often, these are also talked about as "safety improvements" - which they sort of are. Given the same baseline intelligence, it's harder to dangerously fuck up plumbing or electrical in 2026 than it was in 1926.

AlexandrB··on Tesla Roadster
It's a numbers game. As much time as Waymo had been on the road, it has not been long enough to hit a "drunk driver running red light" situation. It'll happen eventually.
AlexandrB··on Tesla Roadster
Unless you have to replace the battery, then it's probably $20k just for that.
AlexandrB··on Tesla Roadster
$6k maintenance per year? That's crazy high, where are you getting that number?
AlexandrB··on Tesla Roadster
> Wild that they devoted so much effort to an economically completely infeasible model.

If this ships, it will deliver a fraction of what's promised here. My money is on the "flying" version being delayed repeatedly until it's quietly cancelled. Anyone remember the fast battery change stations[1]?

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oj6LaYFall4

AlexandrB··on US Rep Announces Congressional Legislation to Protect Video Game Ownership
You're dreaming. Prepare for DMCA2, where it will be illegal to run an LLM on a compiled binary for the purposes of decompiling under penalty of jail time.
AlexandrB··on New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing
Surely, the user is doing all the hard work. The scale or whatever is just a tool to do so - like a ruler. Imagine if your measuring tape put the measurements you take behind a paywall.
AlexandrB··on New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing
The V in IOT stands for Value.

The E in IOT stands for Ethics.

AlexandrB··on Siri is so bad at everything
Yeah, the lack of memory is a huge problem - makes it impossible to conversationally correct a mistake. Instead, you have to start the interaction from the top and hope that this time it works out.
AlexandrB··on Siri is so bad at everything
That's also what drives me absolutely insane - I want a guide from Apple that gives me a regular syntax I can use to get predictable results with Siri. The fuzzy, natural language stuff in Siri is so bad that it's completely unpredictable what will work.
AlexandrB··on Siri is so bad at everything
The #1 reason is while driving. It's also the only reason I have Siri enabled at all since you can't use CarPlay without enabling it.

Edit: There are other cases where hands are not free as well - like cooking - where it's useful to be able to start music or add a todo.

AlexandrB··on Switzerland proposes banning profiling-based ads to minors
I don't know, but is "free journalism" actually good? If the incentives of free journalism (thanks to being ad funded) are to increase engagement and avoid criticizing their advertisers is the product actually journalism at all?
Page 1 of 34Next →