HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Avenger42

738 karma · joined September 9, 2009

submissionscomments
Avenger42··on YouTube removes hundreds of the best climate science videos from the Internet
That's probably just so that it'll show up in their store.
Avenger42··on Data from man's pacemaker led to arson charges
> Should we even have to consider that a pacemaker could be used to gather data about us before we consent to a pacemaker? It shouldn't.

Your pacemaker gathers that data (exertion history over time) so that your doctor can view it after the fact and ask you "what were you doing last Thursday afternoon? The pacemaker says it was running extra high between 3:30 and 4:30."

I think most people would opt into such a device for their own health - in fact, many might wear it on their wrist and pair it with their phone.

Avenger42··on Data from man's pacemaker led to arson charges
From the article:

> Compton, who has extensive medical problems, including an artificial heart implant that uses an eternal pump

(I'm fairly certain they meant "external" there.)

Avenger42··on John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying
The issue with having experts on the jury is twofold:

- If they're experts in the field, they may have had enough interaction with the case in question (or the people involved in the case) to have formed an opinion without having heard any testimony

- Due to their expertise, the jury could decide "it's easier (more convenient, more likely to be correct, etc) to defer to the expert" and just vote whichever way the expert votes

By not having experts, everyone makes their own decisions on how to weight different pieces of evidence, and no one's opinion drowns out anyone else's (at least, any more than would have happened anyway with that particular jury).

Avenger42··on John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying
Ignoring the idea of a corporation being judged by other corporations, the idea that "peers" should be judged more strictly (i.e., limited to "people in similar situations" monetarily, professionally, etc.), I feel like you would run a very clear risk of creating juries that function similarly to "good-old-boy networks" that are unwilling to judge too harshly.
Avenger42··on Show HN: Arrived – Stack Overflow for US Immigration
Try this link instead:

https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/106514

If you change the proposal # to 106514, it instead redirects to your link with 106514 as the question instead:

https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/106513/parliament...

So that ID is used for both proposals and questions within area51.

Avenger42··on Show HN: Arrived – Stack Overflow for US Immigration
There's nothing wrong with a site that says "we can answer typical questions about A, B, and C, but we can't answer questions that require legal advice, so please don't ask those or we'll close them". That's how they handle it at the Workplace SE site.
Avenger42··on Show HN: Arrived – Stack Overflow for US Immigration
> I'm a believer than an app always outdoes a "mobile-friendly" site.

On the other hand, the website is available on all platforms. An app is typically only available on whatever platform(s) the creator thinks is/are most valuable.

Avenger42··on Trump Fires Acting Attorney General
Even in such a case, the AG should be free to ignore the recommendation and say "sure, we've got enough evidence, but we're not going to pursue it". For example, if the charge is minor enough, or if the optics of it look bad, or the person in question were already being prosecuted by a different office, they could tell the FBI Director they weren't going to bother, and then go hold a press conference to explain why (so that the FBI Director doesn't beat you to the press to say "we've got them dead to rights and they won't prosecute for [X] reasons!").
Avenger42··on A Sumo Matchup Centuries in the Making
Sure, you can write that story too, but this author seems more interested in across-the-eras comparison stories, like the one he linked comparing Peyton Manning to other great quarterbacks.
Avenger42··on Dispute at Harvard leads to a restraining order against a prominent scientist
I'm only going by what's in the judge's finding, which states:

> "Plaintiff has submitted other affidavits and emails based on personal knowledge of others, all of which support that plaintiff then had no mental health issues or concerns"

This immediately followed the line:

> "Defendants submitted affidavits from five of those 35, two of whom included Muela and Grass, one of the three alleged to have knowingly participated with Rubin in the alleged scientific misconduct and her boyfriend."

Which, to me, suggests that the first 5 affidavits did allege that he had "mental health issues or concerns".

Three of those five can be dismissed:

> The "fear" that three of the lab members expressed concerning German appears, at least to this court, exaggerated.

The other two could be explained as "Rubin's retaliation was getting to German, and two people were worried enough about German that they wrote 'he might have a mental health issue or concern' in an affidavit" - although multiple others were willing to say, either in affidavits or emails, "he's fine".

The other two could also be explained as "Rubin wrote an affidavit for them to sign, and stood there until they signed it" - given that Rubin was found to have retaliated against German, would it be within his character to similarly terrorize other lab members? I don't know, and I don't need to know - the judge's finding seems to me to strongly suggest that the only reason German's mental health was brought into question was because Rubin intentionally raised it.

Plus, if you're willing to say "pissing off 5 out of 35 makes him an asshole", would you say the same about "pissing off 2 out of 35"? Or what about "worrying 2 out of 35", since we don't know what their affidavits actually said?

Avenger42··on Dispute at Harvard leads to a restraining order against a prominent scientist
> to see the higher authorities side with the person that started the problems just to look politically correct and go against the "installed power"

From the judge's opinion:

"I accept that at least Rubin, as PI for plaintiff and a number of grad students and because he is head of the Rubin Lab, brings in a lot of funding and has a lot of authority at Harvard. So much authority that Cardozo would likely be deferential and not interfere with Rubin's choice to dismiss a grad student."

Avenger42··on Dispute at Harvard leads to a restraining order against a prominent scientist
> Let's remember that he had problems with other people inside the team, not only with the PI.

Note that the judge specifically said this:

"It does not appear to be disputed that at all relevant times the lab members were approximately 35 in number. Defendants submitted affidavits from five of those 35, two of whom included Muela and Grass, one of the three alleged to have knowingly participated with Rubin in the alleged scientific misconduct and her boyfriend. Plaintiff has submitted other affidavits and emails based on personal knowledge of others, all of which support that plaintiff then had no mental health issues or concerns."

So out of 35 people in the lab, only five submitted affidavits, and three of those were connected to the original complaint. German submitted (an unknown number of) affidavits and emails in support of his position.

Avenger42··on Dispute at Harvard leads to a restraining order against a prominent scientist
> It is interesting that this article mentions German was with his parents as well. That swayed me a bit against believing that German was the real victim.

This confuses me. I don't see how his parents being present affects the story.

Avenger42··on Interview with Chris Lattner [audio]
Apparently the place to get answers is the Swift evolution mailing list - they mentioned it several times.
Avenger42··on Interview with Chris Lattner [audio]
> I just don't get the yellow car bit at all.

Note that it was actually a "white car" bit. Casey, Marco and John originally did a podcast called Neutral which was about cars, and the very first line of the first episode was Marco quizzing Casey on why he only seemed to buy white cars. White cars have become synonymous with Casey ever since, and Marco took the opportunity to bring it up again with Chris.

Link: http://neutral.fm/episodes/1-big-fat-and-bloated

(Technically, the question was "what is it that makes somebody buy a white car?")

Avenger42··on Pardon Edward Snowden
The statement says Ellard had "previously retaliated" against a whistleblower - but no timeframe is given. Unless other information is given out[1], who's to say that that activity didn't happen before Snowden's actions, and that Snowden could look at that retaliation and decide not to report anything to Ellard?

Even if not, Thomas Drake is a prime example of what happened to whistleblowers at the NSA - and Drake was an employee, who (theoretically) had access to greater whistleblower protections than Snowden would have had as a contractor[2].

So yes, I'm saying that it's very easy to believe that Snowden took a look at what happened to NSA whistleblowers and took a different path.

[1]: from the POGO story: "POGO has been told that mention of the finding will appear in a semiannual report (SAR) of the Intelligence Community IG (ICIG) that should be released in the near future. It makes brief mention of the case without citing Ellard by name." So we may get some more information about timeframes at some point.

[2]: From TechDirt (https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20161215/16354636293/snowd...) today: "The new directive created better protections but would have done nothing to aid Snowden in taking his complaints to the proper channels because he was only a government contractor, not an actual government employee."

Avenger42··on Pardon Edward Snowden
You mean the IG that is facing termination for retaliating against other whistleblowers?

http://www.pogo.org/blog/2016/12/intelligence-community-land...

Avenger42··on MacBook Pro
The new keyboard has less key travel, not more. From the Macbook page:

> So we designed a unique butterfly mechanism, which is wider than the scissor mechanism and has a single assembly made from a stiffer material — allowing for a more stable, responsive key that takes up less vertical space.

Avenger42··on CA Comodo used broken OCR and issued certificates to the wrong people
Yes, apparently I should have been more specific.

To be fair to Keverw, it's easy to think that I meant to reply to dman's post and was asking what the term meant.

Avenger42··on How Evan McMullin Could Win Utah and the Presidency
This has been posted a couple of times before; see earlier discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12708344
Avenger42··on CA Comodo used broken OCR and issued certificates to the wrong people
Chargeback?
Avenger42··on Shame on Y Combinator
> I disagree that Trump would be such a shoe-in for 2020. The Democrats just need a better candidate.

Note that it's almost unheard-of for the sitting president not to run for a second term. (I certainly can't remember a case in my short life.) So either Trump or Clinton will almost certainly be on the ballot in 4 years.

Avenger42··on Agents See FBI Chief Comey as a ‘Dirty Cop’: FBI in Revolt
There's a grand total of one source for an article about the FBI being "in revolt", and he's not even an FBI agent. They can't get a single one to confirm, even off the record?
Avenger42··on AT&T, Apple, Google to work on 'robocall' crackdown
That's exactly what I've been doing for years. I also gave it a custom ringtone that's 4 seconds of silence and turned vibration off, so unless I'm actually doing something with my phone, or else listening to music, I don't notice the interruption.

The issue is that nowadays, I rarely get spam from the same numbers multiple times. They just generate a new fake number if the first one didn't get a response.

Avenger42··on State Dept.: Clinton IT aide's email archive is lost
His public service career may have ended, but he got gigs at several private firms, as well as Harvard, Exeter, and several other universities.

I think most people believe it's unlikely Clinton will serve any time for the email lapse; instead, she's considered the front-runner for the White House.

On the other hand, Snowden had to flee the country and, like Assange, he may never be able to set foot in a country with the relevant extradition treaties.

I think the high/low court point still stands.

Avenger42··on State Dept.: Clinton IT aide's email archive is lost
> purposely disclosing classified information like Snowden did will result in prison

Not necessarily. General Petraeus purposely handed over documents to his biographer / girlfriend, and he got nothing more than a slap on the wrist.

It seems again to be a high court / low court thing. If you're important enough, your crimes get you lesser sentences, but if not, they throw the book at you.

Avenger42··on SpaceX Launch Livestream: CRS-8 Dragon Hosted Webcast
The landing takes place at approximately 36 minutes into the video.
Avenger42··on PayPal Withdraws Plan for Charlotte Expansion
> I won't even get into the impact on stockholders who buy the stock to, in general, make money with their investments not for social issues.

Several years ago, in response to a request that Apple commit to only agree to measures that wouldn't impact the bottom line, Tim Cook told an activist investor "If you want me to do things only for ROI reasons, you should get out of this stock." (It was in response to a question about Apple's environmental stance, but Tim likened it to a request to ignore accessibility issues.)

If I disagree with Paypal's disagreement, I'm free to withdraw my investment and go to a company that will ignore social issues.

Avenger42··on [dead]
Posted earlier here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11423411
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →