130 karma · joined March 29, 2014
>4. This law will allow some kids to have a normal metabolism and a normal life. Nothing more. Nothing less.
But the objection of Dr. Morrow is that the procedure may have risks for the children involved (and their children also). Whenever there are risks as well as benefits, there needs to be a discussion as to what is ethical.
>Since modern economics is focussed on greed and selfishness...
is shallow
>What exactly is rational about a system which centuries of history have proven is unable to function without a predictable cycle of manic-depressive booms, recessions/depressions, and anti-democratic bailouts?
Economists claim individuals are rational, not that the whole system is "rational". Rational individuals interacting could result in a really shitty result, which is bascically what macroeconomics is about.
Depressions suck, that is why macro-economists try to smooth out the business cycle. The fact the we needed the latest bailout is a sign they haven't solved this problem yet. But I don't have a better solution.
One of the main goals of economics is to provide advise for government policy to make society better off (by some average of human well-being). I would say it takes more spirit to choose the discipline than can and does do this, than to fall for shallow critiques from outside the discipline.
According to economics, all people are selfish (or self-interested if you prefer an less loaded term). How then can we make the world better when we are only interested in ourselves?
First, economics shows that in many cases, all individuals working for their own interests works as well as if everyone cared only about the common good. This is the first and second welfare theorems of economics.
Second, to the extend that we are altruistic, we should focus that altruism in an efficient way. For example, giving to someone slightly less wealthy than yourself is less efficient than giving to someone a lot less wealthy than yourself. And altruism exists not just in giving money, but also donating time and effort to maintaining the social institutions that benefit all of us. Given my experience with economists, they may actually be more altruistic when measured this way. And a rational person might choose to engage in the latter kind of altruism, while giving zero dollars to charity, since they already "give" money through the tax system.
Finally, given all of the above, economists tend to allow themselves the freedom not to feel altruistic. From a utilitarian perspective, what is needed is not so much more altruism, but more efficient use of people's existing altruistic feelings.
Even the data-cleaning that the author claims is missing from Kaggle competitions, is not really missing, it's just Kaggle have made your data cleaning much simpler.
The main advice I would give is to find a problem where you can get an understanding of the data, i.e. not just treat it like a black box.
Military spending may or may not be justified, but if the whole world cut all military spending, it's not like space travel would get dibs on that money.
Space travel has to justify its existence on its on terms. Right now I'm pretty happy with NASA's science based program. The Mars rover strikes me as a great way to get a lot of science for the money, and learn a lot about operating autonomous robots in space.
The programming language used to create a program does not directly affect the user.
The skill of an artist does does directly affect the viewer of art.
If you’re a parent, you should be absolutely terrified that a 9-year-old’s constitutional right to fire an Uzi trumps your right to decide at what age your kids can play at the park unsupervised.
Something has to change. Now.
I would have liked to have more detail on his critique of the "guess and check" approach to science. My own opinion is that there is a very good reason why scientific progress follows the pattern he describes, of new theories being based on either new experiments, or in depth analysis of existing theories.
The reason is that science relies on belief in objective reality, and yet we don't know what objective reality is. So in order to reason about what the universe really is, the best and only starting point is our current model(s) of physics.
The moment we make an assumption about what reality is that isn't based in physical theory, we are liable to be wrong. For example, Newton was criticized for his theory of gravity, because people knew that reality was composed of little machine-like objects, interacting at a microscopic scale. There was no room in this worldview for Newton's "occult" force of gravity which acted at a distance.
It would make a big difference if they were ordinary users, vs maintainers of other important libraries of pieces of software.
While everyone deserves their say, this issue seems somewhat subjective, and a package maintainer shouldn't have to pay undue attention to individual users who don't necessarily represent the whole community.
To summarize my problem with the article: it claims that the second amendment should not be used as a reason to allow 9 year olds to do dangerous activities like shooting automatic weapons. And yet nowhere does the article cite (or even describe) someone citing the 2nd amendment in this debate. The article doesn't say that the police used the 2nd amendment as a reason not to charge the girl's parents. It doesn't show the the 2nd amendment prevented laws against 9 year olds shooting guns in firing ranges. It doesn't cite people using the 2n amendment as a reason to defend the girl's parents.
However, you are overstating the case for the author's having dealt with reverse causality. From the conclusion:
When we addressed causality in IV estimates, the significance of the correlation between participation in social networking sites and subjective well-being disappeared.
See my top level comment for my own take on the article.
The authors find that social network usage has a negative correlation with happiness.
To control for unhappy people turning to social networks (reverse causality), the use instrumental variables (IV). This involves finding an instrument, that is something that causes people to use social networks more/less in a quasi-random way. Their instrument is availability of DSL. I'm not sure how they deal with DSL availability also affecting happiness through other mechanisms (e.g. general internet usage). In any case, the correlation between social network usage and happiness is not significant once they use the IV strategy.
They then use a method I'm not familiar with (structural equation modelling, SEM) to obtain some other results which are discussed in the abstract.
I believe that the abstract (and the popular article discussing it) should have mentioned the insignificance of the correlation when using the IV strategy, since I doubt many casual readers would by able to critically evaluate the SEM strategy (which yielded the results that the abstract and journalistic article discussed).
It's not clear that even 100% coverage would have picked up this bug, since it doesn't automatically appear as a result of taking a particular code path.
I think that comparing to a naive algorithm on a large number of strings, or using a fuzzing tool, might be helpful, but this might also slow down the test suite excessively.
I find unit tests are a bit like good form at the gym. Whenever someone gets injured, they think back to the last exercise they did and find some imperfection in their form. They then attribute their injury to not using perfect form. Similarly, whenever a bug appears, there is a tendency to find a unit test that would have caught the bug, and therefore attribute it to insufficient testing.
The real value of testing (and good form) can only be demonstrated by having a criteria for good testing and seeing if following this reduces the number of bugs.
I'm not saying that a desire to look down on and judge other people doesn't bias people's views on obesity. But the main reason people believe that "people are all fat because they can't control themselves" is that there are so many individual stories of people losing weight by following a diet.
When I was a child, I was told that I was very smart (which I was) and pressured to fulfill my potential. Other children may be pressured to be hard working and studious. I would rather celebrate people who are naturally gifted, and also people who choose to work hard. What is important is that people's actions arise naturally from their own desires, not from external pressure or manipulation.
So a particular claim about the state of the world, e.g. "obesity is caused by a psychological propensity to overconsume, which can be controlled", simply cannot be true, because it might cause some people to justify a dismissive and callous attitude towards people with obesity?
That is what the logic of your statement sounds like to me.
>The correlation is moderate, so our findings are interesting
A fair comment
>but it does not mean that parents should worry if their child draws badly.
Just an irrelevant disclaimer.
>Drawing ability does not determine intelligence, there are countless factors, both genetic and environmental, which affect intelligence in later life.
Just a disclaimer to rule out "determinism", which is itself a meaningless concept in the probabilistic world we live in. Given the correlation they discovered, it is accurate to say that drawing ability predicts intelligence to some degree.
While this increases the total output of society, it also increases inequality.
We already have in place mechanisms to deal with inequality, namely income tax and welfare. As the total output of society grows, we will be able to afford more generous kinds of welfare, until eventually we probably settle on a negative income tax scheme.
Note that a correctly designed welfare system wouldn't result in lots of people living on welfare, but rather everyone working fewer hours.
So I imagine that the future could be quite good, as long as our methods for redistributing wealth are able to keep pace with technological change (and there are some great examples to follow in the Western world, e.g. Scandinavia, Australia and NZ)
If they tend to be the same people involved and they tend to coordinate their actions the same way each time, then it is fair to say they are a single entity.
This is basically my view on this matter. We can only take for granted the existence of the objective universe. Everything else must be derived from experiment, including concepts that seem fundamental like time or causality.
One interesting thing about causality is that the fact that the macroscopic world obeys cause-and-effect laws is usually attributed to the second law of thermodynamics. But where does the second law of thermodynamics come from? I've heard it stated (can't say if this is universally held by physicists) that the second law of thermodynamics holds because the initial state of the universe had very low entropy, while the final state of the universe will have very high entropy. That is the second law of thermodynamics is "caused" by both the initial and final states of the universe. So causality and time are something that we don't fully understand yet.
Individual events like this could be cherry picked, so I don't know if they are good evidence or not. If I wasn't convinced by the science I described above, I don't think I would be convinced by this, unless it was accompanied by a similarly rigorous statistical analysis.
We happen to live in a world where sometimes things can be ascribed specific causes, but that is due to the nature of the physical universe, not an abstract truth.
Causality in our best theories of physics (general relativity, quantum field theory) is extremely complex and subtle. But that isn't needed anyway, what we use in ordinary reasoning is "naive" physics, an approximation of physical reality. I don't think this "naive physics", which we could also call common sense, can be derived from a statistical model, although maybe it can.
Going back to the randomized trial, presumably the choice to give a drug to a patient vs a placebo was determined by a random number generator. This in turn is a physical process, and there is no reason why the physical process that generates this number could not also influence a person's health outcome. It is only our naive physics model that tells us that there is no such process, and the only way the random number generator affects the health outcome, is through the choice of drug.
So to summarize, doing causal inference relies on a model of reality, and this model is sufficiently complex that the model itself cannot (for now) be derived through purely statistical means, but rather is arrived at through ordinary human thought.
For example, take a randomized trial, where half of patients are given a drug, and half a placebo. If we define Y to be the outcome of interest, and X to be 0 when the patient received the placebo and 1 when they received the drug, then a positive outcome would be a correlation between X and Y. A person might object that "correlation does not imply causation", however, we know enough about the causal process involved, to infer that if Y and X are correlated, this must be because X caused Y.
There are many other ways that causation can be inferred, such as instrumental variables, regression discontinuity, or panel regressions. However all these methods require making an assumption about the causal process underlying the statistical distribution. Whether these assumptions are correct is often a matter for debate.
When I directly answer why it wouldn't, you act as if I was supposed to be explaining addressing the ethics, and that my answer betrays me as callous and uncaring.
But you didn't make the argument that society should avoid "pulling the rug from under people" for its own sake, regardless of its affect on motivation to work. So I didn't address that point.
I did, however, explain precisely the ethics of my viewpoint in my original post, you just chose not to address this, and took the easy way out by focusing on a technical issue (the effect on people's motivation to work) and then pretending I had failed to address a moral issue that you raised.