HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TFortunato

778 karma · joined January 23, 2011

I build robots.

Current: Staff Robotics Engineer at Chewy

Prior: Atlas @ Boston Dynamic; Robotics and Embedded Systems Engineering @ Amazon Robotics, Rethink Robotics, iRobot; Automation Engineering @ Ginkgo Bioworks.

Early Career: Electrical Engineer in Semiconductor Industry @ Applied Materials, Analog Devices, Allegro Microsystems

submissionscomments
TFortunato··on TSA Says Theyre Not Discriminating Against Black Women but Body Scanners May Be
Sure, and personally I'm not saying they literally set a bunch of engineers out to build a machine to explicitly target black people. I am saying that they probably didn't put the same level of testing there in that they did against disproportionately targeting white men in business suits when they were pitching investors and getting senators / the people who sign the checks to buy these things.

Or maybe they just didn't think about testing the machines against the diversity of actual people who go through an airport daily vs. who was available in the office at the time to test with.

Maybe they honestly believe that folks with natural black hairstyles, or who wear a 'turban' or ponytail, could be disproportionately hiding something suspicious up there, and we need a machine to tell us to check them out more often.

Hell, maybe they just didn't care at all who got flagged, as long as it didn't inconvenience them too much and they got paid at the end of the day. I mean they sure as shit don't mind the reality that this really does seem to be a lot of security theater with little benefit, besides the benefits to some peoples wallets.

Whether you want to define any of that as deliberate malice, willful ignorance, laziness, the banality of evil, or something else, is entirely up to your own values I suppose.

TFortunato··on TSA Says Theyre Not Discriminating Against Black Women but Body Scanners May Be
I mean, it is an option.

The machine is one part of a hugely flawed system, and I think its totally valid to argue that we shouldn't be substituting a machine for, I dunno, actual human judgement.

The machine in this case doesn't seem to be demonstrably solving any problems, but it is disproportionately flagging black people, people with hair coverings ('turbans' in the article), etc. as suspicious, and that flagging is being used as part of a procedure to single those people out for further scrutiny. These systems don't seem to be solving any problems, and I'm not seeing a lot of defensible positions of why it should work that way, besides "eh, that's just how it is"

TFortunato··on TSA Says Theyre Not Discriminating Against Black Women but Body Scanners May Be
So can we agree that the system (which I'm taking to mean the combination of tech, people and procedure) is doing a really shit job then, because, beyond not doing what it's supposed to do, it's disproportionately singling out certain races?

Perhaps if it's singling out dense hair vs. actual places where people are hiding something, despite any evidence being presented that it's useful to do so, we should... I dunno, not use it? Definitely not spend millions of dollars on it.

I'm not sure what problem it's solving, when the solution involves humans mindlessly following a procedure, that dictates that a machine that happens to single out black hair and 'turbans' decides someone is suspect.

TFortunato··on TSA Says Theyre Not Discriminating Against Black Women but Body Scanners May Be
Just because the technology isn't explicitly designed as a 'single out black people' machine, doesn't mean that it isn't disproportionately affecting them due to how it is being used. Just because this imaging technology can't tell the difference between dense hair and explosives does not make someone's thick hair, or hair covering "an area of suspect density" that should automatically be flagged for more invasive searchs.

It's definitely trying to split some really fine hairs to be saying 'actually, it isn't discriminating against black people, it's discriminating against hair types that are highly correlated with being a black person, and it's totally acceptable that people with those hair types should be considered suspect / subject to further scrutiny', as if that is some sort of edge case that couldn't have possibly be thought about beforehand.

I absolutely don't think we should be defending a tech / procedure that only seems to be negatively affecting people, costs millions, and doesn't seem to have any positives effects,

TFortunato··on TSA Says Theyre Not Discriminating Against Black Women but Body Scanners May Be
The reason it is an issue is because the TSA is disproportionately singling out people for more invasive searches under the guise of, "we have this shitty technology that can't tell the difference between explosives and black hair or a 'turban', and that's what the procedure tells us to do." Just because it isn't designed to explicitly 'single out black people', that was the outcome of using this combination of technology and procedure.

To top it all off, we are all paying millions of dollars for this, via taxes for some fancy security theater to tell us, whether there is the "ability to hide contraband", which seems utterly insane.

TFortunato··on U.S. Supreme Court Puts Limits on Police Power to Seize Private Property
On reading, this sounds a lot to me like "trial by a jury of one's peers", only the response to the system being (choked for democratic consultations / having massive court backups and shortage of jurors) has unfortunately so far been mostly public apathy, and people being pushed into accepting plea deals / waiving their rights for a jury trial in many cases.

EDIT: I dont say this to be snarky. On the contrary, the idea of "law's being applied equally" being enforced by citizens exercising their powers democratically, vs. the whims of one judge, is really appealing, and explains a lot of why we supposedly have things like jury trials being a right for all.

It's just unfortunate that the reality is, we are trying to do this, but if you look at folks who are actually trying to highlight things like discrimination in the system or "hey, maybe we arent applying these laws equally"...well the response they get for doing that isn't always what one would hope for from an enlightened body of citizens.

TFortunato··on Ask HN: Is it just me or is the AMP project making everything slower?
It would be really nice if we started using URIs / URNs more instead of URLs for everything, and did a better job of separating "what" from "where"
TFortunato··on Ask HN: Is it just me or is the AMP project making everything slower?
What bothers me about this argument is that there are plenty of other ways to make a news site fast...like just using straight static html content and minimizing JS usage.

See http://text.npr.org or http://lite.cnn.io for example

TFortunato··on Underclocking the ESP8266 Leads to WiFi Weirdness
Thanks for the correction! Been a while since I looked at wireless stuff, but on checking it was 802.11b that used DSSS, but newer 802.11 standards use different modulation techniques.
TFortunato··on Underclocking the ESP8266 Leads to WiFi Weirdness
Semi-educated guess: 802.11 is a spread-spectrum signal, where you take your information, and use it to modulate a much faster "noise" signal. (Which is then used to modulate the carrier wave)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-sequence_spread_spect...

My guess is that by underclocking the PLL, you are slowing down to pseudo-noise signal, so it will have a narrower bandwidth. The 2.4 GHz carrier is generated separately, so is unaffected by lowering this clock. The overall effect would be that your RF signal is still centered in the same carrier, but the signal looks narrower.

TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
Yep - and there are absolutely some cases where you do want to manually use it which is why the x86_64 ABI on SysV (used by Linux and OS X, still specifies the long double type as 80-bits, and why GCC and Clang will still emit these instructions when long doubles are used!

(Sorry, this is more for the folks who aren't familiar with this, since it seems like you are familiar, but I didn't want it to seem like this isn't widely supported when they read "legacy" or "some platforms")

Here is a good toy examples that runs into the same numbers shown in the parent, showing the two different instruction types, and that long double can give you the correct answer, while still being run in hardware, vs. going all the way to float128s which are currently emulated in software!

Code w/ Assembly: https://godbolt.org/z/W3ZmqJ Output: https://onlinegdb.com/Sy_I3Q1ME

TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
Fair point, I was a little fast and loose with my words there, which is definitely dangerous when it comes to things like C language / ABI standards! :-P
TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
Yeah I agree that everything typically runs in XMM registers and that's what people want. I'm not sure what about the availability of extended precision makes it s a misfeature? For some cases it IS what you want, and it's nice to be able to opt in to using it..

EDIT: If I had some application where I needed the extended range, like maybe I was going to run into the exact numbers above, I'd appreciate the ability to opt-in to this. Totally agree I wouldn't want the compiler to surprise me with it, but also not terrible, or useless.

Code w/ Assembly: https://godbolt.org/z/W3ZmqJ Output: https://onlinegdb.com/Sy_I3Q1ME

TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
Long doubles are typically 80-bit x87 "extended precision" doubles as far as I've seen. (Except on windows :-P ). It's part of the reason why LLVM has the 80 bit float type.

https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/language/types

https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/size-of-long-integ...

They are definitely still supported in modern Intel processors. That said, there can be some confusion because they end up being padded to 16 bytes for alignment reasons, so take 128 bits of memory, but they are still only 10 byte types.

They are a distinct type from the "quad" precision float128 type, which is software emulated as you mentioned.

All that being said, you are right that most of the time float math ends up in SSE style instructions, but as soon as you add long doubles to the mix, the compiler will emit x87 style float instructions to gain the extra precision.

Example: https://godbolt.org/z/PMZVdb

TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
How do you mean? The x86-64 instruction set / abi specifies long doubles as 80-bits, and still supports them ...
TFortunato··on 9999999999999999.0 – 9999999999999998.0
So interestingly, processor makers are on the same page with you re: computations, and lots of processors can internally do computations in "extended precision", e.g. 80-bit floats, only converting to/from 64-bit doubles at the start and end of the computation.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_precision

TFortunato··on ‘If It’s Not Broke, Break It’ – The Animation of Spiderman: Into the Spiderverse
(Note: Original title was too long, so I had to crop it)

Very cool article about how traditional animation and cartooning techniques were combined with computer animation to create a really uniquely stylized film.

TFortunato··on A Not-Called Function Can Cause a 5X Slowdown
Unfortunately, this is conflating static linking with bad dependency management. ("Just copy it into your own repo", is a different step, that is unnecessary to do the second step, "and link it statically")

There is no reason I see why you couldn't just have a build that produces the library .a file for zlib, which can then be pulled in as a dependency of your build / linked in statically.

I totally agree, they had a nightmare situation on their hands, but I don't think static linking was solely to blame :-)

TFortunato··on Who Killed Prolog? (2010)
Isn't this exactly what datomic / datalog are?
TFortunato··on Rethink Robotics shuts down
Sad to see them go. I spent just under a year there ~2 years ago doing embedded systems, right before some big layoffs, and I really had a great time there.

It's a great group of people, and I wish them all the best. Judging by the amount of recruiter calls and emails I got today after the news broke (apparently working off my old resume!), I think these folks will land on their feet!

TFortunato··on ARM Assembly Is Too High Level: ROR and RRX
Hah! Glad to know I'm not the only one who reads "undefined" as "why don't you try it and see ;-)"

I have to be a bit more careful though with this one lately, when I'm working on industrial robots vs. the embedded boards I'm used to!

TFortunato··on Bellman's lost in a forest problem
I assumed it was a riff off of the millennium prize problems (which do have a bounty of $1M each), as a way of saying "here are some other very interesting unsolved problems"

http://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/millennium-prize...

TFortunato··on North American vs. Japanese zoning
br3aer1t
TFortunato··on Frida Kahlo and the birth of Fridolatry
Absolutely!

And that's pretty interesting about the "fair skin fetish" in the east, I was unaware of it.

I'm not trying to say that this is because of European colonization, or anything like that. I just think that people use colonization as an understandable metaphor when talking about art or culture, especially w.r.t how it is interpreted & distorted by other possibly more dominant/well-represented cultures.

TFortunato··on Frida Kahlo and the birth of Fridolatry
Gotcha. And to be fair I don't want to just pile on, and criticize your reaction to it.

I understand where you are coming from when you say: How about famous people get interpreted by different cultures differently", but I think it misses the larger point of the article, and the "colonising" quote in particular.

Granted I am not a art guy by any means, but I took it to be referencing the larger concept of "cultural imperialism." In particular, it's the idea that Frida's art, or in this particular case her looks are not good enough, are not able to stand on their own, and therefore we need to tweak them to make them more palatable. So in this case it was "make Frida more sexy" in this ostensibly biographical picture about her, by applying a standard of sexiness and beauty seen by our culture, e.g. "less unibrow..."

In a larger context, I take the idea of "colonising" culture, or the phrase "cultural imperialism" to be referencing similar themes: -that the 'natives' can't do things on their own. - That rich cultural traditions are somehow inferior, or need to be reduced down to a handful of icons w/o understanding of the larger context around them.

I'm probably rambling - again not an art guy, and you can probably find a better reference on the topic than me :-)

EDIT: So something I thought of that might be a good metaphor. On HN, there is often a lot of snark about media representations of "hackers" and tech folks in general, and how they get things wrong, or boil down complex ideas into an overly simplified (and wrong) version, or will try to make something that "looks techy", or 'looks like a hacker' while being clearly ridiculous to actual technologists.

So while again its not the same, there are parallels - Basically this idea that Frida, and 'foreign' artists in general, can be boiled down to a few tropes or symbols to be come this immediately recognizable 'idea-of-frida' or 'idea-of-foreign/exotic-art' while completely discarding the nuance and the actual work / process of the artist.

TFortunato··on Frida Kahlo and the birth of Fridolatry
Maybe I was being a bit snarky, but "Colonising"/"Colonizing" != "Colonializing"/"Colonialising" :-P
TFortunato··on Frida Kahlo and the birth of Fridolatry
What article did you read? The word "colonializing", doesn't appear in this article at all.
TFortunato··on The Soon-To-Be-Extinct Embedded Software Engineer
As someone who held the title of Embedded Systems / Embedded Software engineer at multiple places, just want to respond that optimizing things at the register level is NOT the main focus, or even a sizable amount of what embedded engineering is all about...
TFortunato··on Tesla is hit by $2B patent troll case from Nikola Motors
>"who had ever heard of 'Nikola' before this"

I mean, apparently some large companies like Anheuser-Busch, (people who actually buy trucks) have heard of them, if they announced they are buying up to 800 of them from Nikola...

That said, I do agree that these (and a LOT of design patents) are questionable at best, but I don't have any skin in the game when it comes to the trucking industry.

TFortunato··on Schools Struggle with Vaping Explosion
Sorry to be "that guy", but could you explain what you mean by metal content being negligible unless you dry hit?

I assumed when people were talking about metal content, they were referring to metal vapors from the heating elements or something, but I'll admit that I don't know enough about this, or what a dry hit is vs. normal use, or how we know when metal vapors or whatever are/aren't a concern.

(I feel so old right now, hah!)

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →