14,842 karma · joined October 22, 2008
Former
CEO & Co-founder Faktory.com
Co-Founder Hello Group (Acquired in 2017 by www.thenorthalliance.com)
https://www.linkedin.com/in/thompete/
Square, 80/20, HelloGroup, MetaDesign alumni
Essays: http://www.000fff.org
meet.hn/city/us-New-York
Socials: x.com/hello_world
---
It's being used by many people today. It's not for everyone. It will evolve and at one point we won't even know we are using it.
The thing about blockchain isn't that it isn't that you couldn't build it with "web2" the thing is it would be unfeasible to do so and still maintaining the trust.
By separating the "owners" of the database from what it gets used to verify, things that are a kind of wicked problem or at least a chicken and egg problem become possible.
Here are a couple of examples from my perspective of what is technically doable but practically unfeasible with a proprietary.
https://twitter.com/Hello_World/status/1465382119811784708 https://twitter.com/Hello_World/status/1463539727202754563
I am pretty convinced that the government will be using this sooner or later too, for things that require transparency, but they are not going to be early adopters (in contrast with the internet where they were)
But I am fine with you not seeing this or agreeing. Time will tell, I put my money were my mouth is :)
Whether I will be right time will tell, I am pretty sure I will, and the idea that this is a useless technology is simply a question of vision.
There are plenty of use cases which are theoretically possible with Web2 but not feasible without Blockchain.
Web3 is a special case of wild wild west in a market with way too much money inflating it all, but the fundamental principles about having an open database accessible to everyone is here to stay.
The stock market is down up to 90% in some cases.
You need to think about this when some of the problems there are today get resolved and new generations start building with this as part of the toolbox.
But each to their own. I've just seen this so many times before and I can personally see the use cases, they are just not what most people think they are.
There is plenty of use for it, it's just not the same as for Web2.
People laughed at email, buying online, payment was even illegal in the beginning.
I was also there at the time from the very beginning.
This is the same thing. Hype, then crash then re-construction then normalized.
There is so much use for blockchain especially as infrastructure for society and in 10 years from now we will not even be thinking about it.
It's no different.
Same thing with the first .com bubble. AI have been through this too and is now having a revival.
Blockchain and Web 3 is not going anywhere it will just not be championed by the current generation. The coming will use this as it was the most normal in the world.
Babbage and Lovelace came close but they didn't realize they had (almost) invented a computer they just thought they had invented a calculator. They thought they solved a math problem when in fact they had solved a physics problem.
We could have been traveling between stars by now.
AND
"If there is no difference how could it be based on past experience or whatever?"
These are two different propositions and questions.
Past experiences can tell me that if I see dark clouds then it could mean rain.
I could be wrong, I could be right, but I have no way of calculating the probability of that.
You don't make a probabilistic calculation based on some formula to figure out whether you bring your umbrella with you or not.
You just guess, sometime based on past experience.
Sometime you are right, sometimes you are wrong. But you are always just guessing and no formula will allow you to end up with whatever probability you calculate.
Has nothing to do with probability.
If you can predict that it happens exactly 10% of the time (ex. every 10th time) then you have an explanatory model that can explain why that is and you don't need statistics.
I don't think you are asking what you think you are asking.
The point is that there is no difference between saying.
It either happens or it don't.
And then
There is a 40% chance is happens.
The 40% is not based on anything of consequence to the discussion at hand.
Why use something that is completely separated from what it purports to make claims about?
This is not just unscientific it's an anti-scientific approach.
"Can physics explain that if you put together a glass of water and a glass of ethanol you end up with a mixture of water and ethanol?"
Wouldn't that be chemistry (an emergent property of physics)?
But yes we can explain if it happens and how it happens, if we have a theory for it that have been tested.
If not we will do trial an error/experiments and see what happens.
Can you explain how probability is used in statistical mechanics in a way to contradict what I am saying?
P.S. Thanks for being a sport and talk about this in a truly respectful way.
If you want to understand where I am coming from, I can really recommend David Deutsch talk about probability here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfzSE4Hoxbc
It was a big awakening for me once I realized not only where probability theory came from (not physics) and how engrained it is in our thinking.
Probability can be used to say something about closed systems like a game of poker using a deck of cards.
If 4 aces have been used I know that there will be no more aces dealt. I can explain why there won't be another ace. And even if magically there was one, we can explain that someone cheated or an extra card was accidentally in the deck.
If 3 aces have been dealt and there are 10 cards left there is statistically a 10% chance of me getting an ace, however I have no way of knowing. The card has already been dealt and I will either get it or I wont.
If I play 10 games will I be getting it 1 time? if I play 100 will i be getting i 10 times? I have no way of knowing.
Now if I learn how to read you and know that you blink more often if you get an ace then I have found an explanation for why I might fold. Not based on statistics but because I can read you. I might still be wrong but I have an explanatory model not based on statistics to play against you, one which I might have to adjust if it turned out to be wrong (ex. you know I know so you change behavior) but at least it's providing me with something more tangible (you give clues I might be able to learn how to interpret)
With the probability it's purely based on blind belief, not substantiated by reality.
Now a deck of card is isolated and not really consequential to society.
But now apply this to open systems economics, weather, climate, elections etc. and you will start to see the problems with assuming there is casual connection when you end up turning that into policy.
And the Nobel price giving credit to something that turns out to be wrong isn't really something novel.
It's a metaphysical claim.
There is no causal connection between what i describe the probability of X to be and the probability of X.
You can say it's 50/50 I can say it's 20/80 none of that have any effect on the outcome.
I can either explain the outcome or I cant and adding probability doesn't change that.
Again we are not talking about ex. a deck of cards where there is a set number of cards. We are talking about open ended systems like reality.
At no time does probability help me with figuring out what the outcome is.
I can either explain what will happen or I can't. There is no 50/50. I just don't have the correct explanation i.e. an explanation that is hard to vary.