HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on An average family in Tokyo can own a new house for $850/month
> The first thing to note is that in Japan, housing isn’t an investment. It’s a place to live.

Fixing this can be a major obstacle in countries with inadequate pension systems. In countries where dependency on rising property values is the chief or sole form of retirement planing for vast numbers of people, fixing a broken housing market becomes dependent on fixing the retirement system.

And when land values are consistently propped up by government to a greater degree than other investments, it moves people even more into land speculation as their retirement investment because of its artificial safety.

TomMckenny··on If Sweden succeeds, lockdowns will all have been for nothing
Likewise as it fails, their higher fatality rate helps show what was avoided. Although most countries under lock down could not handle the peak hospitalizations that Sweden can which would mean far more deaths. And one would need to compare Sweden's results to similar countries like others in Scandinavia. And at the moment Sweden's death rate is 6 to 10 times its neighbors[1]. So a success or failure in Sweden is extremely informative but not completely transferable.

Swedes are pretty generous conducting this experiment on their population for the edification of the survivors.

[1]https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/new-covid-deaths-per-mill...

TomMckenny··on Amazon asks workers sheltering at home to return or request leave
If the top comment is a genuine question with neutral tone then so is the similarly phrased "When will Republicans start mass arrests of journalist?" I don't explicitly state a value judgement and I can follow up with "you can't blame them for acting in their self interest". Yet claiming it is a neutral question would obviously be mistaken.

Likewise the claim that "following incentives is excusable" includes, among other hidden assumptions, that it is actually happening and that there is actually an incentive. It is obfuscation in both cases. It certainly does not make the question an economic one.

I don't see anything above accusing anyone of thoughtcrime. I assume this is a shibboleth used to dismiss political opponents, end conversation and instruct fellow travelers what opinion to have on the mater. At any rate, I'd be more concerned about thought police from a leader who purges anyone who disagrees with him[1] than a random internet voice.

[1]The most recent being: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/us/coronavirus-live-cover...

TomMckenny··on Trump signs internet privacy repeal
Where is the true part? I see the subjective word "overinflated" and a misdirection about what "popular websites" do.

This is more a case of a press release being a press release no mater who says it.

TomMckenny··on My experience with the CARES Act
I thought we were supposed to blame the World Health Organization now.
TomMckenny··on Amazon asks workers sheltering at home to return or request leave
I'm not addressing the extremely wise decision that a government make it financially possible for people not to spread disease. Nor disputing that the vast majority of people are willing to do this under these extreme circumstance.

I'm addressing the assumption, wrapped in theories about incentives, that everyone (strangely except any persons expounding the theory) is eager to quit work for "welfare" at the first opportunity. And, by extension, that this is why there must never be a social safety net that can keep anyone alive. Because, according to this demonstrably false theory, society would collapse.

People do not quit their jobs to receive handouts exactly because of their principles and because they are not the cynical robots that theoreticians make them out to be. Corporations may maximize wealth regardless of harm to society or others but the vast majority of natural persons don't.

TomMckenny··on Amazon asks workers sheltering at home to return or request leave
Have you quit your job to collect these allegedly easy to obtain checks? Or is this character flaw exclusive to warehouse workers?
TomMckenny··on When U.S. air force discovered the flaw of averages (2016)
>Why would a government build an expensive, high tech piece of equipment, then not ensure it could X

Maybe short design periods in some cases too. Either way it was not too uncommon. There were bombers with escape hatches big enough for the crew, provided they didn't wear parachutes[1]. Fighter bomb releases that required ducking down to reach them[2] and fighter planes who's fuel feed stopped when pulling negative Gs [3]

[1] Lancaster bombers

[2] P-26 or F2A I think

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miss_Shilling%27s_orifice

TomMckenny··on YouTube bans coronavirus-related content that directly contradicts WHO advice
There is a great deal of complexity here.

On the broader topic, breaking up Youtube, Facebook and the like is entirely desirable but would probably be pointless unfortunately. Increases in copyright zeal make a new competitor to YouTube impossible and the network effect guarantees both theirs and Faceebook's dominance. In light of this, I imagine the only solution is to legislatively guarantee an uncensored platform on essentially the same logic that requires net-neutrality.

But I point out that "uncensored" is entirely ambiguous. For better or worse, the vast mass of people want and expect it with the percentage very dependent on the particular item. From archaic restrictions on "dirty" words over radio waves through to displays of sex to recruiting terrorists to national secrets to doxing individuals to child pornography.

For right or wrong, somewhere, the public, legislators and each individual decides to draw a line. In addition, for short periods of crisis or certain locations or certain influencers, the line can move. The often misused example of yelling fire in a theater comes to mind but a national leader harmfully using false announcements to raise the value of stock he owns would be an example. More relevant would be the South African leader who zealously told his people AIDS can only come from drug abuse.

On the YouTube issue, for right or wrong, they drew the line in a place some would not. I would guess because they view such messaging as unusually fatal in the short term and they don't want to be a part of it. And that they could not find any simple judgement criterion that would do what they want without doing too much and yet be palatable world wide. If we legally require them to carry every upload regardless of content then it will lift all their burdens. But it will certainly create very real problems for others.

My point is that the issue is far more complex than bumper sticker sized answers.

TomMckenny··on The epidemiologist behind Sweden’s controversial coronavirus strategy
It's not really true vs false, it's a matter of deciding what level of evidence is convincing. One point is that we already know the approximate effectiveness of social distancing from many 1918 data points and its epidemic with similar contagiousness. Some places in 1918 did it and some did not, like San Francisco vs Philadelphia where the difference was stark.

Maybe the effect will be less this time for some inexplicable reason but I would not want to run the experiment in my country.

TomMckenny··on The epidemiologist behind Sweden’s controversial coronavirus strategy
It is also why this approach would be foolish in countries with less developed treatment capacity. Capacity, for example, that is already at it's limit even with social distancing.
TomMckenny··on Coronavirus may mean automation is coming sooner than we thought
If consumer buying power drops too low relative to production, you enter the downward cycle seen in 1929.

Where consumer earnings come from in the future is crucially connected to how society decides who owns the robots.

TomMckenny··on The NSA called me after midnight and requested my source code (2018)
Since the source code could not help with decryption and the file was trivial to decrypt anyway, the NSA was either playing four dimensional chess that requires making a pointless midnight phone call or it's actually fallible.

Rather than fairly justified suspicion of the NSA, we might want to apply Hanlon's razor in this case.

TomMckenny··on Facebook says it has removed promotion of anti-quarantine events
>that all involved are trying to minimize general death and misery

Unless the anti-quarantine events are organized by a hostile power.

And this seems likely since they are insanely harmfully, arose suddenly and with widespread and great organization and have a lot of precedent. [1][2][3]

And especially since it's already been explicitly shown for at least some of the domains connected to the protests.[4]

[1]https://money.cnn.com/2018/01/26/media/russia-trolls-faceboo...

[2]https://www.wsj.com/articles/russian-backed-facebook-account...

[3]https://thehill.com/policy/technology/358025-thousands-atten...

[4]https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/04/whos-behind-the-reopen-d...

TomMckenny··on It bid high and lost. Should Amazon be allowed a do-over on JEDI?
Government contracts can be awarded to politically supportive entities and denied to those that aren't. Of course in a nicely functioning democracy there is little reason to believe this happening.

But when the head of government intervenes in the process for no clear reasons and then refuses to explain what that intervention was or why it happened or allow anyone else to comment; and when this is defended as remaining silent because speaking "may tend to incriminate" ala the 5th amendment, then it is clear there was grossly inappropriate intervention.

The issue is not whether Amazon or Microsoft win the contract. The issue is whether contract awards are going to be used to force companies to support and obey the party in power. That and the causally related "it can't happen here" mind set.

TomMckenny··on Amazon employees plan ‘online walkout’ to protest treatment of warehouse workers
As an important aside, I'm sure everyone has noticed that grocery store clerks aren't allowed to wear masks in practice. I'm sure everyone has noticed quite a few other jobs where this is so. It seems endangering the lives of certain kinds of workers is nearly universal. Not to excuse them but I imagine Amazon has a lot of company in this[1]. I am very glad at least Amazon employeesare doing something about it.

[1]https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/04/16/coronavirus-worker-at...

TomMckenny··on It bid high and lost. Should Amazon be allowed a do-over on JEDI?
It's not a trial, it's the public asking their government to tell them what's going on in this matter. And the government flatly refused. From this, it's absolutely reasonable for the public to think its government is hiding something now. And it's an order to _others_ in the DoD to remain silent. If it were a trial, this is ordering potential witnesses to remain silent on threat of termination.

What the White House is saying by claiming presidential privileged is 1) the president did indeed discuss it, which in itself is problematic and 2) that discussion is on par with a national security issue, which is an additional abuse of power.

As an aside, the 5th exists to prevent coerced confessions. In court, it is not to be taken as a sign of guilt because if it were, the point of the law would be moot. Where no court (or police) are involved, there is no possibility of coerced confession. Which is why everyone correctly views refusing to answer questions to friends, parents or reporters as very much a sign of guilt. And why confessions signed in police stations are very suspicious in many people's eyes. It certainly does not allow a government to refuse to answer to its people.

TomMckenny··on It bid high and lost. Should Amazon be allowed a do-over on JEDI?
DoD officials are barred from answering questions about White House influence on the decision owing to its assertion of "presidential communications privilege"[1]. This is, quite simply, a confession.

Nothing is solved by believing that the administration is somehow different than the dozen or so near identical leaders in other countries: that somehow this one uniquely is not pressuring companies hostile to it (in spite of the fact it has already publicly done so[2][3]).

And while a deferential Amazon might be bad, it's really something you'd want to nip in the bud before Google or Facebook become too terrified of the white house.

[1]https://www.politico.com/news/2020/04/15/pentagon-amazon-tru...

[2]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2017/07/06/w...

[3]https://www.wsj.com/articles/snag-in-media-merger-stirs-tens...

TomMckenny··on Poverty, not trauma, affects cognitive function in refugee youth: study (2019)
Poverty is also thought to have caused the diffidence in performance in the marshmallow test[1]. Poor kids learn to take advantage of the moment and distrust the future. And poor kids tend to be lower earners in later life than wealthier kids due to advantage differences[2][3]

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_marshmallow_experimen...

[2]https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/marshmall...

[3]https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/095679761876166...

TomMckenny··on Truisms (1978)
I presume it's an observation, not advice. That often those who are called exceptional have some skeletons in their closest. That there are more statues of Jefferson Davis than Harriet Tubman.
TomMckenny··on California Supreme Court: Transaction is not required to sue online providers
Square bans the use of its service for debt collection. The ruling says doing so is a violation of civil rights.

Does this actually strengthen rights for minorities or does it dilute those right by including bill collectors under the law?

Edit: as pointed out below, I am extrapolating from a ruling on standing an implication that has not explicitly been decided one way or another. I have done this so strongly that what I posted in the second sentence above is essentially false. I'll leave it as full disclosure of my error.

TomMckenny··on Capitalists or Cronyists?
The Great Depression and the fact that vast quantities of capital were annihilated in two world wars which seriously reduced the power of those who own society.

There is another point you hint at that I want to underline: nations freely use ideological rhetoric to hide the same thousand year old wealth patterns. China is not communist, N Korea is a kingdom, the NSDP outlawed and jailed socialists and, as the article points out, social mobility in the US is fought by the ruling class at every opportunity.

TomMckenny··on Apple and Google partner on Covid-19 contact tracing technology
As an aside, I'm not clear why tech startups and VC panicked over this catastrophe. Given their extreme flexibility, I would think this is the most promising sector to do some good stuff at the moment and do well after in any disrupted future environment.
TomMckenny··on A man owns the most advanced private air force after buying 46 F/A-18s
The story is that tax payers gave his company money to buy our F18s from us so that he can accumulate a force of enemy aircraft. His company will also train pilots specifically as the enemy would.

And while he will do this at a considerable profit, it will theoretically be better executed per dollar that the military doing it in a separate division. Another post claims he will generate sorties more than twice as efficiently.

So the above is either true or false.

If it is false and the contract costs taxpayers more than the military would then, as you suspect, it is entirely a pork-barrel waste of money. The fact that other nations with highly regraded military don't do this theoretical efficiency boost strongly supports this.

If it is true and the contractor is somehow more efficient, then that is even more worrisome. Scarier still is that it is taken as an inevitable state of affairs and no one seems concerned about it. That US destroyers have a catastrophically bad helm UI supports this, even though that would be conspicuous pork-barrel in it's own right.

Same with the fact the sale was F18s. Either the enemy has them or not. In one case it's pork-barrel, in the other case the US has somehow sold fighters to an enemy.

TomMckenny··on How did the U.S. end up with nurses wearing garbage bags?
There is a difficult follow up to this. When the dust settles months from now and some 40% of the country becomes convinced none of these problems ever happened, how shall we prevent this or other fiascos next time?
TomMckenny··on Education Without Truth in Postmodern Perspectivism
The article is an absurdly over the top straw-man and its target audience falls for it because they don't know that.

I could make an equally broad claim that Mormons believe absurd things. And when someone says I misunderstand Mormonism, I could claim that's just an appeal to ignorance.

People who don't believe in religious or cultural tolerance frequently float this conspicuously straw-man representation of those who believe in wider cultural tolerance. Typically using the ill-defined term "post modern". It's usually the same group that distrusts higher education and social criticism so a chance to attack them in an obfuscated way like this is doubly attractive.

TomMckenny··on Tell HN: Toilet paper, hand sanitizer, and now web cams
Mainstream economics understands the flaws in markets such as panics, run on banks, imperfect information, monopolies, cost to enter a market, lag in ramping up production, transportation time and bubbles. All of which are at play at the moment.

I can't know what was said in your classes. Assuming no control on prices in a crisis, did they say how holding a large stockpile of a rarely needed item for the long term with it's associated storage cost and risk is in some way more profitable than simply cornering the local market on the commodity at the time it is needed and indeed helping those prices rise rather than fall? In honesty, that may be a hidden assumption against price gouging more than an ideal market example used in a classroom.

At any rate, few if any mainstream economists suggests that sudden monopolization of emergency commodities that are needed immediately but briefly during a crisis would be remotely a good thing. It is more a Cato institute / libertarian position driven by ideology rather than real world data and history which consistently refute it. It is also why no sane society allows it in emergencies on crucial goods.

As if to prove the point, the theory has just been tested yet again: there are no world wide government price caps on toilet paper and yet there is an enduring shortage at the moment.

If interested in this, here is a Nobel prize winning economist writing right now on the issue:

https://twitter.com/paulkrugman/status/1246431163050266624

TomMckenny··on Tell HN: Toilet paper, hand sanitizer, and now web cams
People started hoarding out of hysteria. Which creates shortages for no reason. Which drives the prices up for no reason. Which benefits and encourages hoarding. Which encourages yet more hoarding out of speculation.

Which means resources needed at this instant are instead sitting idle, at best awaiting higher prices at some arbitrary future date. And earnings, rather than going to producers, are wasted on pointlessly destructive arbitrage. So in crisis, the market has led us into a soviet style toilet paper shortages for no reason. Not to mention far more important critical supplies.

TomMckenny··on Tell HN: Toilet paper, hand sanitizer, and now web cams
Which might be fine for things like web cams but for critically and immediately needed sanitation products, it proves a fatal flaw in markets. The reward for quickly buying up commodities and reselling them at enormous markup always out weighs stockpiling them for years and potentially never selling them at the same mark up.

Not to mention destructive hysterical hoarding. There is someone in this thread who noticed an extreme shortage in webcams so when only two were left in a shop, he bought both.

TomMckenny··on This Video Has X Views
>If it's actually spot on, it's a miracle.

Not that it matters, but I think Tom may have gotten this wrong. If his code is invoked many times faster than google updates it's video count then the odds of seeing an exact match in the total is proportional to that difference.

Which, ironically, means it's using even more cycles than necessary to do his intentionally silly trick, further proving his point.

← PreviousPage 2 of 24Next →