832 karma · joined July 5, 2010
And let's not get ahead of ourselves with the whole "push notifications have always been ads" - push notifications have always been with providing the end user with desired information. That may well come to include advertising, but up until this point advertising in push notifications has been an outlier at best.
98% of this filing is about misapplication of patent law and bad patents. This has nothing to do with anti-trust other than one line in one paragraph in a 70-paragraph defense and counterclaim section.
They're characterizing Microsoft as a bully who is attempting (under cover of NDA) to use a limited number of patents (with limited scope) to extract a per-device license that is greater than what it charges for providing the entire operating system (and access to its patents) on WP7.
In layman's terms, it's like if I owned a patent on a keyboard and tried to keep you from making a computer to compete with mine by charging a licensing fee for my keyboard patent that was more than the cost of my entire computer. That's what Barnes and Noble is accusing Microsoft of doing.
If you haven't, and you want to suffer through alcohol-fueled ranting and explanations, read on. My advice would be to get your economic advice from actual economists (and preferably sober ones).
Obviously, a retailer of Apple's scale has that much more to gain from disrupting the industry. Even moreso if they plan on having to negotiate with payment processors when they bring an NFC solution to market.
In return, the school pays for classroom sets of calculators, training for teachers and proprietary software and hardware that interfaces directly with the calculator for use in math and science classes. Given the number of high school math textbooks with extra sections for use with calculators and recommendations of a particular brand of calculator, it's hard to imagine that TI isn't marketing to the textbook companies as well.
With regards to education, the involved parties operate much like Oracle and the other "complete systems" vendors in the enterprise world: buy influence with the decision-makers and their subordinates, keep up the hard sell until the contract is won and then maintain the sell to ensure future business. That's not to say that the educational vendors give bad customer service, but at the same time, providing the end-users (the students) with a quality product at a reasonable price is hardly the primary concern.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=4...
I can't imagine it makes the online shoppers happy, though.
It's much more like suing mom-and-pop stores for dumping trash in the back alley.
It's not like Oracle's behavior with MySQL and Java is something new for them. Larry Ellison has always been a guy who buys a company, streamlines their processes, figures out a way to squeeze every last cent out of their products and then hires 1,000 new sales reps to sell it to enterprise customers. More than anything, I'm puzzled that it took this long and I'm puzzled that this hits anyone as something unexpected.
After all, I was the same shadow for a time... and I think many smart kids are, especially after doing a stint in that awkward phase and then realizing that they are, in fact smarter than their tormentors. My folks are smart and admit to having been bullied and using wit to deflect it, but I was never cautioned against bullying others; it was just assumed that I'd do what it took not to be a mark.
And so I need to admonish my kids not to compromise like I did... because we all know that the 10-year-olds that we parent and influence probably won't figure this out until maybe it's too late for some other kid.
Honestly, that's the problem with explaining lock-in to many PHB-types: not only can they not conceive of what a disaster would look like, but they can't even imagine that one could happen in the first place.
Well, I suppose you can. But you can't if you want me to take your rhetoric seriously.
Obviously, that isn't the subject matter that this paper is covering, but it definitely seems to be making an attempt to paint HFT as a Force for Good in the marketplace (or at least dispel attempts to paint it as a Bad Thing), and in my mind as a software developer, even more than impacts when things are Working As Intended, the bugs are what scare me.
Just look at the comparison to a 2-year college and do your own analysis. http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/10/20/the-skyrocketin...
"Every individual, partnership, association and corporation engaged in a business, profession or other activity for profit within the City of Philadelphia must file a Business Privilege Tax Return, whether or not they earned a profit during the preceding year."(http://www.phila.gov/revenue/pdfs/Rev%20PDFs/BPT_internet.pd...)
Basically, this is a $300 one-time licensing fee to conduct a business from a property within the City of Philadelphia.
There are two types of examples that this article uses:
1) Home-based "I'm just dicking around and use Google ads to offset the cost of my basic Wordpress subscription and server" bloggers. This seems kind of shady to me and I would be really interested to see about what an actual accountant and/or lawyer would have to say about this. After all, this is someone going asking the City of Philadelphia's Revenue Department if they have to pay more taxes. That's like going to a divorce lawyer and asking if you need a divorce... of COURSE the answer is going to be "yes."
2) Home-based business that turns no profit - Regardless of the profitability of a business, in the United States (and most everywhere else in the world) you have to pay the relevant city/state/county/federal licensing/inspection/regulatory/screw-you fees. That's the way running a business is. Don't like it? Don't run a business (out of your house or otherwise) if you can't make peace with that.
All in all I find this article to be long on rhetoric, anecdote and high-minded moralizing and short on details and investigative journalism. Were I a denizen of the City of Philadelphia and concerned about this, I would put in a couple of hours of research at the reference desk of the public library and wait for some better analysis on this subject from a slightly more reputable source before shelling out for this fee.
My personal least favorite is furniture shopping. Furniture (for me) is a very personal decision on artistic merit that is best done in quiet solitude. I want to touch, smell, examine, and test the furniture and I want to do it at my own pace and without a shadow who won't stop yammering in my ear. Look, I understand that this is a pressure sales job. I understand that you don't want your co-workers to steal your sale. Give me your card, I'll do my shopping, I'll find you if I have questions and when I want to buy something, I'll let you know.
Fortunately, this sort of issue (esoteric, complex and intractable to 30 second analysis by 24-hour news networks) tends to fade quickly from the headlines, so with any luck, we won't have to endure the idiotic platitudes of news anchors and their paid analysts for much longer.
Put it this way, can you imagine the Chinese government being receptive if the US State Department offered to send over several hundred English-language teachers and pay part of their salaries?