HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_ywdj

1 karma · joined June 30, 2025

submissionscomments
_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Firstly, please let's drop the hostility. I'm not here to win arguments or score points. I engage in these discussions to test my understanding of the topic and further develop my knowledge, and to share my perspective with others who are open to it.

In response to your comment:

> You decried those examples as handwavy

To clarify, I didn't say the examples were handwavy; I pointed out the crucial distinction between disorders specifically attributable to specific gene defects (like Huntington's and cystic fibrosis), vs. conditions that arise through the interaction between positively-selected genes and environmental triggers. It's a category error.

What I referred to as "handwavy" was the sentence "There's lots of obvious bad stuff floating around in our genomes" - specifically the phrase "lots of obvious bad stuff".

I was calling this out as an unexamined assumption, rather than a the simple incontrovertible fact that it was presented as.

> and pointed out that moreover this ground had already been covered in the article and that the article concurred with those examples

But the article doesn't concur with those examples.

The commenter listed illnesses caused by specific-gene defects, and the passage you quoted names several psychiatric conditions that are known to not be caused directly by specific-gene defects. Again, a category error.

> Your reply to me misses the point that I was making and argues against a point I wasn't making – which strikingly is the very thing that prompted me to counter your top-level post.

You seem to have read my top comment as directly critiquing the article itself, rather than the approach that has dominated the field (along with the rest of medicine) for decades. (Fair enough that you read it that way.)

I acknowledged to you that the article conveys that some researchers are rethinking the approach, but I don't see evidence of enough of a rethink.

Most importantly, they're still looking at things mechanistically; studying brain structure, going deeper trying to find particular genetic "causes" (after the many years of looking at genes have yielded little useful insight), and proposing some mysterious "p factor" and asserting: "if it is real, it has a startling implication: there could be a single therapeutic target for psychiatric disorders". That's what I mean by the "mechanistic lens".

The core position I'm arguing against, which is presented in the article and by several commenters, is that mental "illness" is likely caused by "bad" genes or biological processes "going wrong". My position is that we should generally assume that the genes are meant to be there, and focus on what in the person's life is causing the genes or biological systems to express in an undesirable way (which is what the practitioners I've named have been doing for years/decades with great success).

I've expressed my position at length in other comments. At the time of writing, the position I've articulated in detail hasn't been refuted. I'd welcome anyone to do so, so I can learn more about the topic.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
There seems to be a bit of replying to the wrong comment going on, but I'll comment here in response to you and the parent...

This line of argument is flawed because:

1) Plenty of depression, anxiety and of course ADHD occurs in childhood, while bipolar and schizophrenia more commonly occurs in late adolescence or early adulthood. Plenty of reproduction happens - particularly by men of course - at ages later than these when these illnesses can manifest (we can even see how some men with ADHD or bipolar tendencies have reproduced at higher rates than other men, and rationalise why this would have been the case through evolutionary history).

2) The suggestion that such widespread tendencies are in the gene pool only as an undesirable accident doesn't pass Occam's razer. We must assume they are there because they have been selected for, unless there is evidence to the contrary, which nobody in this whole thread has been able to offer.

3) We can easily see reasons why it has been beneficial to have some level of propensity for tendencies like depression, anxiety, ADHD, bipolar and even some schizophrenia in the gene pool.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Yep but the whole point is that it's not 100% the way it is with the right genetic conditions for disorders like Huntington's Disease or Down Syndrome.

Looking at the ADHD example, aside from the genes, consider what else is consistent: same gestational environment (mother's food, air, water, emotions, microbiome), possibly the same living environment in early life (I'm not clear on how many of these twins were separated, and if so, at what age), but even if they were separated, they're still living in the same time in history, likely the same city/country, likely at a similar socioeconomic level, they have the same appearance/height (so people respond to them similarly) and if they were separated, both experiencing trauma of separation (both from a sibling, and one or both from parents).

So there's a whole lot going on that can explain the high heritability figure.

But even if you disregard all of that, you still have to explain the other (at least) 20-25%.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
I'll try to reply quickly, as I think we at least mostly understand each other, and it's time to sleep where I am.

> That's simply not true that all (or even most of) our genes have been selected for "for tens/hundreds of thousands of years". Most diseases that occur after reaching reproductive age are not strongly selected for (this also holds true for animals). On top of that human social structures also help to weaken/circumvent evolutionary pressure.

All the conditions we're talking about can very often express before reproduction happens; anxiety, depression, ADHD, bipolar, personality disorders, even schizophrenia (though that's later than most but still by the early 20s). And it's always been common for men to reproduce well into advanced age.

I gather you're arguing that mental "illness" hasn't actually been positively selected for by evolution, but in fact is just caused by crappy DNA that entered the gene pool by mistake and has stayed on for the ride.

It's a coherent claim, but doesn't really pass Occam's Razor.

For all the conditions I listed above, we can see how, in certain circumstances, they can be beneficial either to the individual or the group, so we don't need to conjure up an assumption that their emergence and persistence were undesirable accidents.

> I'm lactose intolerant

I'd be happy to research and debate this further at a later time if it turns out the topic materially hinges on this

> I also don't see a big distinction between "curing" it "creating better conditions". Isn't curing it a way to create better conditions?

It's a case of treating the symptoms vs the cause that pertain's to one's own life (their life experience and/or their environment).

Take the ADHD example. Current common treatment is to prescribe amphetamines. Future treatments according to this article might be to "switch off" the gene that causes ADHD-type behaviour. My "better conditions" approach is to look at the kid's overall personality and environment, investigate whether there's any trauma or distress underlying the behaviour (which is tragically often overlooked in the current treatment model), then once you've ensured the kid is in a safe and nurturing environment, if they're still hyperactive or unfocused, look at their whole personality and direct them towards activities that are suited to their talents and strengths (this happens sometimes but not nearly enough).

Using drugs or genetic treatments or anything else to "switch off" the ADHD is most likely to end up being somewhere between a lamentable underutilisation of talent/ability, and an egregious act of neglect/abuse.

When we treat genes as the "cause", we overlook so much in someone's life experience and environment that is highly controllable and that can have a far greater impact than by interfering with genes or biochemical pathways.

> I'd like to see scientific evidence that bodies develop diseases to get people "to clean up their diet" or be introspective.

The very existence of physical discomfort/pain or emotional distress is a demonstration of the biological signals we've developed to motivate changes to our conditions or behaviour.

We all know that eating too much of the wrong kind of food or drinking too much alcohol leads to physical and emotional pain/discomfort/distress that tells us to change.

Same goes for dysfunctional behaviour that leads to a relationship breakup or social rejection, leading to a period of introspection.

Sometimes the link between pain/illness and behaviour/environment is not so clear-cut, so we need to see a practitioner or do some research of our own.

But there's nothing in the least bit fringe or controversial about this concept.

> People are lazy and changing habits is hard

> we know that improving levels of exercise and adjusting your diet

I keep hearing this from experts on medicine and physiology. Some of them still dispute the "sugar is more harmful than fat" evidence (which I know is a separate issue that I don't want to start debating here/now).

I'm more optimistic about human potential.

People respond to incentives, and people will happily follow practices that clearly deliver benefits.

I know this from personal experience. I drank heavily, ate terribly, smoked and didn't stick to exercise. I tried doing everything mainstream health advocates recommended, but didn't get sustained results so I lost motivation and went back to bad old ways.

Then I found approaches that worked, and I've happily done them every day for over 8 years, because I've found that when I do, my life just keeps getting better.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
> Do you have an explanation for this except the genes?

Yes of course - the environmental/experiential conditions in which the carrier of the genes find themselves.

Remember, ADHD is just a culturally defined description of behavioural tendencies, not a genetically hard-coded outcome like the shape of someone's face, so it's a mistake to think of them as being genetically determined in the same way.

Of course the genes someone inherits from their ancestors will influence their behaviour, but genes express differently depending on many conditions, and for behaviour it's highly contingent on one's own life experiences; indeed it's extremely important for survival and continued evolution that one can adapt their behaviour to the environment in which they live.

Even recent twin studies [1] don't find anything more than about 75-80% heritability of "ADHD" diagnoses, so you still need to explain the other 20-25%.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41380-018-0070-0

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
I understand the article is trying to convey that (some) researchers are rethinking the old approach of thinking of distinct definitions of disease.

My point is that they're still largely making the same mistakes; yes they're blurring the distinctions between "disorders", but they're not going back to first principles, nor giving due consideration to the coherent and compelling work of other eminent figures in their field.

> > So, trying to categorise "disorders" into discrete definitions with distinct "causes" in order to restore the mind to some "normal" state cannot possibly work.

> Yeah, nobody's trying to do that. Researchers are clearly aware of that.

They are still focused on identifying biological causes for disorders, rather than seeing variations in behaviour – even extreme ones – as adaptations that have been selected for by evolution.

It's articulated here:

> They have a few theories. Perhaps there are several dimensions of mental illness — so, depending on how a person scores on each dimension, they might be more prone to some disorders than to others. An alternative, more radical idea is that there is a single factor that makes people prone to mental illness in general: which disorder they develop is then determined by other factors. Both ideas are being taken seriously, although the concept of multiple dimensions is more widely accepted by researchers.

I sigh at that statement, when several prominent figures in the field, all with advanced qualifications in mainstream medicine or psychology, have been offering coherent explanations and effective treatment approaches for years or decades.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
My point is that it's not "obvious bad stuff", and the continued presumption that it is is probably the reason why so little progress has been made in the field.

Even that passage of the article you quote doesn't characterise the genes as "bad stuff"; just known genes that seem to correlate with the (contextually undesirable) conditions manifesting.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
You haven't said anything about being a qualified expert in the field, so I'll assume you're not - please correct me if otherwise.

> To anyone in research in the field, the distinction you are trying to make is moot

I wouldn't think this is true; it's about the most important distinction there could be in genetics - i.e., flaws/defects of specific genes vs traits/predispositions that have been selected for over the history of evolution.

If a trait has been selected for over tens/hundreds of thousands of years of evolution, it's a mistake to try and "cure" it; it's not something that can be cured, as it's there for an important reason. The right approach is to understand the conditions that trigger the symptoms, and create better conditions so the problem corrects, just as I've done.

> If that works for you I don't want you get you of that view, but that seems to romanticize illnesses too much for my taste.

This is an emotion-driven (and rather patronising) response, whereas I'm focused wholly on what is scientifically plausible and demonstrable.

I welcome new evidence to challenge the position I've put, but so far it hasn't been forthcoming.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
I'm making the distinction between illnesses that are directly caused by an identifiable genetic defect (e.g., Huntington's), and conditions that can arise when a certain combination of genes/genetic expressions are present but even then only arise some of the time.

As a professional in the field you'll know the terminology better than me and that's great, but you must understand the distinction I'm trying to make.

In the former case, we can clearly see a 1:1 causal link from genetic defect to the manifestation of the disease (whether it's a single gene or more is not central to the point).

In the latter case, the genetic predisposition is there, but there must also be some other form of conditional trigger.

One of your examples with which I'm quite familiar is asthma, which I've experienced at times in my life (though neither of my parents did).

I started experiencing it at about age 9 (as an allergic reaction to dust, dust mite and possibly other chronic infections I had at that age). Then it stopped in my mid teens. Then it started again when I smoked tobacco in my 20s, then stopped as soon as I stopped smoking. Then it started again in my mid 30s when I was experiencing severe stress and anxiety, then it stopped when I undertook a combination of approaches to reduce the stress/anxiety in my life, and a dietary program and other remedies to reduce chronic infections. That was 6 years ago and I've not needed asthma medication ever since.

The point is, there's nothing genetically deterministic about my asthma, given that it's come and gone through out my life and has been clearly influenced by environmental factors.

Further, it's plausible that the asthma has been a beneficial symptom, to protect my body from allergens and pathogens, and signal that I needed to change my lifestyle. Certainly, it was a big part of what signalled to me that I need to stop smoking, and later to clean up my diet and make other improvements to my emotional and physical health.

As I've proposed in several other comments, it's just as plausible that the conditions we regard as mental "illnesses" are likely not genetic flaws or other malfunctions at all, but rather beneficial adaptations that have been selected for by evolution (e.g., it's obvious how the presence of "ADHD" in a small percentage of the population would have been beneficial in prehistoric human tribes).

Given this, our real challenge is to do a better job of interpreting and responding to these conditions, as several practitioners going back decades have already figured out how to do.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Just as is the case for mental "disorders", none of these conditions are attributable to a known gene or gene combination, or have a 1:1 match between carrying a certain gene combination and having the disease (meaning there must be an environmental trigger in addition to the genetic predisposition).

For almost all of them (possibly all of them in some cases), there is evidence of links with auto-immunity and the presence of active pathogens (including viruses, bacteria, funguses, etc), suggesting that the illness is related to the body's efforts to fight off or cope with pathogens, or to some effect of the pathogen's activity.

Those who invoke conditions like Huntington's Disease and haemophilia are on more solid ground, as these are directly attributable to single-gene mutations. But these conditions are also very very rare, unlike mental "disorders".

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Many of these "disorders" manifest before reproductive age; depression, anxiety, ADHD, bipolar, even schizophrenia occasionally.

Think about the condition we currently call the "disorder" ADHD.

We can easily imagine how the behavioural tendencies ascribed to it would have been beneficial in hunter-gatherer times; i.e., it would be beneficial to the tribe for a certain number of people to be restless and explorative, rather than being conformist and content doing repetitive tasks. Same goes for bipolar; think about how many of our leading writers, inventors, musicians are diagnosed bipolar, and how useful it would always have been to have had a few people with that kind of creativity and propensity for bursts of novel productivity in the tribe.

And I can easily think of ways depression and anxiety are adaptive and supportive of survival, rather than not (for depression it's the ability to contemplate/reform a troubled life, and anxiety it's the avoidance of danger). Even schizophrenia in certain circumstances.

And of course when we invoke Occam's razor, it makes far more sense that these genes are there because they're beneficial, rather than being there due to a historical accident.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Huntington's disease is one of a small number of conditions that is caused by a single-gene defect (along with haemophilia, and a few others).

It's very rare.

What is known about mental "illnesses" are that they sometimes manifest when certain combinations of genes are present, but not always, and when you look at the details of cases you can pretty much always find an outer-world factor that triggers the state (e..g, abuse, trauma, neglect etc).

So we're talking about very different things.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
Of the conditions you mentioned, cystic fibrosis and haemophilia are due to specific, single-gene mutations, and both are quite rare.

There's a huge difference between conditions that are caused by a single-gene defect vs conditions that sometimes arise when a combination of genes are present/expressed in combination with other (e.g. environmental) factors.

> There's lots of obvious bad stuff floating around in our genomes

Too handwavy. Please be specific :)

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
These genes didn't just appear in the last couple of hundred or even few thousand years.

And the fact that they're widespread means they're selected for, not just not selected out.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
> There are plenty of inheritable genetic physical diseases

So I can respond to something solid, can you name some?

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
A further thought...

This paragraph in the article says it all:

As a result, the world’s largest funder of mental-health science, the US National Institute of Mental Health, changed the way it funded research.

Like so much in medical research, efforts are governed by what research will be funded, and ideally what will lead to the discovery of a drug or intervention that can generate billions of dollars of revenues. Those researchers who figured this stuff out decades ago don't need to be considered.

Beginning in 2011, it began demanding more studies of the biological basis of disorders, instead of their symptoms, under a programme called the Research Domain Criteria. There has since been an explosion of research into the biological basis of psychopathology, with studies focusing on genetics and neuroanatomy, among other fields.

"Focusing on genetics and neuroanatomy" is the perfect way to miss the forest for the trees.

But if researchers hoped to demystify psychopathology, they still have a long way to go: the key finding has been just how complex psychopathology really is.

Complexity doesn't have be difficult to understand.

Sigh.

_ywdj··on The links between mental disorders
A few thoughts, as someone who has been deeply researching this topic for my own reasons and for several loved ones over many years (I think I first started looking up the DSM-IV in 2005).

- This article reveals the folly of viewing a complex system (the mind) through a mechanistic lens. We want to be able to look at the mind the way we look at a malfunctioning car ("ah, the timing belt's out") or computer ("one of the memory sticks died"), repair/replace that component and expect it to carry on as "normal". This can never work. The mind is an organic, emergent phenomenon, not something that has been "designed" to work in any "normal" way; it has evolved to adapt to circumstances that can change and differ dramatically for all kinds of reasons. So, trying to categorise "disorders" into discrete definitions with distinct "causes" in order to restore the mind to some "normal" state cannot possibly work.

- I realised after a few years of researching this stuff that the notion that psychiatric "disorders" manifest due to "bad genes" doesn't make sense. The whole point of evolution is that only genes that promote survival and replication can make it through. Sure, you can get random mutations, but that doesn't explain why so many people have the same kinds of "disorders". So whatever are the genes that "cause psychiatric disorders" in big enough clusters that they can even be attempted to be named and described in the DSM, those genes must be there for a reason that has aided our survival - even if they have some negative aspects too (nature is all about tradeoffs after all). Realising this changed the way I view mental "illness". I realised that my depression was my mind's way of telling me that something was wrong in my life (relationships, career, physiological health) and I needed time out to examine it, understand it and correct it. Schizophrenia can be seen as an alteration of your perceptions to numb you from a stressful/traumatic situation, a trigger of extreme creative thinking to help solve serious life problems, or a display of aberrant behaviour to signal to outsiders that you are in need of help (see studies of how often schizophrenia manifests after a period of severe stress or trauma). Bipolar can be seen as a pattern of swinging between a high energy/creativity state in order to get important things achieved quickly, and a low-energy state for recovery.

- The discussion in this article seems astonishingly simplistic and naïve to anyone who has read/heard any of the many researchers who have spent years examining mental "illness" from the perspective of trauma, and who have found success treating all kinds of conditions through trauma healing techniques. Such figures include Stan Grof, Ram Dass, Iain McGilchrist, Peter Levine and Gabor Maté.

- My own experience: I'm one of those who has fit the diagnosis for several conditions at times in my life; depression and anxiety most clearly, but also (at least mildly) bipolar, borderline PD, ADHD, some addiction. I tried all the conventional things (pharmaceuticals, mainstream psychiatric talk therapy) and didn't get much relief. About 8 years ago I discovered unconventional approaches to subconscious trauma healing, and have undertaken these consistently ever since, and my "disorders" have steadily resolved. All that's left is some latent anxiety, but that continues to improve too.

_ywdj··on Bruce McEwen, who found stress can alter the brain, has died
> What's next, are you going to suggest basilar skull fractures are somewhat linked to emotional stress?

If you want to discuss this topic in good faith you should edit your comment to remove this appeal to ridicule.

I don't know what you think I'm advocating that motivates the bilious accusations in the rest of your comment.

From what I can tell:

- We seem to agree that people suffering chronic, difficult-to-treat illnesses have it extremely tough, and it would be ideal if they didn't (I know this from personal experience)

- We also seem to agree that the profit motive creates perverse incentives in medical research and treatment.

Outside of that, your comment seems to be just another example of the very phenomenon I was pointing out.

To be clear: I've experienced difficult-to-treat illness that seems to be autoimmune-related for much of my life.

I'm now almost completely well, having undertaken a variety of treatments including deep emotional/trauma healing work over the past 8+ years.

There is no mainstream physician, of any supposed level of competence, who would have recommended the approach that has enabled me to achieve the level of health I've now reached.

There are notable exceptions – Gabor Maté and Bruce Lipton being the most prominent – yet neither are taken seriously by the scientific/medical mainstream, despite both having advanced mainstream medical credentials.

_ywdj··on VCs Are Just Tired
This comment is starting to wrestle with the complexities of the topic, which is great!

Dang's job is to prevent flamewars on this site, and to cultivate intellectual curiosity.

All he was objecting to in the original comment was that it was of the style that can spark flamewars.

Ultimately, I think we want the same things.

_ywdj··on VCs Are Just Tired
> This is like a pharmaceutical company...

If there was anybody who would be motivated to scapegoat a single actor or cause for dysfunction in the medical industry it's me.

I've endured debilitating health challenges, including severe pain, for almost half my life. I've had plenty of time and motivation to research and contemplate everything that's wrong with the medical system, including corrupt dealings between pharmaceutical companies, regulators, research institutions and medical practitioners.

And, much like apportioning blame to VCs, there is some truth to this point of view.

But it's not the whole story.

At least as significant a factor is that there is a real, legitimate need for pharmaceutical opioids, and a widespread epidemic of "pain" that is little-understood by mainstream medical researchers and practitioners, which is mostly to do with the fact that physiology is extremely complex and still only partially understood.

Fortunately, I've never had to turn to opioids or other pharmaceuticals to treat my pain conditions, and after many years of research and experimentation, have been able to become pain-free via natural - though unconventional - approaches.

I think it would be great if other people had the access and motivation I've had to achieve good health, rather than ending up dependent on opioids or languishing in other ways.

But 10+ years of thinking about it, including plenty of, yes, curious conversation, has taught me that problems in the medical system can't all be simplistically blamed on corrupt pharmaceutical companies.

> tonal arguments to dismiss the hardest of questions

What "hard questions" was the root commenter raising?

Real "hard questions" involve honestly considering all facets of a topic, and taking on the responsibility of contributing to the formulation solutions that are practical and effective.

> Perhaps this is not a true intellectual community

In what way was the root comment more "intellectual" than what I'm advocating?

_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
I've been discussing these topics on HN for a long time. I've learned it's better to meet people where they're at than to demand people immediately leap to my place of understanding.
_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
No doubt! Given this, it'd be much better if my parent commenter had brought that kind of humility and a spirit of acceptance and constructiveness to the discussion.
_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
> It's absolutely interesting, there's A LOT we don't [k]now

Thanks for conceding that, as a mainstream medical professional.

But maybe give people a break.

Given that there's a lot we don't know, it's fair enough for laypeople to talk about it in fuzzy terms and use metaphors that make sense to them, until your profession has more detailed knowledge to share.

As one of the many people who has suffered severe pain and debilitating illness for many years, which has not responded to conventional medical treatment but has responded in interesting ways to various practices that purport to address problems with the fascia, I appeal to you to dial down the know-all attitude and be part of a good-faith discussion from which we can all learn and benefit.

EDIT: In response to your question “What does "releasing the fascia" even mean?”, this quote from a recent medical journal paper [1] may suggest an answer:

There are some researchers who suggest strongly that any change in the viscoelasticity of the fascial system activates the nociceptors.3,12 The hyaluronic acid becomes adhesive and less lubricated, altering the lines of forces within the various fascial layers.3 This mechanism could be one of the causes of articular stiffness and pain in the morning.11 In fact, the stiffness experienced by some patients when they wake up in the morning could be related not with the joint but with the fascial system: if there is a minor quantity of hyaluronic acid or when it is not equally distributed, the tissue is dehydrated and has less possibility of sliding.3,11,12

So as I understand it, what people refer to as "releasing the fascia" describes a mechanism to detach adhesions that form between the fascia layers due to this reduced viscoelasticity.

I claim no expertise on this topic and cannot vouch for the medical validity of this paper; I just learn what I can from the material available, and apply it to my own healing efforts where it may be applicable.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4173815/

_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
> we shouldn't run headlong into X fixes everything territory

Nobody in the article or this discussion thread has said we should do this, or said anything else that seriously contradicts anything you've said.

Not a single person has said anything to contradict the notion that you should see a doctor if you have serious health problems.

The article is very clearly about early stage observations and preliminary research.

These grave warnings are an unnecessary downer in a discussion that should be focused on interesting possibilities.

_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
> I don't like this article because it doesn't sound like science

The article is specifically about the fact that the scientific community has little knowledge or consensus about this topic, but that hypotheses are being formulated and research undertaken.

This is the epitome of how science progresses in as-yet unexplored fields.

> there are quite a few people promoting pseudo-scientific ideas that can influence patients to put off effective treatments

Perhaps you should provide evidence that measures up to your own standards: what data is there to demonstrate that significant numbers of people have died of cardiovascular illness because they tried to treat serious limb swelling with just massage?

On the flipside, here's some relevant data:

– "Drug overdose deaths involving prescription opioids rose from 3,442 in 1999 to 17,029 in 2017" [1]

– "Orthopedic pain (34.8%) was the primary reason for an opioid prescription, followed by [...], back pain (14.0%), and headache (12.9%)" [2]

If it turns out that fascia-related issues are frequently a factor in these kinds of chronic pain conditions, which currently seems at least somewhat plausible, it may well turn out to be a scandal that this topic has not yet been more heavily researched, given that many people outside the pharmaceutical sector of the health industry have been talking about it for years or even decades.

[1] https://www.drugabuse.gov/related-topics/trends-statistics/o...

[2] https://www.ajpmonline.org/article/S0749-3797(19)30216-8/pdf

_ywdj··on Fascia encases tissues and organs and may have widespread effects (2019)
Over the years I've written here several times about my efforts to explain and overcome mysterious chronic health impairments including fatigue/lethargy and tension/pain.

In recent times, my research and experimentation has led me to explanations and treatments that focus on the fascia, and whilst I've not yet achieved full recovery (a recovery time of several years is par for the course with these kinds of issues), this approach does seem to be helping to improve my conditions.

The approaches I've been undertaking include yoga/pilates-type stretching exercises and specific types of massage that seek to break up fascia "adhesions" [1].

I'm being careful not to make any specific claims of diagnoses or remedies, as I'm fully aware from my own experience (and background as a scientifically-minded person) that this this whole topic is nascent in terms of solid scientific evidence, and rife with pseudoscience.

But it does seem clear to me that there is "something there", and that more research into this topic could likely lead to explanations and remedies for conditions like "chronic pain" and "chronic fatigue", which many people currently endure for years or for life without understanding or relief.

[1] It's not the only work I've been doing; as I've written about here before, diet, cardio exercise and emotional work have all been part of my regimen for some years, but since introducing the practices that focus on fascia, my condition has improved faster and in different ways.

_ywdj··on Ask HN: Random upper back pain is ruining my life. At wits end. Anyone else?
There was a thread [1] here a few days ago about the book "The Body Keeps the Score", which examines the link between emotions and physical pain.

I posted the comment [2] that is still top of that thread; basically I've been living this for many years. I've certainly found that chronic back pain (which I've experienced) responds to deep emotional healing.

Physical exercise is important too; I'm not claiming, and you shouldn't accept anyone else's claims, that emotion-based treatments will magically heal the pain without exercise or physical therapy.

But the reverse applies too, and the subconscious mind can certainly keep muscles tense and joints out of alignment for a long time, in spite of any exercise or physical therapy you undertake.

I'll repeat the offer that I made in that subthread: I'll be writing a document or perhaps rather starting a discussion forum, so that I can explain everything I've experienced and learned, and allow others to take what they need from it.

Feel free to email me (address in profile) to be included.

Be assured, there are things that can be done. I know how you feel, but trust that you don't need to suffer like this forever.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21340636

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21341101

_ywdj··on The Body Keeps the Score: Book Summary
> it was obvious to me why people who see themselves as 'scientifically-minded' would dismiss it

Most people who reflexively dismiss the mind+body link haven't heard of Lipton.

Rejection of this concept is the default for conventionally-minded people in western society, because we've been conditioned over generations to see the mind and body as separate entities (likely due, ironically enough, to religion), and consequently it's a largely unquestioned assumption in medical orthodoxy.

People who are enthusiasts for modern science (i.e., devotees of Richard Dawkins, staunch atheists, etc), seem particularly resistant to questioning this orthodoxy.

Anyway, it doesn't matter. My own worldview is not heavily based on Lipton's. I just suggested it to give people something to start out on, in case it takes me some time to write my own doc.

Like everyone else here, you're welcome to contact me for a copy. I'd welcome your constructive feedback.

_ywdj··on The Body Keeps the Score: Book Summary
You're welcome to contact me for my own doc once I prepare it. I'd welcome your feedback and help in making it valuable to you.

For what it's worth, I come from a mainstream scientific background, and my own view on this subject is not heavily based on Lipton's.

_ywdj··on The Body Keeps the Score: Book Summary
Are you actually in need of this kind of help in the first place? If not, why not just ignore it and move on, rather than posting drive-by bile like this as your one-and-only contribution to the entire thread?

His presentation style is not for everyone, sure. Nobody’s is. He talks in pictures and metaphors, which for many people is the most effective way to receive information.

Not you? No worries!

But consider that you’re only talking about persuasiveness of language/presentation for yourself, not science.

The very quote you picked out to mock is perfectly valid science.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →