HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anikan_vader

960 karma · joined January 10, 2020

submissionscomments
anikan_vader··on F-35A has flown from a highway for the first time
I agree that ground anti-air has played a larger role in denying either side air supremacy than fighter jets. But it is important to note that Russia failed to establish air supremacy over Ukraine during the almost year before western anti-air arrived. Meanwhile, the Ukrainian air force effectively carried out anti-air missions (including against drones) and even some ground attack sorties.

So, tellingly, the Russian air force failed to establish supremacy over Ukraine when Ukraine fielded only Soviet-era aircraft and anti-air (and in comparatively small numbers). Which strongly suggests that the Russian Air Force is not a particularly good opponent either.

But critically, the Ukrainian Air Force continues to exist as a fleet-in-being. So while it may not currently be capable of much force projection (I would argue that the Russian air force is also not capable of much force projection against a serious adversary), it does force its adversary to strategically deploy anti-air.

As Russian anti-air systems become depleted (which may be sooner or may be later, but due to the rapid destruction of S-400 systems of late, my money is on sooner), it is quite possible that the Ukrainian air force will play a larger role, especially given that training on F-16s commence in a handful of weeks.

anikan_vader··on F-35A has flown from a highway for the first time
>> How is this useful if you can’t refuel or reload ordnance?

You can. It is true that there are logistics challenges to provide fuel/ammunition to a vehicle that does not have a fixed base (such as an airfield). Similar logistic challenges are solved for tanks.

>> aren’t you a sitting duck for the enemy?

Only until you take back off again. In the event that your airfields have recently stopped existing, that will likely be as soon as you refuel/reload.

anikan_vader··on F-35A has flown from a highway for the first time
It is not, as the Ukrainian air force continues to conduct regular sorties and has successfully prevented the Russian air force from every gaining air supremacy.

The Russian air force has taken massive losses, both in terms of planes and pilots, but it also continues to exist, from a non-generous and factual perspective.

anikan_vader··on I built Excel for Uber and they ditched it
Less so ethics and more so credible legal action against offending companies and individuals.
anikan_vader··on New world record with an electric racing car: From 0 to 100 in 0.956 seconds
Sure, but once you have speed you can use aerodynamics to get grip (e.g., F1 cars). So this is really only relevant if you need acceleration from low speed.
anikan_vader··on MIT Pirate Certificate
It clearly demonstrates a time when MIT completely hung one of their own out to dry, in contrast to the “all tech men carry batteries” defense. It is representative of the modern administration’s inability to empathize with the students and faculty they represent.

And yes, I would characterize fighting peacefully for open access as trying to have fun in a way that MIT should be trying to protect.

anikan_vader··on Many in the AI field think the bigger-is-better approach is running out of road
There is plenty of evidence for non-determinism in matter, which the brain is notably made out of.
anikan_vader··on Maps distort how we see the world
I mean it’s pretty easily explained by the Industrial Revolution starting in Europe, which is very far north. The explanation that heat induces laziness is a bit suspect given that in older eras many of the most prosperous civilizations were near the equator. (Egypt, Sumeria, the Persians, Indus River Valley Civilizations, etc.)
anikan_vader··on FreeBSD spends 7% of its boot time running a bubblesort on its SYSINITs
Plenty of children come up with bubble sort as a sorting algorithm. It’s intuitive to go down the list swapping any pairs that happen to be in the wrong order.
anikan_vader··on The D.E.N.N.I.S. system: Résumé tips for Senior Devs
Why? LaTeX is one of the most useful programming languages to know these days.
anikan_vader··on UW scientists tried to avoid reporting a virus research accident
Given the university’s response, this is clearly an institutional problem. The United States of America should not award them more grant money to study viruses in any capacity.

Putting millions of lives at risk via this kind of intentional negligence (failure to report and failure to quarantine after exposure) should be a felony.

anikan_vader··on The Great Electrician Shortage
Oh no if only the free market had a mechanism to correct labor shortages. Anyways…
anikan_vader··on Building telescopes on the Moon could transform astronomy
>> it is insignificant.

But compared to the government’s science funding through the NSF, it is an order of magnitude larger than entire major fields of academia!

anikan_vader··on How can some infinities be bigger than others?
Cantor’s arguments always receive a very negative reception from most of the HN crowd, just as they did from his peers at the time! He was nearly shunned for opening this can of worms, which is one of the reasons why he spent many years refining his arguments to be as elegant as possible (diagonalization came long after the original result).

Similarly, there are plenty of people who don’t believe in the square root of negative one. Others don’t believe in the existence of irrational numbers (e.g. the Greeks). Kids often argue against negative numbers, especially the idea that you can multiply two of them together. Personally I think it is abhorrent that mathematicians believe 0 exists (how can nothingness be a number?!)

But on the whole the rigorous mathematical arguments tend to win in the long run over the impassioned appeals to “common sense.” Today Cantor is regarded as a hero by nearly all mathematicians.

anikan_vader··on How can some infinities be bigger than others?
>> if we can deal with ratios in calculus due to infinitesimal sizes using limits

Cauchy proved this in the 19th century using analysis. You did not cite a proof that we can somehow use analysis to do something vaguely similar for infinities.’

>> I know there are supposed theoretical problems with random sampling

Yes, no uniform distribution exists on the integers.

>> But I don’t care

Clearly. It drives me bananas when people knowingly post comments in mathematical discussion that have no rigor and instead are appeals to emotion.

anikan_vader··on How can some infinities be bigger than others?
Do you have an example of when this is true? It is certainly not true of integers, or rationals, or real numbers. Typically the Cartesian product of an infinite set with itself is bijective with the original set.
anikan_vader··on Judge decides against Internet Archive
Well, collective ownership and communal property are arguably just as “natural” as private property.
anikan_vader··on The teen mental illness epidemic began around 2012
Child poverty has declined significantly since both 2007 and 2012 (although they did rise momentarily after 2008).
anikan_vader··on China says debris from balloon shot down over US “belongs” to them [video][1min]
Not really how it works when you a violate another superpower's sovereign airspace. Interesting to see them so invested in it given that it's just a "weather balloon."

Actually though, it seems pretty remarkable how poorly Chinese diplomats have handled this. Perhaps it is to maintain domestic support, but they seem to have made a series of unforced diplomatic errors, both with non-credible statements and with belligerent statements like this (which are typically not recommended when you fly spycraft over your adversaries mainland).

anikan_vader··on Why Finland Selected the F-35A (2021)
It's the only 5th gen fighter jet that is available. The fact that the price point happens to be highly competitive with 4th gen fighters is almost irrelevant.
anikan_vader··on Retirees Are One Reason the Fed Has Given Up on a Big Worker Rebound
If only there were some mechanism in a market-based economy to solve labor shortages…
anikan_vader··on Using rats to clear land mines in Cambodia
An interesting idea, although I think the US is actually ahead of the curve on mines. From Wikipedia:

>> Opponents point out that the Ottawa Convention places no restriction whatsoever on anti-vehicle mines which kill civilians on tractors, on school buses, etc. The position of the United States is that the inhumane nature of landmines stems not from whether they are anti-personnel as opposed to antivehicle but from their persistence. The United States has unilaterally committed to never using persistent landmines of any kind, whether anti-personnel or anti-vehicle, which they say is a more comprehensive humanitarian measure than the Ottawa Convention. All US landmines now self-destruct in two days or less, in most cases four hours. While the self-destruct mechanism has never failed in more than 65,000 random tests, if self-destruct were to fail the mine will self-deactivate because its battery will run down in two weeks or less. That compares with persistent anti-vehicle mines which remain lethal for about 30 years and are legal under the Ottawa Convention.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottawa_Treaty

anikan_vader··on Anti-War Speech Sent Eugene V. Debs to Prison, 1918
>> The UK is only a monarchy at the ceremonial level.

This is a common claim, but I can't say that I agree. The House of Lords holds real power, as does the king in his role as head of state. The UK is not an absolute monarchy by any means, but the king is far more than just a figurehead [1].

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/07/how-archaic-...

anikan_vader··on Anti-War Speech Sent Eugene V. Debs to Prison, 1918
For example, the IRA member Bobby Sands was elected to the UK parliament while in prison during his (subsequently fatal) hunger strike. Parliament then immediately passed a law banning people from running for parliament from jail.

Of course, the UK is a monarchy, not a republic, so its relevance to the subject at hand is somewhat dubious.

anikan_vader··on AP fired reporter after dangerous blunder – Slack chats reveal chaotic process
It would have been highly unusual for the Ukrainian military to have depleted their entire anti-air arsenal in April, given that, at the time, they weren't receiving Western high-altitude anti-air systems. (Nor were they facing a persistent campaign by Russian warplanes deep behind the front line, since by that point the Russian air force had largely given up on straying deep into Ukraine.)
anikan_vader··on AP fires reporter behind retracted ‘Russian missiles’ story
They were anti-air missile(s) originating from an S-300 fired at Russian aerial threats (likely cruise missiles or Iranian drones).
anikan_vader··on Status vs. Wealth: Why the Rich Don't Act Rich
>> When you are older and settled down

In general when you are settled down it is easier to care less about trying to gain additional romantic partners.

anikan_vader··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
> and ending with the creation of the central banking system, which arguably goes against the spirit of the Constitution.

I see you're not a fan of Alexander Hamilton. The (first) US bank predates the other items in your list, though.

anikan_vader··on Two-Twenty-Two
My bad, thanks for the correction. I am surprised though – I thought higher frequency waves were more dangerous, but clearly that is not universally so.
anikan_vader··on Two-Twenty-Two
The Atlantic article that this one links to admits that negative side-effects of UV-C have been known since at least the 40's:

>> But though Wells and other early pioneers of this technology could shine their 254 nm lamps aloft to clean the air floating in the upper portion of rooms, or use the light inside vents or ducts, they couldn’t actually shine them downward, directly onto the occupants of rooms, without ill effect. That’s because, although 254 nm inactivates pathogens, it also causes skin and eye damage at certain doses.

This is a very contradictory tone with the article, which essentially claims UV-C is totally safe for humans. EDIT: The author of the article explicitly acknowledges this.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →