HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bnegreve

2,040 karma · joined January 4, 2011

submissionscomments
bnegreve··on To my surprise and elation, the Webb Space Telescope is going to work
> the JWST could then rocket off on its own, fully-assembled

I am no expert, but this has to be quite a challenge. How much fuel do you need to do that?

bnegreve··on Ant mill
41 mm/s is not fast, according to this website a black ant runs at 80mm/s: https://idswater.com/2019/12/13/how-fast-is-an-ant-in-mph/
bnegreve··on Ant mill
Found it:)

Anteater: [...] I am on the best of terms with ant colonies. It's just ANTS that I eat, not colonies--and that is good for both parties: me, and the colony.

Achilles: How is it possible that--

Tortoise: How is it possible that--

Achilles: --having its ants eaten can do an ant colony any good?

Crab: How is it possible that--

Tortoise: --having a forest fire can do a forest any good?

Anteater: How is it possible that--

Crab: --having its branches pruned can do a tree any good?

Anteater: --having a haircut can do Achilles any good?

bnegreve··on Are cryptocurrencies to blame for high GPU prices?
> The ideal state of being would be one in which we have limitless fusion power or similar and we basically just do whatever we wish. If we get that and alchemy we win the Universe.

No, using energy inevitably changes the state of world we live in (that is actually the point). Use crazy amounts of energy in a distributed and unregulated manner, and the world will be nowhere like the one we evolved in, and we will die.

bnegreve··on Defrag Like It's 1993
> That would have been a strong reason for me not to use FreeBSD.

Well, with this new website, you can now enjoy defraging without having to suffer the consequences of a bad file system.

bnegreve··on The longest train journey – in 2021
> This cannot mean the longest trip by train in terms of time or in terms of total length of track covered – we could put in dozens of interim stops to make a trip as long as possible

I think the longest shortest path between two cities would make more sens than the geodesic distance

bnegreve··on Catholic church's proposed redesign of Notre Dame interior provokes outrage
> This move looks like trying to fight the previous war.

With 12 millions visitors per year (pre fire/covid), they are probably willing to take that risk.

bnegreve··on Go Where No Drone Has Gone Before
75mm?
bnegreve··on Weekly Top 10 lists of the most-watched TV and films
> If the average watch time was less than the runtime, that means more people watched the movie for at least some period.

I'm suggesting some of this total watchtime is not meaningful (<1 min watch time) and may still contribute to a significant proportion of the total watch time.

You assume all the watch time is meaningful.

You also assume there are no users with multiple accounts.

I think these two assumptions are not very reasonable, and can explain why you find your own estimate "literally unbelievable".

bnegreve··on Weekly Top 10 lists of the most-watched TV and films
This is not correct:

- if there are multiple users per netflix account, you underestimate the total number of netflix users.

- if the total hour-count includes users that have only watched 10% of the movie, you over estimate the number of users that have actually watched the entire movie. (by counting in the ones that haven't)

In both cases you end up over estimating the fraction of netflix users that have watched the entire movie.

If you assume that there are two users per netflix accounts on average, and that 10 users out of 11 will drop the movie after 10% then your estimated percentage will be 4x higher than the real percentage. So, its probably more around 9-10% of netflix users that have seen the movie.

bnegreve··on The case of the 500-mile email (2002)
This file is actually interesting to look at. It almost reads like a history book about measurements.
bnegreve··on Nuclear radiation used to transmit digital data wirelessly
> I still can't think of any use for this that isn't better solved some other way.

What about this?

"In some safety-critical scenarios, such as concerning the integrity of reactor containments, and metal vaults and bulkheads in maritime structures, it can be important to minimise the number of penetrations made through such metal structures for communications cabling. The use of neutrons for information transmission through such structures could negate the need for such penetrations and is perhaps also relevant to scenarios where limited transmissions are desirable in difficult circumstances, such as for emergency rescue operations."

bnegreve··on It‘s been 9 years since Valve rolled out the Steam Linux beta
> I know that I stopped pirating games, music and movies when I started using Steam, Spotify and Netflix.

But is it a causal relation? You probably have a steadier income now than you had back then.

bnegreve··on Neural Networks from Scratch
I don't think it is a good idea to describe neural networks as a large graph of neurons interacting with each other. It is not really helpful to understand what is going on inside.

It is more useful to understand them as a series of transforms that bend and fold the input space, in order to place pairs of similar items close to each other. I would like to see people trying to illustrate that instead.

It also has the benefit of making the connection with linear algebra much easier to understand.

bnegreve··on X-rays reveal censored portions of Marie Antoinette’s letters to Swedish count
Yes, they can be a hundred times faster so now it's only 273,378,930,384,066,111,944,300,099,749,229,403,236,110,674,297,569,624,874,932 years.

More seriously, GPUs are faster because they are highly parallel, and parallelism can only give you a speedup that is linear with the number of processing units. So unless you're planning to build a GPU with trillions units, that won't help much.

bnegreve··on My Room in 3D
Look, my point is simple: if you agree that snow and sugar are white, then the sunlight is also white.

It has to be because white was historically described as the color of the snow (or whatever is white) under the sunlight.

Now, if you want to adopt a more precise definition of white and other colors, based on (not so) recent scientific insights about the light, you can. Then the sunlight is not white, neither is snow or sugar. And is also certainly not yellow.

Let's be honest, the sun light is almost perfectly white, and kids use yellow to draw the sun, because it wouldn't make sense to draw it with white.

bnegreve··on My Room in 3D
Of course there are different shades of white, what I am saying is that the color of the sun during the day is what people most would classify as "white" and not as "yellow" if it the color was printed on a sheet of paper.

If the sun color was actually yellow, people wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a white object and yellow object under the sun light (they would both appear yellow). And clearly they are.

On the other hand a white object doesn't get any "whiter" under another kind of light than it appears under direct sun light, this again is because the sun light is white, and not yellow.

Of course there is some subjectivity here, but it is a misconception to call the sun light yellow. For example, this "bright sun" RGB [1] color, is clearly not the color of direct sun light. Hopefully, you will agree with this.

[1] https://www.colorcombos.com/colors/FCD440

bnegreve··on My Room in 3D
> There is sun, which is slightly yellowish

The sun light is white during the day, otherwise, anything white would appear yellow.

bnegreve··on Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
I see, it's actually a bit scary. But if oxidation doesn't happen fast enough (no matter why) the O2 surplus can still be explained somewhat indirectly by the emergence of photosynthesis billions years ago. Or maybe by something else. Anyway, I finally got your point, interesting.
bnegreve··on Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
Ok, I'm not saying that the exact same molecules of O2 from the GOE were preserved until today, rather that the presence of O2 in the atmosphere is related to the emergence of plants and photosynthesis. This is what I meant by "O2 comes from prehistoric plants".

For the record, the "memory" if you want to call it like this, would be the (unoxidized) carbon buried underground and/or segregated in the plants body.

bnegreve··on Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
Hum, I'd like to read more about this. I find hard to believe that the current atmospheric conditions are completely unrelated to the rise of oxygen attributed to photosynthesis, and that they can only be explained by anthropic selection (which is always a possible explanation anyway).
bnegreve··on Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
If by air you mean (di)oxygen, it kinda does come from the plants, but prehistoric ones rather than modern ones.

E.g. see [1] "The growth of these forests removed huge amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, leading to a surplus of oxygen."

[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/carbonife...

bnegreve··on Stop using your work laptop or phone for personal stuff, because I know you are
I just have two different unix accounts on my laptop, one for work, one for personal.

Most of the time, I have two X servers running, so I don't even to login/logout, I can switch from one to the other anytime.

bnegreve··on Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side
> These colorization processes exaggerate information about the grayscale tones that our eyes can’t pick up

It is a machine learning model, so not really.

Instead, the model makes an educated guess of the most likely color, based on vast amounts of pictures sampled un-uniformly from very different areas of the world.

bnegreve··on Astrobiologists have released the preliminary results of a SETI survey
> Given the number of stars out there, it seems wildly improbable that we are alone

This tells you nothing unless you also know the probability of (intelligent) life emerging on a planet. As far as we can tell it could be very low, and earth could very well be a unique combination of factors that allows it. Remember, there are many more possible deck of 52 cards than there are planets in the universe.

bnegreve··on Zoomable lens without any moving parts
[The] camera uses a liquid lens powered by a motor that uses precision manipulation on that packet of fluid to switch between a 3x telephoto zoom and a macro mode [..]

If I understand correctly, the lens in the Xiaomi Mi Mix Fold does require a mechanical movement to be adjusted (it's also clearly visible in the video), so I'm not sure what is the point.

bnegreve··on Coq 8.13
From coq FAQ:

Did you really need to name it like that?

Some French computer scientists have a tradition of naming their software as animal species: Caml, Elan, Foc or Phox are examples of this tacit convention. In French, “coq” means rooster, and it sounds like the initials of the Calculus of Constructions CoC on which it is based.

https://coq.inria.fr/V8.1/faq.html#htoc4

bnegreve··on Elon Musk to offer $100M prize for 'best' carbon capture tech
To burn the trees, you need oxygen.

You want to use oxygen from the atmosphere, and bury it underground?

bnegreve··on Elon Musk to offer $100M prize for 'best' carbon capture tech
> The best way to permanently take away CO2 from the atmosphere is to cut off the trees and somehow store them where the CO2 cannot escape

I really don't understand this logic. The oil industry spends billions every year to extract oil (= fossilized biomass) buried deep underground, because burning biomass gives you cheap energy.

If you cut down and store enough trees to compensate for the current CO2 emissions, you will have access to an immense volume of biomass, much easier to "extract" than oil is. What do you think is going to happen with this biomass? People are going to burn it to make cheap energy again..

Actually, why would you even go through the trouble of cutting down the trees in the first place? You could just, not extract the oil and end up with the exact same amount of energy you will have at the end of this complex process.

bnegreve··on Big O Notation – Explained as easily as possible
> But the author did exactly that, when they considered addition to be constant.

Ok, I agree the article is imprecise. It should say fixed width integer addition instead of simply addition since the latter can either refer to a simple ADD cpu instruction or to the much more complex '+' operator in python.

However, once you agree on this, the concept of step is clear enough: it is an ADD instruction (or LOAD+ADD+STORE if you wish, still constant time for fixed width types). Obviously, it does not mean that every occurrence of '+' in python can be computed in constant time.

← PreviousPage 3 of 25Next →