HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cantastoria

346 karma · joined January 6, 2010

submissionscomments
cantastoria··on How Google Killed GDrive and Spiked Its Skype Acquisition
Really? Then why is there a big list of files starring at me when I open Google Docs? There's also a "File" menu with the typical options. Perhaps internally they don't represent these data as files but that seems to be how they're presented to the user. Am I missing something?
cantastoria··on How Google Killed GDrive and Spiked Its Skype Acquisition
Maybe, but being right once doesn't mean they're never wrong again. It's hard for me to see how Google wouldn't have been better off buying Skype and integrating it into GMail. Easier said than done for sure but a hell of a lot easier than getting Skype users to switch to Google Voice. Also, last I checked Google Docs still wants to save things as files. I guess Pichai never had to at least prove his idea correct and justify his decision. Maybe these guys are good product managers but they seem to be pretty bad at strategy. The point I'm making is that they don't seem to have been held accountable.
cantastoria··on How Google Killed GDrive and Spiked Its Skype Acquisition
I blame eBay for that one. Not actually acquiring the underlying technology to Skype was pure idiocy on their part. I don't blame Skype one bit for taking advantage. My point was that apparently Craig Walker having kids in school and lawyers saying it would take months for the deal to go through was enough to kill a deal that had a high chance of success. I understand Chan was protecting his territory but shame on Google management for going along with it.
cantastoria··on How Google Killed GDrive and Spiked Its Skype Acquisition
Given how well DropBox and Skype are doing this doesn't say very much about Google management. I'm surprised Pichai and Chan still have their jobs.
cantastoria··on Rising Wealth Inequality: Should We Care?
I agree with your analysis but I think you missed the fact that al ot of other countries tax spending through VAT rather than income. I'm not saying this is a better system (I don't think it is...). For instance, the standard VAT in Norway is 25% (14% for food and drink) so the slack is being taken up (in a big way) somewhere else.

I also don't care if there is a large income disparity. All the remedies I've seen proposed to fix this "problem" essentially just raise taxes on top earners. I can't think of a worse place for that money than in the hands of a politician.

cantastoria··on Why usability is still a competitive differentiator
You're assuming your prospective customer is able to tell a good design by just looking at it. Has that been your experience? How do you show them attention to design?
cantastoria··on Why usability is still a competitive differentiator
It can be a differentiator but it's a hard one to sell. Telling someone your software is easier to use will usually be met with an eye roll or a snarky "of course you think it's easier to use, it's your software...". Ease-of-use needs to be either demo'd or experienced during a trial period. The question is how do you get a potential user to that point?

Further, you'll notice very few companies that make highly usable products advertise them that way. Look at an Apple ad or Netflix or Toyota. Very rarely do they ever talk about ease-of-use. They always focus on what the product can do and how it makes you feel.

cantastoria··on Ask HN: Best light-weight bug tracking tool, more robust than TRAC?
We love Sifter...

www.sifterapp.com

It's beautifully done, the only drawback is that you can't send it e-mail.

cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
All these people who cry out for affirmative action to be removed, I will see them write two pages about why it should not be there, but they will never advocate the really fair solution, because it will make them extremlely unlikely to ever get into the schools.

But this is essentially how admissions works for whites and asians. They look at your scores if you make the cutoff your in (barring sports scholarships or legacies which I'm also against).

Are you saying of all the applications from black people they received, they did not find 50 that met the cut-off mark? That's a bit unlikely, is it not?

Then why do they have different admissions standards for minority applicants? If it were possible for minority applicants to meet the normal admissions standards affirmative action programs would be unnecessary.

If you want a score based system, then say so and accept that whites will be a tiny minority in those schools

I want a score based system. I'm against affirmative action precisely because it is a hybrid system. Whites and Asians are held to one standard, minorities to another. As I've said before, if you want to admit lower scoring minority applicants adjust the general admissions standards accordingly so they can get in.

cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
All the schools have geographical quotas

Sure but not different admissions criteria based on geography. You still have to meet the criteria regardless. Not so for race based preference systems which are well known for relaxing standards to achieve the desired racial balance.

If a particular school is 40% Jewish and those students are all there because they met the admissions criteria then so be it. It's absurd to create an elite admissions policy and then create preference programs for designated races. I'd much rather the standards were lowered until the desired racial balance occurred organically. However, universities seem to want it both ways.

cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
Yes but there are few (if any) universities that have a "southern accent" based affirmative action policy. If such a policy existed it would exactly the same.
cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
The system is there to spread dark skin across all strata of society, breaking the stereotype that a particular skin color belongs in a particular lower strata.

The problem with this though is that whites have to pretend that the system doesn't exist for it work. If dark-skinned students are allowed in because of a well known preference program the stereotype is in fact reinforced.

cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
Oh I'm sure this is true on some level but it must be difficult to have to constantly deal with the assumption that you're there because of your race. It's just another level of scrutiny, and I guess racism, which is ironically created by the program meant to destroy it.
cantastoria··on Does Diversity Punish Asians, Poor Whites and Others?
I often wondered what psychological effects these diversity programs have on those who are supposedly benefiting from them. Do they walk around campus thinking to themselves "I'm here because I'm black"? This goes double for those minority students who would've been accepted without preferential treatment.
cantastoria··on Dutch Agency Admits Mistake in Climate Report
Were the results of your friends code going to be used to set global energy and environmental policy?
cantastoria··on Will the real programmers please stand up?
Actually we've tried giving them a choice. Most chose to do the assignment rather have to go through a high pressure interview answering whiteboard questions. We're not asking them to solve problems that could possibly be used in any of our products so they don't feel taken advantage of and it's usually something fairly simple (e.g. design a parking lot management system). All in all they probably spend as much time writing the small sample app as they would in the typical all-day interview loop.
cantastoria··on Will the real programmers please stand up?
I also don’t understand what the alternative is: just take people at their word they are great programmers?

We've had great success giving candidates a week to design and implement a small application from end to end. It really let's you see everything all at once. Can they design? Good comments? Good data structure selection?

It's the best of all worlds. The candidate has time to really show off their ability, you'll get a much more holistic view of their skills and it puts them equal footing with the interviewer because they've had a lot time to think about the problem. We found that whiteboard coding questions tend to favor "geek jocks" that are really just good test takers.

cantastoria··on Real Lives and White Lies in the Funding of Scientific Research
I think another problem not discussed in the article is the "manufactured consensus" phenomenon where well funded labs can populate a particular niche with grad students and researchers who are all working from the same theoretical framework. This creates a feedback loop of ever increasing funding and publishing for this ever growing group.

Any researcher who does not subscribe to this false consensus will find it almost impossible to get funded or published. Thus those with radical ideas are kept out of the system. You see this in many of areas scientific research (e.g. viticulture, climatology, linguistics...)

cantastoria··on [dead]
they're only hoping to make the default UI so good that it discourages other manufacturers from rolling their own

This sounds a lot like the rational for the Nexus One. Google will a set a standard so high it will become the baseline for everyone else, minimizing fragmentation (if not eliminating it).

It didn't work then and I'm not sure why they think this is going to work now. Handset makers do not want to become "box makers" for Google, period. If that means splintering Android into a million pieces, so be it.

Google has painted themselves into a corner. The most touted benefit of Android (that it's "open") is proving to be its biggest drawback. But now the question is how do they can maintain control of their platform without mimicking Apple?

cantastoria··on Stack Exchange 2.0
This seems like history repeating itself. Joel's first foray into the consumer market (CityDesk) was a failure but he was able to fall back on the large community of programmers his blog attracted to make FogBugz a success. With StackExchange it seems like things are happening in the reverse order.

It must be frustrating to not be able to break out of the programmer oriented market. I'm not saying this will be a failure but without the large audiences from Joel and Jeff's respective blogs they've got some serious mass marketing to do. It might be time hire a marketing firm.

cantastoria··on Health Reform Expected to Untether Job-Locked Entrepreneurs
The evidence for “job lock” is strong. One example: Americans’ likelihood of self-employment jumps when they turn 65 and become eligible for Medicare

It's much more likely that people over 65 have started receiving their Social Security/401k benefits and have another source of income which minimizes the risk.

I'm not sure why people think insurance is going to be more affordable now. There are aren't any real price controls in the Health Care bill. Exchanges may lower the price but if Massachusetts is any guide premiums are going to increase.

There seems to be this belief that the government is going to mail you an insurance card if you don't already have coverage. I think a lot of people are going to be shocked once they find out what the government has signed them up for.

cantastoria··on Twitter Isn't What You Think It Is
I can't see Twitter surviving if their long term strategy is to sell firehouse access to their competitors. Relying on your competitors to keep in business is a bad business plan to say the least.

The way I see it they're pretty much screwed. They're going to have to start looking at different ways to monetize and they don't have many choices. Injecting adds into everyone's Twitter stream will mean a drop in users for sure plus it will contaminate the firehose. Relying on smaller developers to pay for API access probably isn't going to generate enough revenue especially if other options are available from Google et al. Once again, Google will destroy yet another marker with free...

Of course one also has to wonder if Twitter isn't just a "pet rock" that will run out steam on it's own.

cantastoria··on Who Fatally Wounded Microsoft? It Was Bill Gates.
Meh... I think this is part of the story but not the real reason.

If I remember correctly, most handset makers resisted Windows CE out of fear of becoming "just another bunch of box makers" for Microsoft. I think that's why you saw such an embrace of Symbian (or pretty much anything that wasn't Windows).

It may be hard to believe now but there was a time when everyone was terrified of Microsoft.

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
Yes to everything except for Wave and AppEngine.

I'm pretty sure Google didn't invent web based maps, e-mail and the web browser. Wave and AppEngine were good but useless...

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
And what I'm supposed to do with the source code? Relaunch it as another product and try and compete with Google? Free source code is the oldest trick in Google's book, it amazes me people still fall for it.

Just out of curiosity, does anyone know of an example of a successful startup whose products are based on source code from Google?

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
even if you don't use it yourself - how many times have you had to help out friends or relatives whose Windows installations got screwed up?

Actually never... but anyway.

Sure, giving stuff away may be a cheap ploy to earn goodwill

But it's not a cheap ploy. It's a destroyer of value. Once Google moves into a market it's impossible to compete against them (same used to be true of Microsoft and still is in markets they're dominant in..)

My point is that as a community of people interested in startups/founders one would think Hacker News would be upset by this but everyone seems to celebrate when Google moves into a market and destroys it with free.

Is it really that bizarre that I feel differently about the two companies?

I think it's bizarre you think they're different.

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
I wish we could see more evidence of this talent in their products.

It seems like their "shot-gun" approach is to release a lot a half-baked crap just to generate some headlines and then hope people forget about it (e.g. Wave). I think this used to work when they were competing with Microsoft (which also released half-baked crap but for got called on it.. constantly). But now I think a lot of companies are releasing good products right out of the gate (e.g. Apple, Facebook) and this strategy is going to be less successful in the future.

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
Most true open source software doesn't have the launch pad of GMail either. Besides that, the fact that the open source community clones software and gives it away is just as sad. Open sourcing something doesn't make it pure.

If that were enough to be "evil" then everything would be evil.

I don't care if Google is evil. They're a large corporation trying to make money like any other. They don't care about us.

* Nobody is claiming that Google is innovative in this example.*

My point was that the vast majority of Google's products are clones and yet they're still considered innovative where the same is true of Microsoft and they are not thought of that way.

cantastoria··on Google Buzz
Google has always been this way as far as I can tell. They're basically using Microsoft's old strategy of "clone it and give it away so we can sell more of Windows" only with Google it's ads.

The difference is everyone still loves them. Microsoft was seen as ruthlessly destroying their competition. Google is seen as innovative. Bizarre.

cantastoria··on Ask HN: Review my startup: Cashier Live
Swapping out my "small business perspective" hat for my "engineer with VC sensitivities" hat: the centralization of data and services proposed by cashier live are just nuts. It creates a massive and precarious single point of failure in direct proportion to the number of customers it acquires and the number of transactions it processes. Asked to comment on the technology I would be conscious bound to speak out against it. Asked to invest, I would have to decline.

This is an odd criticism. Why is this any different from letting Google store my spreadsheets or Mint.com store all my banking/cc or 37Signals store all my business contacts. Is it because it's a startup? So much for cloud computing...

I think cashier live would have a chance if it polished up its code, released it under GPL, partnered with accounting firms instead of directly CC processing firms, and went into the premium fee support / consulting business while learning to franchise sales to put qualified reps on the floor of customer's shops to hook things up.

This will turn them into every other POS vendor. I don't see what GPL'ing the code will do (that's not a feature to most people). Same with accounting firms... I'm going to ask my accounting firm for advice on a POS system??? For most small businesses, your accountant is guy that works out his house and can barely use e-mail.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →