HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

clolege

244 karma · joined October 4, 2015

less distortion, more headroom
submissionscomments
clolege··on Proof of stake is incapable of producing a consensus
You any specific verifier/wallet, you won't - but the fake chain will have 0 uncompromised actors after the fork.

Which means that large stakeholders suddenly stop verifying blocks. Long-term active wallets stop transacting.

The same might be true for both chains after the fork, but I would imagine the fake one would have a larger change in participation (weighting older wallets and larger stakes) than the real one.

clolege··on Proof of stake is incapable of producing a consensus
> I think this is where you get the problem - if you just have two sets of signatures, how do you tell which is legitimate and which one isn't? How do you conclude in which set the cabal was lying?

I feel like you should be able to deduce it from the distribution of participation after the fork, right?

The “fake” chain would lose all honest verifiers (and all transactions from honest wallets?) which seems like it would be pretty detectable with simple statistical analysis. Staked nodes not participating (and active wallets not transacting) becomes less and less likely the longer the post-fork chain is.

clolege··on Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for representative elections [pdf]
> No voting system is perfect (Arrow's impossibility theorem)

Arrow's impossibility theorem only says that no _ranked_ voting system is perfect, so it doesn't apply to cardinal methods such as Approval or Score.

> That they have some edge conditions that could be theoretically exploited belies that fact that plurality voting (ie, FPTP / one person one vote) is a complete train wreck for spoilers and favoring extreme voting.

I agree, but I think the nature of the exploitation should still be considered. For IRV, we would be introducing a dependence on unauditable voting machines to tabulate votes, which would make it harder to verify the integrity of future elections.

clolege··on MacBook Pro 14-inch and MacBook Pro 16-inch
Well the iPhone has a touchscreen whereas this will be used with a mouse.

I'm wondering what the behavior will be to run the mouse across the top of the screen?

clolege··on What Is Voter Satisfaction Efficiency?
Right - you have to count up with software or it will take you a while.

To me, it's a hard choice that cardinal systems don't force you to make.

clolege··on What Is Voter Satisfaction Efficiency?
Key word (electronically)

To me, any voting method dependent on software is a non-starter. A full paper trail is much easier to audit

clolege··on The handshake emoji is more complicated than you might think
The handshake emoji bothers me for the same reason as the fist-bump emoji on slack - it ignores consent. What if the receiver doesn't want to shake your hand? Or what if they don't identify with the skin tone that you chose for them?

These types of emojis would be more powerful if all parties had to engage to make them happen. Senders would have to run the risk of being left hanging, which would make a successful shake/bump mean a lot more, and everyone could choose their own skin tones.

My beef is likely with the chat apps that implement this functionality rather than the emoji spec itself, but the implication of letting one person choose the color of both hands in an interaction like this seems to further complicate the consent issue.

clolege··on Heavy is the Head that wears the AirPods Max
Counter-example: Anker's bluetooth speakers are widely viewed to sound better than those from JBL, Sony & Bose and they have fewer years in the audio industry.

There are a many technologies present in products like this that a company that is purely "focused on producing the best headphones" wouldn't normally concern themselves with such as a DAC, amp, DSP, microphone & wireless protocols. When these components are tightly designed together, Apple can disrupt much in the same way they're doing with their M1 line.

clolege··on AirPods Max
This is anecdotal and I mentioned this somewhere else in this thread, but I did a quick shootout between my Sony MDR7506 and a $80 Soundcore Motion+ bluetooth speaker and the Soundcore actually blew the 7506 away.

TBF I was powering the headphones with just my Pixel 3, but it's not a particularly hard to drive headphone.

There's been quite a bit of advancement recently with bluetooth speakers, and we'll probably see some more disruption in the affordable hi-fi space soon with what Purifi is doing with Class D amps.

clolege··on AirPods Max
I actually compared my Sony MDR7506 with my Anker Soundcore Motion+ this morning and the Soundcore blew away the Sonys to my ear. Yes, the Soundcore is an unrepairable bluetooth speaker, but they both cost ~$80
clolege··on AirPods Max
Haha fair enough. I ran an HD 6XX with a Jotunheim for a while, but ended up preferring a pair of JBL LSR305s with an SVS sub a lot more.

I think the main reasons were being able to experience the sub frequencies with my entire body (they're too big to fit in your ears!), and share the experience with my friends.

clolege··on AirPods Max
> For speakers multiply that by 10 at least.

I put together a ~$3k system recently that has blown away any headphone experience I've had [0] [1] [2].

I guess for me, the experience goes beyond just what the music sounds like. Being able to dance without having to worry about anything falling off of my head or out of my ears, and being able to share the experience with my girlfriend and others effectively multiplies the joy I get by an order of magnitude.

[0] https://www.minidsp.com/products/streaming-hd-series/shd

[1] https://vtvamplifier.com/product/vtv-amplifier-stereo-purifi...

[2] https://www.parts-express.com/solstice-mltl-reference-tower-...

clolege··on AirPods Max
$450 endgame? What do you have?
clolege··on AirPods Max
Totally valid point. In most cases, I think the layman will generally find an equivalently priced speaker setup over $600 sounds better.

Reasons that I can think that someone might still go with open backs are:

• Portability - You can move around your house or go running without leaving the music.

• Less dependent of environment - they basically sound the same in a small, big, or acoustically reflective rooms.

• Leak less sound than speakers - you can blast music without waking up your kids or downstairs neighbors.

• Better high frequency reproduction - whereas full sound systems will generally do better with lower.

EDIT: Added price stipulation to where speakers start to sound better. Agreed that if you're not willing to spend much and want to listen alone, headphones are the better choice.

clolege··on AirPods Max
I've been eyeballing the AirPods Pro as well! I had a coworker who was using a pair for video conferencing, and recommended them at first - but eventually became repeatedly inconvenienced by the battery running out and having to change to a wired set.

Not sure if the problem could have been solved with more consistent charging - but it convinced me to stick with wired WFH drivers for now.

I'd still consider getting a pair for running if it wasn't for my environmental concerns wrt the rattling problems.

clolege··on AirPods Max
> A $400 Sennheiser 650 will no doubt blow them away while still being $150 cheaper.

Of course they will. But it's not fair to compare open backs with closed backs without a huge asterisk [0]

> If you want the best sound quality for the buck, you usually need to go with open-backed (or simply “open”) headphones. The open (but uncomfortable) SR60 is probably the best value in the business, followed by the awesome DT-880, which is far better than everything in this review in both comfort and sound quality. But open headphones are like screen doors: they let all exterior noise in, and more importantly, they let all of your music out. This will annoy anyone around you, so it’s extremely inconsiderate to use open headphones in buses, trains, airplanes, shared offices, or anywhere else near other people, and it’s irresponsible to recommend them without this huge warning.

[0] https://marco.org/headphones-closed-portable

clolege··on AirPods Max
Right - I gifted a pair of MDR7506s to my girlfriend the other day.

I love that they include an insert telling you exactly how to take the entire headphone apart - I don't think I've owned a pair like that before.

But, I broke out my B&O H6s to do an A/B test after giving them to her, and I think it was a mistake? The H6s are of course in the next higher price price bracket, but the 7506s did not compare musically to them at all.

As much as I appreciate the repairability of the 7506s, I think would recommend something a bit more musical as a daily driver.

clolege··on AirPods Max
I've never had a pair break, just had to replace the pads as they wore out after a couple of years. I don't think I've been _particularly_ careful with them, but I definitely don't toss them into my backpack or anything like that?

What did you upgrade to?

clolege··on AirPods Max
Unfortunately, I haven't been able to try it out yet. I'm not particularly interested in the TV watching use case (I don't watch TV), but I think that there could be some cool AR use cases that I would love to play around with.

Such as a Zombies Run sort of game where you could hear the zombies behind you, or approaching from other streets. Not sure if any such applications exist yet, though?

clolege··on AirPods Max
Are you guessing on the 500ms? Looks like the most recent AirPods Pro can achieve 144ms [0], so I'd imagine the Max to be slightly less.

Not great, but should allow phone conversations without too much fatigue.

[0] https://9to5mac.com/2019/12/22/airpods-latency-test/

clolege··on AirPods Max
The Porta Pros are still amazing headphones. Lifetime warranty, cheap, and great sound. They work perfect for exercising, if you're willing to put up with the cable
clolege··on AirPods Max
Is it possible that they might actually be able to accept an audio signal over the cable as well?

It would be nice for those that have lower-latency needs.

clolege··on AirPods Max
Are there any other offerings for wireless spatial audio? That would be the main selling point for me.
clolege··on AirPods Max
These are quite appealing for their spatial audio support, without seeming quite as throwaway as the in-ear AirPods [0].

I wonder if they'll end up sounding like beats?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23826070

clolege··on Microdosing: Improving performance enhancement in intelligence analysis (2019) [pdf]
Interesting, I've recently started committing to a hard 10-minute workout each day of the week, and it's been helping me focus through my ADD a lot better too. I feel so much more alive.

I've also picked up meditating 10 minutes a day and that's been helping as well, but I don't think as much.

clolege··on Kuo: Apple to include new scissor switch keyboard in MacBook
I wonder if you had a counterfeit Magsafe adapter? They commonly get shipped with used Macbooks, and get quite a bit hotter than their genuine counterparts.

I have personally preferred the Magsafe adapters ever since I had a USB-C powered Macbook slide off my bed by accident. It didn't fall far, but it landed right on the power cable and damaged both the USB port and the cable.

Understandably, Macbooks are not designed to withstand any sort of drops, but I'm positive that the Magsafe of my 2015 MBP would have popped out, and the body of the PC would have been fine.

clolege··on VNC Roulette
I actually accidentally left my bike beside a busy street last night here in Seoul unlocked. I went back and got it today (Sunday night) and not a single person had touched it.

I don't think that it's population density as much as the shared culture of the place you live. I would have totally blamed myself if my bike wasn't there today, and I think it would be stupid to blame anyone else.

clolege··on Introducing the Shift Card: Use Bitcoin where Visa is accepted
I've had the same exact experience. They locked my account for weeks without response to my emails, and when they finally get back to me they told me that I'm "ineligible to use their service" but without ever a reason why.

The entire ordeal was really frustrating and I would strongly recommend against their service also.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4