HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cnewey

147 karma · joined August 1, 2017

submissionscomments
cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
I can't speak for the US, but I've been told by the clinical specialists at my local hospital that Humira cost £400+ per pen (this was back in 2015). I don't think that AbbVie can offset any of that price as a charitable donation, so I guess that price must be what they actually charge.
cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
I'm trying to fathom your point. Regardless of how much rent or mortgages cost, do you think it's acceptable or fair for individuals with chronic illnesses to bear the cost of a treatment which would cost them more than their rent (i.e. an additional cost which healthy people wouldn't have to pay?). That sounds like a pretty bad deal if you ask me - not only would one have to deal with a chronic disease, one would also have to budget for a (very considerable) additional expenditure which healthy individuals wouldn't have. At the end of the day, that is what makes the price of Humira unfair and immoral - its ability to severely financially disadvantage its patients (by being priced disproportionately compared to the cost of R&D / production).

Now, if you're talking about spreading the cost of all medical care across the entirety of the working-age population (essentially, national insurance) - that's a more sensible proposition. In fact, that's (broadly speaking, of course) what the NHS does in the UK - and the system works quite well.

cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
Perhaps the NHS shouldn't - not paying for Humira would essentially obliterate AbbVie's UK market, which would make a considerable dent in their profits... I guess that would probably make them re-think their pricing structure!

However, presumably the treatment is "worth" the NHS paying for it - even if it is massively overpriced. I can't really pass comment on their medication choices.

cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
Bearing in mind that accommodation is quite frequently the single largest outgoing in many people's finances (i.e. commonly approx. 30% of income), do you really think that the cost of medical treatment should exceed this? Do you really think that medical treatment should be an individual's single largest outgoing cost?

As for giving money to scientists/doctors/researchers, that isn't really the case either. See [1] - the cost of prescription medication appears to be largely determined by "what the market will bear", rather than how much a drug costs to research and develop.

[1]: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/25456...

cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
Actually, I don't think that's quite correct. The specialists that prescribed me the Humira treatment were quite keen to impress upon me the cost of the drug - i.e. that it "costs the NHS over £400 per pen" (and this was back in 2015). Of course, this is purely anecdotal but I'm inclined to believe the source as they've no motivation to mislead me.
cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
I'm not especially familiar with the structure of the US health insurance system, but I think that the lower costs mentioned on the page you linked largely depends on either receipt of considerable amounts of state aid, or having pretty high-quality insurance.

Certainly, if you were to flick through various forums for those with Crohn's disease (e.g. [1]), you'd find many stories of people paying hundreds (or even thousands) of dollars for a month's Humira treatment.

[1]: https://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=38&m=22...

cnewey··on Humira’s Drug Formula: Start at a High Price, Go Higher
Humira really is a life-changing drug - but it is offensively, eye-wateringly expensive. Each auto-injector pen costs approx. £500; and I have to take one every 2 weeks. To put that in perspective, that's a cost of about £1000 per month - which is considerably more than my mortgage. My house costs less than my medical treatment.

Fortunately for me, I live in the UK, where the NHS is able to help absorb these costs. In the US, I guess they aren't so lucky - if I lived there, my Humira treatment would financially destroy me - and probably my entire family, too. It's morally reprehensible for a company to have access to such a life-changing treatment and then proceed to charge such disproportionately vast sums of money (certainly, far beyond the cost of R&D).

I suppose you could say that instead of crippling its patients physically (like their medical problems do), Humira cripples its patients financially - and I'm not sure that's a great deal better.

cnewey··on YouTube Demonetization Screenshot Leaks and Secret YouTube Meeting
Your argument that algorithms are transparent is equally flawed. There is an entire field of research dedicated to introspection of layers in convolutional neural networks! A system that is complex and nuanced enough to be able to deal with a problem such as auto-moderating YouTube videos will be phenomenally difficult to inspect (and nearly impossible to "adjust" in the way that you seem to be suggesting).

To clarify; I am not saying that it will never be possible to solve this sort of problem with an algorithm - just that doing so would require solving the small inconvenience of general artificial intelligence first... :-).

It certainly isn't beyond the realm of possibility in the (very distant) future, but to suggest that it's possible right now (and that it would be better than a human!) is to over-egg the pudding somewhat.

cnewey··on YouTube Demonetization Screenshot Leaks and Secret YouTube Meeting
You're implicitly making the assumption that an algorithm is unbiased and less likely to be fallible - and unlikely to be susceptible to bias or manipulation (at least, compared to a human). There is a considerable amount of academic and popular literature showing that these assumptions are false, at least at a technical level.

The problem of vetting YouTube videos isn't necessarily something that can be solved by an algorithm, at the end of the day. Lots of the simple cases, sure - but such an algorithm won't work on even the most moderately challenging content. After all, moderating complex content such as video doesn't just require a well-trained neural network to recognise objects portrayed in images and sounds in audio... deciding whether a video is appropriate or not for monetisation is something that requires an explicit understanding of the social and cultural context which the video is going to be viewed in - which is both highly subjective and difficult to express in an algorithm.

NB;

- Neural networks (and other AI techniques) can be tricked and manipulated (see [0,1]; examples of adversarial images)

- Machine learning algorithms can induce or confirm bias through inadequate training data and poor assumptions. (see [2]; a book about bias in machine learning algorithms)

[0]: https://arxiv.org/abs/1510.05328

[1]: http://www.evolvingai.org/files/DNNsEasilyFooled_cvpr15.pdf

[2]: https://weaponsofmathdestructionbook.com

cnewey··on “Hey”, an interruption tracker written in Scheme
Thanks! I love the idea most of all, and knocked up a very rough and ready Python version this afternoon so that I could start using something similar straight away. I'll definitely keep an eye on the project's progress :-)
cnewey··on “Hey”, an interruption tracker written in Scheme
This looks fantastic and I'd love to start using it. Unfortunately it seems to be written in a particularly obscure Lisp dialect and the build script is... temperamental at best.
cnewey··on Dragon Helmet: Open-source collaboration that aims to create a high tech helmet
I saw that, but there's no explanation of what the virtual assistant will do in context of the helmet (automate emails? terminal commands? maps and navigation? cowsay?).

As for the rest of the armour links... I never understood the point of submitting something to HN that was barely more than a landing page. Just seems a bit misjudged, is all.

cnewey··on Dragon Helmet: Open-source collaboration that aims to create a high tech helmet
I don't know if the website is deliberately vague, or the proposers of this project just don't know what it's going to be yet. There's not really any mention of why it would be useful, what it would do, and why anyone would want to build one.

  * It's unlikely to be a motorcycle helmet because sharp embedded electronics inside a helmet is a recipe for head injury
  * It might be useful on a bicycle (for couriers, etc), but having windows popping up while cycling is a pretty bad idea
  * It might be useful for walking around (but probably not because it would look stupid)
Honestly, this is frustrating to read because I still can't figure out what it's for.
cnewey··on In Colorado, opioid deaths fall following marijuana legalization
In the article's main image, cited directly from the paper in question (https://img.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/files/2017/10/...), there doesn't really appear to be much of a correlation. Looking at the high variance in the opioid death data (because there are - fortunately - so few samples), so I'm not really certain if one can extrapolate a trend so soon after the legislation was enacted. The data simply appears to be too noisy. Even the paper states that the upper limit of its 95% confidence interval is a net reduction in deaths by a whopping... 0.03 per month.

I've said this before, but; by all means, we should embrace the (clearly very real) medical value of this plant by allocating funding and legal frameworks to research it properly. Lots of current cannabis research is plagued by bad experimental methodology, statistically insignificant conclusions, extrapolation of non-existent trends, and broad hand-wavey statements that aren't really backed up by facts, and it's a shame because it cheapens the value of a genuinely promising medical treatment that offers hope for people suffering from a litany of conditions (myself included).

cnewey··on Medical marijuana patients report reduction in use of prescription drugs
This is a pretty weak article, and (from what I can make out), a pretty weak study too. Obviously, there's the usual concern about sample sizes (30 people does not a scientific study make), but this study is also self-selected (i.e. survey respondents chose whether to take part or not - obviously a considerable source of bias), and even more worryingly, it appears that the "study" in question is simply a survey where participants report changes in their own use of prescription drugs. So not only are there very few participants in the study - but they're also self-selected, and so are their answers. This is anecdata at its finest and really shouldn't be in a peer-reviewed journal. (P.S. the journal article itself isn't linked on the Chicago Tribune's website at all...).

I really think there is genuine medical potential to be discovered from cannabis and exploited for the greater good - but our enthusiasm to access these potential benefits should not get in the way of doing good science. This sort of badly-executed study just cheapens genuine efforts to do sensible research into its medical value.

cnewey··on GM is launching a $5K tiny electric car in China made for city commuters
As others have said - many people (quite rightly) have concerns about supporting the Daily Mail by giving it clicks, eyeball time, and advertising revenue. Partly because of their reputation of being rather unpleasantly right-wing when it comes to immigration, the economy, women's rights, etc; but also partly because their reputation as a truthful source of news is resoundingly poor (as evidenced by the DM being disallowed as a source on Wikipedia, their reputation for publishing embellished or downright untrue stories, etc).

[edit]: After doing a bit more digging, it also turns out that CNN Money often publishes companies' press releases almost verbatim. Oops.

cnewey··on GM is launching a $5K tiny electric car in China made for city commuters
For those looking for a somewhat more reputable source for news on this article, CNN[0] has a good piece.

[0] http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/07/autos/gm-china-electric-car/...

cnewey··on Solve large jigsaw puzzles using genetic algorithms and OpenCV
There are several prominent women in CS that I know personally and respect (some of whom are image processing/CV researchers), who find the image sexist and demeaning. I sympathise with their viewpoint and am inclined to agree with them. I'm clearly not looking to create controversy or be offended on other people's behalf - I'm just trying to not be a dick.
cnewey··on Solve large jigsaw puzzles using genetic algorithms and OpenCV
For any curious minds wondering about the provenance of the Lena image, here's a short article written in 1996 by the (at the time) editor-in-chief of IEEE Transactions on Image Processing. The controversy (and both viewpoints) are summed up quite adequately.

http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~chuck/lennapg/editor.html

To respond to your point - while you might be technically correct in that the Lena image commonly used today is not a "nude" image per se... are you genuinely saying that you don't understand why some people don't like it - or why it's unpleasant and/or degrading to women in the field? Its provenance is well known, and the very association with Playboy (nudity notwithstanding) is likely enough to irritate or upset women in image processing/computer vision circles (I say this having had personal experience of various -- female -- lecturers at my alma mater disagreeing with the use of the Lena image).

cnewey··on Solve large jigsaw puzzles using genetic algorithms and OpenCV
In that case, I apologise! It was not my intention to be blunt or rude if you were asking out of curiosity - sincere apologies.
cnewey··on Solve large jigsaw puzzles using genetic algorithms and OpenCV
If I need to explain to you why using a nude image of a model (taken from a pornography magazine, no less) is hostile and disrespectful, then I suspect you are part of the problem.
cnewey··on Solve large jigsaw puzzles using genetic algorithms and OpenCV
I'm rather disappointed to see the Lena image still being used as a demonstration for image processing techniques (regardless of its historical context).

At best, it's crass and tasteless. At worst, it's openly disrespectful and hostile to women. There are millions (billions) of images on the Internet that are available for use under a permissive license - it doesn't take a lot of effort to use something else.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2