HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

distortedsignal

433 karma · joined October 31, 2016

distortedsignal+hn@gmail.com
submissionscomments
distortedsignal··on The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?
All of those elements are so common - this should be easy to test. We'll see.
distortedsignal··on Arc Browser 1.0
I think this is the Ouroboros of curiosity - discovery, investigation, disappointment, amnesia. If it doesn't catch, we don't really remember it. This seems very human.
distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Sorry, I misunderstood.
distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Yeah - but that's a different problem. How many barbers are there in your city? How many taxi drivers?

Now - how should Google satisfy all of those people?

I'll confess that I don't have the answer here. But if you're trying to look up "barber ${my_city}" or "taxi ${my_city}", and there are more than one page of results, everyone but the top 10 (top 20? how many results per page are there on google these days?) is going to be unhappy.

Unless there are 20 (or 40?) or fewer barbers in your city, more than half the barbers are going to be unhappy with google. It sucks, but when x people are clamoring for y resources, x - y people will be unhappy. And if y is significantly smaller than x, a significant amount of people are going to be unhappy.

distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Help me out here - could you give me examples of "what laptops people consider the best" pages that <i>aren't</i> in the top of Google? I still don't understand, and I want to.
distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
We've all had our denvercoder9 moment, for sure.
distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Yeah - I think that "commercialization and commodification" is kind of what I've attributed this to. I think the webring concept is probably the best way to get away from this, but it's not trivial to find those hidden gems. The good ones become/became less hidden. The bad ones get/got buried.

But if these are the complaints about Google - "I only see sites that are so good that they constitute the mainstream" - I'm... ok with that? That seems like a good outcome to me. I don't mind using that tool.

From what I understand of your complaint, sometime in the last 20 years, the Google stopped finding outsider art. I would guess that's due to SEO. And with anything that's known to drive revenue to a business, that sort of thing becomes a target. So people target the Google algorithm to place better. I don't know that there's a solution to that. But I don't think it's because of a change inside Google - more like a change in society.

distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
I want to point out - if you get to the seventh page of Google, it's been known for some time that those results are... specious at best. Check out this xkcd from almost a decade ago:

https://xkcd.com/1334/

https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1334:_Second

If you're really going to page 7 of Google... man, that's a desperation I've never known.

distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Ok, I'll try that.

Top results (excluding sponsors b/c UBlock Origin):

PC Gamer

The Verge

Games Radar

Youtube (channel: Jarrod's Tech)

A giant ad showing some laptops to buy

Youtube (channel: PC Builder)

RTINGS.com

PC Magazine

Youtube (channel: Top Tech Now)

CNET

Tom's Hardware

Another giant ad showing some laptops to buy

Engadget

PC Magazine

Laptop Mag

TechRadar

These are mainstream tech press sites. And maybe the reason that it's a bunch of similar listicles is because the thing you're looking for (a laptop) is a product with relatively few entries in the market.

What are you expecting here that Google isn't giving you? I'm trying to be as charitable as possible, but, for me, the expected results are about as good as I could hope for.

distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
Tried this test three ways - from my wifi, on my phone's LTE connection, and via a VPN that my family uses, all in private windows to prevent Google using my local cache.

All found my LinkedIn in the top 2 slots.

It seems pretty stable to me? How could I make this cleaner?

distortedsignal··on Become Ungoogleable
I'm not sure that I agree.

My brother tried to set me up with a girl last week. She has a pretty uncommon name. Googled her. Found... a lot of stuff.

I have a VERY common name. Think multiple (relatively) famous people (photographers, US Medal of Honor winner, enough lawyers to choke a court system for DECADES), but if you google my name and the city I live in (1,000,000+ people), my LinkedIn is like the second result.

For everyone saying that Google has gotten worse over the time they've been using it, these two use cases (which are pretty challenging) do really still work.

distortedsignal··on Stanford president resigns over manipulated research, will retract 3 papers
I like to call "not being afraid to look dumb" "weaponizing my own stupidity." I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, but if you aren't worried about looking like a dope from time-to-time, you can help the actually smart people in the room agree on stuff.
distortedsignal··on I stopped buying new laptops (2020)
On my (2020 intel) MBP, SSD IO is VERY power hungry. Usually the culprit is Firefox, but my company is on the MS office suite, so sometimes it’s Outlook or Teams. It’s frustrating.
distortedsignal··on My small, no name company has lost its mind with AI
I’ll push back on this, at least in its current iteration. I just asked it to list some restaurants near my apartment (major intersection in San Jose) and it wasn’t particularly close. While there are several restaurants less than half a mile from the intersection, ChatGPT listed restaurants from several miles away.

Given the “weights in a matrix” architecture of ChatGPT, I’m not sure it’s possible to store enough data to make the query practical to answer. Say there are a couple hundred intersections in my city. You have to store the token of “restaurant name” “close to” “intersection” for each intersection. I don’t know the size of Google’s Maps DB, but I would guess it’s several Gigabytes per city. From my understanding of the theory, you would need to store BOTH the LLM weights AND the Maps data for ChatGPT to have a shot at generating good answers for that type of query.

I’m happy to be wrong here. If I’m misunderstanding something, please let me know.

distortedsignal··on The One Ring card, Magic: The Gathering’s coveted collectible, has been found
Since Orb specifies a full rotation of the card during descent, how would the destructive play be ruled? I would imagine that there's some kind of group theory argument that if each individual piece of the card turns over, then the entire card has turned over, but it's not satisfying from a physics perspective. Do you have any rulings from the time?
distortedsignal··on The One Ring card, Magic: The Gathering’s coveted collectible, has been found
You might be conflating two things.

One is Chaos Orb, a card in the original Magic sets. https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multive...

One is Chaos Confetti, a card in one of the Un- sets that you were referring to. https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multive...

I don't know if the Chaos Orb play is real or apocryphal. It may be that Chaos Confetti is a reaction to the story behind Chaos Orb.

As a side note, neither of these cards are legal in any common tournaments anymore.

distortedsignal··on Physicists discover a new switch for superconductivity
That's neat! Is there an arXiv link to the paper? It looks like the Nature link requires a subscription.
distortedsignal··on Kera Desktop: open-source, cross-platform, web-based desktop environment
Delightful. Thank you!
distortedsignal··on Kera Desktop: open-source, cross-platform, web-based desktop environment
I think these types of projects are super cool, and being someone who was BORN IN THE 1980s, I really like the Desktop Analogy. Is there somewhere that I can look at several of these web-based desktop environments at the same time? Is there a good list of open-source web-based desktops that anyone knows of?
distortedsignal··on The impact of the ‘long peace’ on modern military capabilities
How do you know which conflict you're going to fight next?

Each of these commanders may be better suited to a different conflict. The commander who is competent in one conflict may be a buffoon in a different conflict.

Even winning battles doesn't necessarily set up a commander for success. If your enemy changes between conflicts (say, going from a near-peer adversary to an insurgent adversary, a-la-Gulf War 1 -> Gulf War 2, or insurgency to near-peer, a-la Russia-in-Chechnya to Russia-in-Ukraine), radically different strategy, operations, and tactics are required.

I think this goes a long way to explaining the old saying "everyone prepares to win the last war." It boils down to "this guy did good last time, he'll do good this time too" when what helped him the last time is a very specific way of thinking that is not applicable now.

TL;DR: Responding to Change over Following a Plan

distortedsignal··on Lawyer who used ChatGPT faces penalty for made up citations
If I'm a lawyer, I hope that my opponent fabricates cases.

Judges don't generally take kindly to that kind of thing, and that is only going to help my side.

Aside from that, it seems pretty trivial to prove that the cases don't exist. Here's a guy on YouTube talking about the case: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GExSDY6Wz9Y

distortedsignal··on Apple Vision
https://store.steampowered.com/valveindex
distortedsignal··on Chapel: Programming Language for Parallel Computing
Chapel website: https://chapel-lang.org/

Looks like there's a workshop set up for tomorrow to help people get started with the language: https://chapel-lang.org/CHIUW2023.html

distortedsignal··on In Erlang/OTP 27, +0.0 will no longer be exactly equal to -0.0
Shouldn't both of those be NaN? Does Erlang have a NaN?
distortedsignal··on It's time to reveal all recommendation algorithms – by law if necessary
> ... I don't see why we should put up with it.

I mean, you don't have to. Don't want to see YouTube's algorithmic feed? That's cool - just HTTP 3xx your youtube.com to the subscriptions page. There are some good browser addons to do just that[1][2].

Granted, that doesn't remove the recommendation algorithm from your YouTube experience. You would have to use some kind of content blocker to remove the algorithmic feeds from the video pages. I find that uBlockOrigin works well for that.

[1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/redirector/

[2] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/redirector/ocgpenf...

distortedsignal··on It's time to reveal all recommendation algorithms – by law if necessary
I hope the /s at the end of the last comment was loud enough to not be stated.

But I read the article. Yeah, it was dumb. Specifically:

> If recommendation algos aren’t shared then we need - by legislation, if necessary - a switch that turns the recommendation engine off.

This is... baffling. On YouTube - the case-in-point of the article - you already have access to a non-algorithmic feed of videos: namely, your Subscriptions feed.

And if you don't want a recommendation algorithm, good luck finding new content that you like.

And if you "turn off" the recommendation algorithm, you want... what, exactly? The latest videos uploaded to the platform? Still a recommendation algorithm. Videos with words in titles similar to the last video you watched? Still a recommendation algorithm. Videos that the creators of your favorite channel watched? STILL A RECOMMENDATION ALGORITHM.

I was wrong. The desire of the author is far dumber than I originally gave credit for.

distortedsignal··on It's time to reveal all recommendation algorithms – by law if necessary
I feel like "open the recommendation algorithms!" is easy to _say_, and it's less easy (and maybe impossible) to do effectively.

Should we have access (by law) to the code that makes recommendations on content? That seems like a governmental overreach. If that was the case, then we should have to have direct access to the brain of every editor/layout person of every newspaper. Why was one story above the fold vs below the fold vs on page 4? I don't see a whole lot of distinction between those two.

Once we get access to that, how do we keep people from abusing these algorithms on the supply side? Thought SEO sites were bad before? Guess what happens when those sites know what they're _actually targeting_, as opposed to blindly guessing!

As a question, how well do you understand the recommender system that you've created? For a given piece of content, would you be able to guess at the penetration into the platform? As an outsider, I sometimes feel like the recommender systems I interact with have grown out of the platform holder's control (see: Nazi/ISIS/ISIL propaganda on YouTube, etc.). I think these are the points the article is reacting to.

So if the article is saying "I would really rather not see Nazi/ISIS/ISIL propaganda," then, ok, that's good. That's a good want. But we're going to need an algorithm to determine what that propaganda _is_, and then downrank that for that user.

So, is the conclusion of the article... misguided? Sure! Is the desire of the author valid?

I don't know. I don't have time to read these articles.

distortedsignal··on There's something off about LED bulbs
> The impetus is on you to decide when things have started to look uncanny. “I wish that would be addressed by the industry — like, maybe if it reached a certain light-loss factor, it would just shut down, you know?” Nelson said. “Or if it shifted in color past a certain point, it went into failure mode.”

This is complicated, and I don't think the consumer knows what they're asking for. From my understanding (and watching a lot of Big Clive lightbulb teardowns on YouTube), this would require an active sensor in the bulb. Most of the circuits in these bulbs are embarrassingly simple - 3-4 mostly passive components, and 1-2 silicon based chips or raw transistors. If you add an active sensor to that system, your cost balloons significantly. Then you have to calibrate the sensors. Then we get into the "printer cartridge" problem, where "my light bulb won't turn on because it's insufficiently cyan, but I only want a red light."

We didn't know that we wanted things when we had incandescent bulbs. Now that we're being forced to switch away from incandescent bulbs and use a new technology, users are able to ask for things. I think that's partially exciting (users having preferences is good!), but it's also potentially complicated by companies not providing low-cost solutions that are as good as the old thing. So, overall, good and bad.

distortedsignal··on Stop Building on Corporate-Controlled Languages
They should, but that's another issue.
distortedsignal··on Analog Chess
Is that... true? Are there tournament rules that say that? I'm not much of an OTB player, but this strikes me as somewhat against the spirit of the game. I will freely admit that I don't play blitz unless it's on a computer (I hate chess clocks) and computers don't allow illegal moves, but I would be very surprised if tournaments operated like this. Even small, local tournaments.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →