HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

drongoking

376 karma · joined August 26, 2016

submissionscomments
drongoking··on 'Barnacle' car windscreen clamp sparks student fury
"One poster on social news site Reddit claimed he had been able to extract a mobile network Sim card from one of the devices, and used it to access the internet for free."

When life gives you lemons, dig the sim cards out of them and get free internet.

drongoking··on Researchers: Are we on the cusp of an ‘AI winter’?
I think when performance on a real world task can be expressed as a single percentage, we've over-simplified the hell out of it and it's time to rethink the problem.
drongoking··on Researchers: Are we on the cusp of an ‘AI winter’?
I'm always bemused by the idea that AI is nothing but machine learning, and ML is nothing but predictive analytics. Equating research in AI with a "boring hyperparameter search" shows how narrow it's become; saying you've "gotten 97% on a problem" refers to, obviously, classification accuracy of a model on a set of labeled instances. "Use AI/ML to solve X" means finding a way to translate X into a prediction task over feature vectors.

There's an old saying "If all you have is a hammer, all your problems start to look like nails." We may see an AI winter come about simply because we run out of things to pound with our hammer.

drongoking··on Ask HN: What has your work taught you that other people don't realize?
- Groupthink is a very real thing, and stronger than most people realize. People in a group will hold and defend beliefs that they would never individually hold, simply because they're (perceived to be) part of the group's beliefs.

- Being results-oriented can be detrimental to doing anything useful.

drongoking··on Facebook's PR feels broken
This is a place that famously had a motto "move fast and break things." In other words, fail early and fail often. For that culture to succeed you need people willing to admit (and tolerate) mistakes. Sounds like that's pretty well gone.
drongoking··on Predicting where AI is going in 2020
I'm generally pessimistic about predictions of the future. In this case I can't help but smile. They're trying to predict how a field (AI), which deals with complex adaptation, will intelligently adapt its adaptive techniques in the coming year, within an environment (we humans) that are themselves changing behavior while adapting to AI. That's approximately three meta levels. Good luck, guys!
drongoking··on Tell HN: Happy New Decade
Congratulations, you've become That Guy.
drongoking··on Lenia – Mathematical Life Forms
I thought that cellular referred to each point (cell) having its own neighborhood and reacting individually. IIRC, cellular automata have been generalized (made continuous) in both space and time by various researchers, making them (as you point out) less "cellular".

As for how they are different from general dynamical systems, the GDSs I've seen have a small set of differential equations that describe the whole system; a cellular automaton has the same rule for each cell but the system comprises a large number of cells. In other words, locality and massive parallelism.

But this isn't my field so correct me if I'm wrong...

drongoking··on I don’t use Semantic Web technologies anymore, though they still influence me
Community aside, I'd love to read an article on what's good and bad in the current semantic web. Maybe it would have to be written anonymously.

Or maybe contact O'Reilly and write an intro book "Semantic Web: Just the Good Parts" for their series.

drongoking··on I don’t use Semantic Web technologies anymore, though they still influence me
This is too extreme. If, like Google, you have a flock of Ph.D.s who you can put onto an NLP problem to extract semantics from text, then semantic markup becomes less valuable. Not all of us are in that situation. And I don't think parsing text is the only application of the semantic web. Having hugs databases full of knowledge is interesting in itself.

As for semantic markup being confusing and usually wrong, I don't know where you get that.

drongoking··on The Cathedral and the Bizarre
I don't buy his argument and I think he's confused. Lots of people have released code on github (as have I) so that other people can use it. Lots of it isn't used, so it looks abandoned. Maybe it is. So what? Why is that considered a failure of Open Source?

I think he's applying closed source's rules. A closed source project is a failure if no one uses (ie, buys) it, since it represents a development cost that wasn't compensated. Not so with open source. I don't suffer if no one uses my project, and the existence of my repositories doesn't detract from anyone else's work.

drongoking··on Cyc
Two questions.

It's difficult to evaluate CYC given Cycorp's secrecy. Domingos called it something like a colossal failure, which is hard to believe, but it's hard to argue given how little info gets out of Cycorp. So does Cycorp have any interest in changing this? Do they care about improving their reputation in the AI community?

How would you compare Cyc (both the knowledge base and the inference engine) with current efforts in the semantic web? Is OWL/RDF just too simple to encode the kind of logic you think common sense needs?

drongoking··on Cyc
OK, what experiments would you design to test whether AGI is possible? Given the decades (centuries?) of thought that have gone into the issue, I'm sure a set of experiments would be valuable.
drongoking··on ArXiv Monitor
I think you are correct: this site doesn't really do what it claims. I'm not sure how it's different from just searching arXiv.

I am pleased to see paperswithcode.com as a collection point of research. But the fact that it casts all of AI as one big set of contests on datasets where "progress" is equated with small increments of classification accuracy is, well, a disappointing view of the field.

drongoking··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
The Turing Test has nothing to do with chess or any other game. It's a conversational test between two parties. It doesn't refer to human-level performance on any specific task. Please check Wikipedia.

> Sure; all the parts haven't been completely connected to make self driving cars, general game playing AIs or conversation bots.

This implies that connecting these systems is just a detail to be worked out. But the systems have nothing in common ontologically---they share no inputs, outputs, or intermediate concepts. The fact that they both use neurons doesn't mean much. You may as well say we can connect snails and dogs.

drongoking··on Aldous Huxley Foresaw America’s Pill-Popping Addiction
Heh. Except it took forever for states to begin decriminalizing/legalizing marijuana, and it isn't legal at the Federal level yet.
drongoking··on Aldous Huxley Foresaw America’s Pill-Popping Addiction
Yep. Huxley was heavily into Hinduism. "The original soma, from which I took the name of this hypothetical drug, was an unknown plant (possibly Asclepias acida) used by the ancient Aryan invaders of India in one of the most solemn of their religious rites." (_Brave New World Revisited_, Aldous Huxley)
drongoking··on Aldous Huxley Foresaw America’s Pill-Popping Addiction
I'm genuinely surprised. Maybe it's just for psych ailments (e.g. anxiety) that use has declined.

> the biggest rise in prescriptions during this time period was for back pain and other types of chronic pain.

Now I'm doubly surprised. Some benzos have muscle relaxant properties but I've never heard of them prescribed for pain.

(I've never experienced benzo withdrawal but I've heard it claimed to be as bad as opiate withdrawal.)

drongoking··on Aldous Huxley Foresaw America’s Pill-Popping Addiction
I hate to be That Guy Who Argues With Everything, but I will. I'm a big fan of Huxley and Brave New World, but he wasn't particularly visionary with Soma. Drug use goes back as far as humankind does because people have been trying to cope with the stress of life since there have been people. If you're looking for a drug that helps with the anxieties of everyday life, alcohol would have my vote. It's been used for thousands of years, for better or worse. Alcohol use comes with lots of problems, of course, but that doesn't stop it from being the socially acceptable drug of choice.

As for Valium, it seems odd this article even makes a big deal about it. Valium (and benzodiazepines in general) aren't prescribed as much these days because of their addictive potential. Their spike of popularity came and went in a few decades, roughly 1960-1980. Benzos are still popular in illicit use, but a key point of Soma was that it wasn't illicit---it was sanctioned by the state.

drongoking··on The Plain Text Project
I'm confused about what plain text means if JSON and YAML don't qualify. They are non-binary and non-proprietary. Is CSV plain text? And the example URL of openfootball has data files with fixed column positions and square brackets. Looks like you're packing semantics implicitly into the parser rather than leaving it explicit. I don't see why that's an argument in favor of plain text.
drongoking··on AI is mostly about curve fitting (2018)
> We've seen that threshold crossed with neural agents like AlphaGo which can be reasonably described as thinking.

I don't recall ever reading in a technical paper, or in an interview, a leader in the field of ANNs claim they were thinking. If you have, I'd like to see a reference. Most are fairly honest about the differences between artificial neurons and real ones, and between human cognition and what ANNs are doing with data.

drongoking··on The Bus Ticket Theory of Genius
Two reactions to this. I almost believe these:

1. The difference between collecting bus tickets, working on mathematics, and figuring the crystallization patterns of snowflakes is virtually nothing. To the people obsessed with it, it is all-important; to outsiders, all three look indistinguishably pointless. Only in retrospect can anyone say whether the activity led to something society considers important. The truly obsessed don't care.

2. Genius is overrated. We like stories of great individuals changing the world with their genius because we like stories and we dislike chance. But for nearly every invention and idea, history shows that multiple people were working on it at the same time. Civilization's progress is more a sequence of ideas whose time had come, but we prefer stories of great unique geniuses.

drongoking··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
Not exactly. Incorporating a world or domain model usually means taking pre-existing declarative knowledge in some form (e.g. from a semantic net) and using it to aid learning.

To quote the article, "Model-based reinforcement learning aims to address this issue by first learning a model of the environment’s dynamics, and then planning with respect to the learned model."

So they've sped up learning from examples by learning a model first, but it's still learning from examples.

drongoking··on How to recognize AI snake oil [pdf]
You miss the point of the slides. His point isn't about supervised vs unsupervised, it's about the general areas where AI seems to excel and fail. It's being used to predict social outcomes where it does very poorly, may be inscrutable, and is unaccountable to the public.

Your examples (deep learning applied to perception) are what he argues AI is generally good for.

drongoking··on John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general intelligence
> (edit: I'm not claiming he's a field expert in a week guys, just that he can probably learn the basics pretty fast, especially given ML tech shares many base maths with graphics)

This may be his biggest impediment. ML has gotten very far with looking at problems as linear algebraic systems, where optimizing a loss function mathematically yields a good solution to a precisely defined (and well circumscribed) classification or regression problem. These techniques are very seductive and very powerful, but the problems they solve have almost nothing in common with AGI.

Put another way, Machine Learning as a field diverged from human learning (and cognitive science) decades ago, and the two are virtually unrecognizable to each other now. Human learning is the best example of AGI we have, and using ML tech as a way to get there may be a seductive dead end.

drongoking··on Fast Markov chains in ~20 lines of sh, grep, cut and Awk
> which recently popularized the term n-gram.

Eh? It's well known in Info Retrieval; it goes back at least to Salton's IR group at Cornell in the 1970's.

drongoking··on How to Make Custom AI-Generated Text with GPT-2
Amen!

It is slightly better now than it used to be, i.e. you now have to read two sentences to realize it's incoherent gibberish, rather than just one. But thinking you're getting closer to understanding this way is like the metaphor of climbing a tree to reach the moon: you can keep reporting progress until you run out of tree.

As for it being entertaining, sure, the first attempts were entertaining and instructive. Now, years later, reading more gibberish from a neural net on HN, not so much.

drongoking··on Questions to ask a company during a job interview
I came here to say basically this. I've worked at enough companies to know that their ideas of what their values are may not be accurate.

Instead of asking about values, ask about behavior. No one is going to say no to "Do you value code quality?" Aking what they've done (and sacrificed) to support code quality will give you a better idea of what their relative values are.

Asking about their tech ladder will get you an HR answer. Asking "Who was the last person promoted to X? When?" will give you a better answer. And if they can't remember the last time, that's an answer in itself.

drongoking··on Time anxiety: is it too late?
Interesting essay.

Related to time anxiety, Oliver Burkeman pointed out the paradox of "making good use of time". Taken too far, it turns time into an instrumental goal. You never really enjoy it; you're always just investing time in a future that never comes. And you suffer time anxiety.

drongoking··on Life expectancy and cause of death in popular musicians (2016) [pdf]
In sociology many results are obvious. You just don't know which ones until you do the study.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →