HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

egwor

605 karma · joined March 16, 2011

submissionscomments
egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
There's a real danger here that there are high level summaries upon summaries from those who don't really understand the details of the markets. Every broker will have various liquidity pools and those pools will be pinged to execute your order. The order has to get best execution (there are legal requirements on it).

Without knowing the internal details of RH all of this is speculation. I think that what folk are saying is that Citadel pay for the information on order flow (they don't provide any liquidity?). it sounds like that pays RH bills who have to pay execution and exchange fees. If that's true then isn't the choice to pay the information cost to Citadel or pay some fees to another broker?

I suspect that your casino analogy would be more accurate if the gambler was borrowing money from another casino (i.e. leverage or buying options) and they said 'You've hit your limits in borrowing' or the main casino you're in said 'We don't take bets higher than X'.

egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
Are they though? Do we know all the facts? This is a heavily regulated market and Congress are going to get involved. Let's wait and see.

One thing to consider: if they've provided leveraged finance to buy this stock then they're exposed by this massive move too. They therefore have to manage risk, and so limiting further exposure does make sense. If these people can't pay their bills (if leveraged), I don't know who takes on that risk. It might be RH or this could be passed on to others. Either way someone needs to take that risk on. Some have asked why not just stop the leveraged finance, and I don't know the answer.

Another thing to consider: is it legal to allow manipulation of prices? The folk are trying to hold the price up. This is a tricky subject to consider. As a professional there are various rules on what is manipulation. Presumably a broker has some responsibility here.

All in all, who knows if this is clearly justified. Folk are equally able to go and place orders via other brokers. Whining that broker X can't trade Y doesn't hold water as an argument. If they don't trade X, find a different broker (this is entirely standard practice. Not every broker can trade every instrument). You're not required to execute there.

I'm afraid that folk are going to have a really bad wake up call. These markets are really complex and the warnings that your capital is at risk is a really big warning to be heeded. Don't invest what you can't afford to lose. I'm sorry that people are losing here. :(

egwor··on Facebook shuts down the Socialist Workers Party in Britain
Another view is that they're banning it to show that banning organisations according to some policy isn't effective and therefore they shouldn't be policing it 'because, how could they?'.
egwor··on Ask HN: Anyone else burnt out due to extended lockdown and work-from-home?
I'm sorry to hear that. Is there any way to ask if she'd like you to fly out (assuming that is practical/allowed. In the UK everything is locked down)
egwor··on Context switching costs more than we give it credit for
It is all to do with practice and techniques. Get yourself a copy of Leith's How to Cook. Link I just googled: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Leiths-Cook-School-Food-Wine/dp/184...

A few things:

* It will show you how to cut and the correct techniques to use. Have a look at the Amazon 'look inside' to see how to cut onions, carrots and asparagus

* When cutting things like carrots, are you cutting one carrot or multiple? (the next point is important for this)

* Are your knives sharp? There should be almost no effort cutting through a carrot, for example.

Background to Leiths:

* They're a real cooking school that teaches professional chefs assuming very little knowledge

* It was set up by Prue Leith and Caroline Waldegrave. Prue Leith is one of the judges on the Great British Bakeoff.

* Leiths is well known in London for both their professional courses and for amateur ones too (e.g. a day to de-bone a chicken)

egwor··on New MacBook Pro models to feature magsafe, no touch bar and more ports: analyst
Good point. Most people are going to be using this for presentations or for connecting to a TV. If you're going to need an adapter since most cables are full sized hdmi, then why not just use an adapter from usb-c?
egwor··on New MacBook Pro models to feature magsafe, no touch bar and more ports: analyst
I agree. It feels like 'What I want to hear'.
egwor··on New MacBook Pro models to feature magsafe, no touch bar and more ports: analyst
HDMI is simply too thick. I can't see this happening.
egwor··on Poland plans to make censoring of social media accounts illegal
Deep question.

Sometimes people repeat ideas without sufficient critical thought. That critical thought may well be due to lack of understanding around the subject which limits the ability for the person to review whether it is correct before spreading the information wider.

I think that some of this is because the news that we get from credible sources doesn't explain why they're credible (e.g. no sources). Consequently when we see news in the same form from other venues (which are less credible) they look and appear no different from the credible sources. My proposal here is that news sites should link and quote sources. Example: The Times (UK) quoting the UK Government on lockdown rules. The government web site is actually clearer in many cases, and people don't seem to know where to go to get the actual facts.

(I've not covered bias here either, but that's important).

Another issue that we have is that the experts that are used sometimes don't understand it either! I follow a Doctor (@curexcomplex on twitter) who is an expert immunologist and she often corrects those on news sites. I think that part of this is that when ideas are dumbed down so that a non expert can understand, some of the nuances or subtleties are lost. We can then have 'Chinese whispers' where non-experts then repeat information and the nuance or subtleties are further eroded.

I think that also we have a 'fast' news culture, where there's a level of 'coolness' of spreading news first. I think that means that we don't necessarily check things because we want to share that 'cool' story as fast as possible. I've done this myself and been corrected by peers (who are actually experts in Chemistry (the video was on chemistry) which I'm definitely not!)

Everyone thinks that they're above average. That means that they think that their view is valid. The opinion is equally valid but as a reliable source this is not directly related. For example, unless a Celebrity is a reliable source (a qualification in the subject would give credibility) on immunology we should call them out as such when they talk about vaccinations. For example we could say 'You don't have a high school qualification in Biology. Your credibility in areas relating to biology is therefore less than someone who has a degree in Biology. Your opinion will therefore get a lower weighting by default.'. That doesn't mean that their opinion is less important than anyone else's but their credibility on this subject is worse. I fear that most don't understand this concept. I think this is much like how in history we have primary sources and secondary sources. Maybe we ought to have a way to indicate if the person is a primary source or secondary source.

Lastly, I think that the news sites need to sell ads, so there is and incentive to publish stories quickly and less incentive to take extra time to confirm stories are correct. This is made worse because people have moved on by the time a correction is provided, and it is not shown with the same visibility. That means that the correction is not seen by the same number of people.

(One other thing; I think that folk need to be more humble about learning things when they don't know, and when people are factually wrong we should be happy to say that and to receive it. Obviously this needs adequate supporting evidence.)

Edit: grammar

egwor··on Dropbox to cut 11% of its global workforce
I'm a paying customer and I just realised that I'd not been using my Dropbox on my rebuilt laptop for >6months. I gave up with the crappy view. That's pretty bad if I only just noticed!
egwor··on Haskell is our first choice for building production software systems
Quite a few universities in the UK teach haskell as a way to start everyone on a level playing field and to introduce various concepts.
egwor··on YouTube bans Steve Bannon's podcast channel
I think it is for emphasis and for clarity. It is to clarify that the ban isn't temporary. A ban could be revoked or it could have a time limit. Permanent means it can't be reverted. I wonder if 'suspended' might also link to the wording within their ToS, so that's why they use ban vs suspended.
egwor··on A Polar Vortex collapse sequence has begun
Note that with global warming the gulf stream can change course and so some countries will actually be cooler (not warmer) in winter.
egwor··on Poll: Switching from WhatsApp
It was (maybe still is) quite big in Asia too
egwor··on WhatsApp updates its Privacy Policy to mandate data-sharing with Facebook
Yeah, this is one of the reasons why I'd be pro splitting up Whatsapp and Facebook/Insta. I don't really follow the monopoly rules, so don't really know when it might be crossing that line. I guess the EU review of these firms will tell us.
egwor··on SEC Approves NYSE’s Plan for New IPO Alternative
There’s a lot of auction theory that comes into play that an individual investor is unlikely to know and I would imagine a startup may not fully comprehend either. I would worry that this is still not a level playing field.
egwor··on “I took FSFE to court. This is my story”
Wow, this is horrible. It sounded like the court sided with you even though it was beyond their remit/reach to be able to fine them, which I think is pretty damming of the situation.

I hope that you can take some time out to recover and then go on to find something worthy of your time and effort within a positive environment.

(edit: grammar)

egwor··on Windows 10 20H2: ChkDsk damages filesystem on SSDs with KB4592438 installed
Yeah, since I don't control what gets run on my desktop there's very little option. The web mail vs of Outlook is even locked out.
egwor··on Windows 10 20H2: ChkDsk damages filesystem on SSDs with KB4592438 installed
I have the exact opposite experience. We're running an older version of Office (2016?) at work with Windows 7. Thse are supported by MS via the extended support contracts. It will be upgraded shortly. Basically I get blue screens, rendering issues, slowness, freezing, crashing, random glitches. I regularly lose emails. The changes to Outlook are abysmal too. When a meeting invite I've accepted is amended (e.g. a 'Starting in 5 minutes email or update'), the calendar invite is no longer accepted so the reminder doesn't pop up. Whomever decided that un-accepted invites shouldn't pop up, has caused so much upset, tears and hate. I would describe my windows machine as entirely useless. It has got so bad that I use my iPhone to respond to emails and to use the calendar features. I've been considering learning some .NET to write a pop up app that is always on top so that when there's a meeting it shows up. Has anyone done that? It seems pretty basic.
egwor··on Qt 6.0
I just don't understand the free/commercial differentiation. I was trying to get some projects working from uni, and I wasn't sure what I was allowed to do nowadays. I thought it all had to be commercially licensed so gave up.
egwor··on BiVector.net – Geometric Algebra for CGI, Vision and Engineering
As a school kid (14? 15?), I won a prize to go to Birmingham University (UK) each Saturday morning for a term, to do a maths course. The teachers took turns in taking me and another to the course. One of the things I remember doing was playing with all kinds of geometrical transformations of triangles (e.g. bisect each of the edges to get the circumcentre and then add a circle which had that centre. As you adjusted the shape of the triangle everything updated in real time). It was running on what must have been a mainframe. This was my first (and only?) experience of using a mainframe. I remember being rather unimpressed with the mainframe, since it hung and crashed once. The interface was also a bit crap. As all of the students started doing this work, the mainframe started to struggle and slow down! These libraries look to be able to do similar stuff which is very cool.

I had fond memories of that, and was a reason I got into Computer Science and Maths. I wanted to recreate it, but I've never really tried to do it. These libs look like they could be just the thing.

egwor··on Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes
(as in 1meter rather than 1min!)
egwor··on Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes
Ooh, interesting. Wouldn't that be an extremely short time to measure? It would need to compare <1m response time vs <10m? I would imagine that having an accurate time chip for that short duration would be quite expensive? I have no idea though. I'd be interested to know more
egwor··on Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes
If they can boost the signal of the key, then it would appear that the key is in the car. The car is unlikely to stop if the key signal is lost due to safety concerns.
egwor··on Apple Addresses Privacy Concerns Surrounding App Authentication in macOS
If it were a pre-downloaded list then this is not surveillance. What it is doing it ensuring that software hasn't got malware in and/or that the developer's certificate hasn't been removed (e.g. for distributing malware). That's a good thing, like running a checksum on a downloaded file.
egwor··on Using all-Apple Thunderbolt hardware to kill my MacBook
I have the MacBook Pro 16" 2019. I can confirm you don't have to try very hard for this to break. Disconnect the thunderbolt connected display when asleep and boom. I've learnt that if you close the lid then this seems to help avoid the issue.
egwor··on Actionsflow – IFTTT/Zapier free alternative based on GitHub Actions
Aren't they limiting it to three applets too?
egwor··on JPMorgan to pay nearly $1B for metals market manipulation
Depends what the instrument is and when.

If orders are spoofed during the start of day or end of day auctions or during other specific times when indexes are calculated then this impacts the settlement prices which has a knock on impact to other features of the market. It’s like the LIBOR rigging and the FX manipulation.

egwor··on Staff Report on Algorithmic Trading in U.S. Capital Markets [pdf]
How's this different from in FX where someone buys EURUSD in USD quantity? Venues trade EURUSD not USDEUR. So they want to trade 1000 dollars. Current fx rate is 1.18162. So that's 846.2957634434 euros. Minimum settlement in euros is 1 cent, so what is done with the 0.57 of a euro cent or what happens to the difference between 1000 USD and 999.9931898? I think the answer to this is bankers rounding.
egwor··on PDF: Still unfit for human consumption, 20 years later
I’m going to bite. The web site we’re discussing is full of poor points too. The person you are responding to makes some good points.

- once you’ve saved it as a pdf you can email to anyone. Most (all?) phones support it out of the box. They can then print it out and you can be sure that the entire page is rendered correctly. If you try and save that as an ePub, lots of people won’t know how to open it. For HTML files; often the default HTML store is a browser specific format. Even more often there’s some dependency that means that the page doesn’t actually render after the web site changes (e.g. it missed a dependency or because of JavaScript use or because the format changed between versions). This is one of the reasons why tickets for events come via pdf.

- read only. Want to send your CV and make it difficult for the recruiter to edit. Perfect solution is to use pdf. You also know that the pdf will look the same to the people reading it (and printing it) as when you created it.

- want to create a pdf really easily? Print to pdf. Done. Want to reliably do that to HTML. Good luck. Often there are weird issues that pop up. It often doesn’t render properly once the complexity of the document becomes slightly involved.

- PDF’s excel for technical documents. Yeah, I agree with this. They’re great at providing professionally rendered files, guaranteeing a rendered look across technical fields. This is why they’re used in research. Your argument boils down to ‘the pdf requires a very specific format’. Yes. That’s the intent behind pdf. It doesn’t provide ways to re-render the document, and I don’t think that it was intended to be used that way. Should it, so that less able folk are able to access content: yes.

- All my lecturers used to use ps/pdf for their lecture slides. It worked very well. It got the info across and we could get a copy of the notes. All done.

I feel like the only strong argument here is that it would be nice for the file to render for accessibility and for differing sized screens. That would be nice. Sounds like a great challenge.

Overall this article is a bait article, and I don’t think it should be on hackernews. The stuffed with fluff argument basically boils down to PDF’s are bad because for the PDF’s we’ve looked at “Authors don’t use bullet points”. Cummon! Let’s have some intelligently thought out arguments for a sensible discussion.

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →